Added: 3 years ago
From: shizzle0401
Views: 597,022
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (663)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 14 People have no heart. This song is gut-wrenching. I'm a grown man and every time it makes me cry. Because i think of the one i love. And the one that i care deeply about. I feel sick whenever shes not by my side. And i miss her. Shes 1,000 miles away on a trip and i feel like a part has left me. She means everything to me. And I mean everything to her. We've already promised each other when we're married this will be the first song at our wedding. Thank you Justin for sharing your heart.

  • My favorite song of all time. I can never get enough and cry every time I watch this moving performance. -3

  • @Hellbound4Life666 girls do that but then realize that you are way better then what the other guy is dont let anyone tell u otherwise

  • (cont..) so much, and i just want her back, so im gunna keep talking to her a little more day by day, but im planning on meeting up with her at the end of the week and taking her out with me for a day and im planning on playing this song for her, and asking her back out again. if she really wanted me gone, she wouldnt be talking to me...right? i want her back so much. this is killing me, and i need someone's advice. anyone's.

  • @Hellbound4Life666 Fom a woman's perspective, you need to give her the time and space. She has promised you that you will not lose her." If you don't give her the space she may see your love for neediness and you could push her further away and eventually lose her. Best of luck to you. I hope you get and keep your girl.

  • (cont..) he had a gf and was four years older than her, and that she "just wanted a friend", i called him and told him that he needed to fuck off. i think he's just as confused as i am. but idk. anyway, she got real distant, and she didnt talk much afterwards, and when i went to go take her home again, i gave her a hug and asked her to promise me to come back and she said "i promise", and now we're talking, but she still says that she doesnt think she wants to be with me. i love her (cont..)

  • (continued from last...) his house twice now, and he has a gf that he's had for 2 years, and her and i hung out yesterday, and we were fine (earlier she said she wanted space cuz she didnt know what she wants; me or nothing). and we kissed and hugged, and she told me before we got out of the car to go into his house "i promise you wont lose me" and she kissed me. but when we got back from his place, she was distant again. be aware that the night before, since i didnt know that (cont...)

  • Hey everyone, I need help with something.. so my gf broke up with me on valentines day and didnt bother to tell me until i found out on facebook. she is my life, my everything. we've been together for 5 years, and she's doing a program at the community college called running start and she told me finally on friday that there's this guy she's been going to for help with one of her classes, and she has a little crush on him. this has destroyed me. because she's been over to (continued....)

  • it's amazing how beautiful he sounds... some people aren't as good live... but he is.

  • 12 people jumped fron the 18th floor balcony

  • nice song :) thanks Shay

  • I'm here from Shay! Hi.

  • Beautiful

  • Love put into words, in the most beautiful way. Simple, elegant, and pure.

  • this song almost get me too tears, through the voice, the emotions and the fantastically use of rythm and instruments, and whenenver i fetch what he is aying, it hits hard (i'm hard of hearing so reading the text is required for me to understand the text (hich i have done many times now, so i understand the meaning). Damn, it is a good song and fantastic live performance!

  • I want a tattoo with some lyric from this song but I have no idea which is best. Any help?

  • @TheChrisG69 Open the blinds, let the city in

  • @noorsaar not bad. I thought about "Open" and "Wide" on each arm to go with "so my arms are open wide." Still not sure what to get though. Thank you!

  • Wow... thanks everyone for your support :) I don't think he's seen it.

    But we are still together and very very happy :)

  • damn, i feel for the singer!

    come read my song review and tell me if you feel the same way

    musikeroatmusikera dot blogspot dot com

  • I close my eyes and i smile, knowing that everything is alright.

  • ~_~ Can't stop listening to my Blue October. A real human being singing for us.

  • I frequently listened to this song in those years, my most painful days....

    and now, i feel happy...yet this melody is still a great company to come up...

    thank you blue october~~your music supported me through my worst period of life

    thank you Justin... Love from Taiwan

  • Hurts my heart and tears overflow my eye lids:(

  • Can't believe that people want to have this played at their wedding.. It's a song with suicidal references.. I mean common! just look at the title..

  • @NerdRage5 oh come on. all of blue october songs have SOME suicidal references. -__- doesn't mean that the whole song is about it. this is the one with the most about love.

