I prefer this version.....I've heard it in the other versions and to me, it really strikes a spot in my heart in this version. I love it when Barry doesn't sing in falsetto....perhaps because it doesn't happen often but he is incredible just the same.
@sapphireangelwings11 I agree with you. Barry has a beautiful and incredible "natural" voice, a bit "faltering"...., is really wonderful!!!!! Beside he is, still... so gorgeous.....!!!! (February 2012)
This isn't fuzzy, but I'm stating it anyway. If you don't want to read it, then don't. I am so sick of machine-made music and its avatars I want to upchuck. I will not commit my brain to an adroid. So Barry and Robin (and, Robin, I know you've been ill, so I understand the sabattical) as well as Steve Perry and other great musical artists, why don't you step up to the plate and rescue the world of music? I do things every day that are out of my comfort zone because I have a duty. So do you.
This is a Psalm if I've ever heard one sung--and I've heard many. I believe in Einstein's concept that whatever force moves throughout the universe also moves at the sub-atomic level. Whatever inspired King David also inspired the words of this song. It is consistent with everything I've learned about God.
MOFANSHK, thank you for this upload. Even though I enjoy Celine Dion's version, the "closest to the heart" versions for this and other Bee Gees' songs are better to me when watching and hearing the Bee Gees' own performance of their contributions to the music world. All four of the Gibbs boys made phenomenal contributions to the world of music. I agree with Robert Stigwood that theirs is a rare natural talent that was honed to perfection by the artists themselves. God bless to the Bee Gees.
These artists came to my country in 1998 and gave such a warm concert as if the first time in their lifes. So kind and professional. I admire them deeply since I am a little child and I thank them for share their talent with all of us. Love u!!!!!
@rockophiliac She didn't sing a cover though. I respect your opinion...but if you watched the video recording of this song, you'll see that the Bee Gees specifically wrote this song for her.
So much better WITHOUT Celine Dion. But it sounds like the boys are singing to a backing track (listen for multiple Barry harmonies). Still, loved the Bee Gees since 1972!
I like it so much when the Bee Gee's are performing songs they wrote for others. It always put a new light on the song, apart form the fact that it is always a beautiful singing
I love this video mainly because Barry is singing in his real voice, not in falsetto. We can't deny that this 'real voice' singing is very touching and amazing!!
No, the version on The Record was recorded before this concert, you weren't supposed to hear it of course, its a demo, he sings it in falsetto so its in Celine's range, he did that with all the Guilty and Heartbreaker demo's as well from Striesand and Warwick.;)
@ninmmm Bit of a late reply but here goes .... this particular performance is in a different key which perhaps Barry cannot sing high enough for specific parts of the song. Also falsetto places huge strain on the voice and he was probably simply giving himself a well deserved rest from previous songs sung in falsetto at this time. I'll admit his performance in ''natural voice'' is fantastic but this song sounds even better in falsetto!
Este tema siempre me hace llorar especialmente el instante cuando escuchan la versión terminada de Celin. Fue un gran asierto haberle entregado esa canción. Sin embargo escucharlo de sus propios acordes es electrificante. Gracias por compartir este video. Love The Bee Gees forever
@BEEGEESMIAMOR Yo también estuve ahí!!!! Fue fabuloso, un gran concierto. Parecía que tocaban los temas por primera vez. Son unos grandes! Saludos desde Baires
@andreaclaudia69 Muy suertuda tú....!!!! Hermosos recuerdos, me imagino. En Chile solo tuvimos la suerte de tener a Andy en el festival de Viña en el año 1984 y fué sensacional como era él, y todos sus hermanos. Y que por favor Barry se cuide mucho, el "guapetón", que a pesar de los años sigue siendo estupendo. Saludos desde Santiago de Chile, a los hermanos argentinos....!! (Febrero 2012).
@BEEGEESMIAMOR Qué suerte tienes de haber estado ahí cuando todavía los Bee Gees estaban en pleno...!! A Chile nunca vinieron....!!!!!!! Es muy doloroso ver cómo este grupo de tres hermanos tan talentosos se vaya desaparareciendo. Actualmente estamos temiendo por la vida de Robin, que se encuentra luchando contra un cáncer de hígado. Pidamos a Dios por él. Y que el estupendo Barry se cuide mucho, please......!!!!
