Twilight cars: book and movie comparison

[AeralinnPink]

THE BOOK IS NEVER THE SAME AS THE MOVIE!!! GET A LIFE YOU LOSER YOU OBVIOUSLY KNOW WHAT 'MISTAKE' MEANS..... YOUR VIDEOS ARE A MISTTAKE! AND HOW WOULD U LIKE IT IF SOME LOSER TRIED TO MAKE UR VIDS LOOK DUMB? OH WAIT ! THEY DONT HAVE TO! U DO IT URSELF!!!! I REPEAT-GET A LIFE YOU LOSER!

[spiderheiress]

@AeralinnPink

Thar be trolls a-lurkin' in these here parts....

[englishbliss]

LOL! u fail vamps DO NOT SPARKLE! get it right!

[spiderheiress]

@englishbliss

If this is the case, then "u fail" as well because you have implied that vampires actually exist outside of fictional/mythological stories.

[englishbliss]

@spiderheiress no vampires do exizt. they are people who kill others and drink there blood! Many people do this. it is normal. so you double fail! xD

[spiderheiress]

NOTE: "whywecnthvnicethings" is my other account, and so if you're confused about getting a reply to a comment from that account, it's me.

[whywecnthvnicethings]

@snowhite1991

If you had read the uploader comments section or looked at the date this video was published, you might have noticed that I made this video a few months before Breaking Dawn was released. Those cars didn't exist in the series at the time.

[Maldonado365]

umm that aint no '92 chevy silverado... TRUST!

that really is a '53...

[whywecnthvnicethings]

@Maldonado365

Argh, read the info... I mentioned that I made a typo in the year. Is it a '53, though? The picture of the '53 that SMeyer had on her website, in representation of the book car, looks less modern than the one in the movie, although they're similar.

[Maldonado365]

@whywecnthvnicethings my bad.. yea its a '53 im very positive it is

[HiVultage01]

I'll take that Jeep Wrangler, although I'm happy with my 1998 Grand Cherokee.

[InvaderAdrianna]

:O u used a perfectly good song 4 twilight? y? twilight is gay!

[spiderheiress]

@InvaderAdrianna

Is "gay" an insult? While I find this use of "gay" immature, I do think the "Twilight Saga" is comprised of badly written pieces of crap. I chose this song because it was by the only band I recognized from Youtube's useable song selection. I'm not an Evanescence fan, though. Amy Lee has a nice voice, but I feel like once you've heard one of their songs, you've heard 'em all.

[Talenastwilight]

what about Bellas before car from Breaking dawn the mercedes 'guardian'? you forgot that one lol, apart from that what you have done is cool.

[spiderheiress]

@Talenastwilight Perhaps you might have noticed the date this was posted: March 18th, 2008. Breaking Dawn didn't come out until August of 2008, so at that point in time, those cars didn't exist in the Twilight world.

[chancetakeone]

Can any one tell me what year Edward's Volvo S60R is? I've looked everywhere and I can't find any site that tells.

[SuperAlicecullen1]

i have a Aston Martian Vanquish to

[larrelander]

sorry eat!!

[spiderheiress]

I never got around to annotating it - it's not really a silverado 1992. It's at the bottom of the info - it's from the 60's-70's.

[larrelander]

jeh right , if that is a silverado 1992, i will it my shoes

[YuilaWinthrop]

DUDE!!!!! i have Edward's car from the book!!! Er. Well my mom does. and it's silver. which makes it exactly edward's car. eep. i just totally love that. lol.

[ilovedillionsmith]

omg what the hell about bellas cars in breaking dawn huh!!!!

[IanWithTheViolin]

In the movie, Carlisle has a Mercedes-Benz S 600, not S550 AMG - it's kind of od, because Bella's "Breaking Dawn" car is suposed to be Mercedes-Benz Guardian, which in reality is actually the same as Mercedes S 600, only that it has some really cool stuff added - it's official name is Mercedes-Benz S-Guard... it's really, really beautiful in black and it's even more expensive (the price is estimated at around 560,000 EUR)... still, I want S 600 (which price is around 170,000 EUR)...

