@icecoldhubbas watched this on the wall tour 2011 roger waters uses this clip and sings a duet with this clip is simply fantastic am sure u will change ur opinion have a listen its listed left side.
A simple question: I ask you - can it get any better than this? And no the answer I'm sorry to say is that it can't - this is truly AS GOOD AS IT GETS. 32 years and counting. Long live Pink Floyd!!
All anybody can tell me about pink floyd is how much LSD they did, i actually think that is an overrated statement, i'm pretty sure they did some type of drug, but people assume they did large amounts of Acid because of there music, you can make really good music and not have to be drugged out.
@thefish389 I don't think they performed, at least in the studio, under the influence. Both Waters and Gilmour are (quality) control freaks when it comes to their music.
this sounds like perfect and real quality sound in my opinion.
the reason why is it feels like your living in 1980 when things didnt always have to be clear but just good enough to understand and to have a good time listening to the music you love. the past is a beautiful thing and pink floyd is the past and future of the music i listen to. RIP syd and rick you guys made this band become what it is and more. your contributions wont be forgotten. to the rest of floyd you guys are still great :)
@Cap285 ...hey man we could at least keep...... justin bieber....!! damn i gotta stop the booze....!!! lol lol....!!!! takecare man...beautifully said
I saw roger do the wall dec. 2010, he had this video on in the background as he followed himself live...gotta say, it was fantastic...closed my eyes...and for a few minutes, it was 1980.
@Imperatorcf yeah...RIP Rick...that fucking douchebag fucked you all over....things were so awesome but fucking diva Rogers destroyed pink floyd forever thanks to this shitty diva album
should we trust the government ...fawk that has been the mistake we have been maken from the start .........both USA .AND CANADA ECT ECT ..............government = control + tax = MODERN DAY SLAVERY
Pink Floyd Live in Oakland 1977 3-disc 2CD/DVD set and Pink Floyd The Wall Live at Earl's Court 1980 DVD available at Tommygun Video please see our Youtube channel for link to web site/video and audio clips/more info
Hey ,how are you all doing ....build that wall ...make 3 feet high /// just big enough that ya can duck behind it ...but not so high that when I come running i can't leap it tuck duck and come up shooting ,,,,helping ya defend it .Love you all ...and those i don't .......well helll why ya think ya we got walls.
Excellant song and so well realised...as anyone who has a possesive mother will know. Perfectly captures that feeling of familiarity alternating with resentment and regression. The real brilliance in Pink Floyd is how well they could convey the gamet of emtions and spaces between in such an eloquant fashion.
chidisima rola esta de pink floy saludos a toda la bandera del centro de la Republica mexicana(recuerdo del concierto de floy en el autodromo hermanos rodriguez 1994)
I had limitted slipped diferentuals against the LSD Doctors medical research into the mind bending examination of the drug prisoners brain damaged life
if only Roger knew then what he knows now....Pink Floyd could have been so much more.... The man for all his 80's faults is a damn genius... Absolutely mesmerizing clip...
@nunkamaimunka I dont know what you're trying to say, but if you're defending pink floyd, dont waste your time. They have been my favorite band since middle school. I was making a joke in saying that all other music sounds like crap compared to them but ou're to stupid to pick up on a fucking joke. By the way, what the hell did you mean by telling me to "go to my mother and shut the fuck up?" Was that supposed to be some kind of joke? It makes no sense, and wasnt funny at all. fuck off
@tff1293 yeah, nothing ever sounds so perfectly empty and full.....and nasty, and promising, and despairing, and hopeful, and bleak...Kinda like life.
I was lucky enough to see this show in 1980.....I also saw Rogers reincarnation of the wall a few months ago...... the 2011 show was visually mind blowing....but in so many ways the 1980 shows were better....31yrs ago it was Pink Floyd performing The Wall and you were acutely aware that you`d seen a band...in 2011 it was a show......1980`s video technology was obviously shit....It`s hard to believe when watching these vids but the stage was lit...trust me the band did`t play in near darkness.
