Added: 3 years ago
From: xKeyshia18x
Views: 187,339
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (155)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • She has a very smooth voice ...very nice....

  • dont miss the one and only fantasia live in concert at the robinson center in Little Rock,AR

  • simon is a effin hater u go girl

  • Simon's such a white guy LOL

    He just doesn't get it does?

  • @stardusth2o Simon never sang in his life perhaps, he certainly knows the business of music better but he does not understand music like Randy. I guess he is waiting for the good ole days of Dr. Do Little's music. Give him some sweet melodies from "happy days" and he be fine.

  • simon is always right!

  • "the birth of mah chald"

  • Why do I feel like I'm in 2050 watching something great from the past? This is a classic! WOW

  • attention idol fans the time as come to start requesting her new single "collard greens and cornbread" on your local radio station and buy it on itunes

  • What the hell was Simon listening to?

  • had never heard this song before this performance, and i must say she rocked it!!!

  • simon STFU

  • I love it!!!

  • fantasia is EPIC!!!!

  • This version rocked! Love the raw power in her voice :-D

  • l'm sorry but her voice make me laughing so hard,LMAO, haha ^_^

  • @ntv5000 thats not funnie thats juss mean and i knoe this was 7 months ago and this might have changed ... and if yu still dont think she cant sing after hearing one of her songs on "Back to me" honestly ... oh nevermind cuz i dont have anything nice to say ... have a blessed day =)

  • DO YOU PEOPLE HEAR HER VOICE I DONT THINK YOU DO GO BUY THE FANTASIA BACK TO ME CD IF YOU ALREADY HAVE A COPY BUY ANOTHER GIVE IT AWAY SPREAD THE WORD SHE HAS A TALENT BUY HER CD ITS ALMOST GOLD THIS IS A SHAME THIS GIRL SING LIKE CRAZY AND WE TAKE IT FOR GRANTED SO GO BUY HER CD UNTIL ITS ATLEAST GOLD ITS SELLING GOOD BUT NOT FAST ENOUGH COME ON PEOPLE THIS IS TASIA GO BUY THE CD IM BEGGING YOU ITS WORTH IT SHE DID HER THING THIS GO ROUND BUY HER CD DONT SLEEP ON IT BUY IT NO BOOTLEGGING

  • awful" awful! awful".......some songs just shouldn't be covered and this is one time!!! ruined it!!!!!

  • I thought that was awesome! If anything, the few scratchy moments added to the soulful sounds and all-in-all, well done in my opinion.

  • sorry...but her face looks horrible.....

  • LOVE THE EARRINGS

  • I see that alot in her too the screeching making all dat noise...but she`s beautiful she does have a beautiful voice and she's workin wat she got to get wat she want...I LOVEE U TASIA

  • OMG!! her powerful voice just claims every song she sings!! Mabuhay ka Fantasia!

  • attention fans please vote for her new single "im doin me" on vh1 top 20 countdown to vote go to (vh1.com:vspot top 20 countdown) so vote hard and please try to do hundred more votes so we can get her on the countdown

  • The next  whitney houston.. powerful voice...Miss Fantasia...

  • haha...fantasia was extremely country then...what happened to her accent and heavy tongue?

  • @Isprtle5  Great words you Tube User... I couldn't have said it any better.. Hope everyone enjoys my video response...

  • attention fans request her new single "im doing me" on your local radio station so we can help on the charts

  • fantastic burrito!

  • Sounded great but Fantasia's from the Aretha school of singing which means as the voice grows older and the range decreases the screeching will grow. Fantasia like Aretha before her will continue to try to hit notes she cannot reach - she will just scream them if she cannot hit them properly.

  • @taurusg32 Aretha can still sing, however in the 80's Aretha was starting to lose her voice because she smoked 40 cigarettes a day.(According to Aretha herself she stopped in 1991 because she admitted that it ruined her voice) Fantasia on the other hand does not smoke so I highly doubt she will be like the current Aretha.

  • nice baby

  • awsome singer to me her style of singin is amazin.

  • Simon was right, there were parts of the song she screeched.

  • omg she does sound like Aretha! dang she sings this beautiful too. forget simon, he's mean. elton loved it.

  • GO SUPPORT TASIA WITH HER NEW ALBUM (BACK TO ME) COME ON, YOU GUYS....LETS GET OUR GIRL TO THE NUMBER ONE SPOT....

    ~TEAM TASIA~

  • fantasia new album in stores now everywhere and its hot

  • she will be on gma this morning and behind the music tonight

  • Haha! Gotta love Simon. The man's brutally honest. A trait that's not very popular in today's bullshit society.

