Hey guys Ryan Malcolm here I'm the skinny guy in this vid... wow so many views. Thank you to whoever put this vid up. I want to apologize for the jokes. That was a while ago. My band Low Level Flight have just released our fourth top ten video here in Canada. It's called Cash Machine. Check it out. Again Really appreciate all the comments! Ryan Malcolm.
Awesome! Start the two man cover band "Shy Man and Girth Knuckle" (Audibly virtually indistinguishable from the real deal) and make millions. If this works I'll take a check signed by Girth Knuckle; which is payment in itself because I would be the owner of a signature by someone named Girth Knuckle. Anyhow, I digress. I will keep a look out though. Ya know, there was a German named "Helmut Zucker" so Girth Knuckle could actually be like the "John Smith" of Denmark... Yep, I just sharted...
Bloody phenomenal. Great voice guys. Do agree with other's comments though. A little bit of respect for such a beautiful song, and you would have earned my respect.
Singers?go fu*k yourselves.This is it? The sound of silence..yeah sure..uhm canadian IDOL they say?probably Canadian Idiot- just another "cool" yuppie with soft skin and "wetlook" hair. I can see,you have no idea about what the song really is,maybe you feel like the rest of the world would laugh at you if you sang it a bit..with some feeling? The song itself,is sad,serious..hurts me. other words: S&G rock! ('course if you know who that is..)
I didnt say they're bad singers.I just dont like the way they express the lyrics.They have NO IDEA what they're singing,the song was composed soon after JFK was shot and it contains a lot from those times..And those IDOLS ...lol..feel to tired to explain this,everyone's different.they're both good singers,just sadly thats' all they know ...
Agreed, they are great singers and have give an epic performance. But, the guy on the left especially, is almost making a mockery of such a beautiful beautiful song
How can the one person disagree and state that they 'have said numerous times that there is no basis behind the lyrics?....or something along those lines.... If that person ever watches YouTube *LOL* they can clearly see Art explain that this song is about a breakdown in communication between a couple..........
Disagree Simon and Garfunkel have said numerous times that they wrote these lyrics with no meaning behind them, I think they sing it amazingly and they capture the haunting-ness of the song.
I find myself coming back to this video everyday. I watch it...I listen to it and then I sing it while I'm at work. If I could have a ton of money OR a voice that could move people like these 2 gentlenmen.....I'd be broke but oh so happy! Incredible and breathtaking...thanks for posting!!!
Mr Nahumrahim,do you really know what you are talking about you do chat some crap,i suugest you listen to the original,its called singing in different keys you muppet,as for the singing i thought you was excellent and not a note was missed fantastic NEIL...... NAHIM WALKING KNOB
Ok, they've got great voices... but the left side guy is out of tune in some pieces... for he maybe wants his own show... I rahter listen to the right side buy, sounds better.
Ok, they've got great voices... but the white tshirt guy, is out of tune in somes peaces... for he maybe wants his own show... I rather listen to the other guy.
Awesome and a half! I found myself wondering how this would sound with a beat-boxer though. Perhaps this is just from juxtaposing other A Capella videos I've been watching during the last couple hours. Who knows.. again. Nice work.
its well done... if i wasn't watching it. why is that guy doing stupid moves?! its not that funny! anyway, i'll give it a good rating because of the content, not the video!
Yep. He actually left and is coming out with a new album.
The silly acting kind of got to me as well. It is a very somber song, I believe is the adjective you were looking for. Kind of ruined the mood. That being said, you don't know who his audience was and that can affect whether he's comfortable simply leaving it as somber or not.
I know who his audience was - it included some of his family members and other people he knew quite well. I think his goofiness is his way of showing off his personality and flavour while still singing really well, and I think it was his decision whether to leave it as somber or not. Either way, it still sounds good.
This is a very beautiful and serious song. The harmony is rare and wonderful, but I don't understand why the one young man found the need to demean the song by acting foolish,and disrespectful. If he hadn't behaved in that manner, I could see a record company being interested in them as a duo!It's very unsettling to hear the laughter when you are just listening to the song without the video.
yea, not bad but the position of the camera might have picked the counterpart over the melodic line. Im so used to listening to it with a guitar tho lol
great job
Veldent 3 days ago
so sick!!!