I call 'em idiots who have never seen Floyd or played a guitar in their pathetic lives. Go listen to some shit music fools. Lady Gaga is out there for you
this song always makes me cry. in the concert, 4 days ago, it was fucking amazing. you get a very strong feeling when you see your hero singing those wonderful songs. and i might never get this amazing feeling again.
For someone in my family.......you'll know who u are.......mother do you think SHE'LL break your little boys heart.......oooooohhhhhhh....love ya....."U"
@hollowharmony1 "Um no", what a compelling argument you have managed to conjure up with that complex brain of yours.
Waters wrote most of the chord progressions and came up with the majority of the themes by himself. He wrote "The Wall" and "Animals" almost entirely by himself. All the parts with rhythm guitar, like this song here? He did that. The bass player had to play rhythm guitar because all Gilmour was good for is soloing.
@Inthedeadofknight I don't deny Roger was a significant part of Floyd but to say he is "Pink Floyd" is an overstatement. Everyone did their part to make Pink Floyd what it is/was. And Gilmour's guitar playing/solos was a major part of Floyd's sound. Pink Floyd would not be the same without Gilmour. DSOM is evidence to this.
@hollowharmony1 Like I said, Dave has a beautiful tone and can play his instrument well, but he was in no way the creative mind behind all the revolutionary music that Pink Floyd created. Wright contributed to it and I'm sure Dave did here and there, but the majority of the creativity came from Waters.
@Inthedeadofknight Yeah Roger was probs the main creative drive behind the band. But Dave and the rest were still a significant part of the overall sound of Floyd. Probs not as major as Roger but still important..
Sure Dave has a beautiful tone and could fit within the music Waters and Wright had written very well, but there's a reason that it was possible for Roger to tour The Wall live with someone else in Gilmour's place.
I am in awe of how gentle this atmosphere is. I am reminded of a campfire-lit rainy night that I'm not sure ever occurred, but it's ok. Thanks Pink Floyd.
People are arguying about who's the best person in Pink Floyd, but you don't get the point, Floyd is best as a WHOLE, they wouldn't be near as good if they didn't work together to get where they are seperatly today.
I also can't imagine Roger playing the guitar outro to Comfortably Numb or the start of Run or the end of Sheep or any part of Dogs! There was a Waters-less Floyd. Wrote some great songs as it goes. Each member of floyd played their part, to try to say otherwise is ridiculous. Richard Wright wrote the music for GGITS and Us and Them. Imagine DSOTM without those songs!
Waters was the artistic brains of floyd from DSOTM on. He came up with the ideas, the majority of songs, lyrically and musically and the concept of each album. Also, if it hadn't been for Gilmour singing on DSOTM and WYWH they wouldn't have been so popular. Let's face it
Nooooooooo, ROGER WATERS!!!!!!
Trade for Roger Waters..
www305familyCom 2 days ago
@www305familyCom he's alive....
WYR11 1 day ago
beautyfull song
express the fellings, the emotions
very good , simply perfect
live Pink Floyd , live Waters and Gilmour
RodShut 1 week ago
Who is playing the bass here ? ? ?
corporacionmonstruo 1 week ago
Yeah this is weak. I'm a huge fan but this is bad. I get no feeling from this...
icecoldhubbas 1 week ago
@icecoldhubbas watched this on the wall tour 2011 roger waters uses this clip and sings a duet with this clip is simply fantastic am sure u will change ur opinion have a listen its listed left side.
padorification 5 days ago
Amazing song.
cuerollen 1 week ago
"Big mother is watching you."
RegLeachFan 1 week ago
2:08 NO FUCKING WAY
satinsguard 1 week ago
what a perfect voice he had...
DonConstantinos 1 week ago
@DonConstantinos for roger
DonConstantinos 1 week ago
Pink Floyd fantastic!
cheevous 1 week ago
Mother should we kill Justin Bieber?