  • @NerdRage5 it really takes a certain mental frame to understand and love most blue october music. this is one of their happier songs... i personally would chose this song over ANYTHING else to play at a wedding. you just don't see it the same way

  • @sanders9194 Thank you very much! Anyone can take it as they like.. But the song is truely about finding your soul mate after death. It's amazing <3

  • @TheTotallyrandomXD I see you are happy with your mate. I once believed in true love and soul mate but that all died the day after my wife of 10yrs told me my dad died after fighting brain cancer for 3yrs......I caught her srewing her bar tender on MY couch when I got home. That was 3/2011 for the record. Now she's trying to take the things in life that remind me of my father.

  • @NerdRage5 It's not about suicidal references. It's about finding your soul mate. Listen to the lyrics.

  • my favorite Blue October song!!!!!!

  • You see so much like me I can't understand how it is but then that is what music is all about. You make me smile, cry, feel!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Justin keep up the great work in your words and music. You are amazing and your will find what you are looking for one day just be patient<3

  • Pure bliss put into words. Justin is amazing <3

  • hey shizzle0401, i think i watched this video so many damn times, and i never thanked you for uploading it. So thanks man, this is one of my favorate songs, and one of my favorate videos. You have no idea how much it means to me, so thank you.

  • i really wish I could find out where this video came from. It's not something someone shot on their cell phone... but it doesn't look like the Argue With A Tree DVD either. Anyone know?

  • There is no "old" or "new" Blue October. It's all just...real.

  • 17 and I already know what my wedding song is going to be

  • I LOVE THIS SONG

    

  • Comment removed

  • I'm so yours for the taking! So yours for the taking!

  • I really miss this Blue October. Not the new one.

  • two words........... GOOSE BUMPS... the argue with a tree DVD and album are both highly underrated....

  • ryan, make it snow

  • I'm crying. I've loved this song since I dedicated it to old girlfriend of mine. She said she wasn't feeling it anymore and broke it off. I came to hate this song and the band it accompanied. I heard "Calling You" On Pandora awhile back and looked up this song again. I can't hate this. I don't hate her. I don't miss her, but the memories will hopefully fade, in time. This song is still the greatest and most powerful love song I've ever heard and I'll never forget it. Thank you, Blue October.

  • @Shadowinchester ...amen

  • 11 people fell asleep

  • I miss you, too.

  • I was at that concert :) Amazing

  • Thank you , in a way, for being here for me Mr. Furstenfeld. I was married for 16 years and he left me for a 23 year old. I worked 2 and sometimes 3 jobs to hang onto the house he borrowed for himself repeatedly. I almost died. Ended up in the hospital. I kept asleep for almost a month in the hospital. Lost my house, my car, my life, but most of all my 3 kids. His family was locally powerful and I was invisible and uncared for. Thank you for at least helping me not feel alone. forever, Inga

  • LOVE Blue October, but was nauseated when i hear that "Twilight" crap used this song. This music is so far over the "Twilight" fans' heads........

  • @TheBlueeyedJew Why do you have to bash Twilight fans? Shouldn't you be happy that this band is getting recognized by people who may not have ever heard of them? Honestly I have never heard of this band before and if it wasn't for a story that I read a while back that mentioned this song I wouldn't be here.

  • God, that's so beautiful.

  • I wish they still played these songs live. ryan is absolutely captivating on the violin. too bad the break up impacted their performances so much :(

    i just seen them again last week and there was very little played that was a love song. if it was justin centered it on Blue

  • Awesome!!! Best most heartfelt! Looks like he got lost in the song!!

  • I want this. I want this so bad.

  • First few tones made me cry O.o

  • Comment removed

  • Justin Furstenfeld, I love you to pieces. Blue October makes sense in many ways.

  • price tag is #1 song reviewed on youtube! how come!!

  • wowwwwwwwwwwww what an amazing and movin performes even the guitarplayer had tears running down his cheek at the end!!!!!!I did too.Love you guys.....

  • Brian Uvegas.... you know..... that 18th floor balcony...

  • one of their best performances ever

  • Chills, so amazing. Really happy I'm gonna see them live in 2 months!

  • The very first dance I shared with my wife was to this song. It is forever sacred to me.

  • 11 people is on 17th floor balcony.

  • Oh yeah, Almost forgot Misc.