DColeman138 4 months ago
Great Job
tuckert96 8 months ago
Hey guys Ryan Malcolm here I'm the skinny guy in this vid... wow so many views. Thank you to whoever put this vid up. I want to apologize for the jokes. That was a while ago. My band Low Level Flight have just released our fourth top ten video here in Canada. It's called Cash Machine. Check it out. Again Really appreciate all the comments! Ryan Malcolm.
lowlevelflightmusic 8 months ago 5
Awesome! Start the two man cover band "Shy Man and Girth Knuckle" (Audibly virtually indistinguishable from the real deal) and make millions. If this works I'll take a check signed by Girth Knuckle; which is payment in itself because I would be the owner of a signature by someone named Girth Knuckle. Anyhow, I digress. I will keep a look out though. Ya know, there was a German named "Helmut Zucker" so Girth Knuckle could actually be like the "John Smith" of Denmark... Yep, I just sharted...
purdumj 1 year ago
This could have been a great performance!!
They have the song & sound to perfection.
I wish it had been done without all the silly antics
and laughter, Thanks for posting, see ya bye
borncountryful 1 year ago
the jokes were totally uncalled for! besides that it was a great performance!
mevitorino 1 year ago
This is incredible. Perfect pitch...
I'd love to see these guys live. It's awesome.
purelivingmusic 2 years ago
Muss das immer wieder hören, gerade der Anfang ist so stimmig :)
Vampierella80 2 years ago
toll!
Vampierella80 2 years ago
These guys are great!
pibby53 2 years ago
Saugeil, schweres Lied aber sehr gut gesungen.
zoran06 2 years ago
The guy who does the alternate voice (not lead voice) is a bit too loud. But otherwise it's all good.
foucker2 2 years ago
Comment removed
Vampierella80 2 years ago
actually amazing
Degreesify 2 years ago 8
the guy on the right is perfect but the guy on the left with the glasses kills it meaning bad like the guy on hte right should do it by him self
123123321321321321 2 years ago
lol and the guy on the left won the canadian idol lol
hoteba 2 years ago
This was actually very good xD
Airforce9999 2 years ago
hard song to sing as we all know it...
v3mol 2 years ago
not for every one... altough i CANT sing on pantera..... !
MxRyder19 2 years ago
i like cake too..........
v3mol 2 years ago
Very good!!!
grayfoxxx1 2 years ago 3
Extremely well sung, but it's such a powerful song I could have done without the goofy acting.
drjekyllmshyde 2 years ago 13
seriously
jesustokesxx 2 years ago
very nice !! howmuch?>
usmcalx 2 years ago 2
well done ... thanks for sharing
beachcomber20 2 years ago
very well done...love it :)
nurd95 2 years ago 2
I'm amazed, what a truly good take on the song!!
pjhailes 2 years ago 2
GOOSEBUMPS
daveclassicrocks 2 years ago
Excellent!
JWNESTA 2 years ago 2
very good job
fluffy1255 2 years ago
WoW :)
4u2me3 2 years ago
great cover
minitouris 2 years ago 2
PERFEKT!!! WoW
PoisonSin 2 years ago
Excellent! I'd have liked to have seen that show!
ironmtnangel 2 years ago
Good Work!!
Hardie79 2 years ago
Wow! oô
BlackXAnqel 2 years ago
Verry good (5/5) but i search the right song so u can add anything in the title next time
Sorry for the broken english i'm german.
HackerinyourPC2008 2 years ago 2
Goooooooooood Nicos
ouzo1power 2 years ago
these guys are great
finefilth 2 years ago
TRop beauX ^ ^
LaughingAdmiral 2 years ago
Amazing Voices!!! 5/5
kodekai 2 years ago
holy shit... this is great O_O;;
simoc69 2 years ago
exelente, felicidades muchachos
titipaco 2 years ago
too good
u are great
Sidartha84 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If you like this song,
watch my video of my twin and I performing it!
and let me know wat u think!
brandonacker 2 years ago
I hate when people wear a tie and T-shirt. like WTF man? u look like a idot, but can sing well anyways.
moonstomper13 2 years ago 6
a idiot*****
AN Idiot
typo?
