Aretha has more ease and power in the high belting area than damn near any other singer that ever was, but I like and prefer Mariah's vocal tone here to that of Aretha's (if I am to be entirely honest)... I mean, she literally sounds like an ANGEL at points in this video. The Queen and the Songbird both slay everything though, so in the end, they both win :P
I think Aretha sounds more like she's yelling rather than singing in some parts. Mariah's 0:54 with Outside was the shit and the Honey bit afterwards was too. Both are great singers :D
Wow. For like 90% of the video it was a mistake pitting these two against each other. Aretha SLAYED...except for on her last two notes! The one from "Loverboy" is my absolute favorite!
I think Aretha hits those notes more easily because her natural voice is high, while Mariah's natural voice (I think) is actually low so she'd put a little more effort when she belts above F5 (she stated before she considered herself an alto).
The messiah of course! Nah I give this to Aretha even tho im a lamb. Aretha low notes and highs...insane. also Mariah is great but she used a lot of production to get her notes(she is hitting them just in multiple takes) Aretha wasn't privy to that technology and well shit o.o
@shaunmike i agree taht aretha wins this but mariah's studio belts are not that enhanced(if at all). if you listen to her live G5 and G#5 belts you'll see that many of them have the same quality as her studio belts.
@Aontiverozol Actually depending on the severity of the nodules surgery isn't always required, countless people have rid them selves of nodules by going on vocal rest for long periods of times. And the surgery isn't so dangerous , it's simple really unless your julie andrews who basically had her vocal chords reconstructed.
@Aontiverozol I think it's the edge of her mixed belt that almost transposes to head voice. I believe to have heard that couple of time in vision of love live version. What I think about MC's mixing is she is not so great at it. Her voice is naturally light but rather thick which is absolutely not a good type to do mix. Aretha is obviously in contrast. Celine can mix well coz her voice is thiner than MC.
@iLLusion625 that barely even counts as a whistle note. women's voices always accidentally hit high pitches mariah's just happens to accidentally go higher than most because of her whistle register so it's really not that impressive lol
@ablackguy123456789 hahahahaha... did you say "REALLY NOT THAT IMPRESSIVE"??? hahaha... i can't believe you said that.. if it's really not that impressive then I DARE YOU OR ARETHA TO DO THAT.!.. BWAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHHAHAHAHA....
@lathanregintree yeah exactly. it's great for dramatic affect or whatever but it's hardly anything to brag about especially if you overdo it like miss lea michele.
i'm so tired of people acting like mariah can't hit G5s and G#5s live. just because she doesn't do it as often as aretha does doesn't mean she can't! not every voice can handle singing 80 G5s and G#5s per concert and why bother when F5s and F#5s will still impress listeners?
tough choice. aretha's G5s and G#5s are so strong and powerful. but mariah's G5s and G#5s are very pretty and resonant. hmmm i pick aretha :) great video!
Incredible comparisons....Mariah is a huge fan of Aretha, it is one of her main idols...Aretha is Aretha, luuuuuv her! Mariah is Mariah....such different singers. I think they're both the greatest of their generations. Mariah's voice is more beautiful....aretha is the queen of soul...I mean...this is so difficult! I think it is a tie! Aretha or Mariah...??? impossible to decide!
Everytime I watch this I try and push for that magical G5!! Unfortunately my mix will only take me to F#5 at a push.
Amazing videooo! Aretha makes me wanna catch the spirit whatever she sings but Mariah's G5s on Anytime You Need A Friend do me IN EVERY SINGLE FUCKING TIME! THAT RICHNESS AND RESONANCE IS JUST UN-MATCHED AT THAT PITCH!!!
@SymphonicSage12 IMO, Mariah is more of a lyric soprano as her upper-chest register sounds healthier than her lower register. I'd say Mariah wins on this one, but live wise, Aretha wins easily.
@joewhite31 I consider her a contralto. Sure her Upper register sounds healthier, but she finds most ease in her lower. Plus her base tone is low, she just has a massive range. But it's whatever, I don't really care for voic types, she can sang her butt off hahahah.
@kelvinpyaeko LOL Kumtekmeon is an idiot. He knows #NOTHING over vocal issues, drooling over a karaoke strainer whose career is nowhere to be found, poor child.
@shaniceslaysurfav bitch shanice's whistles go flat all the time! o holy night, halo, if i were a boy....please don't make me go on...i can barely think of more than 2 or 3 of her live whistles that didn't go flat.
@misses18yearold HOW DARE YOU DISS SHANICE?? she is a musical genius! she has far more musicianship than aretha and mariah combined and you have no right to be talking bad about her especially being a mariah stan
@shaniceslaysurfav honey you need to crawl out from under your rock because shanice has no musicianship. mariah and aretha are superior to her in every way and if you consider shanice to be better than either of them...good for you...
@misses18yearold you're embarrassing yourself. everybody knows shanice is a superior vocalist to mariah. stop talking shit about shanice and face reality!
@shaniceslaysurfav bitch you're on my turf now and i'll talk shit about whoever the hell i want. if you don't like it, gtfo and go cry to your fellow shanice stans on SHANICE'S videos. then again, i suppose it can get awfully lonely having convos with your other accounts.