[mirsa001]

for the sneck peck at new moon in and slam jacobs caris black in the movie or yellow i think not red and alices car is the same in the pcture

[1shea13]

I think by changing it from a BMW to a Mercedes shows that the Cullens have a lot of money. I mean, a Mercedes is more expensive than a BMW. Personally, I like the Mercedes better, it looks more...stylish I guess, something that Rosalie would be driving

[JmLova]

the S60R is much nicer than the C30

and bella's 1953 chevy is much nicer than the one from 1992.

and of course rosalies bmw owns the mercedes

[ilovecolinmorganxxx]

u forgot billys car

[Bella34Twilight]

I sooo <3 rosalie's BMW way more than the mersadies

[demilov20]

I like the Volvo C30 better than the book. And the cars from the Twilight Saga really helped me, I know what to get The Mercedes Guardian or if it's not available, I'll just get the 911 Turbo Porsche or The Vanquish

And I love the son Evanescence :D

[cacorkins]

I think you might be mistaken about Bellas truck in the movie vs bellas truck in the book. that doesnt look like a 1992 silverado to me. are you sure its not a 52 or a 62 and you typed 92 by mistake?

[spiderheiress]

Yes, you're right - it was a mistake, and I tried to add an annotation clarifying the actual year, but something went wrong and it didn't go on the video. I think I'll try again, though - I forgot about that.

[cacorkins]

ok cool. I saw that and was like....hmmmm lol

[davellas]

Thanks, Just finished reading the books and I wanted to know what the vanquish looked like! nice! :-))

[TwilightObsessed33]

you forgot the motorcycles :( i like them

[spiderheiress]

Actually, it was just the cars in the video, since the exact models aren't provided in the books and I published this video before they were on Stephenie's site. I'm sorry for any inconvenience, and I'm actually considering taking this video down due to the outdatedness and its general pointlessness.

[SomeAussieChick01]

dont take it down!

i gotta know what car to get when i get my license lol

[PrincessKristina1]

I like the volvo c30 more than the one he actually should have...same with rose, like the movie car better ^^

[ckbabesx]

Someone Could Sit In Between Two Seat Like Alice Since Shes Small And Thinn

[ckbabesx]

See If You Put Alice's Porche I And Edward's Ashton Martin And Jacob's Rabbit In The Video, You Should Have Put All The Cars In The Twilight Series In Cause Even If They Int In The Film They Are Still In The Series. I Like Edward's Volvo Better In The Film, And I Lovee Alice's Porche:O:)

[spiderheiress]

Well, the only cars I don't recall putting in are the borrowed car Jacob and Billy used before Jacob finished the Rabbit and the Breaking Dawn cars, and I made this video before the release of Breaking Dawn (the BD cars are Bella's Ferrari and the Mercedes Guard).

[sexyboi142]

ok ummm bella has the same truck in the movie an in the book

[ckbabesx]

Aww Ok Coolness x:)

[sweetie2597]

did you notice how in the book Edward gives the Cullens rides to and from school but if you look closely the C30 only has 4 seats. How do you fit 5 vampires in a car with only 4 seats (including the drivers seat)

[FOREVER24678]

I know you got most from the sites but the sites I went to didn't have all this... I'm curious how did you find all this out and I don't remember Edward haveing a Aston Martin Vanquish... please refresh my memory. I'd appreciate it.

[spiderheiress]

Edward had a Vanquish in the book; he takes Bella to the prom in it, and it is also mentioned in Breaking Dawn when he lets Jacob borrow it. I wasn't sure if they were going to use it in the movie when I made this video, so I put it in the category indicating that it hadn't been revealed yet. They ended up not using it.

[alannna]

He only took Bella to prom in it in the Twilight outtakes. In the book he did take her to prom in the volvo.

[Lynny740]

gosh.. i love the vanquish!!! definately beautiful... it's edward's favourite car... i think...

[tamarkbloomuedu]

The only change that I hated was the volvo. I did NOT like the one they used in the movie, thought they should have kept it the same, but whatever...

[movieguy103]

i think that emmets jeep looked better in silver then in red and the Volvo C30 was probably only used because it had just came out and Volvo payed the film producers to indorce the C30 which i think is nicer then the S60 but they are both nice

[edwardisonlymine]

The porsche is in new moon! So is the Volkswagen Rabbit! You retard!

