Added: 2 years ago
From: KatherineJenkinsTV
Views: 149,538
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (164)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • She does this perfectly as a mezzo! Sierra is perfect as a soprano! Stop comparing!!!!

  • @PhantomPhan321 I agree with you. Both of them are great singers. I have both their versions of this song on my iTunes.

  • Check out YouTube "Katherine Jenkins Quello Che Faro". (Everything I Do - In Italian - From Robin Hood Prince Of Thieves) An absolute masterpiece!

  • che voce mediocre! ma beato lui che se la munge tutta a sta biondona! ;-)

  • @IosephusMacerIf From the mouth of a tone deaf filth monger ? 

  • Would anyone know what key she performed it in?

  • Her tone quality and resonance is so, so, close to perfect that she almost sounds like a string instrument...it's so beautiful

    *tear*

    :D

  • umm. i like her voice but this song needs to be sung in its original key...like sierra did.

  • @bakere512 She can't sing it in the original key because she is a mezzo soprano. Sierra is a soprano

  • She is Great .. i love her songs very much .. and i love her :D .... Fan From iraq

  • Ela não tem uma identidade musical (pop ou clássico). Ela precisa ouvir mais Maria Callas.

  • *Puts a mask on male model* Per-phect...lol

  • :O I want that red dress!! :L x

  • Phenomenal. Absolutely phenomenal...

  • Whow...beautiful....

  • Sensational performance from the worlds greatest soprano..We all love you Katherine

  • remembering this song...with tears....where ever..you are'''''''''your memories'''will be here'...in''my heart''esp''our song collection's

  • She thinks she's Sarah B right man. She said once that her most successful song is Time To Say Goodbye, with Andrea Bocelli. HELLO? I think Sierra is more like Christine because she has a similar voice with Sarah when she (Sarah) was younger.

  • is this a real video or something someone made on iMovie.. those parts with her live shadows is ridiculously amateur and poorly edited. It just looks bad compared to the rest of the video. Phenomenal voice.

  • What a great voice she has!! I love this muisical!! Andrew has done it again!!

  • I worship this magnificent woman!!!

  • I think Katherine Jenkins sings this song beautifully and so deos Sierra Boggess...Its a beautiful song, what more can I say? Andrew Lloyd Webber is a genius!

  • i LOVE YOU KATHERINE , FOREVER

  • She's lovely. As is Sierra. Why do we always have to compare and contrast?

  • 目前还没有机会看到全剧,但此曲真的很好听。昨天居然还听到中文­版的,神了!

    I haven't got a chance to watch the whole musical, but this song is really wonderfull. How amazing that I heard the Chinese version yesterday!

  • she sings better than Madonna and she looks better, she will be a great star someday, oh yeah

  • @MsCaleb79 you defnitely CANNOT compare her to Madonna for God's sake!!!!!!!

  • @mmmhperrita yes, you don´t know who she is, she is a singer too!!

  • Comment removed

  • Gorgeous! I prefer Sierra though! :)

  • Thank God she's not crappy like Sarah Brightman. She and Sierra are 100,000,000 xs better!

  • I like both versions. They both have qualities that I enjoy. Sierra has a lot of energy when she sings and Katherine is a little more laid back. Her voice is a little more cushioned and effervescent. Sierra hits her notes hard and has a lot of power. They are both lovely, beautiful, but very different singers. Love that we can enjoy both versions.  ALW ftw!!

  • They both have such good voices.Katherine sounds like a true opera singer while Sierra puts so much love into the music

  • Gorgeous woman; with an absolutely incredible voice. I envy her children if and when she ever has any; they'll get to listen to her sing them to sleep at night, what an honor.

  • she is so beautiful!! it's unreal

  • LINDO LINDO MIL VEZES LINDO...

  • I prefer Sierra. Katherine did an amazing job though.

  • Nup Sierra much better

    Not saying Katherine is bad but I per fur Sierra.

  • This is brilliant.....I reckon she should do a duet with Lena K 'Stop Walking Away'

  • Brilliant...