@misses18yearold I Guess So Dahaling. It's Just A Word Like Any Other. However, If That Word Offended You, Then My Apologize. P.S Im Gay So The Word Doesn't Bother Me Much :-)
@QueenMariahCarey oh i didn't know you were gay. yeah i don't like that word but i don't get mad at gay guys when they use it cuz they don't mean any harm lol
@shaniceslaysurfav watch?v=hk27zGpn2ts 3:34 watch?v=zENW28LMXuY 3:22 and there are quite a few other examples i just gave you 2 because that's as much as your little mind can process ;) #dismissed
Both incredible! Aretha just slams them like they're nothing it's ridiculous....then Mariah, her tone is sustained so beautifully...she loses NONE of her vocal quality as she ascends up her chest range!
Aretha has more consistency and power in the upper belting area, but I prefer Mariah's sound/tone. I call it a tie. They both excel in upper belts for different reasons.
Mariah has such ease with her upper belts,... yet not like Aretha, but I think comes down to technique, Aretha is a big and well perfect 'mixer' which takes nothing away from her skill and greatness as an upper belter, but Mariah doesnt nearly or consciously mix like Aretha, yet still has that resonance and tone that doesnt flicker/change when hitting the top 5th octave... which to me is why I prefer her, but im not nsaying she wins, because different tastes. different winner but yeah thats mine
Aretha has much more ease up there. But Mariah has more resonance. I'm gonna go with Mariah. Her's sound much more pleasant to the ear. But Aretha's sound great as well. Great job on this!! :)
Hmmm..Aretha is more emotionally moving, and has more power in the upper register, in esp., when she gets happy, and hits her effortlessly, infamous G#5. She rules the upper register and G#5!
@pritykazy It always depends on what one wants more of. Raw strength, of course arethra, patti take the cake (pun not intended). If youre going for tonal quality and vocal acrobatics mariah takes the cake. :) I prefer Mariahs belts btw
Mariah´s voice has a unique quality her high notes, even her A5 (not shown on the video) sound good. Aretha on the other hand mixes her voice too much with head voice in order to be able to hit those notes, making it sound common; I mean her high notes sound a lot like Patti, Jennifer Hudson, Jennifer Holliday, while Mariah sounds MAriah even in High Mixed voice.
Wow I didn't know Mariah had so many G5's/G#5's to be honest...but I just love the tone of Mariah's. I do believe they definitely aren't as effortless as Aretha's but Aretha's sound less appealing to my ear.
I absolutely love the G5's in "Outside" from the Butterfly album! Those are probably my favorite.
@MsArethaforever but that's not true to the whole extent that ANY one can sound resonant in studio..lol unless you put some technology gimmicks on shitty singers like miley or rihanna, they won't sound so. and you are kind of implying mc sounds resonant as if only in studio
@MsArethaforever of course, aretha's has more resonance and belts more effortlessly, tbh. and their placement for belting are different, but it's still not true to an whole extent that any one sound so. lol
@vagugagoogoo When leona can do a G5 without sounding strained, shrieking or squealish and with resonance, then maybe she will be up for that title. Until then she will be forever owned by the queen of soul and songbird supreme hehe
@vagugagoogoo their legends, respected legends, where is leona? licking her wounds after having a flopped album and living off of her one little tiny hit.
@vagugagoogoo LOL! Leona doesn't hold a candle to these legends. Leona is mini Mariah. So how could she better than Mariah if she is a lesser copy? Thank you, now sit your fruity ass down bitch.
mariah is very good.. we all know that.. but sorry ARETHA SLAYS.. More powerful.. she can easily ACCESS her upper belting register.. mariah is never known for her upperbelts.. ARETHA DOES.. and probably her upperbelts is the best
@pritykazy mariah has always been known for her upper belts lol... not AS HIGH in chest as Aretha of course, but she is a class A E5-G#5 vocalist.. one of the only poeple she falls short to is Aretha
@Dam112 nope dear.. mariah is known for having 5 octave range.. but her e5 to g#5 is OK, ok compare to ARETHA.. but great compare to others.. how many times mariah hitted g5 and g#5? in her 20 years career? for about 30 times only.. but aretha hitted those notes for like 700times lol.. she was known for having whistle registry..great runs and riffs and melismas.. but never with uperbelts..well still great.. but not as great as REE,
@pritykazy yes 'dear'.. 5 octave range.. her high belts and whistle register, and tbh that is just by people that dont really know much about music because within the industry she is known for ALOT more.. she has MANY G5's & G#5, but as i said - Aretha is a higher upper belter, a G5+..
@Dam112 lmfao, mariah is very good singer as ive said.. im a fan of her.. but she was NEVER FAMOUS WITH HER UPPERBELTS, her upperbelts was nicely placed vocally.. but she;s no GOOD aretha.. WHO DIRECTLY HIT her upperbelts.. in an INSTANT.. aretha had easy access in her upperbelts.. mariah took so long and always hitting lower notes to be able to hit her upper belt.. celarly maiah was never knowned to had great upperbelt like RETHA, just delude your self moron now next
@pritykazy i am nto taking anything away form Aretha she is the queen of upper belts - i am in no way delusional do not act like such an ignorant twat.. Mariah has more ease in her upper register than most female singers.. mariah DIRECTLY hits her upper belts and with ease (not so much now'a'day yes, but over all).