I didn't know about other ONO performance different from 1997 Las Vegas one! Please someone would be so kind to tell me about the complete set of ONO shows all around the world? Thanks, and CIAO from Italy!
Alicia5525-I'm glad to say hello ... all disappear completely, but if there is love
for us, in other souls, our stay is eternal.
So it is with BEE GEES never disappear entirely,
because you, me and many more continue to love.
ROBIN is exceeding good health status.
On Friday 3 February 2012 confirmed to the bbc,
his remarkable improvement. And we celebrate all that ...
BEEGEESMIAMOR 3 weeks ago
Alicia5525-Me da gusto saludarte...todos desapareceremos del todo, pero si hay amor
por nosotros, en otras almas, nuestra permanencia es eterna.
Así pasa con BEE GEES nunca desaparecerán del todo,
porque tú, yo y muchisímos más los seguiremos amando.
ROBIN está superando muy bien su estado de salud.
El pasado viernes 3 de febrero 2012 confirmó a la bbc,
su notable mejoría. Y todos celebramos eso...
BEEGEESMIAMOR 3 weeks ago
beegees is the best who dont like just wotch beatles
l1ngan 1 month ago
wow vintage Barry without the falsetto. I wish theres a cleaner video w/o that much noise
thelotr2010 3 months ago in playlist thelotr2010's favorites 2
I prefer this version.....I've heard it in the other versions and to me, it really strikes a spot in my heart in this version. I love it when Barry doesn't sing in falsetto....perhaps because it doesn't happen often but he is incredible just the same.
sapphireangelwings11 4 months ago 2
@sapphireangelwings11 I agree with you. Barry has a beautiful and incredible "natural" voice, a bit "faltering"...., is really wonderful!!!!! Beside he is, still... so gorgeous.....!!!! (February 2012)
Alicia5525 3 weeks ago
WO)W ,Les bee geess ,je vs aiment....xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
JoliJOjO96 5 months ago
dan,uit,ik,moet,slapen,hony,ik,begryp,ju,maar,ik,vond,het,geen,echte,zoen,als,wy,toen,kom,jy,eens,zoenen,jy,weet,ook,2jaar,is,lang,jy,dan,xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxbay,hony,tot,orgen,eten,niets,gehad,ok,love,you,ik,zeg,jy,by,elkaar,gebeurt,dit,nooit,ik,ben,altyd,ook,alone,men,denken,ze,is,vry,nou,jy,straks,prettig,utube,lekker,slapen,ok,
mollysangelique 5 months ago
why no falsett? way better..
lostfloor 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ik,zet,ze,niet,op,last,van,jy,okmyn,pc,damned,jy,bent,wel,de,baas,over,my,uit,pause
mollysangelique 5 months ago
ik,zet,ze,niet,op,last,van,jy,okmyn,pc,damned,jy,bent,wel,de,baas,over,my
mollysangelique 5 months ago
ik,zet,ze,niet,op,last,van,jy,ok
mollysangelique 5 months ago
I like this version better than the falsetto one, although I have never heard the Bee Gees sing anything I didn't like.
goodthing99 8 months ago
is there any other video of Barry singing Immortality in normal voice ? video with better audio plz
thelotr2010 10 months ago
This isn't fuzzy, but I'm stating it anyway. If you don't want to read it, then don't. I am so sick of machine-made music and its avatars I want to upchuck. I will not commit my brain to an adroid. So Barry and Robin (and, Robin, I know you've been ill, so I understand the sabattical) as well as Steve Perry and other great musical artists, why don't you step up to the plate and rescue the world of music? I do things every day that are out of my comfort zone because I have a duty. So do you.
129Susie 10 months ago
This is a Psalm if I've ever heard one sung--and I've heard many. I believe in Einstein's concept that whatever force moves throughout the universe also moves at the sub-atomic level. Whatever inspired King David also inspired the words of this song. It is consistent with everything I've learned about God.
129Susie 1 year ago
We're very lucky, MOFANSHK.
129Susie 1 year ago
MOFANSHK, thank you for this upload. Even though I enjoy Celine Dion's version, the "closest to the heart" versions for this and other Bee Gees' songs are better to me when watching and hearing the Bee Gees' own performance of their contributions to the music world. All four of the Gibbs boys made phenomenal contributions to the world of music. I agree with Robert Stigwood that theirs is a rare natural talent that was honed to perfection by the artists themselves. God bless to the Bee Gees.