JustinBouvier 2 years ago
yep typo. so what u got the message. ;)
moonstomper13 2 years ago
errrrr... nothing at all.
sorry.
JustinBouvier 2 years ago
fucking whore voice in the background destroys any possible way this tune hits like it should..
VikingUndetected 2 years ago 2
natural, musical, simple, powerful voices yet power with discipline.
lookscudkill 2 years ago 3
I loved it!
RainbowShock 2 years ago
chill out guys
HereIamWhatNow 2 years ago
Not bad, would better if it wasnt in american accents.
Snoopo 2 years ago
are you fucking retarded? simon and garfunkel themselves are american you idiot.
lomax555 2 years ago
You must some fucking idiot.
Snoopo 2 years ago
He's right you know
popsickle59 2 years ago
Snoopo - lol. Just lol.
ekhangel 2 years ago
Beautiful
HereIamWhatNow 2 years ago
love. this. shit.
jhayes113 2 years ago
Dat was pretty good
shtulic 2 years ago
This was cool (:
snuttjessi 2 years ago
i like like like it
valamint 2 years ago
you people are crazy ... the song was sung well and they where obviously enjoying themselves.
Draconjager 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sorry but one of you need to keep practicing can't hit the high notes perfectly
thenenini 2 years ago
That's it! The high notes, seriously...
VorpalDerringer 2 years ago
Not bad at all - good harmony on the bridge
penntocali 2 years ago 3
Forever...
Alanss27 2 years ago
Bloody phenomenal. Great voice guys. Do agree with other's comments though. A little bit of respect for such a beautiful song, and you would have earned my respect.
filostylez14 2 years ago 4
nice ... NOT. what u need to mock them for?
papaginseng 2 years ago
These guys managed to bastardize their beautiful rendition of it. Shame.
AVideoC 2 years ago
good voice.. but they disrespected the song..
fukin fags
kukie1000 2 years ago
maybe next time dont mock them. other then that it was great!
pinkhaze4200247 2 years ago
WOW!
nategwinn 2 years ago
this game me the chills
Greatbuilds 2 years ago
this is the best ive heard since simon and garfunkle.. haha love it
sme411 2 years ago
AWESOMENESS!!!!! THank you so much for sharing!!!!
danslilkitie83 2 years ago
This is wonderful!
serabi87 2 years ago
Apparently this is not an easy song to sing well. This is the best cover I've heard on YouTube.
pyrobryan 2 years ago
this sounds great :D nice job
NearTheDark 2 years ago
Amazing....!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
GAM1AS21 2 years ago
this is a great cover. Good job. 2 thumbs up!
kwallace2122 2 years ago
Great!
Web57ess 2 years ago
INCREÍBLE!!!!!!!!
mauroariel84 2 years ago
i cry when i hear this *wimpers*
GuildOfAssassins 2 years ago
Wow!!! What a vocal...! Wonderful.
wildhueter 3 years ago
pure 0wnage
Baumschul 3 years ago
They're amazing.
SirNatann 3 years ago 2
nice ;]
Magorlos 3 years ago
Saw this show back in 2004 - overall a fantastic night and this number was a real highlight
linterkat 3 years ago 2
Singers?go fu*k yourselves.This is it? The sound of silence..yeah sure..uhm canadian IDOL they say?probably Canadian Idiot- just another "cool" yuppie with soft skin and "wetlook" hair. I can see,you have no idea about what the song really is,maybe you feel like the rest of the world would laugh at you if you sang it a bit..with some feeling? The song itself,is sad,serious..hurts me. other words: S&G rock! ('course if you know who that is..)
btwSavior 3 years ago
I thought these guys were amazing. Can you sing like that? Prally not even close. Great job guys. Very entertaining. Some people are such critics...