I dont know where you get she ''takes so long to hit those notes...
either way, i have no time for rude cunts when a general conversation was being had - peace
@pritykazy Mariah is known for her upper regist. Aretha would never be able to sing songs such as Anytime you need a friend, or make it happen because she is a Dramatic Soprano which means that although her voice can reach high notes ( being to mixed and repetitive for my taste) it dones´t have the agility Mariah´s voice has, and so Mariah is able to hit high notes repeatedly where Aretha would find it hard. Plus Mariah´s high notes are from rare quality, one of a kind, Aretha has a typical voic
@pedy19 keep deluding yourself that mariah was known for her upper register.. im not saying that her upper belts are not good coz it was great.. but sorry cant change the fact that ARETHA is the queen.. of the upperbelts.. and yeah aretha cant sing mimi songs, so is mimi.. she can't sing aretha;s song she messed up wit aretha's don't play that song, and remember divas live 1996.,. aretha KILLED MARIAH in chain of fools.. lol.. typical voice? haha.. call me when an typical singer belts D6, LOL
@pritykazy First, Belting is a definition not entirely correct, since it is supposed to be chest voice as far as I realize...well neither Mariah´s nor Aretha´s high notes are in chest, but in mixed voice, ( Aretha starts mixing in lower notes than Mimi, since her chest voice is heavier). Then D6 would never be a belt, it´s head voice, and Aretha´s D6 is not strong and actually doesn´t sound good. I love Aretha voice but in medium range. Plus Chain of fools MAriah was singing higher, even though
@Chimier I don´t agree with that expression and it is used when the mixed voice resembles more to chest, than to head. Well that´s subjective, not even opera singers use pure head because although it´s high it lacks strength therefore it is only used by contemporary singers ( Mariah excelled the technique).
@pedy19 Opera singers mostly use chest, mixed and head. And when proper technique is learned, the registers of the voice gain a "squillo" that allows them to be heard over orchestras and sing without a mic.
@Chimier wait a sec...it´s not that simple. You must spend years of practice in classical so you can actually have this ability...plus not everyone would be able to do it...let´s not get overwhelmed please
@Chimier you made it sound so... anyway classic techniques would bring some handicaps to their style since, their voice would lose (in part ) some speed. I mean classic singers might have this huge projection but they sacrifice some things in order to attain it.
@Chimier Limber in their own parameters, just listen to Pavarotti singing Hero, he was a Lyric tenor, therefore his voice was one of the most agile voices in tenors (only a Liggero being more) still you can tell. Please this argument is useless, you´re trying to prove something you don´t really know nothing about.
@Chimier Pavarotti´s voice isn´t dark... not at all. Yes ok, I don´t know that much, it´s just I´ve got some opera singers as close friends, so If you want to learn what I know I´ll gladly teach you (it´s not that much as I´ve said)
@pedy19 I wasn't talking about Pavarotti's voice when I said a darker voice won't be as agile as a lighter one. I was making a statement regarding what you said about agility in perimeters.
@pedy19 No. The technique itself requires them to do so. They must lift the palate, "create" a space in their mouth, (sounding like "sapo cocas" it´s not nice). You might want to check out classical trained Tenors singing pop using their technique and you´ll realize, they would find it hard to sing, songs as "yeah" from usher since the song rhythm is quite fast. Being an opera singer doesn´t mean you´ll be able to sing every kind of genre.
"Yeah" by Usher is a piece of shit, what respectable classically trained voice would want to sing it? and even more, who would want to sing like Usher with his whiny high larynx? eww.
Where's is 1:25 from?
Asradewmt 2 weeks ago
mariah slayed with her soprano range. her vocal tone is so much higher then arethas the voice of a true coloraltura soprano :)
lathanregintree 4 weeks ago
Aretha has more ease and power in the high belting area than damn near any other singer that ever was, but I like and prefer Mariah's vocal tone here to that of Aretha's (if I am to be entirely honest)... I mean, she literally sounds like an ANGEL at points in this video. The Queen and the Songbird both slay everything though, so in the end, they both win :P
ManOfBamboo 1 month ago
I think Aretha sounds more like she's yelling rather than singing in some parts. Mariah's 0:54 with Outside was the shit and the Honey bit afterwards was too. Both are great singers :D
Failorang 2 months ago
Wow. For like 90% of the video it was a mistake pitting these two against each other. Aretha SLAYED...except for on her last two notes! The one from "Loverboy" is my absolute favorite!
AStevenson91 2 months ago
I think Aretha hits those notes more easily because her natural voice is high, while Mariah's natural voice (I think) is actually low so she'd put a little more effort when she belts above F5 (she stated before she considered herself an alto).
deonoxivar 2 months ago
mariah ...........
muhammadbenny2 2 months ago
Mariah ! She totally destroyed Aretha :)
KillBabyKillfy 2 months ago
4:35 which song is this???
PrincessShiba85 2 months ago
@PrincessShiba85 0:54 Outside, 4:35 Subtle Invitation
MimiDahhling30 2 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 thanks!
PrincessShiba85 2 months ago
00:54 which song is this?
