They were partisans and that is not contested by anyone.
The Naliboki massacre was unfortunate. The problem is that no one has presented evidence that it was the Bielsky group as opposed to the multipe Soviet Partisan units.
Why not be an adult and go with actual substantiated facts. Or just wait for the IPN report later this year.
Those "partisants" were Jews and they killed 130 polish farmers from village Naliboki in 1943.. but in this movie thye're presented as heroes! Sure - for Hollywood attacking at 5 o'clock in the morning sleepy civilians and killing them - is a heroism. Why ? Because killed civilians were POLISH ! If killed people would be Jews- then Hollywood wouldn't present their killers as heroes!
D. Craig shows jewish brother Bielski/killer making massacre in Naliboki as a hero! Shame!
@Pankracyogame So what would you have them do? die? Yes, there was a war on, and the Polish Farmers wanted the food for themselves first and the Germans second. What does that make them? I'm sorry they had to die, but I'm sure that many if them would have killed many Jews as well. What about the farmers who shared their food, they were not killed, at least not by Jews! I have distant relatives who told me what it was like in parts of Eastern Europe, it was not easy to be a Jew at the time!
@Pankracyogame Why do say the those partisans were "Jews" why should this make any diference at all? You hate them because they defended themselves, because they were Jews! So mistakes were made by partisans during a war in which they were nearly wiped out, what would you do if your back was to the wall and you were starving? It's okay to kill Jewish children though, just not Polish collaborators! What proof do you have? Were you there?
"You hate them" Wrong brainiac - if anything I despise them as I despise Chaim "let's send our own children to Auschwitz to live 1 day longer ourselves" Rumkowski from Lodz ghetto
They were partisans and that is not contested by anyone.
The Naliboki massacre was unfortunate. The problem is that no one has presented evidence that it was the Bielsky group as opposed to the multipe Soviet Partisan units.
Why not be an adult and go with actual substantiated facts. Or just wait for the IPN report later this year.
BulanSabriel 3 years ago
Those "partisants" were Jews and they killed 130 polish farmers from village Naliboki in 1943.. but in this movie thye're presented as heroes! Sure - for Hollywood attacking at 5 o'clock in the morning sleepy civilians and killing them - is a heroism. Why ? Because killed civilians were POLISH ! If killed people would be Jews- then Hollywood wouldn't present their killers as heroes!
D. Craig shows jewish brother Bielski/killer making massacre in Naliboki as a hero! Shame!
Pankracyogame 3 years ago
@Pankracyogame So what would you have them do? die? Yes, there was a war on, and the Polish Farmers wanted the food for themselves first and the Germans second. What does that make them? I'm sorry they had to die, but I'm sure that many if them would have killed many Jews as well. What about the farmers who shared their food, they were not killed, at least not by Jews! I have distant relatives who told me what it was like in parts of Eastern Europe, it was not easy to be a Jew at the time!
HelgiWartooth777 1 year ago
@HelgiWartooth777
if, had... bollocks
Bielski bandits were murderers, rapists, arsonists...
Memoires of those thugs often mention that they STOLE so much food they send some of it by russian plane to the other side of the front...
And yet they murdered malnourished peasants (women and kids included).
But you jews don't look at facts and alwyas defend such bastards...
Pankracyogame 1 year ago
@Pankracyogame Why do say the those partisans were "Jews" why should this make any diference at all? You hate them because they defended themselves, because they were Jews! So mistakes were made by partisans during a war in which they were nearly wiped out, what would you do if your back was to the wall and you were starving? It's okay to kill Jewish children though, just not Polish collaborators! What proof do you have? Were you there?
HelgiWartooth777 1 year ago
@HelgiWartooth777
"You hate them" Wrong brainiac - if anything I despise them as I despise Chaim "let's send our own children to Auschwitz to live 1 day longer ourselves" Rumkowski from Lodz ghetto
Pankracyogame 1 year ago 3