  • Fantastic video. Gorgeous, talented singer. Proud to be a fan! 10/10 Katherine.

  • love this song going to see this musical soon and cant wait

  • we learned about you today in school!!

  • Absolutely Amazing! 

  • A bit overdone, yeh great voice but it all seems a bit over produced to me.

  • The top notes are simply breath-taking, what an amazing voice!

    what an inspiration to all us female singers:-)

  • The top notes are simply breath-taking, what an amazing voice!

  • I am slightly biased, but Sierra sings live, up to 8 shows a week, and rehearsals, and i know i couldn't even sing happy birthday in the corsetry she wears, and this is a pre recorded, probably tweeked version, lovely looking girl, probably lovely voice, but can she do it live, in front of a thousand people, in a corset, while on a moving stage?

  • @Xandrandra of course she can!!! shes a Neath girl!!!! pure welsh bred!!!

  • @Xandrandra lol, yes, Katherine Jenkins can do this live

  • I think I heard this version of Love Never Dies in Barnes & Noble one day. It was beautiful. :)

  • Love the song but Hate the doggy advert be4hand!!!!!!!!!

    Good choice of campanionship James.........

  • ace

  • It's good, but she seems a little rushed...the entire mood is lost if too fast.

  • Very nice, but she could slow down a little...it looses the mood if rushed.

  • Katherine sends us to Sarah Brightman in the first years of her majestic career. Katherine, as mezzo, gets to have a voice sweetly lukewarm and velvety, that in songs as this, where she caresses our soul and calms our spirit. But, to the coloratura degree it doesn't reach. Only Divas "hors concours" like Sarah Brightman arrive there.

  • GOD that woman is FINE!!!

  • if they ever do a film sequel to the phantom of the opera, they should make this the official theme and music video. Beautiful singing from Katherine :)

  • speachless, But I have plenty of tears so I think I will just shut up right now,Thank you. 55555.David .

  • @beachfrontal -Thank you David for

    the stunning performance by Katherine.

    Beautiful lyrics-Love gives you pleasure-

    Love gives you pain-Wonderful music

    from Andrew Lloyd Webber.I saw the Phantom

    of the Opera three times with Michael Crawford

    -Mesmerizing- and still love it......many555555---Polly

  • @luvperu1 This tore at my heart strings, I have now heard it 7 times this evening, I find it just such a tremendous , and truthful song ,Yes love Hurts it sure does, that's why it is so frequently depicted as arrows piercing hearts ,now that has got to hurt, doesn't it??

  • @beachfrontal - my dearest David..really no words for such video.

    I'm speachless, the performance of Katherine touched me.

    THANK YOU

    All the stars for this GIFTED WOMAN.

    God bless you

    Maria

  • @YThemertY Me too!!! it got inside didn't  it.

  • I know Jenkins and I know the song and I've seen the film and I know the words and I'm still STUNNED!

  • fantastic

  • BEAUTUIFUL!!!

  • spectacular voice! have not seen the musical though it is now on my "must see" list.

  • Beautiful Voice!

  • Very nice...

  • Just got the email from Mr. Foster. Fantastic.

  • Lovely Voice. Nice work

  • Bravo! A beautiful voice!

  • Beautiful song + voice= Mr. Webber has made another masterpiece.

  • I'd like to hear Sarah Brightman sing this.

  • A sweet pure Mezzo-Soprano....

  • So beautiful! Thank you.

  • WOW  impressive voice...

    feels so nice & proud to live in a time along with such singers ;-)

  • wow another beautiful song by a truly wonderful lady who should have been on broadway years ago because her wonderful voice is so beautiful that she can entertain the world

  • I thought "All I ask of you" was my favourite song, but now I am having to change my mind - "Love never dies" has became my favourite. Such beautiful lyrics, tune and singing voice! Thank you very much for posting.

  • Gorgeous woman who sings great!

  • What a beautiful song! What a wonderful performance, splendid soprano!

  • fantastic!!

    

  • Crikey, Katherine is hot! Lord Lloyd Webber's romantic sweeping melody, together with Katherine's wonderful cleavage in that red dress, really does it for me; and then there's that slightly cheeky shot of her in that short black skirt at 4:10!