PrincessShiba85 2 months ago
aretha song at 4:53?
ablackguy123456789 3 months ago
NOW THIS IS A VOCAL BATTLE!! FOR GET THE OTHER SINGER VS SINGER BATTLES!! ^_^
lathanregintree 3 months ago
The messiah of course! Nah I give this to Aretha even tho im a lamb. Aretha low notes and highs...insane. also Mariah is great but she used a lot of production to get her notes(she is hitting them just in multiple takes) Aretha wasn't privy to that technology and well shit o.o
shaunmike 3 months ago
@shaunmike i agree taht aretha wins this but mariah's studio belts are not that enhanced(if at all). if you listen to her live G5 and G#5 belts you'll see that many of them have the same quality as her studio belts.
ablackguy123456789 3 months ago
por siempre mariah la mejor
15gabito 3 months ago
@Aontiverozol Actually depending on the severity of the nodules surgery isn't always required, countless people have rid them selves of nodules by going on vocal rest for long periods of times. And the surgery isn't so dangerous , it's simple really unless your julie andrews who basically had her vocal chords reconstructed.
hessounusual95 3 months ago
@Aontiverozol Celine recovered from her nodules though by going on a 6 month vocal rest...?
hessounusual95 3 months ago
What's the song at 3:48? I listened to it before and I loved it, but I can't remember the name :S
stardusth2o 4 months ago
@stardusth2o Mine Again :) You should do a vocal showcase of it, her vocals are amazing.
MimiDahhling30 4 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 That's right! I love that song, I lip synched to it a couple times XD
And that's a good idea, because her singing WAS insane in that song.
stardusth2o 4 months ago
@stardusth2o Haha! If you do it, don't forget the F#7 chirp at the end. xD
MimiDahhling30 4 months ago
@Aontiverozol I think it's the edge of her mixed belt that almost transposes to head voice. I believe to have heard that couple of time in vision of love live version. What I think about MC's mixing is she is not so great at it. Her voice is naturally light but rather thick which is absolutely not a good type to do mix. Aretha is obviously in contrast. Celine can mix well coz her voice is thiner than MC.
PairJaNaJa 4 months ago
@Aontiverozol okeedokee. thanks for clearing that up for us ^_^
ablackguy123456789 4 months ago
@Aontiverozol i wasn't talking about the G5 belt i was referring to that high pitched noise that illusionwhoever was bragging about.
ablackguy123456789 4 months ago
aretha song at 4:53?
ablackguy123456789 4 months ago
now Aretha, can you hit the part 3:02 that HIGH..?! lol i don't think so.
iLLusion625 4 months ago
@iLLusion625 there's definitely not a high note at 3:02. what are you talking about?
ablackguy123456789 4 months ago
@ablackguy123456789 whoot?? are you tone deaf?? can't you hear that super high note at 3:02.. A whistle register note.? you sure?
iLLusion625 4 months ago
@iLLusion625 that barely even counts as a whistle note. women's voices always accidentally hit high pitches mariah's just happens to accidentally go higher than most because of her whistle register so it's really not that impressive lol
ablackguy123456789 4 months ago
@ablackguy123456789 hahahahaha... did you say "REALLY NOT THAT IMPRESSIVE"??? hahaha... i can't believe you said that.. if it's really not that impressive then I DARE YOU OR ARETHA TO DO THAT.!.. BWAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHHAHAHAHA....
iLLusion625 4 months ago
@iLLusion625 sweetie, that accidental whistle interrupted her transition between notes so it was basically a voice crack. nothing to be proud of.
ablackguy123456789 4 months ago
@ablackguy123456789 This is not whistle. This is a consequence of mixed voice.
rekupp 4 months ago
@rekupp really because i only hear mariah's voice make that noise not patti, aretha, whitney, or jennifer who also use mixed voice
ablackguy123456789 4 months ago
@ablackguy123456789 Jennifer Hudson does it...you need better ears. This is not whistle voice. One does not simply "slip" into whistle register.
rekupp 4 months ago
@rekupp i need better ears? lol ok mariah actually does accidentally hit whistle notes sometimes. talk about needing better ears...
ablackguy123456789 4 months ago
@ablackguy123456789 This is NOT whistle register.
rekupp 4 months ago
@rekupp if it's not a whistle then what is it? a wheeze?
ablackguy123456789 4 months ago
@ablackguy123456789 I AGREE!lol i do the same all the time,lol
lathanregintree 3 months ago
@lathanregintree yeah exactly. it's great for dramatic affect or whatever but it's hardly anything to brag about especially if you overdo it like miss lea michele.
ablackguy123456789 3 months ago
@rekupp i do all the time,lol when i belt to high ^_^
lathanregintree 3 months ago
@ablackguy123456789 what's so impressive is her ability to control it, not that just she can go high.
PairJaNaJa 4 months ago
now Aretha, can you hit the part 3:02 that HIGH..?! lol i don't think so.
iLLusion625 4 months ago
why does mariah notes sound higher even though they are the same note
mcsguardianangel 4 months ago
i'm so tired of people acting like mariah can't hit G5s and G#5s live. just because she doesn't do it as often as aretha does doesn't mean she can't! not every voice can handle singing 80 G5s and G#5s per concert and why bother when F5s and F#5s will still impress listeners?
ablackguy123456789 4 months ago
tough choice. aretha's G5s and G#5s are so strong and powerful. but mariah's G5s and G#5s are very pretty and resonant. hmmm i pick aretha :) great video!
ablackguy123456789 4 months ago
whit this notes... Mariah is an Alto? , Godness! Genuine Soprano!
