at the end of this video you talk about doing something to the spine of the blade, have you done a video or explained this process somewhere else? i am very new to knife work and i want to learn the correct way of doing things.
thank you very much for taking the time to post this series, it has been a huge help
@evcrawfish Watch my video of heat treating the Khopesh sword, that should make things clear. :) You're very welcome for the videos, glad you're getting something out of em. Thanks for watching.
@ArtistBlade1972 cool, yes sir, i just finished making (well kind of) my first ever knife. and i've been studying sugarcreekforge's channel, as well as gavkoo and several other guys who are doing blacksmithing and knife making. picking up pieces here and there. i gathered some stuff from my junk pile today to start assembling my first charcoal forge, gas is planned down the road. anyway, i am going through and watching all of your vids.
@rcmoot A magnet isn't nearly as accurate as looking for the point of decalescence/recalescence. The curie point marks the lower transformation temp. This is only the correct quench temp for 1084, which this is not. I never multiple quench simple steels, only low and medium chromium alloys. Thanks for watching...
One question for now ... is it proper to lay the blade horizontal, or should it be hung vertically to prevent warp? Does it matter? Oops, I guess that is two questions.
@dordtrecht Are you asking about the actual quench or normalization? It can warp in either process. Most people who quench the entire blade quench point down vertically. People who edge quench do it horizontally. It's tricky to judge temperature when you are first starting out, and overheating will definitely warp a blade. That, along with not properly relieving forging stresses, are the top 2 causes of warps. Hope that answers your question.
Thanks for answering my question ... perhaps this will clarify what I am asking ... the answer may be the same. I guess (because I don't know all of the terminology yet) in this video you showed the part of you heating the blade, I guess to normalize it, and then you placed it on the anvil, horizontally flat.
I would be the normalizing process ... where you are hardening the blade by heat and cool three times. Also, if it is proper to lay the blade horizontally flat, do you bring your anvil temp up to black or just leave it at room temp? I like your videos on this blade processing, however, on this particular one it is not clear as to what to precisely do to harden/normalize the blade. Thank you.
@dordtrecht Ok, sorry, I should have been more descriptive. What you are referring to is called thermal cycling. I normalize the blade 3 times. This is to reduce the grain size in the steel structure. Also, this relieves forging stresses. and reduces the chance of warping. This is not the hardening process. When I heat it the final time and quench in oil is when the blade actually hardens. This is followed by a tempering cycle to remove strain cause by martensite transformation.
@WoebringerofDoom I can hold it just fine. I've done this hundreds of times. The blade is not even sharp at this point.. Even if it did grab it would smack the bar behind it....
@Pookster47676 Depends on the steel type. This particular blade was quenched in a mixture of automatic transmission fluid and paraffin wax. It is a solid at room temperature. I use this for all hypereutectoids. For hypoeutectoids with the exception of 5160 I use very light weight mineral oil.
at the end of this video you talk about doing something to the spine of the blade, have you done a video or explained this process somewhere else? i am very new to knife work and i want to learn the correct way of doing things.
thank you very much for taking the time to post this series, it has been a huge help
evcrawfish 2 months ago
@evcrawfish Watch my video of heat treating the Khopesh sword, that should make things clear. :) You're very welcome for the videos, glad you're getting something out of em. Thanks for watching.
ArtistBlade1972 2 months ago
@ArtistBlade1972 cool, yes sir, i just finished making (well kind of) my first ever knife. and i've been studying sugarcreekforge's channel, as well as gavkoo and several other guys who are doing blacksmithing and knife making. picking up pieces here and there. i gathered some stuff from my junk pile today to start assembling my first charcoal forge, gas is planned down the road. anyway, i am going through and watching all of your vids.
evcrawfish 2 months ago
@evcrawfish Alright brother if I can help ya in any way let me know.
ArtistBlade1972 2 months ago
how long are you waiting before you temper ?
rcmoot 5 months ago in playlist Knife
quench more than once . what oil are you using?
rcmoot 5 months ago in playlist Knife
too small of pan to quench.
rcmoot 5 months ago in playlist Knife
should have been testing with magnet , instead of just judging colors
rcmoot 5 months ago in playlist Knife
@rcmoot A magnet isn't nearly as accurate as looking for the point of decalescence/recalescence. The curie point marks the lower transformation temp. This is only the correct quench temp for 1084, which this is not. I never multiple quench simple steels, only low and medium chromium alloys. Thanks for watching...
ArtistBlade1972 5 months ago
should have preheated the steel first before sticking straight in.
rcmoot 5 months ago in playlist Knife
i thought this was a damascus blade.. wheres the pattern??
m579064 1 year ago
@m579064 You won't see the pattern until after the blade is etched...
ArtistBlade1972 1 year ago
@ArtistBlade1972 lol just watched part 6 cheers man, have a habit of doing that.. keep up the good work!
m579064 1 year ago
what kind of wool did u use for the tip?
m579064 1 year ago
lol kaowool! i should have waited till id watched before posting
m579064 1 year ago
One question for now ... is it proper to lay the blade horizontal, or should it be hung vertically to prevent warp? Does it matter? Oops, I guess that is two questions.
dordtrecht 1 year ago
@dordtrecht Are you asking about the actual quench or normalization? It can warp in either process. Most people who quench the entire blade quench point down vertically. People who edge quench do it horizontally. It's tricky to judge temperature when you are first starting out, and overheating will definitely warp a blade. That, along with not properly relieving forging stresses, are the top 2 causes of warps. Hope that answers your question.
ArtistBlade1972 1 year ago
@ArtistBlade1972
Thanks for answering my question ... perhaps this will clarify what I am asking ... the answer may be the same. I guess (because I don't know all of the terminology yet) in this video you showed the part of you heating the blade, I guess to normalize it, and then you placed it on the anvil, horizontally flat.
dordtrecht 1 year ago
@dordtrecht this increases the ductility of the steel by removing some of the hardness. I hope that is a little more clear...
ArtistBlade1972 1 year ago
@ArtistBlade1972
I would be the normalizing process ... where you are hardening the blade by heat and cool three times. Also, if it is proper to lay the blade horizontally flat, do you bring your anvil temp up to black or just leave it at room temp? I like your videos on this blade processing, however, on this particular one it is not clear as to what to precisely do to harden/normalize the blade. Thank you.
dordtrecht 1 year ago
@dordtrecht Ok, sorry, I should have been more descriptive. What you are referring to is called thermal cycling. I normalize the blade 3 times. This is to reduce the grain size in the steel structure. Also, this relieves forging stresses. and reduces the chance of warping. This is not the hardening process. When I heat it the final time and quench in oil is when the blade actually hardens. This is followed by a tempering cycle to remove strain cause by martensite transformation.
ArtistBlade1972 1 year ago
dude put a stop on the drill press, a bolt or some thing to keep the blade from spinning around. for that one time it slips.
WoebringerofDoom 1 year ago
@WoebringerofDoom I can hold it just fine. I've done this hundreds of times. The blade is not even sharp at this point.. Even if it did grab it would smack the bar behind it....
ArtistBlade1972 1 year ago
What kind of oil do you use to quench?
Pookster47676 1 year ago
@Pookster47676 Depends on the steel type. This particular blade was quenched in a mixture of automatic transmission fluid and paraffin wax. It is a solid at room temperature. I use this for all hypereutectoids. For hypoeutectoids with the exception of 5160 I use very light weight mineral oil.
ArtistBlade1972 1 year ago