MrNinelifecat 1 week ago 2
A simple question: I ask you - can it get any better than this? And no the answer I'm sorry to say is that it can't - this is truly AS GOOD AS IT GETS. 32 years and counting. Long live Pink Floyd!!
eyesthatshine 2 weeks ago
MOTHER WILL SHE TEAR YOUR LITTLE BOYYYY APART!?
frankyh101 2 weeks ago
<3
tehya95 1 month ago
Waters voice is sheer class!!!
raverbaby1 1 month ago
the best song in the world pink floyd rules
pixeluniform 1 month ago
<3 <3 mama's gonna help build the wall
Burkadzee 1 month ago
This mother is building a wall. My son and daughter needs protected forom todays trash that people call music!
Pink is un replaceable!
MyJd1977 1 month ago 3
See Roger Waters rendition of 'Mother' with Katie Kissoon's vocals and compare!
ronninj 1 month ago
@ronninj RW + KK version is crap. The original is the best and this is good too.
mayorc 4 weeks ago
@mayorc A little harsh to call it crap? What is the reason you think its crap?
MrScorpions4ever 1 week ago
Stoned? Drunk? This is dire.....and guess how much we paid for tickets?
ronninj 1 month ago
This was my first Rock favorite hit!
r1u9d4o0lf 1 month ago
Como o tempo passa.
celsosmagalhaes 1 month ago
8 are from goverment.
karza666 1 month ago 7
Both Roger's and David's guitar playing at 4:23 is awesome!
DanW900 1 month ago
YES MOTHER i WILL TRUST THE GOV. WINK WINK!
tbohman1331 1 month ago
it's funny to me how roger looks much younger than david here. idk, whatever
overcomingravity 2 months ago
8 people trust the government...
jonastrkr 2 months ago
@jonastrkr LOL
juegas 1 month ago
All anybody can tell me about pink floyd is how much LSD they did, i actually think that is an overrated statement, i'm pretty sure they did some type of drug, but people assume they did large amounts of Acid because of there music, you can make really good music and not have to be drugged out.
HellsAngelsofNC 2 months ago
@HellsAngelsofNC Based on numerous bios I read, they were more fond of Jack Daniels, thanks to an introduction by Janis Joplin.
bradco6 1 month ago
@bradco6 so they perfomed drunk?
thefish389 1 month ago
@thefish389 I don't think they performed, at least in the studio, under the influence. Both Waters and Gilmour are (quality) control freaks when it comes to their music.
bradco6 1 month ago
Viva Waters larga vida.
FOTOCHOCK 2 months ago
this sounds like perfect and real quality sound in my opinion.
the reason why is it feels like your living in 1980 when things didnt always have to be clear but just good enough to understand and to have a good time listening to the music you love. the past is a beautiful thing and pink floyd is the past and future of the music i listen to. RIP syd and rick you guys made this band become what it is and more. your contributions wont be forgotten. to the rest of floyd you guys are still great :)
gorsodredaxe 2 months ago 3
Comment removed
DanW900 2 months ago
my mother showed me pink floyd.
ice0wn4g 2 months ago 4
@ice0wn4g My mother too
MetalMetalize 2 months ago
@ice0wn4g Mine did as well. While I was inside her.
starryxxxsrdxxx 2 months ago
@ice0wn4g same here,i watched the wall with her
corporacionmonstruo 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Mother should we smoke the joint ? Yeah , and than listen to Pink Floyd and enjoy that weed :D !
MetallicaFan2k 2 months ago
Comment removed
MetallicaFan2k 2 months ago
sorry this isnt earls court you fkin moron
jered79 2 months ago
@jered79 well there are at least 5 other videos that are the same concert that say earls court 1980 so hmm..i guess everyone is wrong and ur not?????
biggiesro1089 2 months ago
Comment removed
DanW900 2 months ago
Mother will they try to break my balls. Yes they did, and it hurts.
falconwings 2 months ago
Comment removed
hereg2007 2 months ago
@SupeNuma
you sir, are cool...
motavation69 2 months ago
Dear God,
We will trade you all of today's 'musicians' for Richard Wright. Please.
Cap.
Cap285 2 months ago 59
@Cap285 only not AC DC
jurciks71 1 month ago
@jurciks71 No way! AC/DC is one of my favorites. Notice how I put musicians in quotations. Highway to Hell is safe my friend.