JesusDonaldoOFICIAL 5 months ago
@michaeldriggers123 Outside
MimiDahhling30 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Incredible comparisons....Mariah is a huge fan of Aretha, it is one of her main idols...Aretha is Aretha, luuuuuv her! Mariah is Mariah....such different singers. I think they're both the greatest of their generations. Mariah's voice is more beautiful....aretha is the queen of soul...I mean...this is so difficult! I think it is a tie! Aretha or Mariah...??? impossible to decide!
suppaduppaUSA 6 months ago
Comment removed
suppaduppaUSA 6 months ago
whats the song mariah is singing at 1:39 ?
Anime00Freak 6 months ago
@Anime00Freak anytime you need a friend remix
misses18yearold 6 months ago
@misses18yearold THANX ALOT ! <3
Anime00Freak 5 months ago
I love them both but Mariah is my fave of all time!!
felo4444 7 months ago
Everytime I watch this I try and push for that magical G5!! Unfortunately my mix will only take me to F#5 at a push.
Amazing videooo! Aretha makes me wanna catch the spirit whatever she sings but Mariah's G5s on Anytime You Need A Friend do me IN EVERY SINGLE FUCKING TIME! THAT RICHNESS AND RESONANCE IS JUST UN-MATCHED AT THAT PITCH!!!
JonathanGardnerTV 7 months ago
@SymphonicSage12 IMO, Mariah is more of a lyric soprano as her upper-chest register sounds healthier than her lower register. I'd say Mariah wins on this one, but live wise, Aretha wins easily.
joewhite31 7 months ago
@joewhite31 I consider her a contralto. Sure her Upper register sounds healthier, but she finds most ease in her lower. Plus her base tone is low, she just has a massive range. But it's whatever, I don't really care for voic types, she can sang her butt off hahahah.
MrButler124 7 months ago
@joewhite31 Nope Alto wit ha 5 octave range
aquamarine11500 6 months ago
I tasted what heaven was during 5 min...Thanks
mediterraneoboy 7 months ago
i pick mariah although her voice isn't as strong as aretha's her resonance and clarity is amazing!
im18dammit100 7 months ago
Oh and wack ass shanice sings HELLA muthafucken FLAT! !!! K BYE (:
trybeeMUSIC 7 months ago
MARIAH definitely WINS by FAR ! Aretha hits the same notes , but sounds fuckin whiney and shreiking ..shut the fuck up fat bitch
trybeeMUSIC 7 months ago
@trybeeMUSIC stfu aretha's belts sound like shrieks now but in her prime, she belted G5s and G#5s like nobody's business and they sounded beautiful!
misses18yearold 7 months ago
What font do you use to make the G5s and G#5s?
Raimundo91 7 months ago
what's the aretha song at 1:22?
mariahforever1990 7 months ago
@mariahforever1990 That is from Aretha's version of "People Get Ready" from her album Lady Soul!
TheQueenAretha 7 months ago
@TheQueenAretha thanks!
mariahforever1990 7 months ago
Baaahahahaha!!!! Shaniceslaysurfav. Really? Bahahaha
narutoclaymore 7 months ago
shanice slays both of them btw
shaniceslaysurfav 7 months ago
@shaniceslaysurfav LMAO, that karaoke strainer is nobody. Stay pressed.
Stefano94x 7 months ago
@Stefano94x isn't that pressed bitch also xtinadisciple? the way it talks is so obvious if you check its other comments
kelvinpyaeko 7 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko I don't think that bitch know Shanice. But Shanice's stans are incredibly pressed.
Stefano94x 7 months ago
@Stefano94x may be..i thought kumtakemeon is pressed already..but this bitch is worse lmao
kelvinpyaeko 7 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko LOL Kumtekmeon is an idiot. He knows #NOTHING over vocal issues, drooling over a karaoke strainer whose career is nowhere to be found, poor child.
Stefano94x 7 months ago
let's see. a studio-engineered PHONY(mariah) vs a real singer who can actually hit the notes live(aretha). tough call indeed....
shaniceslaysurfav 7 months ago
@shaniceslaysurfav sweetie you really need help. shanice is the one who uses studio devices to put her (FLAT) whistles in the right pitch
misses18yearold 7 months ago
@misses18yearold BITCH SHANICE NEVER GOES FLAT YOU TAKE THAT BACK YOU CUNT!
shaniceslaysurfav 7 months ago
@shaniceslaysurfav bitch shanice's whistles go flat all the time! o holy night, halo, if i were a boy....please don't make me go on...i can barely think of more than 2 or 3 of her live whistles that didn't go flat.
misses18yearold 7 months ago
@misses18yearold HOW DARE YOU DISS SHANICE?? she is a musical genius! she has far more musicianship than aretha and mariah combined and you have no right to be talking bad about her especially being a mariah stan
shaniceslaysurfav 7 months ago
@shaniceslaysurfav honey you need to crawl out from under your rock because shanice has no musicianship. mariah and aretha are superior to her in every way and if you consider shanice to be better than either of them...good for you...
misses18yearold 7 months ago
@misses18yearold you're embarrassing yourself. everybody knows shanice is a superior vocalist to mariah. stop talking shit about shanice and face reality!
shaniceslaysurfav 7 months ago
@shaniceslaysurfav bitch you're on my turf now and i'll talk shit about whoever the hell i want. if you don't like it, gtfo and go cry to your fellow shanice stans on SHANICE'S videos. then again, i suppose it can get awfully lonely having convos with your other accounts.
misses18yearold 7 months ago
@misses18yearold whatever i'm so over this. you mariah fans are so damaged
shaniceslaysurfav 7 months ago
@shaniceslaysurfav if you're over it, THEN LEAVE!
misses18yearold 7 months ago
@misses18yearold Please Hun Pay That Lonely, Delusional Fag No Mind. Shanice Is Simply A...Nobody And Will Always Come Last To Her Queen Mariah.