129Susie 1 year ago
Very sad that i don't have this one ! Thanks for this here !
BGConcertRecords 1 year ago
A mi juicio #BeeGees son y serán INMORTALES.
luisalberto1975 1 year ago
Achingly beautifully sung. Thanx for posting. Added it to my faves.
rougeFS 1 year ago
These artists came to my country in 1998 and gave such a warm concert as if the first time in their lifes. So kind and professional. I admire them deeply since I am a little child and I thank them for share their talent with all of us. Love u!!!!!
andreaclaudia69 2 years ago 3
This Version of "Immortality" is really more better without Celine Dion!
TheBeeGees1996 2 years ago 18
I really like Celine Dion and her version of "Immortality," but this version is better - more emotion.
truthformeandyou 2 years ago 2
her version sucks no offense, I hate it when singers with Completely different singing style try to sing covers.
rockophiliac 2 years ago 2
Bare in mind Barry wrote is specifically for her.
LukeShoveller 2 years ago
I say Barry, all the brothers wrote it for her vocal style.
LukeShoveller 2 years ago
@rockophiliac She didn't sing a cover though. I respect your opinion...but if you watched the video recording of this song, you'll see that the Bee Gees specifically wrote this song for her.
CelineFan28 1 year ago
So much better WITHOUT Celine Dion. But it sounds like the boys are singing to a backing track (listen for multiple Barry harmonies). Still, loved the Bee Gees since 1972!
actfray 2 years ago
<3 the Bee Gees!!!!
goldicecubes 2 years ago
man sorry for your son keep up the good life hommie
saraana06 2 years ago 4
This is one of the best songs ever,i had this played at my sons funeral 6years ago.
sammysizzle12 2 years ago 4
we dont say goodbye!!!!!!!!!!!
shawnwave 2 years ago
The only new recording on The Record is Islands In The Stream
LukeShoveller 2 years ago
I like it so much when the Bee Gee's are performing songs they wrote for others. It always put a new light on the song, apart form the fact that it is always a beautiful singing
ranicalderon 2 years ago
why isn't Barry singing in falseeto? The Bee Gees' version of this song written by them is sang in falsetto by Barry
ninmmm 3 years ago
I love this video mainly because Barry is singing in his real voice, not in falsetto. We can't deny that this 'real voice' singing is very touching and amazing!!
MOFANSHK 3 years ago 7
Yes, I totally agree with you!
But I stranged that because in Th Greatest Hits album he sings it in falsetto.. And it was recorded 3 years later after this concert
ninmmm 3 years ago
No, the version on The Record was recorded before this concert, you weren't supposed to hear it of course, its a demo, he sings it in falsetto so its in Celine's range, he did that with all the Guilty and Heartbreaker demo's as well from Striesand and Warwick.;)
LukeShoveller 3 years ago
Oh, ok, Understood! ;)
But Immortality on The Record doesn't seem nothing like a demo, the sound seems to be of a arranjed a complete song, with all the ingredients.
And when was it recorded?
ninmmm 3 years ago
It was touched up for release, but the vocal is the same and so is most of Maurice's piano,
It was recorded in October 1996, once recording for Still Waters was complete, the band who play the demo were just the live band who live in Miami.
LukeShoveller 3 years ago
Ok, thanks a lot!
And do you know anything about the return of Barry and Robin together recording and singing again?
ninmmm 3 years ago
Barry will be in England in July and he says he'll meet Robin
LukeShoveller 3 years ago
Great!
ninmmm 3 years ago
No, the version on The Record is not a demo.
cxyian 2 years ago
Yes, it is. Get it right.
LukeShoveller 2 years ago
The Record contains the recording of songs of others recorded in 2001
budbuddiovitch 2 years ago
No.
Those recordings were made in 1994 for the scrapped 'Love Songs' album, 1994 not 2001.
The demo for this song was recorded in 1998.
LukeShoveller 2 years ago
@ninmmm Bit of a late reply but here goes .... this particular performance is in a different key which perhaps Barry cannot sing high enough for specific parts of the song. Also falsetto places huge strain on the voice and he was probably simply giving himself a well deserved rest from previous songs sung in falsetto at this time. I'll admit his performance in ''natural voice'' is fantastic but this song sounds even better in falsetto!