Cap285 1 month ago
@Cap285 ...hey man we could at least keep...... justin bieber....!! damn i gotta stop the booze....!!! lol lol....!!!! takecare man...beautifully said
Tripl3333 1 week ago
@Tripl3333 Heh. Thank you much.
Cap285 1 week ago
@Cap285 and John Lennon
WestonMattandJimmy 3 days ago
@WestonMattandJimmy That would be sweet too.
Cap285 3 days ago
course i'm gonna see the wall...in austin..on may 3 2012...
motavation69 2 months ago 2
@motavation69 FUCK YEAH!!! ill be there with ya too buddy!
SuperNuma 2 months ago
Lovit
conimulier 2 months ago
course mama's gonna help build the wall...
AMAZING SONG
75rhiannon 2 months ago
I saw roger do the wall dec. 2010, he had this video on in the background as he followed himself live...gotta say, it was fantastic...closed my eyes...and for a few minutes, it was 1980.
RIP Rick...
Imperatorcf 3 months ago 4
@Imperatorcf yeah...RIP Rick...that fucking douchebag fucked you all over....things were so awesome but fucking diva Rogers destroyed pink floyd forever thanks to this shitty diva album
theachtungtree 3 months ago
Isn't this the same footage, unmirrored, that Roger sings along to in the current Wall shows?
SecretTimeWarp 3 months ago
One of the BEST SONGS EVER!
HateIronMaiden 3 months ago
LOVE PINK FLOYD!!!!
pissoff1975 3 months ago
Waters and Gilmour are two of the best at duets EVER..
papacramer 3 months ago 3
should we trust the government ...fawk that has been the mistake we have been maken from the start .........both USA .AND CANADA ECT ECT ..............government = control + tax = MODERN DAY SLAVERY
MrDogoman 3 months ago
Epic, can't live under mother's wing. Down with socialism.
TheWrenaissance 3 months ago
...Excellent!!...
SandGs72 3 months ago
How could anyone dislike this? Maybe they were looking for Danzig.
SeethingGreen 3 months ago 2
8 people do not know good music!
gangstareggae 3 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Pink Floyd Live in Oakland 1977 3-disc 2CD/DVD set and Pink Floyd The Wall Live at Earl's Court 1980 DVD available at Tommygun Video please see our Youtube channel for link to web site/video and audio clips/more info
Tommygun1028 3 months ago
Hey ,how are you all doing ....build that wall ...make 3 feet high /// just big enough that ya can duck behind it ...but not so high that when I come running i can't leap it tuck duck and come up shooting ,,,,helping ya defend it .Love you all ...and those i don't .......well helll why ya think ya we got walls.
copycoonie 3 months ago
Excellant song and so well realised...as anyone who has a possesive mother will know. Perfectly captures that feeling of familiarity alternating with resentment and regression. The real brilliance in Pink Floyd is how well they could convey the gamet of emtions and spaces between in such an eloquant fashion.
BelatedCommiseration 3 months ago
Born too late :'(
uberkelvin 3 months ago 2
ΝΑ ΓΑΜΗΘΕΙ Η ΚΥΒΕΡΝΗΣΗ - Fuck to the Government. Thanks google.
HalfBearPig 3 months ago 2
Mother should we trust the government?... NO FUCKING WAY!!!! great advice , thanks x
rockchic33able 3 months ago 69
@rockchic33able best advice you can give your children
bkre8ive 2 months ago
@rockchic33able So long ago and yet so true today with Hitler in the White House.
youbestbequiet 2 months ago
chidisima rola esta de pink floy saludos a toda la bandera del centro de la Republica mexicana(recuerdo del concierto de floy en el autodromo hermanos rodriguez 1994)
damian121212ful 3 months ago
so glad i caught this before they stopped
nrbnrbnrb13 3 months ago
I had limitted slipped diferentuals against the LSD Doctors medical research into the mind bending examination of the drug prisoners brain damaged life
jamesthelord1 4 months ago
pink voice ♥
Lpsyable 4 months ago
I wish I could go back in time to see this concert
emano05 4 months ago
@emano05 I can! Just by closing my eyes and remembering. :-)
And several other tours...It's one of the few advantages of getting older.
