I saw this in a stream before episode 5 played. Comparing it to roxy146, I'd say yours was better. Not just cause I saw yours first, but I just think you handled it a bit better and made the effects more subtle (having the text being the colours of the pony's mane and pelt, for example).
Though I do like both videos, I love this one over Roxy's for several reasons: (Roxy's was good with the effects & textures, but it didn't have that certain "something" that was in this video)
1. I thought the text that was used (with the coloring) fit much better with MLP:FiM's drawing style
2. FRAGILExOPTIMIST's video is simple. No superfluous effects, just clean cut editing with just the right (not to mention, consistent) transitions/effects. It's my favorite style :)
@adecoy95 Mmhmm, as you can see mine was uploaded at least a week ago; I was okay with it at first, how she gave me credit and all--but seeing as hers made it to EqD too and gets more praise for the effects, I dunno, it kinda bugs me. Along with seeing the same clips being used and song length/remix.
If it makes you feel better, I like yours WAY better. Better timing, better scenes. I watch it at least a couple of times a day. Usually during class to give myself a boost :).
@FRAGILExOPTIMIST In my opinion, both videos are equally good and unique. I just see yours as looking more professional with creativity and tightness, while hers was more extensive with a bigger variety of clips and effects. She obviously put a lot of work into hers, and if there wasn't the similar text animation, it probably wouldn't have been much of an issue. I dunno, I really couldn't see hers being any less similar without making it obviously deliberate and worse in quality as a result. :/
@Ewyndall I can understand that. I just wanted to try out a different title style than I normal used--I probably WONT use those characters in a title again.
@FRAGILExOPTIMIST No prob, I actually loved the look of the characters.
I just tried to search for the video by the title "Discord makes those good fillies go bad" and it didn't come up at all (no wonder). On the other hand some people pointed out I can check the tags and search by that, so "Good Girls Go Bad MLP FiM" works :)
Incredible bonus points for using the Cash Cash remix I was until now completely unaware of. If I posted a video response, it would just me me, jaw dropped, thumbs up.
You know about the overuse of the vertical hold issue. I also think you could have done different typography. Overall mad props for this... perfect choice of song and generally very well chosen clips.
YES! I knew we'd get a fuller version of this song with the Discord eps. ^^ Very glad you waited to get both parts, and I think this is the best one yet.
I like the idea, the song was a perfect fit for the episode(s), and they did a good job picking clips. The constant fluttering on the vertical hold, though, gave me a headache, couldn't even finish watching.
@XxVioletmindxX Critics don't write epic novels after they negatively critique one they didn't like. I simply made a suggestion, less film strip effects. No need to get anally anguished on me. I said it was still good.
@XxVioletmindxX Critics don't write epic novels after they negatively critique one they didn't like. I simply made a suggestion, less film strip effects. No need to get anally anguished on me. I said it was still good.
Comment removed
rockchick184 3 days ago
Discord is forever!
ThePDC17 6 days ago
Comment removed
cheesucaek 1 week ago
¢σσℓ!
TheDevilishangel123 3 weeks ago
He did made them go bad. One redeeming feature Discord shone on.
Warpony9000 1 month ago
<3 discords right tooth
zoro112112 1 month ago
note: i cna thank this video for my bronyfication. thank you Fragilexoptimist!
monkeysontypewriter 1 month ago in playlist Pony powers!!!
Fluttershy: i am getting bitchy, you won't like me when i'm a flutterbitch.
discord: oh... i'm sooooo scared. ha!
(scene removed for extreme violence, see freindhsip is witchcraft for cliff notes)
Twilight: and then there was so much blod we just slid all the way back to town.
monkeysontypewriter 1 month ago in playlist Pony powers!!!
Great Job! I like it!
FanCourtneyTDI 2 months ago
Comment removed
Irati4ever 2 months ago
This is amazing. Keep it up!
GreenChannelCookie 2 months ago
You do know fillys are female child ponies and MAREs are average female ponies, the Mane 6 are Mares, not fillys
spritefan10 2 months ago
Comment removed
IngenueCherry29 2 months ago
THIS IS SO AWESOME LIKE OMG I'M SO STAR STRUCK.
(how did I not think of this. Like wow. *w*)
RainbowSprinkles1001 2 months ago
Liking this vid. Faved and good job. You need to make new vids btw, can't have such skill go to waste.
SapareStoll 2 months ago
WAT SONG IS THIS???? cuz i love it!!!
iamawesomecat 2 months ago
:O ......AMAZING!!!!
cutebutnerdy 2 months ago
Haha You Should''ve Put Celestia In This!
PrincessCelestiaPony 2 months ago
It's just great!! The song very suitable for the video ;) Really a great job!! :D
potypotTV 3 months ago in playlist Liked videos
this song is perfect!!!
and the 5 best friends is frightening matching! :D
shibitheshadowhound 3 months ago
Also, is it bad that I'm starting to like this remix better than the original song?