QueenMariahCarey 7 months ago
@QueenMariahCarey lol thanks but you didn't have to use the F word...
misses18yearold 7 months ago
@misses18yearold I Guess So Dahaling. It's Just A Word Like Any Other. However, If That Word Offended You, Then My Apologize. P.S Im Gay So The Word Doesn't Bother Me Much :-)
QueenMariahCarey 7 months ago
@QueenMariahCarey oh i didn't know you were gay. yeah i don't like that word but i don't get mad at gay guys when they use it cuz they don't mean any harm lol
misses18yearold 7 months ago
@misses18yearold Lol Cute
QueenMariahCarey 7 months ago
@shaniceslaysurfav watch?v=hk27zGpn2ts 3:34 watch?v=zENW28LMXuY 3:22 and there are quite a few other examples i just gave you 2 because that's as much as your little mind can process ;) #dismissed
mariahforever1990 7 months ago
what's the mariah song at 4:58?
misses18yearold 7 months ago
5:17 best part of the video :)
misses18yearold 8 months ago 16
@misses18yearold couldn't agree more! "IIIIII found my savin graaaace"
im18dammit100 7 months ago
@misses18yearold agree, her clarity is ridiculous
mcdamian17 7 months ago
tough call. i pick mariah. aretha hits the notes more easily but mariah's resonance is so magical! the queen of soul puts up a good fight though!
misses18yearold 8 months ago
@misses18yearold I kinda agree with you but which one is more powerful?
bohogirl10 6 months ago
@bohogirl10 aretha's more powerful but mariah has more resonance
misses18yearold 6 months ago
Both incredible! Aretha just slams them like they're nothing it's ridiculous....then Mariah, her tone is sustained so beautifully...she loses NONE of her vocal quality as she ascends up her chest range!
HeartToYours 8 months ago
Aretha has more consistency and power in the upper belting area, but I prefer Mariah's sound/tone. I call it a tie. They both excel in upper belts for different reasons.
ManOfBamboo 8 months ago
Mariah has such ease with her upper belts,... yet not like Aretha, but I think comes down to technique, Aretha is a big and well perfect 'mixer' which takes nothing away from her skill and greatness as an upper belter, but Mariah doesnt nearly or consciously mix like Aretha, yet still has that resonance and tone that doesnt flicker/change when hitting the top 5th octave... which to me is why I prefer her, but im not nsaying she wins, because different tastes. different winner but yeah thats mine
Dam112 8 months ago
@Aontiverozol I know right? Her A5 in Fly Like A Bird doesn't even sound high.
stardusth2o 8 months ago
Aretha has much more ease up there. But Mariah has more resonance. I'm gonna go with Mariah. Her's sound much more pleasant to the ear. But Aretha's sound great as well. Great job on this!! :)
stardusth2o 8 months ago
@stardusth2o haha agreeed :) & thankyou for owning that delusional Leona stan lmfao.
MimiDahhling30 8 months ago
@MimiDahhling30 LMAO! Leona stans are too easy.
stardusth2o 8 months ago
@stardusth2o Mariah does not have more resonance than Aretha up there....
Chimier 8 months ago
Comment removed
stardusth2o 8 months ago
@stardusth2o lmfao! Your allowed to have your opnion ;)
MimiDahhling30 8 months ago
Hmmm..Aretha is more emotionally moving, and has more power in the upper register, in esp., when she gets happy, and hits her effortlessly, infamous G#5. She rules the upper register and G#5!
Thanks, for the audio posting.
wsardin 8 months ago
Aretha VS. Mariah they're tie. BOTH QUEENS OF G5
LloydCafeCadena 8 months ago 9
@pritykazy It always depends on what one wants more of. Raw strength, of course arethra, patti take the cake (pun not intended). If youre going for tonal quality and vocal acrobatics mariah takes the cake. :) I prefer Mariahs belts btw
narutoclaymore 8 months ago
Mariah´s voice has a unique quality her high notes, even her A5 (not shown on the video) sound good. Aretha on the other hand mixes her voice too much with head voice in order to be able to hit those notes, making it sound common; I mean her high notes sound a lot like Patti, Jennifer Hudson, Jennifer Holliday, while Mariah sounds MAriah even in High Mixed voice.
pedy19 8 months ago
Wow I didn't know Mariah had so many G5's/G#5's to be honest...but I just love the tone of Mariah's. I do believe they definitely aren't as effortless as Aretha's but Aretha's sound less appealing to my ear.
I absolutely love the G5's in "Outside" from the Butterfly album! Those are probably my favorite.
HigeRox 8 months ago
Aretha slays :)
FanaticoManiatico 8 months ago
1091 views with 14 pages of comments? LoL
roizvirtual 8 months ago
anyone can sound resonant on studio recordings, live Aretha covers Mariah's voice.