jc333jc 4 months ago
Look for Mother by Dread Clampitt, Live it's stunning
MushBeeguy 4 months ago
3:44=Braingasm
KingPleaseMusic 4 months ago
Beautiful!
edgemontkodi 4 months ago
if only Roger knew then what he knows now....Pink Floyd could have been so much more.... The man for all his 80's faults is a damn genius... Absolutely mesmerizing clip...
Chrisss1222 4 months ago 3
to have been there...
gettyz 4 months ago
do i need to be so high???
aggguy666 4 months ago
Perfeito.
cinthiamaia1 4 months ago
fucking awesome!
christianos34 4 months ago
4:45 If you want to show the keyboardist, at least show the right one...
An0n3mu55 4 months ago
tenia 37 años ahi roger waters!!??? parece qe tiene 20
farmalapampa 4 months ago
If roger waters edited this video, he would have called it: Roger Watters performing mother (with the help of pink floyd)
Z0mByZ 4 months ago
I hate pink floyd for the simple fact that they have ruined all other music for me.
tff1293 4 months ago 3
Comment removed
nunkamaimunka 4 months ago
@nunkamaimunka I dont know what you're trying to say, but if you're defending pink floyd, dont waste your time. They have been my favorite band since middle school. I was making a joke in saying that all other music sounds like crap compared to them but ou're to stupid to pick up on a fucking joke. By the way, what the hell did you mean by telling me to "go to my mother and shut the fuck up?" Was that supposed to be some kind of joke? It makes no sense, and wasnt funny at all. fuck off
tff1293 4 months ago
@tff1293 sorry,misunderstood you,removed comment :-)
nunkamaimunka 4 months ago
@tff1293 yeah, nothing ever sounds so perfectly empty and full.....and nasty, and promising, and despairing, and hopeful, and bleak...Kinda like life.
They break me.
eyesoftheworld0 4 months ago 6
This was the day my MOTHER was killed in a car wreck by a drunk driver!!!!
dixiedad67 5 months ago
Saw them way back at Filmore East 1970 and even without the Wall and the rest that came later they still rocked the house!
DawsonvilleBill9 5 months ago
exelente canción unas de las mejoresss
xinocid 5 months ago
i should be doing homework right now....
hhhmmm ap euro<pink floyd
poopbagell 5 months ago 2
"i'll might like, go to the show!"
TheSantiayo 5 months ago
roger is genius.
magoorock 5 months ago 3
Where can I get some of those awesome headphones?
calif562 5 months ago 2
@calif562 Walmart :)
pinkfloydmamo 4 months ago
inspirational, turned me when I was 16. 24 yrs l8r still LOVE them.
jacko4815 5 months ago
Killer bangs Rog!
mcintomney1988 5 months ago
They never did ANYTHING half azzed. It was 1980 and they were cordless, how can persons NOT adore Floyd everything?????
KristyMusicLoren 5 months ago
life would be shit without Pink Floyd
ernesto06202738 5 months ago 116
@ernesto06202738 i cant explain how right you are sir. well said.
ssilikemarijuana 4 months ago
pink floyd best band in the world
steelypies 5 months ago
Pink Floyd Sucks ... NOT !!!
KREEPNASTY1 5 months ago
@KREEPNASTY1
don't play around like that mang. you could get hurt haha! jk
KingIDMF 5 months ago
@KingIDMF Naw your Right King...I shouldnt even be joking around like that with The Floyd.,...PINK FLOYD ROCKS !!
KREEPNASTY1 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
As in the study, comes out to Roger, great charm bet me on stage, music, guitars, alone, all
jodemi22 5 months ago
Comment removed
jodemi22 5 months ago
lindo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! adoro...
jady3775 5 months ago
Gilmour is God!