[spiderheiress]

Yes, I am aware that the Porsche and the Rabbit are in New Moon; however, when I made this video (quite a while before the movie came out), I was unsure of any possible changes wherein the Rabbit and the Porshe might be revealed within Twilight (there was the possibility - Jacob talks about the master cylinder for the Rabbit in Twilight), and, of course, since they had not been revealed, I put them in the category as such. So, you see, I do not appreciate being called a "retard."

[jamie11097]

No one appreciates being called a retard...

[kellbell45678]

UGH

haven't seen the movie yet...gonna see it today

im really mad about the Volvo!!!

it looks like a mom car:(

EVANESCENCE

ahem, sorry

[dazzLedwardcuLLen17]

nice nice... it gave me a review... because i don't know anything about cars... hahaha.. God bless!

[akaMizzDead]

Haha, its funny. All the Cullens have good cars, and then Jacob's crap car. Made me giggle insanely.

[florchip91]

I had the same prolem as you with the audio

so I deleted the v ideo and uploaded it again with no changes XD

awsome job, really liked he pictures

[ulysse31etnono]

Thanks so much !! I've searching after the Edward' s car in the movie while long time and no way to found... apart your vid !! Thanks again !! I know now that's a Volvo C30 :)

[BonjourLorna]

i think the changes they have made are pretty good tbh.

[missginius]

I really don't want to watch the film, it will destroy my fantasy. Good comparism!But really, who can really play Edward, he is just perfect, there is no guy like him.

[edwardisonlymine]

Your an idiot Robert Pattinson was born to be Edward!

[spiderheiress]

LMAO - you spelled "you're" wrong whilst calling someone else an idiot. I must concur with missginius - Edward is described often in purple prose as "inhumanly beautiful." Expecting a human to look inhuman is a bit of a contradiction, if you ask me.

[Globalwarming706]

You're right AliceCullenBFF they are so not eligible to be on the Nice list! ;D ha ha too bad Christmas is over! heh heh....

[thechefo9]

you forgot bellas ferrari but still it was cool

[Twilight2098]

wow... this wasent stuff i noticed!!!

good catch!!

[loveslostinnocence]

that was really fascinating id never thought to analyze it like that :)

[QuitaWest]

>>answering comments below AliceCullenBFF's. i agree with megcabotlover. in a movie you only get to see what the director and the script writer want you to see. while reading you can take description and turn it into a picture in your head. very good books (like twilight) you sometimes can forget ever reading the words; just seeing the "mini-movie" in your head (carries on below)

[walkerke1]

very nicely done. i spent a few days trying to find this info, i guess that it goes to show that how you phrase your searches matter.

[walkerke1]

very nicely done. i've looked for a few days to try and find this info, i guess it's all in the way you word your searches.

[AliceCullenBFF]

If you are smart dont read any of the comments posted below mine, some of them are vile and rude!

[penquinftw]

Books are obsolete. This is the internet age, GET WITH THE TIMES YOU BUNCH OF BACKWARDS ILITERATES!! why spend 40 hours reading a book that is done in a 2 HOUR MOVIE?? face it guys it's over reading is FINISHED!! in the future i hope to remove reading from school curriculum to maximize efficiency why spend time learning a useless skill??!!!

[megcabotlover]

What the fuck?!? Reading is a useful skill!!! Some things are better when you imagine them instead of just watching what some other person thinks. And what about when you're driving?!? How are people going to read the signs on the road if they take out reading from school?!?! Just because you're some illiterate douche bag doesn't mean you have to screw up other people's future.

[penquinftw]

On the contrary, I'm fighting for equal rights today to advance the human race as a whole. Reading while driving is obsolete, long-winded signs are dangerous distractions that cause crashes.

[megcabotlover]

So you're saying that reading is the cause of car crashes?!? Wow are you fucked up. Reading DOES advance the human race as a whole. By reading, we learn about all kinds of things such as acient cities and how people lived. Reading and writing things down is the only accurate way of knowing things FOR SURE!!! It's so stupid that you think that reading is like the devil or something. Looks like someone needs to go back to kindergarten or first grade!!!