  • Gods real name must be Brian

  • This is our song and I couldn't be more happy with him. He means the world to me and this songs describes us so well. I love you.

  • My name is Ambree. I'm in love with the greatest man i've ever met. He gives me reason for life. He is the only thing keeping me going. I really want him to see this next time he watches this video. It's his favorite song, and i want to play it at our wedding. Please, do me a favor... and press the like button. It will make a girls dream come true. :)

  • @TheTotallyrandomXD

    I'm sorry.... how exactly will liking this comment make him marry you??

  • @TheTotallyrandomXD so sorry but im in love with the best guy ever :)

  • 1,401 people have beautiful taste in music. 11 people just forgot to turn on their speakers.

  • 11 people are retarded.

  • 10 people were tearing up soo much they mistook the thumbs down for a thimbs up! Lol! I absolutley love Blue October. I've only had the pleasure of seeing them once (so far) and that was the most emotionally packed concert i've ever seen. Amazing stuff.

  • This song reminds me of a girl who shattered my heart and how I wish things had turned out between us

  • This was going to be my wedding song with my girl. But now I'm baring my cross and just played her "Hate me". Having bad days..

  • Love this song and this performance is just awesome.

  • i cried when i first heard this song...love you so much

  • Amazing live band...

  • I have seen Blue October..3 times in Milwaukee..never an unemotional show...You guys rock...i love how your feelings r in your music and your not afraid to show it...

  • so beautiful, dark, romantic and raw....

  • Song gives me chills

  • This is mine and my husband's song <3

  • Love it

  • brian... make it snow...

  • @graingersito Bet the crowd was like whats he talking about lol. that was beautiful!

  • @graingersito it's Ryan

  • @dan12con dude i was high at 4am i don't even remember posting that comment, haha. i know ryan is the violinist. 

  • gosh its been forever since i have listened to these guys. This was always my favorite song...it always made me cry for some reason. It is so beautiful. What sucks is they had a free concert a few years ago with some other band and i went...but i didnt get to see them b/c my stupid friend and his brother got us kicked out b/c they were running around. Now everytime I listen to them, I get upset that i didnt see them. thing was, they were getting their instruments on stage when we got kicked out.

  • I dont usually like the live version song but this is an exception.

  • This song is pure love!

  • This song is hauntingly beautiful!

    If thats what love is, then I want it.

  • @MsCharley007 This song makes me cry. its just that beautiful.

  • @kutlessRULES4life

    Same here:')

  • @MsCharley007 Ive hit replay a bunch lol i wish there were a repeat button!

  • @kutlessRULES4life Yeah sameee! :')

    make my life much easier ;D 

  • @MsCharley007 I think ill make a complaint to youtube about that lol. I honestly think that this live version is the best. i listened to others and the crowd is singing terribly with it lol. ruining it cause they sing it louder then Justin. he has an amazing voice and this one live video i believe is better then the studio recorded one. :)

  • @kutlessRULES4life Yeah agreeed, I like this one because its so raw and amazing hes just there on stage, singing! and its soooo amazing:')

    yeah I hate that its like you're killing this song :P

  • I also noticed he seemed a little sad at the end when he was done singing... :(

  • My husband and I picked this as our wedding song a few years back. Simply said, it's beautiful.

  • This is my husbands and my wedding song. Simply said, it's beautiful.

  • Beautiful song, I had goose bumps all over my body. This is music ! keep it Up, so innocent, pure, an delicate .

  • Beautiful song, I had goose bumps all over my body. This is music ! keep it Up

  • this song makes me want to fall in love:')

  • @sofiaaa987 INOE RIGHT? :')

  • @Dragonslyrs looks like she's playing bass?

  • simply luv on a stick!

  • Fall in luv w/ this song as soon as I heard it

  • who's that chick?!?!

  • @sanders9194 She went by "Piper", also played bass for Zayra Who sings with Justin on "come in closer" and filled in for Matt while he was playing with A+Machines, I think. Actually, I always liked her style and she was cool too.

  • i wish i was with this one girl on the 18th floor balcony..

  • God, this song, especially this performance, kills me every time. It's so incredibly beautiful. It says so much.

  • I love This Song!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! way to go ....no one can do it better than these guys.. i love all your songs. I'm glad you guys are where you are cause you guys touch my heart so deeply!!!!!!!!!!!!!xoxoxoxoxox­oxoxo

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • 2:13

  • Comment removed

  • i love Justin. i will marry him. <3

  • I love this song sooooo much!! I can't listen to it enough!! 

