Neal E Boyd and Paul Potts at The Beacon Theatre NYC

[lindalds]

I wish they had harmonized.

[gotglasses]

Neal has a clearer high note, Paul carries the C longer than anyone, but Pavarotti at their ages did it effortlessly at High C. The few times I heard him at the Met were memorable.

[mulkkujoonas]

paul potts faced his worse enemy and lost,big time.... neal e boyd got so much better sound and so much more power, there's no competition between...just wish neal sings sometime finlandia,gotta be great....

[vetteagain]

An absolute honor to hear such beautiful, beautiful talent! Thank you very much for sharing!! Just think, we would have been privileged to such talent if not for America and Britain's Got Talent. Wonderful shows. Thx again for sharing this with us!

[dubairadiostar08]

Was Neal only a guest here? I think Paul Potts is the real deal in opera. I never heard Neal E Boyd sang opera again after the AGT-won Las Vegas show, until now. I guess he never was a true-blue opera follower himself. While Paul spends his life now touring the world, including the US, performing what he does best which is opera.

[hansquad]

@dubairadiostar08

Paul Potts cannot be said a true opera tenor yet, he is now a concert artist singing some popular operatic arias and crossover, but no real opera house yet trying to use him. To sing in a real opera full production would be different.

[kinker29]

I think its time for neal to start loosing some weight. Its just not healthy for such a young man or anyone for the matter to be that overweight.He does have a great voice.

[grandmagrumpy]

Neal has a nice quality to his voice, but it's hard to listen when he's flat so much of the time. Paul had to come in and get things back on track.

[kugrad2001]

These voices certainly have their own "color", but no one who has heard them in concert would suggest the Paul, or either of them lack power! The trouble I have listening to Neal is that he seems flat and flatter so often. this tour stopping including this piece, and I wonder if that was why. Hard to sing with someone not quite tuned up. Paul's voice continues to create emotion within me that is unexpected. Neal's voice is moving, but not in the same way

[jsavil]

I agree Neal is better. He also puts more emotion into his songs. I like them both though. I wish I could have been there.

[wonnabeastar]

I'm British and in my opinion Neal is better for me vocally. Paul Potts seems to struggle with the higher notes! The clarity and resonance isn't as nice as Neal's voice. (just an opinion)

[vettespd00]

together they make and amazing show. i think neal is just as good if not better

[vettespd00]

lenegal77, you are so wrong. he is a real tenor!!! amazing

[surpass77]

He is so talented!

[pampurredpuss]

Equally as good, just different.

[lenegal77]

Neal is no Paul Potts. Not even close.

[Dalxien]

@lenegal77

True, but Paul Potts is no Pavarotti.

The point is they're both great singers.