[penquinftw]

History is also obsolete, why learn about useless ancient artifacts when we live in the greatest age of mankind? Books are stuck in the past, I'm helping to advance the human race.

[megcabotlover]

Ugh... go to hell fagot. It people like you that destroy culture and history, everything the humans live for.

[penquinftw]

And it's blasphemous heathens like you destroying the moral fiber of America and condemning us to generations of heresy.

[5665r]

You're a retard!!! If you knew anything about trucks then you would know that Bella's truck in the movie is no where near a 92. It was a mid-60's model!

[spiderheiress]

When I originally made this vid back in March, Summit had just made a casting call looking for a '92 Silverado, and several people had posted on message boards that they had provided that vehicle. Apparently, I was reading the wrong information, and I learned it was a sixties model a few months after posting the video. I thought I added an annotation revising that information, but apparently, it didn't go through. I'll try adding that again.

[thesecretfox1]

seen the movie today WHOO WHOO.the vanquish wasnt in the movie neither was the 911 or the volkswagen

[TwilightNerd13]

You mentioned the rabbit and porsche, but they aren't in the first book (Jacob casually mentions his rabbit, but it's not shown). So of course it wouldn't be in the movie.

[7BillionBelowBand]

So they aren't using Edward's Vanquish in the movie?!? That was my favorite car in the books.

[spiderheiress]

It's unclear right now; they might, but I don't think anyone has found a picture yet.

[rottencat240]

i like edwards car better in the movie :D

[edwardroxmysox754]

that was really cool

[Twilight0304]

Thanks for this??? I am not a car talk person so All I really say were the colors numbers and Brand Hahahahaha Like Bella THANKS

[limxuxu09]

Lol... Car talks... Can't relate... Could not even imagine the cars described in the book... =D

[hayay64]

They got all the cars wrong. How could they do that to Edward's car?! *sigh.

[mrsamandacullen]

ew. mercedes. gross. loved rose's BMW

[unhazy]

*Chevy

Yeah, Bella's truck is definately a '66 Chevy C-10

[unhazy]

Bella's truck is definately not a '92,

It looks similar to a 1968 Checy stepside though. But I'm thinkin' a 1966.

[creativityabsent]

What is the Mercedes used in the movie for ROSALIE!??!

[JoBaa2007]

Carlisle´s Mercedes in the movie is a S550..

It´s sooo amazing, I want to drive such a car!!

(although I even don´t have a driving licence...)

[071XRZ]

the truck in this vid is not a 92, looks more like an early 70s model to me. nonetheless, I agree.

Edward didn't drive an S60 R. It was still too flashy. But it was definetely not a C30. he drove his brothers and sisters to school, so he probably had an 850 GLE.

Carlisle's car is supposed to be an S55 AMG, but it looks like it's going to be an S550. Emmet's JK Wrangler should have been more offroadish. The tires seem too small.

Missing:

Tyler's Sentra

Mikes Suburban?

Jessicas car?

[spiderheiress]

As far as the Silverado goes, I said 92 because the casting company sent an email out to all the site members asking for a 92 Silverado. The S60 R was on Stephenie's site, but I don't know. Maybe it was a misposting.

As for Tyler's Sentra, Mike's Suburban, and Jessica's Mercury, I have yet to see any pictures or gain any information.

[savannahxbannana]

the reason its a different volvo is because when she was writing the book that was the best/neswest one out. and the movie ppl wanted to give edward the newest/best volvo avalible. thats why it is different. b/c the one in the movie is the newest volvo made. =]

cheers

Savvy

[071XRZ]

But the whole point of the Volvo was to blend in. Even a brand new fancy volvo is kind of flashy, especially compared to the other students' cars.

[twilightergal]

Like how much does the Vanquish cost

[Acidlor]

I bet they had lame cars for the vid because the director and producer and such can't like go out buying a ton a great cars. I mean they have money, but they probably don't want to go over the budget with cars that are only going to be seen once or twice.

Now Bella and Edwards car is a bigger issue than say Rosalie's or Emmet's. (grumbles about volvo)

[071XRZ]

you realise that the cars are rented, not bought, right?

Besides, the cars they use aren't lame. They're just as good and fancy, but unfortunately, different.

