Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (32)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I just love your version of this beautiful ballad!

  • Nice one. Anachie Gordon was ma Granda by teh way (nae relation). I was just thinkin when ah watched the sunrise this mornin' "there's the sun". Ah can be quite deep at times, but I only speak for masel. A spokesman for no one. Don't put all that crap on me. How can others write books about me,,when ah don't know what ah' m talkin aboot masel, Shuggy Dylan ps Scotland rocks!! Thought ah seen the Loch Ness Monster wance, but jist the wife wi her teeth oot

  • Sorry but the definitive version is by Nic Jones in my humble opinion.

  • Mary's is the first I've heard of this tune. WUMB in Boston played it, and I've been a fan ever since.

    Jeannie

  • Loreena's version is almost painfully beautiful. Thought it had ruined me for all other versions, but this one by Lark and Spur is wonderful. Not as lush a production as Loreena's but that's one reason why I like it. The vocals and lyrics are more up-front and immediate, but still very soft and delicate. Beautiful interpretation!

  • @spankiek - I love Loreena anway.  Have many of her cds. She is golden.

  • 07kyal, Loreena's is the very best. Thanks for mentioning it.

  • i love the british one day might marry a girl from scotland or englend

  • Very nice, I'd also recommend Loreena McKennitt's version

  • Loreena Mckennit's version is my personal favorite.

  • @veelalynne - I love Loreena's version as well, but my top pick is Mary Black.

  • @07kyal

    Yes, i agree with you. I've got the song from Loreena McKennitt - Annachie Gordon on a CD.

    It's so beautiful!! =D

  • mary black does it the best, but this is ok too

  • Very good rendition of a great Scottish song.

  • Really nice performance.

  • This sounds so great. I think it's just as good as the Loreena McKennitt version.

  • argg cant find sinnead o conners version

  • Its on The Sharon Shannon Collection 1990-2005

  • sinead o' conor would not do REAL justice to this song, sorry,

  • anyone have any idea wherei can find a CD/cassette recording of mary black singing this?

    ill be very gratefull if yiou can help!

  • Its on the Best of Mary Black -- 25 Years, 25 Songs.

  • how can you reference Sinead O'Connor without mentioning Mary Black???? Sadly its not on youtube, but she sang the defininitive version of this number during a Christy Moore gala for irish tele about 1980, most moving thing i ever heard. Only scolding for the lack of Black, in all other respects i mean alot of respect, this is a sweet version. Bravo!

  • Didn't know that Mary had recorded it. Have amended the description to include her.

  • @Larkandspur - Mary Black's version is the first I'd ever heard of this song. The best, in my opinion!

  • @Larkandspur - Oh, you've GOT to hear Mary Black sing this one. It's my favorite version hands down!

  • we have the lp of that!

    christy moore and friends, would lopve to find the CD for my mum and dad!

  • Thumbs up educution - agree that Mary Black's version stopped this RoryGallagher/Thin Lizzy fan in his tracks back in the early 80s (off the "Christy and Friends..." album). Amazing emotion. Well done LarkandSpur; great version of a great song.

  • @educution it's on YouTube now: watch?v=dN2tAU5J0mg

  • @NSResponder thank you, i'll probly need a couple of glasses of waters rehydration after this to compensate for my leaky face.

  • @educution Actually the Mary Black version is on youtube.

    Lewbook

  • this is great...but why does it only have the beginning of the song?

  • Just so you know, I think your version is better than the "professional" famous singers whove done it. Please keep making recordings!

    Happy 2009.

  • BEAUTIFUL!!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more