kgeemonee 2 years ago
I didnt say they're bad singers.I just dont like the way they express the lyrics.They have NO IDEA what they're singing,the song was composed soon after JFK was shot and it contains a lot from those times..And those IDOLS ...lol..feel to tired to explain this,everyone's different.they're both good singers,just sadly thats' all they know ...
btwSavior 2 years ago 4
Agreed, they are great singers and have give an epic performance. But, the guy on the left especially, is almost making a mockery of such a beautiful beautiful song
Trident2010 2 years ago 2
How can the one person disagree and state that they 'have said numerous times that there is no basis behind the lyrics?....or something along those lines.... If that person ever watches YouTube *LOL* they can clearly see Art explain that this song is about a breakdown in communication between a couple..........
nategwinn 2 years ago
Disagree Simon and Garfunkel have said numerous times that they wrote these lyrics with no meaning behind them, I think they sing it amazingly and they capture the haunting-ness of the song.
seanharv610 2 years ago
UR a Moron....but I'm sure you've heard that before......
nategwinn 2 years ago
awesome job guys, but i still like the original slightly more probably b/c voices have different timbre
NIGHTMAREuki 3 years ago
why are they acting retarded while singing this? its a serious song. not a joke. not meant to be laughed at.
they are really good singers, but thats just how i feel about the song.
mastrauzi 3 years ago 5
nice powerful voices; GOOD JOB!!
Andreasmarien1987 3 years ago 2
Holy crap that was awsome! 5 stars from me and instant favourite! Good job....Amazing voices! 3 mins and 7 seconds of my life well spent.
Spoofkill 3 years ago
Those gentlemen sure know how to sing.
Imsokun 3 years ago 2
amazing
gfdsaasdfg1 3 years ago 3
love this version!!!! Awsome Job!
DartsChick28 3 years ago
great!
aaronphomin 3 years ago
What an excellent rendition of this classic. This video was instantly added to my favorites. Wonderful job!
MrJackGrayson 3 years ago 2
Incredible .. Ryan is HILARIOUS.
mcdonald4444 3 years ago
I find myself coming back to this video everyday. I watch it...I listen to it and then I sing it while I'm at work. If I could have a ton of money OR a voice that could move people like these 2 gentlenmen.....I'd be broke but oh so happy! Incredible and breathtaking...thanks for posting!!!
cagekicker18 3 years ago 3
that was incredible!!
philip15philip 3 years ago
so great!
millibelle 3 years ago
i like how the obbligato is louder than the melody. great job
elansargelmir 3 years ago 4
To do that that effortlessly really does take something. Excellent.
Kingfisherswift 3 years ago 3
very nice sound. the harmoney is great. keep up the good work guys.. thumbs Up
lizacat 3 years ago 5
really good voices
thadudekenny 3 years ago 3
Stunning Stunning Stunning! Better than the original.
911928944 4 years ago 3
unplugged and live. Great voices, realley grest... funny performance....
blondbaer 4 years ago 4
That was way better than the original. I thought the original was good but, this was awsome. Should release it.
IamHLO 4 years ago
That was way better than the original. I thought the original was good but, this was awsome. Should release it.
IamHLO 4 years ago
Sweet job on that guys, nice! :)
Malachi1979 4 years ago 4
I love this interpretation. Thanks for doing it justice.
Art.
SatanAndGarfunkel 4 years ago 5
I'm speechless.................awesome!!!!!!!!
cagekicker18 4 years ago
GooD CooRdinatiOn & BlendinG ^^^
batangSM 4 years ago 3
Fantastic!!!! will have to try this with my bro.
johnnysheehy 4 years ago 2
Wow. I always knew Ryan rocked, but his Regean kicks ass too. What a nice coincidence that two step brothers have such a good melody.
adawn 4 years ago
Mr Nahumrahim,do you really know what you are talking about you do chat some crap,i suugest you listen to the original,its called singing in different keys you muppet,as for the singing i thought you was excellent and not a note was missed fantastic NEIL...... NAHIM WALKING KNOB
Jacqkerry63 4 years ago 2
wow not bad guys, wish I could sing like that hahaha
adampope64 4 years ago
Lovely.