MsArethaforever 8 months ago
@MsArethaforever but that's not true to the whole extent that ANY one can sound resonant in studio..lol unless you put some technology gimmicks on shitty singers like miley or rihanna, they won't sound so. and you are kind of implying mc sounds resonant as if only in studio
kelvinpyaeko 8 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko yes anyone can, Mariah's voice is resonant live as well, but not as much as Aretha's
MsArethaforever 8 months ago
@MsArethaforever of course, aretha's has more resonance and belts more effortlessly, tbh. and their placement for belting are different, but it's still not true to an whole extent that any one sound so. lol
kelvinpyaeko 8 months ago
@MsArethaforever with sound effects they can. ex:Katy Perry
MsArethaforever 8 months ago
@MsArethaforever mariah has hit G5s and G#5s live with resonance quite a few times. don't hate
ablackguy123456789 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Mariah holds her own :)
Stefano94x 8 months ago
@Aontiverozol what are you talking about... where have i ever mentioned her ''not hitting a note''
Dam112 8 months ago
i dont think MC has such a lot of G5s and G#5s like that :)
duythanhst 8 months ago
WOW!
THIS VIDEO WAS AMAZING!
Aretha's G5's are so damn effortless! It's just incredible. Her voice was made for belting and sustaining those high notes so well!
When it comes to Mariah's voice, in my own opinion, the sound is kinda brighter and has more resonance, but it doesn't sound effortless.
Anyways, both are amazing. Two living legends.
Great video, keep the good work ;)
Undefeated92 8 months ago
@Undefeated92
What About Janet? :)
WhitneyElizabethH 8 months ago
@Undefeated92 thanks carlos :D!
MimiDahhling30 8 months ago
What version of 'Anytime You Need A Friend' is that? 1:38-1:48
eviLFanTaSY1991 8 months ago
@eviLFanTaSY1991 acapella version
MrGdizle 8 months ago
mariah! >.<
Bluezaphire2402 8 months ago
Sounds like two average singers to me.
Where's Leona Lewis?
vagugagoogoo 8 months ago
@vagugagoogoo Um mariah and aretha slay that "average" singer you just named :)
musicguy713 8 months ago
@musicguy713 Bwahahahhahaha!
Leona Lewis is the best singer of all time!
Way better than the fat foghorn and the drunken whore - ahaha!
vagugagoogoo 8 months ago
@vagugagoogoo When leona can do a G5 without sounding strained, shrieking or squealish and with resonance, then maybe she will be up for that title. Until then she will be forever owned by the queen of soul and songbird supreme hehe
musicguy713 8 months ago
@musicguy713 PLEASE!
Leona can hit any note better than those fat whores!
vagugagoogoo 8 months ago
@vagugagoogoo PLEASE those women slay that commercial product even out of their primes!
musicguy713 8 months ago
@musicguy713 Keep dreaming. Where are they now? Exactly!
LEONA WINS!
vagugagoogoo 8 months ago
@vagugagoogoo their legends, respected legends, where is leona? licking her wounds after having a flopped album and living off of her one little tiny hit.
musicguy713 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@musicguy713 Shut the fuck up you fool!
With your nonsense!
LEONA LEWIS IS THE TRUE LEGEND!
Her last album sold more than both those fat whores flop albums combined!
vagugagoogoo 8 months ago
@vagugagoogoo LOL! Leona doesn't hold a candle to these legends. Leona is mini Mariah. So how could she better than Mariah if she is a lesser copy? Thank you, now sit your fruity ass down bitch.
stardusth2o 8 months ago
@stardusth2o Shut the fuck up you fool!
With your nonsense!
LEONA LEWIS WILL MURDER WHORIAH SCAREY ANYDAY!
How can she be a lesser copy if she's miles better than that fat whore? Thank you, now die bitch!
vagugagoogoo 8 months ago
@vagugagoogoo still trying......SMH!!!!
applmac2009 8 months ago
@vagugagoogoo LMAO, the delusion.
Stefano94x 8 months ago
@Stefano94x No delusion, just basic truth. Deal with it!
vagugagoogoo 8 months ago
@vagugagoogoo Do you know anything about technique? Aretha wipes the floor with Leona and her thin flat ass vocals, and so does Mariah.
Stefano94x 8 months ago
@vagugagoogoo haha - joka
Dam112 8 months ago
for belting , I think aretha wins, because she can span up to Bb4 and B5 pure chest voice
RaciouS91 8 months ago
mariah is very good.. we all know that.. but sorry ARETHA SLAYS.. More powerful.. she can easily ACCESS her upper belting register.. mariah is never known for her upperbelts.. ARETHA DOES.. and probably her upperbelts is the best
pritykazy 8 months ago
@pritykazy mariah has always been known for her upper belts lol... not AS HIGH in chest as Aretha of course, but she is a class A E5-G#5 vocalist.. one of the only poeple she falls short to is Aretha
Dam112 8 months ago
@Dam112 nope dear.. mariah is known for having 5 octave range.. but her e5 to g#5 is OK, ok compare to ARETHA.. but great compare to others.. how many times mariah hitted g5 and g#5? in her 20 years career? for about 30 times only.. but aretha hitted those notes for like 700times lol.. she was known for having whistle registry..great runs and riffs and melismas.. but never with uperbelts..well still great.. but not as great as REE,
pritykazy 8 months ago
@pritykazy yes 'dear'.. 5 octave range.. her high belts and whistle register, and tbh that is just by people that dont really know much about music because within the industry she is known for ALOT more.. she has MANY G5's & G#5, but as i said - Aretha is a higher upper belter, a G5+..
