I underestimated the power of this song the very first time I listened to it. After only the second time through I had changed my mind about it - it fucking rocks, and the live version proves it.
Broken, bruised forgotten sore. Too fucked up to care anymore!
When they opened with this song during the Summer 2006 tour, they pretty much brought the fucking house down. The power of Trent's vocals and Josh's drumming was pretty surreal.
As dumb an answer as you may think it is, it's a reason he's stated in interviews for several songs about his grandmother. So you can go tell Trent it's a stupid answer.
And no, not all of his songs carry an emotional attachment, because they are not all written from his heart. Because he wrote concept albums, it is easy to guess that not all of them mean all that much.
so completely crazy-ass fucking good. This final "where the fuck were you", god, its just incredible. One of the best, with Eraser/Hurt/Closer/Reptile/Last/Were in this together and so many others... yeah long list.
Not since he got off the drugs, tbh. It did wonders for his music, even if it did fuck him up beyond belief.
Musicians should be prepared to sacrifice their well being for the greater good of the awesome sounds... Think The Fragile, his best album, released at his worst time...
Ok, ProjectSikotik, you're basically saying that you'd rather have Trent Reznor die because of doing drugs to make more "emotional" music when he's much more happier off of the drugs making more positive music that is just as good of music compared to all of his other albums? Well, if that's so... then fuck you and go to hell.
the sound is so fucked up... it's probably because the original version is designed for a surround system ( DTS prob'ly ) and so it sounds bad after compressing to stereo ( what i mean is that there are almost no guitars, or they are wayyy to quiet )
IF you mean AATCHB there were quite a few hidden easter eggs. One was of Reptile live, another had Starfuckers with Marilyn Manson. After STarfuckers Mansons stays and NIN plays Beautiful People with Manson singing. Totally sick!!!
a nin fun say that manson never gonna be above nin, a manson fan say the opposite of this, I say that they are both great ,and there are things in both of them in which they are better than the other. (sorry for my poor english)
Very true, he practically admits it in his autobiography (which is a fairly entertaining read). Without Trent, Marilyn would never have gotten past Portrait. Trent wrote the notes to half the songs on AntiChrist, including his biggest hit, 'The Beautiful People.
Yeah...he would've. Down In It (inspired by Dig It) was his first song and it was what started his career. But then again, he listened to Kiss when he was young.
laughs so hard, if it wasnt for Rez there wouldnt be a Manson manson is just a rez wanna be that will never get there. Yep he does some decent stuff sure, but he isnt REZ
i believe this might have been recorded with the dvd set to "dolby surround" which is why the guitars as very quiet, they dont come out if you listen to it in stereo, and of course this video is either encoded in stereo or mono. if it were on "dolby stereo" at the time, then i think theyre a fair bit louder
ღ♫(((¯`♥4Gotten♥♪(♥♫(♥♪(♥♫d)))`♥‿ღ´(((b♫♥)♪♥)♫♥)♪♥Soul♥´¯)))♫ღ
Calun3 3 weeks ago
album version is far more angry than this
MAMBANEGRA5 2 months ago
dieu que c'est bon !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Evangeline70000 3 months ago
I fucking love this song!!!!
beadbitch01 5 months ago
1:38 amazing scream
7256bru 6 months ago
Beside You In Time = BEST THANG EVAR.
itsjustmeshana 6 months ago
i wish u could hit like, a million times. or have a LOOOVVEE button. lmao!! my #2 fav NIN song. <3<3<3<3
mssjeni1 11 months ago
When the drums come in i want to kill someone
bryt12693 1 year ago 3
this song doesn't make me angry....it helps get my frustration out. i listen to it at top volume, everytime it comes on!!
mssjeni1 1 year ago 4
@mssjeni1 Hell yeah! It helps get you pumped up!!!!
jcowell1977 1 year ago
Hearing the name of the song alone makes me piss my pants with adrenaline and go to the nearest zoo and beat all the tigers to death with my earlobe
4Esoteric4Dolphana4 1 year ago 10
I underestimated the power of this song the very first time I listened to it. After only the second time through I had changed my mind about it - it fucking rocks, and the live version proves it.
Broken, bruised forgotten sore. Too fucked up to care anymore!
bopptb 1 year ago 3
@bopptb Oh yeah, and the opening synth sequence is fucking sick.
bopptb 1 year ago
This song makes me fuckin angry too! Fucking love this song!!!!
upaboveit76 1 year ago 2
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
treznor8 1 year ago
trent put down the screen on this song to keep back all the pigs
JimBoopLoop 1 year ago
Rampage music. Yeah, this makes me want to go on a rampage.
86nappygirl 1 year ago
Most of Trent's lyrics are WAH but the music ARR! It's really great music to listen to when you're pissed off at some bitch.