19JAS91 1 year ago
Este tema siempre me hace llorar especialmente el instante cuando escuchan la versión terminada de Celin. Fue un gran asierto haberle entregado esa canción. Sin embargo escucharlo de sus propios acordes es electrificante. Gracias por compartir este video. Love The Bee Gees forever
LadyJane1965 3 years ago
Yo estuve ahí esa misma noche.
Y supe una vez más, que BEE GEES es la mejor banda pop de todos los tiempos.
Gracias MOFANSHK por incluir este video.
I was that same night there.
And I knew once again, that BEE GEES is best band pop for all time.
Thanks MOFANSHK to include this video.
BEEGEESMIAMOR 3 years ago
You were one of the audience there! Amazing! It should be a great night,and I can feel that S. American fans were great too!
MOFANSHK 3 years ago
BEE GEES en Argentina fue uno de los mejores momentos de mi vida.
Gracias por tu respuesta...MOFANSHK
BEE GEES in Argentina was one of the best moments of my life. Thanks for your answer MOFANSHK
BEEGEESMIAMOR 3 years ago
@BEEGEESMIAMOR Yo también estuve ahí!!!! Fue fabuloso, un gran concierto. Parecía que tocaban los temas por primera vez. Son unos grandes! Saludos desde Baires
andreaclaudia69 1 month ago
@andreaclaudia69 Muy suertuda tú....!!!! Hermosos recuerdos, me imagino. En Chile solo tuvimos la suerte de tener a Andy en el festival de Viña en el año 1984 y fué sensacional como era él, y todos sus hermanos. Y que por favor Barry se cuide mucho, el "guapetón", que a pesar de los años sigue siendo estupendo. Saludos desde Santiago de Chile, a los hermanos argentinos....!! (Febrero 2012).
Alicia5525 3 weeks ago
@Alicia5525 La verdad es que fui muy afortunada por haberlos visto en vivo. Vivan los hermanos Gibb y saludos para Chile!
andreaclaudia69 3 weeks ago
@andreaclaudia69 un saludo para ti Andrea, es verdad...
Parecía que tocaban esos temas por primera vez.
BEE GEES ANTES DURANTE Y DESPUÉS DE ESTA VIDA!-
@ andreaclaudia69 a greeting to you Andrea, it's true ...
It seemed that touched these issues first.
BEE GEES BEFORE DURING AND AFTER THIS LIFE! -
BEEGEESMIAMOR 3 weeks ago
@BEEGEESMIAMOR Qué suerte tienes de haber estado ahí cuando todavía los Bee Gees estaban en pleno...!! A Chile nunca vinieron....!!!!!!! Es muy doloroso ver cómo este grupo de tres hermanos tan talentosos se vaya desaparareciendo. Actualmente estamos temiendo por la vida de Robin, que se encuentra luchando contra un cáncer de hígado. Pidamos a Dios por él. Y que el estupendo Barry se cuide mucho, please......!!!!
Alicia5525 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Alicia5525 Me da gusto saludarte...todos desapareceremos del todo, pero si hay amor
por nosotros, en otras almas, nuestra permanencia es eterna.
Así pasa con BEE GEES nunca desaparecerán del todo,
porque tú, yo y muchisímos más los seguiremos amando.
ROBIN está superando muy bien su estado de salud.
El pasado viernes 3 de febrero 2012 confirmó a la bbc,
su notable mejoría. Y todos celebramos eso...
BEEGEESMIAMOR 3 weeks ago
I didn't know about other ONO performance different from 1997 Las Vegas one! Please someone would be so kind to tell me about the complete set of ONO shows all around the world? Thanks, and CIAO from Italy!
claudio1963 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It's better with Celine..
Celinephile 3 years ago
Thanks!
trovey02 4 years ago 2
so amazing so wonderful and so touching that our love BeeGees - Immortality rebirth again.
Thanks again.
tpptp 4 years ago 3
阿伯,唔使咁high嘛!保重呀!多謝哂喎!
MOFANSHK 4 years ago
Very cool! Thanks!
EightysMusicFan 4 years ago
This is the 2nd time I post this video,cus some friends told me that the 1st one could not run. Thanks for loving it again!
MOFANSHK 4 years ago