    Amazing video - one for the spank bank I'd say!

  • This song made me cry. Not many love songs can do that to me... This was stunning.

  • sounds disney for some reason

  • my gosh, I'm not sure which one is more beautiful, her or her voice

  • i went to see her last week in llangollen in north wales, she was fantastic and so beautifull, she sang this amazing live.. Even better shes welsh.

  • Wonderful ! Wonderful ! ....Katherine

  • Wow! I simply cannot imagine what it would be like to have a voice like hers and to look the way she does. You can bet that I will be buying more of her music.

  • beautiful voice; awful song...

  • oh my god is very very beautyfull song her voice is so nice, now i used this song for my cel phone when i get up in the morning. i'm loving it

  • A welsh angel. Thank goodness she shares her talent with us.

  • I'm not absolutely sure about that, but I think, once I have heard angels singing with a Christian orchestra. Your voice is almost like their as I can tell! Especially when you're singing to God from your heart, and when you're singing love songs! I know, He loves you, and loves your voice! You should know, that you can pray to Him simply by singing! And this is a wonderful gift! :)

  • Cant get enough of KJ....

  • It's more than amazing, I can't even find a word to describe how perfect it is!

    I miss Katherine's opera voice so much since she has been working more on pop recently, she's a real master at this!

  • I'm so glad this is coming out on iTunes this month. Been dying to get this.

  • Amazing. Katherine is phenominal. I could listen all day. This song is so precious. She is really is a gift from God. Such a beautiful song

  • Katherine is an amazing performer, and with such beautiful music that Andrew Lloyd Weber writes... Beautiful!!!

  • i can imagine this song in the phantom of the opera!!

  • Does anyone know how or to do the effect at 0:47? I don't know what to call it to search how to do it...

  • every time I listen to this on the internet, I never get tired of it, it's such a beautiful song, beautiful girl, it's so beautiful to listen to, she really is a beautiful girl.

  • This song is beautiful, some of Andrew's best work. It sends chills down your spine <3

  • I love this girl, she amazing? 20/20

  • It looks like she is going back to wearing the same gown in LA DIVA in 2004, she is a very kind person, and I wish she would come back to Australia. I wish you were my girl. I love you

  • I love you so much Miss Jenkins, I just wish I had a girl like you, your very beautiful, and obsiviously a lovely person. I love you Darling.

  • I love Andrew Lloyd Webber. + Katherine sings this beautifully.

  • that was beautiful...cant wait to see the play

  • Prefer this version to one in the West End, and I'm not a big Jenkins fan, but this is beautiful... :)

  • Absolutely beautiful. Thank you to Ms Jenkins and Lord ALW for this timeless piece of music. This is one i will play at my wedding next month :)

  • Ok so why is she getting this video when Sierra sings it in the show? They should have given her a music video I think.

  • I've never really cared much for Katherine. she has a pretty voice and talent, but there's always been something there that's a bit off for me. I don't mean to speak ill of her or hurt her fans, but that's just my opinion. However, I do prefer her version of this song to Sierra's. Sierra doesn't have the range for this and really pushed it to hit some of the notes. she came across as screetchy especially towards the end. Katherine did a much better job.

  • I like her version way better! Sierra's voice is way too shrill and high pitched. Katherine sounds more like original Christines from original Phantom of the Opera productions. I mean no one is ever Sarah Brightman... and you can understand what Katherine is singing whereas sometimes you can't understand some of what Sierra is singing.

  • I agree, Jenkins has a much more impressive voice. In fact, there's no better Broadway voice than hers. She's not as strong an opera singer, although capable, where many others are her equal or better.

  • @Defygrav86

    look up sumi jo's version. Its in Korean.....but its an even bigger contrast to Katherine and sierra

  • Makes me proud to be welsh! Amazing!

  • She is so talented! and beautiful!! This version is more powerful than Sierra's, but I can't choose, I will love Sierra forever :D But Katherine really amazed me, it's like this song was written for her :D

  • Did you see the heart ? :)

  • Powerful, emotional & a sheer joy to listen to & to look at !!!!