  • A passage into my soul has been opened, and I thank you Blue October for building it.

  • Justin if your life sucks have a shot at mines....

  • i'm married and i've fell in love with him with one else. what do i do

  • I love blue October

  • 7 people fell off the balcony.

  • @SynikaI make that 9

  • @SynikaI no 10 people have

  • @SynikaI 10 people now lol

  • @SynikaI

    Seriously... why do you people have to ruin lovely videos with fucking ridiculous comments like that! So what 7 (now 11) people don't like the song.

    It's their choice. We can see they dont like it, we dont need a comment about it.

  • @HarakMolova umad?

  • @SynikaI

    Newfag.... you probably dont know where that came from, let alone who started it. So shut up.

  • @HarakMolova o'rly? CAM'RON started it, 4chan made it spread like hepatitis.

  • my father & i shared the love for this song & band. Every time I hear this song I can only cry, For the memories & laughter we shared singing blue october songs. My father passed away two years ago this November. " And I'll try to sleep, to keep you in my dreams so i can bring you home with me." I miss him everyday. Going to see blue october on friday will be bittersweet... Wishing my dad was there with me & at the same time knowing he will be there in spirit.

  • one of the best love songs out there.

  • wonderful like most of their songs

    

  • just adore this song.a great but underrated band.need them to come back to england,please .saw them twice the other year in birmingham fantastic.

  • I've been searching forever for a song that might be similar to this and I would like as much.. but I can't. It's nice that this song is so amazing, but if anyone had other suggestions, that'd be awesome.

  • This has to be the 100th time i've listened to this. It keeps giving me hope that there's a beautiful life out there somewhere.

  • this song makes me think of a rough patch in my life, and the place i went when i was getting my life back on track, and how i want to go back this time, not heart broken. but with the one i love. its the sweetest song by them i can think of besides calling you.

  • this makes me cry...It makes me think of my ex...i miss him so much... I love this song so much <3

  • @DeeDeeLovesYou112410 I love you baby

  • why the hell did into the ocean get so much publicity and this got relatively none?

  • this band is a God send.

  • Comment removed

  • So amazing...just beautiful!

  • I cry when I see this and hear this.....this feeling will happen for me again one day. I can hardly stand the wait....I am truly grateful to the person who first shared this song with me....I will never forget....

  • Truly amazing.

  • Just love this live version! Check out my cover at DanielRossingMusic here on youtube! :-)

  • I love this video, and I was tearing up, no shame,. Tears were spent on this, but well spent!

  • WOW!!!

    

  • i wanna cry.. i love this song!!

  • One of mine & My Marine's songs <3 I love you, baby! Come home soon.

  • Absolutely stunning performance...I'm just speechless!

  • ...and in that moment, i swear we were infinite... :(

  • we're both trying to make it snow!! <333 yayy finally found this version! :)

  • This is a beautiful song...made me cry. I've never listened to this band before, but will make it a point to add them to my collection.

  • 6 people must have had their hearts broken, well to those people you need to take the word of 1008 other people that your heart will heal and you will find love again :)

  • Fabulously Tender.

  • you can see how the audience is singing along.. amazing. we can pretend we're amazing

  • :'( no joke

  • I absoulty love this band, every single song hits my life in some powerful way I really feel this band can move us in such amazing ways, BLUE OCTOBER FOILED is Just awesome and has SO MUCH MEANING TO MELISSA HALL....... LOVE THEM AND THIS SONG... DANG CANT POST THIS NOW WHY.....

  • I absoulty love this band, every single song hits my life in some powerful way I really feel this band can move us in such amazing ways, BLUE OCTOBER FOILED is Just awesome and has SO MUCH MEANING TO MELISSA HALL....... LOVE THEM AND THIS SONG...

  • @melissahall11 LOL @ MYSELF SUCH A RETARD FOR POSTING TWICE

  • I showed this song to a girl I like and she is now going out with me. It's so moving

  • Wow...what a moving song gosh only if I knew of it a few days ago, would have been the perfect time to play it to her :/ Such a moving song..

  • This song gives me goosebumps too! Its such a beautiful song and the Im just enthralled by the whole performance....<3 it!