  • Tashia voice is a force 2 b wreckon with! She's a beast, I think she is so undrated! She just might need to get rid of whomeva is writting her material. She should be up there with Biance by now! But she is still at a beginner stage of her music! I would love 2 hear her and Leandria from Sunday Best sing something 2gether! I would prob loose my mind if that eva happend LOL!!!!!

  • Simon says he loved her. Aww Simon. But, Simon rarely gave her negative critiques. I love her for not letting Simon get to her.

    

  • 5 years from now shes gonna be a hooker

  • @TopazSkillMauler This performance was almost over five years ago and she not a hooker. As a matter of fact shes very successful

  • @TopazSkillMauler the curse you put on someone maybe your own downfall.

  • It's a great version!

  • fantasia has a new single out call "bittersweet" thats now available for itune and radio so go buy and request so we can help her on the charts

  • She's so cool!!

  • fantaisa is a great singer hands down.!

    she is da biggest powerhouse in da game.!

    lets goo tasia.!

  • It does sound like she has a Chipmunk in her voice. It gets anouying quick.

  • she's funny tho

  • from a musician's standpoint that is probobly the WORST singing i've EVER HEARD!

  • @SG1lover14

    You have my pity, you must be def

  • its Elton John!!!! NOT ELLEN JOHN!!!

  • she ruined the song...

  • yeah... people just don't get Fantasia. And thats cool, but don't cut her down. Shes REALLY not a recording artist though. I've heard some of the crap they've put her voice to on albums.. and it really sucks hard. But when shes been on Broadway or doing ANY other live performance? INCREDIBLE! I think the album media just loses her energy in the translation or something. And her energy is .... FANTASTIC. Hence her name... Her mom apparently resaw this or something.

  • @seraph01972 ... er .. foresaw.. oopsie.

  • What are you guys talking about?! She is the bomb! I don't care what you guys have to say! She is and forever will be my American Idol.

  • I agree this performance wasn't her best on the show; but she aint' "shit" as I'm sure she's doing way better than you!!!!!

  • Couldn't listen. I'm with Simon on this one

  • @deevo12345 i'm with Simon too. but then i find it extremely hard to listen whenever she's singing.

  • god awful

  • sorry but dident like it

  • don t miss fantasia final episode of her vh1 reality show "fantasia for real" that airs on vh1 tonite at 10pm est don t miss

  • the song is beautiful as it is but she didn't move me emotionally. i agree with Simon.

  • She reminds me alot of Corrine Bailey rae

  • good performance :]

  • whoaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­aaaaaaaaaaaaaa chilllssssssssssssssss

  • great voice, yet overdone

  • I agreed with Simon

  • woooooow!

  • Haven't there been like 3 Fantasias on this show.

  • shes got a tremendous voice when she sings it normally but WHY OH WHY does she have to oversing it!! The best vocalists in history let there natural voices do the talking without the vocal acrobatics

  • AMEN

  • She sang the heck out this song!!! GOD-Given talent.

  • go simon!

  • Apparently a lot of you think that if it doesn't sound exactly like the original, it isn't any good. Well, to you I say, any idiot can imitate, but to make a song your own takes skill.

    And that "screeching" that she does is part of soul singing. Simon's a fucking idiot for not seeing that. Almost everyone can sing cleanly, but only a few can sing with a rasp. People who don't have an appreciation for "scratchy" voices just don't get what soul is all about.

  • completely agree. her kind of voice used to be celebrated until all these britney-barbie types came along and suddenly the "acceptable standard" for musical talent became some nasally, pitchy, flat voice with little true emotion and soul. fantasia's kind of voice was celebrated in Aretha and Patti's day - i appreciate clean singing as well but you're completely right - this is SOUL.

  • @averagehomosapien unfortunately you are not simon cowel and you cant do what he can.

  • @taniahurley

    Simon knows what will be popular, what will sell, what will have the widest appeal -- as with many things that fit that criteria, it's not what's the BEST. Clean, simple voices are what's popular nowadays, not gritty, soulful ones like Fantasia's. Simon Cowell's talent lies in making MONEY, not judging. This is why true critics never set out to be rich.

  • @averagehomosapien Actually that scratching means she is going about two or three octaves to high to the point where her voice almost can't handle it.

  • @dman747707

    Sorry, but I don't think you know what you're talking about. If she really was singing "two or three octaves to [sic] high" that would mean her real voice is about as low as a man's voice, which is obviously wrong. She has a naturally husky woman's voice. I grant that her voice isn't for *everybody*. It's not conventionally "pretty" because soul music isn't meant to be "pretty". It's supposed be emotional and heartfelt and sometimes even painful.

  • @averagehomosapien Believe it or not I actually think she has a beautiful voice, but in my opinion her naturally raspy voice goes hoarse at times when she tries to go for really big notes. Hoarseness is not a sign of good soul singers, its a sign of someone who wasn't taught how to control their vocal range. Like I said, I was actually quite a fan, but for you to think that Fantasia looked back at this performance and almost cringe with some of those hoarse notes then you're crazy dude.