  • Powerful,emotional & simply stunning.Nice one Katherine....dont let the critics get to you just carry on as you are & they"ll melt away !! I"m from Swansea & I"ve just told a friend of mine in Ottawa about this posting.He"ll love it !!

  • Katherine..a pristine voice, beauty and by numerous accounts a chacter to match. Another great performance from K J.

  • Beautiful song, beautiful girl and she has green eyes like mine.

  • Wow! Brilliant!

  • This is really nice. She's awful pretty and sings very well. I prefer kiri te kanawa's version. In those days the lyrics were "the heart is slow to learn".

  • Sierra plays the part of Christine well (I am only going by what I've heard from the soundtrack!) but there are notes she struggles with, and obviously, she seems very nervous. Not that I'm criticising. She seems to have a natural eloquence in her speech, especially toward the higher notes.

    Ms Jenkins does a stunning performance here, the only thing I don't like is the arms fluttering about. But that's just me.

  • Very nice. Very very nice.  I actually prefer this version than the one she sang on Dancing on Ice. Katherine also looks much more natural here - none of that wild hair!

    Just to add my tuppence to the conversations going on here;

  • Actually, I've been a Sierra fan for a few years, but this version is ten times better than her's. She was howling, in my humble opinion as a professional actor/vocalist.

    This is lovely and what her's should have been.

  • Sierra's is more emotional, but I think this version sounds more powerful. Both are amazing!!!! <3

    Oh, and I really want the red dress Katherine has in this video!!

  • Poor you if you cannot see one of the worlds best artists as she is .Sierra will come and go .Katherine will still be there as millions of her fans know.Sierra has a pretty voice .but the other one she keeps showing us more of her talent

  • this is lovely, but Sierra acts the song far better and her voice sounds a lot purer and sweeter. but Katherine is a wonder.

  • Absolute rubbish , are you another of those proffesional Katherine haters ?or the other ones ,the opera toffs?

  • Amazing. Can't wait to see Love Never Dies

    xxx :)

  • Beautiful song! Beautiful voice!  Beautiful lady!

  • Absolutely magical performance...Far superior  to that other singer..Sierra !!!.

  • wow. amazing, gave me goosebumps.

  • Lloyd Webber explains why he chose to reuse this tune for this show on his website...read it if you need an explanation. By the way..if you think this tune sounds ANYTHING like "You must love me" ...you're deaf.

  • it was called the heart is low to learn, kiri te kanawa sang it at his 50th birthday celebration at the royal albert hall, i love the new lyrics

  • wow i like it..i think im inlove again

  • It's really good! This voice really suits Katherine, she's still better in this area than the 'pops'.

  • Incredible Karen... a breathtaking performance. I loved it... 5***** and more + favorite

  • search for kiri te kanawa the heart is slow to learn - exact same tune with much better lyrics from about 15 years ago

  • Me too!!! I love the innocence in Sierra's crystal clear voice.

  • sung beautifully tho by KJ..... glen ball looks hot in this video too..lol.

  • our kind of love from beautiful game? its the same tune??????? you must love me from evita? same tune!!!!! Is this the best lloyd webber can do sample his own music?

  • You are joking of course ,this girl fills arena`s .

  • Who is the hunk in the video?

  • absolutely love it!!!! better than the girl who is actually singing it in the musical

  • Excellent. ***** Love the album especially 'fear of falling'. ;)

  • SHE´S TACKY!

  • I love it. I think the show is going to be amazing

  • so happy that music has found it's voice through Miss Jenkins... beauty and talent. look forward to seeing V4Vintage Jewellery in your next shoot.xx

  • I wish she will be the NEW " Christine Dee"!!!~ BRAVO

  • Love Ms Jenkins, hate the song. ALW has lost the plot.

  • Really, Barbie? Really?

  • She's gorgeous x

  • Good work Katherine :)

  • Another lovely song by a lovely lady Thank you Katherine

  • Nice Katerine :)

  • *KATHERINE!x

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more