Back in 2006 at a fund raising even the school did, all the seniors performed to Broadway musical numbers like Phantom of the Opera, Grease, South Pacific, etc...and a friend of mine performed this absolutely beautifully. And I'm a mean critic. It was gorgeous. I'll always remember it. Thank you for posting this to bring back those memories.
this song is beautiful. i want to learn this song ang sing it for the talent show but i'm afraid people will think it's too boring. i haven't heard this song since i was little. linda does such a fabulous job
@tigereyes1994 - I AM singing this song for an audition for a talent show. It's what my voice is suited to as I was trained in musicals. So if they don't like it - tough! The shorter version on stage also suits acappella, which is how I will have to sing it. Linda Eder has a great voice, but I think the original West End cast was better. They even had the poorer London folk speaking and singing with true cockney accents. Something I noticed they scrapped for the Broadway version.
I've never heard this version before, that's why I was surprised when I listen it. Actually, I though Linda Eder's voice is very different of what it is in the others version. Her voice is more sweet, that perhaps the reason this version is the best.
beautiful
Vampirgirlxxx 2 months ago
I really have come to adore this song
LittleMissOpposite3 4 months ago
wonderful
Stargirl7155 6 months ago
God, this is beautiful... Almost heartbreaking because I can hear the sadness.
OperaGhostObsession 6 months ago 3
Back in 2006 at a fund raising even the school did, all the seniors performed to Broadway musical numbers like Phantom of the Opera, Grease, South Pacific, etc...and a friend of mine performed this absolutely beautifully. And I'm a mean critic. It was gorgeous. I'll always remember it. Thank you for posting this to bring back those memories.
21Pfenix 8 months ago
this song is beautiful. i want to learn this song ang sing it for the talent show but i'm afraid people will think it's too boring. i haven't heard this song since i was little. linda does such a fabulous job
tigereyes1994 8 months ago
@tigereyes1994 - I AM singing this song for an audition for a talent show. It's what my voice is suited to as I was trained in musicals. So if they don't like it - tough! The shorter version on stage also suits acappella, which is how I will have to sing it. Linda Eder has a great voice, but I think the original West End cast was better. They even had the poorer London folk speaking and singing with true cockney accents. Something I noticed they scrapped for the Broadway version.
Penscreen 7 months ago
@Penscreen Good luck :)
tigereyes1994 7 months ago
@tigereyes1994 - THANK YOU <3
Penscreen 7 months ago
such an amazing song...beautiful and haunting
Carde21 8 months ago
such an amazing song...beautiful and haunting
Carde21 8 months ago
have you ever heard it in Hunhgarian?
Frozzando 10 months ago
we did an SATB version of this song. i got the solo. i love both versions though.
decondemon 11 months ago
The Original Cast from Houston (with Linda Eder as Lucy) is even better than this one!!
hotwaiter 1 year ago 2
@hotwaiter this is linda eder as lucy! so it can't be....
cassylangley 1 year ago
@cassylangley I meant Linda Eder played Lucy in the original version as well, but the arrangement was better.
hotwaiter 1 year ago
@hotwaiter = im trying to find that version.. but so far my search is like dead.
OhThatGirlDanielle 9 months ago
nice version love it XD!
remycer0 1 year ago
This is my theme song xD
AshleyGAC 1 year ago
imagen Evanescence covering this :DD
RockenRena 1 year ago 3
@RockenRena Shit! :O
TheZarboFilms 1 year ago
@TheZarboFilms EXACTLY :D
RockenRena 1 year ago
this is the best version!
KawaHato 1 year ago
I'm singing this song for contest in February. It's beautiful!
musicmaniacx123 2 years ago
@musicmaniacx123 so am i haha febuary comp
StephanieGwawr 2 years ago
She sounds like a young Streisand on this recording. I saw here this summer with the Boston Pops, she was marvelous!!!
funnyguy52 2 years ago 3
could u send me notes for this song?:))
hancikaaaaaaaaaaa 2 years ago
My music teacher put me to learn this song, I like this sonf, very nice.. and her voice is so wonderful and powerful ^-^
xXLifeOfMyOwnXx 2 years ago
@xXLifeOfMyOwnXx Me too ... I mean my singing gave it to me to learn.
yankiedoodledoctor 1 year ago
I've never heard this version before, that's why I was surprised when I listen it. Actually, I though Linda Eder's voice is very different of what it is in the others version. Her voice is more sweet, that perhaps the reason this version is the best.
Sorry for my awful english.
Pidaanma 2 years ago 3
@Pidaanma
Linda beats Colleen Saxton out time and time again.
beautifullytragic1 2 years ago
This is the BEST version of this song!!! Lucy is my favorite character in J&H by far..she has the best songs!!
dtothehammy93 2 years ago
Beautiful... I didn't know it was this long, though - the only version I'd heard is the one by Coleen Sexton
broadwaylove52 2 years ago
I saw this play on Broadway, and have not heard a better rendition than that of Linda Eder's. Colm Wilkenson is also a penonm.
quaquigi 2 years ago
I love this song!! Its so beautiful<3
TifaLH 2 years ago
I'm singing this for my singing lessons :) thank you for the post.
lolabugz77 2 years ago
holy cow!
so am i!!
C3lti 2 years ago
sorry ment to put my comment here.
im singing this for my lessons to :D
C3lti 2 years ago
Same :D
ajt1194 2 years ago
same ^^
PlastiqueKitten 2 years ago
great
Fidelityshinju 2 years ago
No one but Linda Eder does this song justice. Thank you for posting it!
bamanda68 2 years ago 20
I love this song... it's so beautiful and kind of haunting...
paramorerocks16 3 years ago 29
I know! It's my favorite song from the musical!
bugstomper123 3 years ago
@paramorerocks16 this is such a sad and desperate song...
EmmaRose473 1 year ago
It´s truly the best version here!!! I love this song... Thank you for this wonderful version!
yellowandredtea 3 years ago
i m imagining a wolf..singing its story..at night time..
hjuyiop789456 3 years ago
absolutely beautiful...i have to sing this song for my singing exam and i must say this is the best version of it on the tube.
talk4england94 3 years ago
awesomeee!!!!
cbfan14ever 3 years ago
Thank you very much for posting this wonderful song.
asuGirl88 3 years ago
i just learned how to sing this.. so pretty!
Edface556 3 years ago
I've been Wanting to listening to this album like ages. Thanks Chris. Not only Selena, you rocks TOO....
divolino 3 years ago