Anyone know what these guys are doing now?
Pussycat777 4 years ago
Well, as you probably know, Ryan won the first year of Canadian idol, i believe four years ago, so i don't know what he's up to now.
megankalu1 3 years ago
beautiful, I love S and G but that´s killing the original
PavelOFoverhype 4 years ago
Ok, they've got great voices... but the left side guy is out of tune in some pieces... for he maybe wants his own show... I rahter listen to the right side buy, sounds better.
nahumrahim 4 years ago
Lol, the show actually is the guy on the left. The guy on the right is his stepbrother, who's usually a background vocalist.
changingstillme 4 years ago
Ok, they've got great voices... but the white tshirt guy, is out of tune in somes peaces... for he maybe wants his own show... I rather listen to the other guy.
nahumrahim 4 years ago
Awesome and a half! I found myself wondering how this would sound with a beat-boxer though. Perhaps this is just from juxtaposing other A Capella videos I've been watching during the last couple hours. Who knows.. again. Nice work.
Cheers
Omidon4 4 years ago
flawless
pwt18496 4 years ago
car estigui a capella està prou bé
thegreatvoice 4 years ago
lovely lovely! =D
beautiful voices
IvyRomi 5 years ago
Is it just my volume, or are they singing this soft song way too loud...? o.O
Takuske 5 years ago
I live in Ryan's hometown and I don't know what happened to him. He's so good. I think that's his brother, Regan.
Diana5230 5 years ago
its well done... if i wasn't watching it. why is that guy doing stupid moves?! its not that funny! anyway, i'll give it a good rating because of the content, not the video!
Gramood 5 years ago
wow this is so amazing
Powerlala 5 years ago
kills the original
thosewerethedays 5 years ago
Those guys are great!
bilbopooh 5 years ago
Yep. He actually left and is coming out with a new album.
The silly acting kind of got to me as well. It is a very somber song, I believe is the adjective you were looking for. Kind of ruined the mood. That being said, you don't know who his audience was and that can affect whether he's comfortable simply leaving it as somber or not.
heliosrest 5 years ago
I know who his audience was - it included some of his family members and other people he knew quite well. I think his goofiness is his way of showing off his personality and flavour while still singing really well, and I think it was his decision whether to leave it as somber or not. Either way, it still sounds good.
changingstillme 5 years ago
God forbid you have a little fun while singing. And the younger guy does have a contract. He's the first ever Canadian Idol..isn't he?
jerova 5 years ago
This is a very beautiful and serious song. The harmony is rare and wonderful, but I don't understand why the one young man found the need to demean the song by acting foolish,and disrespectful. If he hadn't behaved in that manner, I could see a record company being interested in them as a duo!It's very unsettling to hear the laughter when you are just listening to the song without the video.
musiclover7777 5 years ago
Nice voices! I especially like the part where they sing at 1:35-1:40, but it would be better with guitar. Nevertheless, it was excellent.
Tikitak7 5 years ago
hey u could u this as like a vocal track and play guitar along to it if u hate singing! thats awesome
WatchingTheWheels 5 years ago
Zseniális. (Brilliant!)
shepardy 5 years ago
SOUNDS COOLER THAN THE ORIGONAL
KurtNilsen 5 years ago
fantastic! thank you sooooooooo much its such good singing
abbiev 5 years ago
Brilliant! Thank you for sharing..lovn it!
thosewerethedays 5 years ago
this is good actoually.
crudemood 5 years ago
yea, not bad but the position of the camera might have picked the counterpart over the melodic line. Im so used to listening to it with a guitar tho lol
kevylei 5 years ago
the girl with the camera was sitting in the front row, far FAR left, she couldn't help it. she did the best she could.
changingstillme 5 years ago
Understandable :), i was just making a note, still a good job.
kevylei 5 years ago
great singing... needs guitar?
zelshark7 5 years ago
it's called "a cappella"... meaning only vocals.
changingstillme 5 years ago
that was awesome both singers were great
danman3514 5 years ago
wow they both sound great thankz you rock so do ryan malcolm yeah you 2 rock u2 rok..
21494 5 years ago