Dam112 8 months ago 3
@Dam112 lmfao, mariah is very good singer as ive said.. im a fan of her.. but she was NEVER FAMOUS WITH HER UPPERBELTS, her upperbelts was nicely placed vocally.. but she;s no GOOD aretha.. WHO DIRECTLY HIT her upperbelts.. in an INSTANT.. aretha had easy access in her upperbelts.. mariah took so long and always hitting lower notes to be able to hit her upper belt.. celarly maiah was never knowned to had great upperbelt like RETHA, just delude your self moron now next
pritykazy 8 months ago
@pritykazy i am nto taking anything away form Aretha she is the queen of upper belts - i am in no way delusional do not act like such an ignorant twat.. Mariah has more ease in her upper register than most female singers.. mariah DIRECTLY hits her upper belts and with ease (not so much now'a'day yes, but over all).
I dont know where you get she ''takes so long to hit those notes...
either way, i have no time for rude cunts when a general conversation was being had - peace
Dam112 8 months ago
@pritykazy Mariah is known for her upper regist. Aretha would never be able to sing songs such as Anytime you need a friend, or make it happen because she is a Dramatic Soprano which means that although her voice can reach high notes ( being to mixed and repetitive for my taste) it dones´t have the agility Mariah´s voice has, and so Mariah is able to hit high notes repeatedly where Aretha would find it hard. Plus Mariah´s high notes are from rare quality, one of a kind, Aretha has a typical voic
pedy19 8 months ago
@pedy19 keep deluding yourself that mariah was known for her upper register.. im not saying that her upper belts are not good coz it was great.. but sorry cant change the fact that ARETHA is the queen.. of the upperbelts.. and yeah aretha cant sing mimi songs, so is mimi.. she can't sing aretha;s song she messed up wit aretha's don't play that song, and remember divas live 1996.,. aretha KILLED MARIAH in chain of fools.. lol.. typical voice? haha.. call me when an typical singer belts D6, LOL
pritykazy 8 months ago
@pritykazy First, Belting is a definition not entirely correct, since it is supposed to be chest voice as far as I realize...well neither Mariah´s nor Aretha´s high notes are in chest, but in mixed voice, ( Aretha starts mixing in lower notes than Mimi, since her chest voice is heavier). Then D6 would never be a belt, it´s head voice, and Aretha´s D6 is not strong and actually doesn´t sound good. I love Aretha voice but in medium range. Plus Chain of fools MAriah was singing higher, even though
pedy19 8 months ago
@pedy19 Belting is certainly the correct definition, and it is not exclusive to chest voice.
And Ree belted that D6. It wasn't pure head voice at all.
Chimier 8 months ago
@Chimier I don´t agree with that expression and it is used when the mixed voice resembles more to chest, than to head. Well that´s subjective, not even opera singers use pure head because although it´s high it lacks strength therefore it is only used by contemporary singers ( Mariah excelled the technique).
pedy19 8 months ago
@pedy19 Opera singers mostly use chest, mixed and head. And when proper technique is learned, the registers of the voice gain a "squillo" that allows them to be heard over orchestras and sing without a mic.
Chimier 8 months ago
@Chimier wait a sec...it´s not that simple. You must spend years of practice in classical so you can actually have this ability...plus not everyone would be able to do it...let´s not get overwhelmed please
pedy19 8 months ago
@pedy19 Where did I say it was simple? Nowhere.
Chimier 8 months ago
@Chimier you made it sound so... anyway classic techniques would bring some handicaps to their style since, their voice would lose (in part ) some speed. I mean classic singers might have this huge projection but they sacrifice some things in order to attain it.
pedy19 8 months ago
@pedy19 No, that's not true at all. Proper classical technique keeps the voice limber, regardless of the vocal weight.
Chimier 8 months ago
@Chimier Limber in their own parameters, just listen to Pavarotti singing Hero, he was a Lyric tenor, therefore his voice was one of the most agile voices in tenors (only a Liggero being more) still you can tell. Please this argument is useless, you´re trying to prove something you don´t really know nothing about.
pedy19 8 months ago
@pedy19 Well, duh. A darker voice won't be as agile as a lighter one.
Pavarotti was singing a POP song. The vocal requirements for a POP song and a classical song are very different.
Yep, I know nothing about it. You got me there. *sigh*
Bye.
Chimier 8 months ago
@Chimier Pavarotti´s voice isn´t dark... not at all. Yes ok, I don´t know that much, it´s just I´ve got some opera singers as close friends, so If you want to learn what I know I´ll gladly teach you (it´s not that much as I´ve said)
pedy19 8 months ago
@pedy19 I wasn't talking about Pavarotti's voice when I said a darker voice won't be as agile as a lighter one. I was making a statement regarding what you said about agility in perimeters.
No thanks. I don't need your knowledge.
Chimier 8 months ago
@pedy19 No. The technique itself requires them to do so. They must lift the palate, "create" a space in their mouth, (sounding like "sapo cocas" it´s not nice). You might want to check out classical trained Tenors singing pop using their technique and you´ll realize, they would find it hard to sing, songs as "yeah" from usher since the song rhythm is quite fast. Being an opera singer doesn´t mean you´ll be able to sing every kind of genre.
pedy19 8 months ago
@pedy19
"Yeah" by Usher is a piece of shit, what respectable classically trained voice would want to sing it? and even more, who would want to sing like Usher with his whiny high larynx? eww.
primohomme 8 months ago