  • @averagehomosapien i like bonnie tyler ... lol

  • @averagehomosapien  yes i agree Simon is an Idoit for sure...

  • Comment removed

  • sounds like Marcia Hines

  • beautiful rendition - the best!!!

  • she did a horrible rendition of this song! she over sang it.. which in the end... killed it! sorry!

  • I'm sorry! She just butchered this song.

  • Techincally it doesn't matter what we think because the Man hiself Elton John Loved it, Elton is like E F hutton Lol!!! when he says he doesn't like it then we can comment

  • what's he supposed to say, he hated it? He wouldn't do that on T.V

  • @lspratle5 that is a show and he CANNOT say he does not like it.....she is terrible....!!!!!!!!!

  • @cellerosvision Well Fantasia was the only contestant that had the honor to sing at Elton John tribute singing sorry seems to be the hardest word had Elton in tears you need to look up the video. Anyway I love me some Tasia and for future reference years after Idol Sir Elton still says Fantasia was his favorite and Season 3 was the best season Ever

  • @lspratle5 and abowe all this she missed the word too....at 0:57 she missing one part of the liryc....how about that? that is not how this song goes.....

  • @lspratle5 dont be so naiv....hes not gonna say that this was shit...wont say it on national tv and in this show, but nobody knows what he really thinks...this girl Fantasia wanted to be so .so "big" but ended up so bad...

  • @lspratle5 so right

  • Couldn't you give her credit for at least trying?

  • I just love watching her perform..she always amazes me..:) You go Fantasia!

  • Some people are just blessed with that star quality!!!

  • this girl is superb

  • That chick will take you to church in a minute!!!

  • Fantasia is the best idol ever.She sings legendsaka Aretha, Patti, Tina, Whitney songs with power and admiration.

  • she is such a talented singer.God given talent.

  • I love you Elton nonone is better than you.

  • she is in her own world...and elton was standing and clapping his hand-amazing!!

  • Elton sings better :/

  • no way and elton can sing

  • etoileLituanienne,not this song

  • she was so herself gotta love that

  • best thing about this..no cara

  • Every time I go back and rewatch her performances, I like her more and more and I loved her to begin with. And I really love those earings:)

  • wow....she killed the end of that song....absolutely one of the best endings EVER on AI.

  • she was amazing, but any song by great performers like Elton John performed on this show always kill the songs

  • best idol ever

  • Agreed

  • Fantasia will always be my favorite but I believe what Simon was trying to say is she over did it and she should have simplified it. It was have been just as great, even better. And I noticed last year, she had a habit of screeching and she doesn't do that anymore. She is the BEST singer of this generation, thus far.

  • i am from Bangladsh...and i agreed wiv Simon...she ripped the song....

  • She raped it .. :s

  • She killer this song... sorry.

  • lol "I'm readay ta du it. Brang it Ohn"

  • I don't know what Simon was talkin bout. She was Great!!!!

  • he says bad comments 2 great singers at times so that they can stand out 4 the night: if everyone did a pretty decent job.

    You can remember their performance easier this way!

  • Is it impossible for this girl to hold out a note? i've never heard her actually hit a pitch and hold it out. I feel like Jennifer Hudson, LaToya London, and Diana DeGarmo just had better control and better pitch than her. Fantasia is definitely a more dynamic performer but singing wise, I just don't get it.

  • she has a different style. you don't always have to hold a note

  • ooh myy goodness!!! That ending was soo soulful.

  • i jus loooove this girl! what a voice! Elton loved it so thats saying something its the best he ever heard his song sing ...enough said!

  • eltons still so much better at it!

  • well he does own it...but we must give credit where credit is due just like elton said...INCREDIBLE!

  • love her no one sings like her

  • she has SO much spirt!

  • lol OMGosh leave her! lol

  • I Thought It Was An Incredible Performance, & She Didn't Win!?!

    I Think Simon Was Mean When He Said She Screeched It Cos I Didn't Hear Any Screeching!!!

  • "She didn't win!?!"

    She did.

  • I Wouldn't Know Who Won Because I Don't Watch The Show, This Is The First I've Heard About Her, I Put A Question Mark In There Because I Really Wasn't Sure.

  • Her voice was screechy but that's just how she sings, there are TONS of singers who have that same rasp in their voice. Luther Vandross, Aretha, Chaka Khan, it's an acquired taste. I, for one, enjoy the raspiness in her voice but some people prefer more linear tones, it's just about people having different tastes.

  • she can sang!

  • LOVE it, I think Fantasia deserved to win AI!!

  • spectacular performance!

  • Get it Fantasia!

  • Fantasia is the bomb, will be getting her new album..

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more