PauloASC 5 months ago 3
5 reason to use condom!...
guillaume1022 5 months ago
By far the best version of mother on youtube....waters' voice is simply amazing........none other will be as incredible
kaileighsdad86 5 months ago
I love Gilmours dramatic solo kicking in at 3:44
whangie1 5 months ago
unreal
winnipegjets12345 5 months ago
c est pas mal mon gars, tu l as. lache pas.
monmarc1 5 months ago
I was lucky enough to see this show in 1980.....I also saw Rogers reincarnation of the wall a few months ago...... the 2011 show was visually mind blowing....but in so many ways the 1980 shows were better....31yrs ago it was Pink Floyd performing The Wall and you were acutely aware that you`d seen a band...in 2011 it was a show......1980`s video technology was obviously shit....It`s hard to believe when watching these vids but the stage was lit...trust me the band did`t play in near darkness.
swnymor1963 6 months ago
This song is beautiful. And it's nice to see Roger play acoustic instead of his usual bass
JaneandJanineDancing 6 months ago
My mom kicked me out today.
I thought this song would make me like her again...
Nope
Bitch
ninojaquez 6 months ago
5 "mother fuckers"
rodrigovh1984 6 months ago 2
@rodrigovh1984 vamo que ya estan a la venta las entradas
Gapbriel 5 months ago
i will always remember when he sang with himself...
nerobloutsi 6 months ago
yes roger, you should run for president
kevmilla 6 months ago 11
melhor ao vivo do que no studio
paula0floyd0jett 6 months ago
Any fool that clicks dislike on Floyd can go pound salt. Learn a guitar chord and shut your trap
jimmybfan 6 months ago
Thank you for this album. Truly saved my life.
mynameisian91 6 months ago 4
I call 'em idiots who have never seen Floyd or played a guitar in their pathetic lives. Go listen to some shit music fools. Lady Gaga is out there for you
jimmybfan 6 months ago 2
Why the solo in this verision is different?
watch?v=ngX5jJVrx8U
libano90 6 months ago
@libano90 because the version you mention is this video mixed with the audio of the CD wich was on another night
mouloudo 6 months ago
This solo is also different from the studio version, it's extended because it's live.
xXxGODSMACKxXx 6 months ago
Comment removed
libano90 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
nobody can play that solo like david gilmour. nobody.
romulopina 6 months ago
ΜΕΓΑΛΟΣ.
GeorgeRingoGirl 6 months ago 3
...ich würde meinen rechten Arm geben auf diesem Konzert gewesenzu sein....da war ich gerade mal sechs....mit 13 hab ich es inhaliert!
schimmelms 6 months ago
this song always makes me cry. in the concert, 4 days ago, it was fucking amazing. you get a very strong feeling when you see your hero singing those wonderful songs. and i might never get this amazing feeling again.
Pink Floyd forever!!!
EvaRamone 6 months ago
ΝΑ ΓΑΜΗΘΕΙ Η ΚΥΒΕΡΝΗΣΗ
JohnSkywalker 6 months ago 64
@JohnSkywalker isoun k esi ekei?!!!?
MrsDemi11 6 months ago
@JohnSkywalker
Το είδες και εσύ ε?
Μεγάλος Roger Waters
Metalgasparos 6 months ago 2
@JohnSkywalker Fuck The Government - Roger Waters Athens July 2011.
speechpessi 6 months ago
@JohnSkywalker ΜΑΖΙ ΣΟΥ ΦΙΛΕ ΜΟΥ!!!
aigio1997 4 months ago
@JohnSkywalker what?
MrNearZ 3 months ago
Merci... I was 5 years old at this moment... and still love it... thanks
pacosxm 6 months ago
Remember people, i will fan do not listen Pink Floyd at youtube or mp3, but on LP sound!
XpozUreH 7 months ago
For someone in my family.......you'll know who u are.......mother do you think SHE'LL break your little boys heart.......oooooohhhhhhh....love ya....."U"
plyitld24 7 months ago
Roger Waters is Pink Floyd.
Inthedeadofknight 7 months ago
@Inthedeadofknight um no
hollowharmony1 7 months ago
@hollowharmony1 "Um no", what a compelling argument you have managed to conjure up with that complex brain of yours.