[AnimalCrossingBeast]

i love the vanquish! it looks really hot! i thought your video was pretty good.! nice job

[MidnightsunsSave]

what is with bella,edward,and rosalie's cars!? LAME! rosalie's isnt even a BMW!!!!!! stupid!

[nuttymadam3575]

im gutted that they made bellas truck newer, that kind of defeats the purpose of the whole 55mph thing, but the rest seem cool, thanks for this! p.s everyone go and see my vids cos im obsessed too!!! lolz.

[MamimiNandaba]

I can't believe they gave Edward an SUV in the movie.

[071XRZ]

they gave edward a C30, which it a hatchback. He used Emmet's car once, which is a Jeep, so maybe you're talking about that.

[MamimiNandaba]

No, no. I know what I'm talking about. The C30 isn't considered an SUV, I guess(?), but it's still the WRONG car. ;=;

[mandamazing015]

that was a gud video. gud job on finding all of those pictures

[broadwaybabe87]

omg Edward is driving a soccer momish car arrrrrrgggg and Emmet has such a pansy jeep srry had to say it, in the book it said that the tires were up to Bella's waist...it's soppose to be pretty monster jeepish grrr.....-.-

[Musiclova556]

Nice video. The Ashton Martin is an awesome car. Wow, you actually have a lot of comments from unknown people... err more like 5 people. I'm trying to be mean or anything.

[jamesterrules]

The s class in the movie is a newer version, and totally different looking. They're redone the body styling in 2007.

[DilNaDiya91]

OMG!! i love the aston martin!! i hope they use it!! ITS SO HOT!!! lol.. the book cars are so much better than the movie cars!!

[spiderheiress]

Yeah, the Aston Marton is one heck of a car!

[DilNaDiya91]

i hope they include it!! lol.. its such an Edward car!! hot car for a hot vampire!! :P

[MidnightsunsSave]

the aston martin is close to $600,000! its also a V12!

[miyuki121]

I can't believe they gave Edward an ugly car!

[koolkitty752]

I'm pretty sure it was a while ago.

[koolkitty752]

That's nice. SOAD broke up you know.

[spiderheiress]

Recently or a long time ago?

[koolkitty752]

MCR's first album is their best by far. And is Megadeth good,or pointless screaming?

[spiderheiress]

Megadeth is good. they, like SOAD, talk about real issues ib the real world.

[koolkitty752]

You still like Green Day?

[spiderheiress]

Not really, but I still have two of their CDs. I'm looking to buy the Megadeth Count Down to Extinction CD as soon as possible, though. And the first MCR CD, I Brought You My BUllets, You Brought Me Your Love

[koolkitty752]

Who says it has to be by MCR?

[spiderheiress]

MCR is the only band whose songs I have imported into my Windows Movie Maker song collection. I'm too lazy to put my Fall Out Boy and Green Day CDs on there.

[koolkitty752]

Whatever. I'm sure there is a good car song somewhere.

[spiderheiress]

Yes, I agree, I just don't happen to have any in my MCR music collection.

[obibz88]

I love the new model of volvo!!!!It's sooooo adorable!!!different, of course...but lovely!

The old volvo was good for edward, but this new model is better for rob!it's more fresh...hard to explain.... :$

[weaselses]

Well, the Porsche and the Rabbit wouldn't come in until New Moon technically.

[spiderheiress]

Yes, that's true, which is why I put that they haven't been in the movie(s) yet; if all goes well, they'll do sequels, although it's uncertain at this point.

[Sophtine]

I miss the S60 R and the BMW M3.

Although it won't make or break the movie, I care. Sadly enough, I do.

[koolkitty752]

I despise this song. He has a good voice,but my god, this is too happy. And nobody cares about cullen cars except for you and your "healthy obsession."

[spiderheiress]

*sigh*

Healthy INTEREST!

I put this song on here because

1. It was on one of Stephenie's Twilight playlists

2. I had nothing better; how could my "dark" songs describe cars?

And yes, other people care also; see all the other Cullen car videos and the comment right above yours!

*glowers*

=)

[Annevamp]

Hey you´re right!!! they should use the same cars, I hope the movie will be succsesfull XD