Wing Chun Vs tai chi

[nordastelo]

Baguazhang.



[ninjamaster2995]

That was more of baguazhang than tai chi I believe.

[tung9082]

not taichi

[alvincorbett1]

not very good bagua

[tonyteh]

requesting guide? lol

[MrEmilio1980]

Ba gua zhang, not tai chi....

[lemurex]

tai chi y ba gua son taoistas, ambos se realizan sobre un ying-yang de gran tamaño. al ba gua tambien se conoce como PA CUA que tambien es el nombre del octagono donde aparecen los 8 trigramas con el ying-yang dentro.

no se porque no tiene audio este video

[Sosalx]

maybe in that kind of setup wing chun is more useful?

[tupanatato]

not tai ch, it's bagua

[shougoo7]

this is not tai chi. it is ba gua.

[jimmyiak]

excellent martial art choreography, but it is not tai chi.. It is bagua..

[STLPLEASURE]

This is BaGua...BaGua doesn't look nothing like Tai Chi...The structure is all together different. Anyone who has practices these arts would Know!

[msnanchung]

that is not tai ji quan--- that is bagua zhang.

[Warkiam]

This is bagua....>.>

[likliufu]

omg this is not tai chi ...

[MrErszenyKrisztian]

This is not tai chi, this is a simple hard styled kung fu :)

[Serathiel]

bagua



[karasu0]

fung hark on!

[certiful]

is it really tai chi ??

[KelGhu]

@certiful No, it's Wing Chun vs Bagua Zhang.

[certiful]

@KelGhu

ah ok !! but Bagua Zhang looks like Tai Chi

[KelGhu]

Tired of people posting without knowing what they are talking about... And in my book, Bagua Zhang is superior to Wing Chun at high level. Wing Chun is better at low level. And, of course, at the highest level, both are equal. :P

[DonMega187]

@KelGhu always depends of the practitioner. everyone progresses at different speed, and most never attain highest level because of limitations. except the individual highest, but usually not even that. also some styles suits certain persons better than others so one should try several until her finds one that suits him, and then ultimately no matter which the chosen style(s) may be at highest level one will customize it to be more of a personal style. this is common for many martial arts

[KelGhu]

@DonMega187 I partially agree here. Like Yan Chang-Fusaid, most people that do external styles cannot understand the power of softness because they don't believe in it. Most external practitionners cannot meditate and do not do Qi Gong (they just don't have the willpower). They are limited by their own thinking and will never reach a high level. Though reaching mid level is very easy with external styles giving them the feeling they know, whereas it is difficult in internal style.

[RevenZan]

@KelGhu i totally agree with you, in my neijia quan training the few times a technique has been successful both myself and my practice partner have had no idea what happened(they, through a successful technique flooring them and myself not having a true grasp of the internal power)

[DonMega187]

@KelGhu always depends of the practitioner. everyone progresses at different speed, and most never attain highest level because of limitations. except the individual highest, but usually not even that. also some styles suits certain persons better than others so one should try several until he finds one that suits him, and then ultimately no matter which the chosen style(s) may be at highest level one may customize it to become more of a personal style. this is common for many martial arts

[Liynfan]

Сам ты нахуй Тай Чи! Это БАГУА!

[sweetscience1988]

to be fair to the uploader its an internal style

[AbsolutHartred]

it's not tai chi....is a scene from the movie''Yip Man 2''

[ryansang126]

go ip man



[TheRiadyqiu]

stupid... this is baquazhang

[Guanyu1kill]

Why must he turn and turn and turn?

[MrOphachew]

Mislabeled thats not Taiji its BaGua the guy in darker close is doing.

[SuperKumantong]

yah.. is bagua... not tai chi

[Mikegoody86]

OH nice video, but yeah it`s baguazhang instead of Taichi, WC Taiji, Bagua.　it`s Practise and training that sets the styles apart isn`t it.

I mean one week of WC training isn`t gonna beat 22 years of Taichi hardened battle experience. It`s not the name on the t-shirt, it`s how much wear is on the sleeves. something like that no?

[ukguy]

That is very poor imitation of BaguaZhang not TaijiQuan. I really enjoyed the Ip man movies but this fight really annoyed me, The person supposedly doing Bagua is really very poor.

[hide1920]

什麼太極

這明明就八卦掌

[penator]

that is not tai chi. the animal style of that is dragon.

[rawguan]

FYI: The style used for this particular fight scene against Wing-Chun is BAGUA ; it was the same style used in Jet Li's THE ONE.

[MechPhantom]

wing chun vs tai chi ? of course wing chun al the way, wing chun kicks all others kung fu's asses

[meow91able]

@MechPhantom Stop saying wing chun is better then others cuz it all depends on the fighter it self on how well it use it.Stop giving kungfu a bad name.

[MechPhantom]

@meow91able haha ok , but for me wing chun is the best no doubt , best kung fu too

[Terryltk]

too bad this movie belittles so many other martial arts.. no disrespect to wing chun.. i am also learn wing chun.. but sometimes these movies send out the wrong message and wrong perception.. wing chun is same like all others martial arts.. it all depend on the martial artist how he learn and train the body..

[Enadkire]

@Terryltk it doesn't belittle. the way the martial arts community in hong kong was structured at the time something like this may have well taken place. and if you watched the first film he always said it is not the style it is the man. Wing chun just allows a person to learn to defend themselves effectively in a short time. And donnie Yen is not even a true wing chun stylist. He is a kung fu/wushu expert who trained from ip chun for the movies.

[NebularImplosion]

it's been said 20 times already, it' bagua...

[Eryaloke]

Yes, Bagua zhang.

[shengchenfan]

Ba Gua

[tummygum]

not tai chi ba gua

[bitter4umate]

that guy was doing Bagua not taiji..dumb ass.

[Lesterishere]

lol how is this taichi ? LOL checkout his footwork

[asgarthhh]

This is not Tai Chi this is bagua. Uploader please change the caption.

[videoroller1712]

Ip man is the best he trained Bruce lee! And wing chun is an amazing style I wish I knew it ;p

[ejchang0708]

詠春 vs 八卦 才對 改一下吧

[2jgard]

It had to be theatrical for the sake of the movie, and so that the movie can appeal to a wider audience. Bagua and Wing Chun might actually work well together.

[thefallenone600]

This movie's bad ass...

[kakashibest134]

Thats not Tai chi

[RobeeMan]

Definitely ba gua.

[mrascoop]

thats not taichi its baguazhang

[schulleee]

tai chi ??? isn´t that rather bagua ??

[peterczc247]

i dont think this is tai chi.

[2jgard]

A very stylized and theatrical version of both arts. Wing Chun and Bagua that is. Unlikely that a real fight would be that stylized.

[sickness324]

@2jgard Actually Wing Chun, is a bit theatrical, but Donnie Yen's portrayal of it is a very possible rendition of the art. The realism isn't in the form or the application but rather at his reaction speed. I don't think I've ever seen someone with the quickness and reaction speed Donnie Yen portrays in the film.

[cfG21]

bagua but a very bad version of bagua

[bboyrulz]

O_O wut movie??

[mudkipzuzu]

@bboyrulz Ip Man 2.

[Lamont24012]

Thats not Tai chi chuan thats Baguazhang . The same style as the last air bender.

[lilgogeta]

thats not Wing chun vs Tai chi chuan

but Wing chun vs Baguazhang

[mrsphlinda]

Donnie Yen wing chun white shirt

[dxdxmov]

thanks for you information

[arjgro]

It is not Tai Chi but Ba Gua