MewYuki23 3 months ago
I saw this in a stream before episode 5 played. Comparing it to roxy146, I'd say yours was better. Not just cause I saw yours first, but I just think you handled it a bit better and made the effects more subtle (having the text being the colours of the pony's mane and pelt, for example).
MewYuki23 4 months ago
This is truly Amazing.
PMVxJunk 4 months ago
I love this. EVEN the picture jump. :D
StaleOreoCookies 4 months ago
Without all those effects this would have been epic ..
Lovexena 4 months ago
It's eerie how well this song fits Discord:)
deedeethedove 4 months ago
Awesomness , awesomenes everywere :D
ElTigre1Latino 4 months ago
Though I do like both videos, I love this one over Roxy's for several reasons: (Roxy's was good with the effects & textures, but it didn't have that certain "something" that was in this video)
1. I thought the text that was used (with the coloring) fit much better with MLP:FiM's drawing style
2. FRAGILExOPTIMIST's video is simple. No superfluous effects, just clean cut editing with just the right (not to mention, consistent) transitions/effects. It's my favorite style :)
Bioniclefan2468 4 months ago 3
What program did you use to make this video?
Cause it's awesome :)
silly51366507 4 months ago
@silly51366507 Sony Vegas Pro 9.0! :)
And thank you!
FRAGILExOPTIMIST 4 months ago
I think I'm the only one, but I like the picture jump effect.
mameraula 5 months ago
oh wow lol, i checked out your channel after seeing roxygirl146's video and um, these are EXTREMELY similar
adecoy95 5 months ago 6
@adecoy95 Mmhmm, as you can see mine was uploaded at least a week ago; I was okay with it at first, how she gave me credit and all--but seeing as hers made it to EqD too and gets more praise for the effects, I dunno, it kinda bugs me. Along with seeing the same clips being used and song length/remix.
FRAGILExOPTIMIST 5 months ago 12
@FRAGILExOPTIMIST
ahhhhhhhh i are sorry D:
im gonna link to yours at the very beginning of my video kay?
i want you to get the credit for having the original awesomeness D:
RoxyGirl146 5 months ago
@FRAGILExOPTIMIST
If it makes you feel better, I like yours WAY better. Better timing, better scenes. I watch it at least a couple of times a day. Usually during class to give myself a boost :).
cruelfeline 5 months ago 3
@cruelfeline Bahaha, well, thank you! :D
FRAGILExOPTIMIST 5 months ago
Comment removed
WolfPupFairy 5 months ago
Comment removed
WolfPupFairy 5 months ago
@FRAGILExOPTIMIST In my opinion, both videos are equally good and unique. I just see yours as looking more professional with creativity and tightness, while hers was more extensive with a bigger variety of clips and effects. She obviously put a lot of work into hers, and if there wasn't the similar text animation, it probably wouldn't have been much of an issue. I dunno, I really couldn't see hers being any less similar without making it obviously deliberate and worse in quality as a result. :/
timburtonlover369 5 months ago
very good:)
Skittyis2cute 5 months ago
I really liked it. The picture jump made it really trippy, which I think was a good effect considering the content. Discord is the best pony!
abaikgirl 5 months ago
I want this video on my iPod............
linuxmatt 5 months ago in playlist linuxmatt's Favorited Videos
bahahhaa I love how literal and awesome this is XD <3
Keyinei 5 months ago
I liked the TV Simulator effect... This is my current favorite PMV.
BlackWolfe 5 months ago
This is probably the most badass PMV ever.
StarChiii 5 months ago in playlist More videos from FRAGILExOPTIMIST 8
@StarChiii Pfft, thank you. Thank you very much. xD
FRAGILExOPTIMIST 5 months ago
It's almost wrong how well this fits.
CTOONfan1 5 months ago
I think the 'picture jump' is what makes the video perfect. Great job!!
BilkTheDestoryer 5 months ago 4
Please fix your vertical hold.
solarex14 5 months ago
Pat yourself on the back. Awesome job.
Straybow 5 months ago 3
@Straybow *pats self on back* o U o;
Haha, Thank you! C:
FRAGILExOPTIMIST 5 months ago 4
@EviChanxX I really didn't expect this. Seriously.
YOU WERE POPULAR BEFORE I WAS;
with that Nyan Chi. ♥
FRAGILExOPTIMIST 5 months ago
What episode was this?
agwebkinz11 5 months ago
@agwebkinz11 Season Two; episodes one and two! c:
FRAGILExOPTIMIST 5 months ago
am i the only one who is not suprised to see no dislikes...
Gracelyassa 5 months ago
@Gracelyassa You jinxed it.
PokingSealStuff 5 months ago
Masterful kinematic typography.
LoopuleasaIonut 5 months ago
Man, I used to HATE this song. Now it is officially acceptable, thanks to your clever use of ponies. Well done!
cruelfeline 5 months ago
One thing though: I genuily hate the title. The characters used.
You do realize if I want to show this to someone I can't coz it's nearly impossible to find it by searching for the title itself?