Waters wrote most of the chord progressions and came up with the majority of the themes by himself. He wrote "The Wall" and "Animals" almost entirely by himself. All the parts with rhythm guitar, like this song here? He did that. The bass player had to play rhythm guitar because all Gilmour was good for is soloing.
Inthedeadofknight 7 months ago
Comment removed
Inthedeadofknight 7 months ago
@Inthedeadofknight I don't deny Roger was a significant part of Floyd but to say he is "Pink Floyd" is an overstatement. Everyone did their part to make Pink Floyd what it is/was. And Gilmour's guitar playing/solos was a major part of Floyd's sound. Pink Floyd would not be the same without Gilmour. DSOM is evidence to this.
hollowharmony1 7 months ago
@hollowharmony1 Like I said, Dave has a beautiful tone and can play his instrument well, but he was in no way the creative mind behind all the revolutionary music that Pink Floyd created. Wright contributed to it and I'm sure Dave did here and there, but the majority of the creativity came from Waters.
Inthedeadofknight 7 months ago
@Inthedeadofknight Yeah Roger was probs the main creative drive behind the band. But Dave and the rest were still a significant part of the overall sound of Floyd. Probs not as major as Roger but still important..
hollowharmony1 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Sure Dave has a beautiful tone and could fit within the music Waters and Wright had written very well, but there's a reason that it was possible for Roger to tour The Wall live with someone else in Gilmour's place.
Inthedeadofknight 7 months ago
I can't belive there's not over 100 million view's?// BEST BAND EVER.. Straight up, & I'm a METAL HEAD.
metalhead33ful 7 months ago
I can't belive there's not over 100 million view's?//
metalhead33ful 7 months ago
im crying...
Commander56651 7 months ago
@Commander56651 me too :D it's wonderful!
Kurtly1967 7 months ago
I am in awe of how gentle this atmosphere is. I am reminded of a campfire-lit rainy night that I'm not sure ever occurred, but it's ok. Thanks Pink Floyd.
Tengent 7 months ago 2
Roger, shut that stupid mandolin sh*t up man, you just wrecked Gilmours solo!
Shagnarsty 7 months ago
@Shagnarsty Yeah right? Where the fuck did that come from? it also helps that gilmour is hidden behind a cage
underage4page 7 months ago
for pink floyd to return, we need a few things to happen.
1) need to resurect richard wright and mason-or find equals, neil perce mayhaps
2) get David some rogaine foam
if these things cannot be done, then a new band shall appear, with full heads of hair, amazing skills, and huge noses.
0Sirk0 7 months ago
@0Sirk0 Nick Mason isn't dead......
slockster94 7 months ago
Comment removed
0Sirk0 7 months ago
@0Sirk0 hmmm dumbest comment of the year??? i think so
cryingskies77 7 months ago 4
@0Sirk0 ,your so perfect....
acdc2decore 7 months ago
can't believe 5 dislikes ??? wtf
and people arguing about who's the best member?
there's no i in team or band.
just enjoy the music arguing about who's fault is they split won't bring them back together
" she won't let you fly but she might let you sing"
DAVASTATER307 8 months ago 4
People are arguying about who's the best person in Pink Floyd, but you don't get the point, Floyd is best as a WHOLE, they wouldn't be near as good if they didn't work together to get where they are seperatly today.
DanikaJadeee 8 months ago
I also can't imagine Roger playing the guitar outro to Comfortably Numb or the start of Run or the end of Sheep or any part of Dogs! There was a Waters-less Floyd. Wrote some great songs as it goes. Each member of floyd played their part, to try to say otherwise is ridiculous. Richard Wright wrote the music for GGITS and Us and Them. Imagine DSOTM without those songs!
brainofpea 8 months ago
Waters was the artistic brains of floyd from DSOTM on. He came up with the ideas, the majority of songs, lyrically and musically and the concept of each album. Also, if it hadn't been for Gilmour singing on DSOTM and WYWH they wouldn't have been so popular. Let's face it