Ewyndall 5 months ago
@Ewyndall I can understand that. I just wanted to try out a different title style than I normal used--I probably WONT use those characters in a title again.
FRAGILExOPTIMIST 5 months ago
@FRAGILExOPTIMIST No prob, I actually loved the look of the characters.
I just tried to search for the video by the title "Discord makes those good fillies go bad" and it didn't come up at all (no wonder). On the other hand some people pointed out I can check the tags and search by that, so "Good Girls Go Bad MLP FiM" works :)
Ewyndall 5 months ago
@Ewyndall You could always favorite if you wanted to show your friends. Just saying...
XxVioletmindxX 5 months ago
@XxVioletmindxX Trying to avoid favouriting everything I like. Sounds silly?
Not when you have over 700 vids in there :-/
If I would favourite every pony vid I like, I'm not sure where I would be now XD I tend to download them though :)
Ewyndall 5 months ago
@Ewyndall Actually when you search it uses search tags as well as titles, and since the title in the search tags you'll be able to easily find it. :)
flaimdude 5 months ago
@Ewyndall Well, the tags have the title in normal characters. You should be able to search for it no problem.
PuffOReilly 5 months ago
Superb editing, nice effects, simply awesome :)
Ewyndall 5 months ago
Great song choice and effects. A little overuse on the picture roll, but otherwise VERY impressive.
jippenfaddoul 5 months ago
Incredible bonus points for using the Cash Cash remix I was until now completely unaware of. If I posted a video response, it would just me me, jaw dropped, thumbs up.
linuxmatt 5 months ago
You know about the overuse of the vertical hold issue. I also think you could have done different typography. Overall mad props for this... perfect choice of song and generally very well chosen clips.
KhyrosFinalCut 5 months ago
picture jumps are overused, but damn this fits well. great job!
Fordarz 5 months ago
This is my favorite Pony PMV~
Idk how you made this so amazing but ♥♥♥
The picture jumps were fine for mee
fifipokemon 5 months ago
this fits so perfectly!
specklednoodle99 5 months ago
Ohh you beat me to it! ;_; ! Great vid tho :D love the effects!
PinkieSparkle 5 months ago
@PinkieSparkle Thank you!! :D
FRAGILExOPTIMIST 5 months ago
YES! I knew we'd get a fuller version of this song with the Discord eps. ^^ Very glad you waited to get both parts, and I think this is the best one yet.
This is just *too* entertaining...;P
ckat13 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great work!
LimeyLassen 5 months ago
Great work!
LimeyLassen 5 months ago
its good, but that constant picture jump made my eyes hurt. >-<
MrJackolicious 5 months ago 22
I like the idea, the song was a perfect fit for the episode(s), and they did a good job picking clips. The constant fluttering on the vertical hold, though, gave me a headache, couldn't even finish watching.
datalaughing 5 months ago
Good work, though I agree the screwed up tracking effect was driving me crazy after awhile.
Drelonek 5 months ago
This fits so well its kind of creepy. Good job making the song-show connection, and not a bad PMV either.
Paradox042 5 months ago
Sitting in the corner with my 5 best friends.
HOW
withagun76 5 months ago 120
Sitting in the corner with my 5 best friends.
HOW
withagun76 5 months ago
it's funny because he actually does in the episode
51stSheep 5 months ago
Nice. Although the incessant use of that old film effect got annoying after the first 5-6 times, very nice.
CrimsonWolfe776 5 months ago
@CrimsonWolfe776 Thank you. Ah, I DO see your point there, I'm sorry about that. o:
FRAGILExOPTIMIST 5 months ago
@CrimsonWolfe776 Then let's see you do a better job.
XxVioletmindxX 5 months ago
@XxVioletmindxX Critics don't write epic novels after they negatively critique one they didn't like. I simply made a suggestion, less film strip effects. No need to get anally anguished on me. I said it was still good.
CrimsonWolfe776 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@XxVioletmindxX Critics don't write epic novels after they negatively critique one they didn't like. I simply made a suggestion, less film strip effects. No need to get anally anguished on me. I said it was still good.
CrimsonWolfe776 5 months ago
@EviChanxX Join it. Oh my god, join it. ; v ;"
FRAGILExOPTIMIST 5 months ago
Discord gets all the bitches ;)
WhirlyWillow 5 months ago
was this a orginal song?
iloverock21210 5 months ago
Amazing! Congrats on making EqD btw!
Pearade 5 months ago
@Pearade Thank you! :D
FRAGILExOPTIMIST 5 months ago
Forget party rock anthem, THIS is Discord's new theme music.
profmalicious 5 months ago
Good job on taking a dirty song and giving it a non-dirty connotation :P
Homestar20845 5 months ago 3
LOVE IT. you sir (or madam, i don't know) are epic. THANK YOU.
bananasarehappy 5 months ago
SO SMEXI
XxVioletmindxX 5 months ago
@XxVioletmindxX NO ONE CAN RESIST DISCORD♥
FRAGILExOPTIMIST 5 months ago 2