ComaAlpha 1 year ago
@ComaAlpha definitely
doors36 1 year ago
Trent might have the best scream in all of Rock and I'm not fucking around.
oneznzeroz 1 year ago 11
Best song ever!
nantucket68 1 year ago
When they opened with this song during the Summer 2006 tour, they pretty much brought the fucking house down. The power of Trent's vocals and Josh's drumming was pretty surreal.
lordmeowmeow 1 year ago
Goood vid, wave goodbye version is better :)
bryanh882001 2 years ago
i think i could kill someone after listening to this. 10 out of 10
rrmmt23 2 years ago 10
I don't like the kind of screaming he uses here =/ there is no power.
But I saw Somewhat Damaged off the last show (1 week ago) and this is FUCKING AWESOME.
Staphylin 2 years ago
This version is great but it just does not do justice for the version on the CD. Just not as brutal and dark. But still kicks ass.
UnknownShadow718 2 years ago
this song makes me realize how much my parents really fucked up in raising me.
awesome =)
xlEmmorielx 2 years ago 9
THis version is very good however the old version is very stoned too
4730478021 2 years ago 4
is this on the bonus features??
I didn't ever notice it
sgf1989 2 years ago 5
fuck, this song make me angry, just listening to it.
morkel77 2 years ago 29
the most anger trent shows the better
saintdoke 2 years ago 4
WHERE THE FUCK WERE YOU!?
nemesiswontdie 3 years ago 43
as in, 'where the fuck were you', what is not to understand ?
bhamdairy 1 year ago
Why don't they ever play this when I see them live!!!
PathofReason 3 years ago
Because it's a bit of an emotional song for him
AGENT24 2 years ago 5
that's a dumb answer, AGENT24. I think it would be safe to say all of his songs carry emotional attachment
999422036 2 years ago 5
As dumb an answer as you may think it is, it's a reason he's stated in interviews for several songs about his grandmother. So you can go tell Trent it's a stupid answer.
And no, not all of his songs carry an emotional attachment, because they are not all written from his heart. Because he wrote concept albums, it is easy to guess that not all of them mean all that much.
AGENT24 2 years ago
Is this sampling "Now I'm Nothing"?
Salvador33HPR 3 years ago
lol, great ears. it sounds very similar
NvikIngsN 3 years ago 2
Ironic you say great ears, cause I'm made fun of for them haha. Random I know but just saying. Anyway, I love both this song and "Now I'm Nothing".
Salvador33HPR 3 years ago
don't let it get you down. YOU have great ears.
openingsound 2 years ago 4
Thanks
Salvador33HPR 2 years ago
Is this Sept 2006 Mountain View CA?
Can Trent possibly get any more perfect he is absolutely amazing.
01Kore 3 years ago
you went to that show man, your pretty lucky. i wanted to go to. i wanted to see the bauhaus to :/
XINDIOS 3 years ago
who ever said its a jazzy bass line is retarted, thats clearly a guitar. you hear bass at 1:50
TReXX210 3 years ago
love this version of the song...
it got a sample of now im nothing at the beggining of it...
StZombie23 3 years ago
LMAO @ 0:56
"the jazzy bassline"
Idk why I find it funny, maybe cuz the original song is so angry and that bassline just makes me filled with joy, lol.
Don't get me wrong, it gets goin' at 1:15
NIN - I'm lovin' it more than McDonalds
djh3mp 3 years ago
hhe dosnt do this song live much these days. :(
mlsmodmusic 3 years ago
3:24
watch that part. trent's jump is amazing!
erk710erk710 3 years ago
I love this song. I would love to hear it live. It's just so... intense.
AnotherOtherDay 3 years ago 4
''I personally like
"Broken, bruised, forgotten sore,
Too fucked up to care anymore,
Poisoned to my rotten core,
Too fucked up to care anymore"
Lyrically this has to be the best song ever for Trent (IMO the best NIN song ever...) ''
Seriously ??
benjomatico 3 years ago
Nah, I think either Into the Void, Closer or The Big Comedown are the best, but it is all down to opinion really.
empty216 3 years ago
As far as instrumentals go I would say La Mer. Just how it starts so simple and builds and builds and all mixes so well.
dimebag983 3 years ago
hahaha dimmu borgir
Synogen 3 years ago
how could I ever think it's funny how everything you swore would
never change is different now like you said you and me make it
through didn't quite fell apart where the fuck were you?!!!!
XINDIOS 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Trent, you turn an awesome cahotic song into some kind of pop... wtf?
neverFearIisHere 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
go listen dimmu borgir
fakoff1 3 years ago
why?
neverFearIisHere 3 years ago
so completely crazy-ass fucking good. This final "where the fuck were you", god, its just incredible. One of the best, with Eraser/Hurt/Closer/Reptile/Last/Were in this together and so many others... yeah long list.
trollmaster02235 3 years ago
fuck the rest and stab it dead!
rexdch 3 years ago 2
I personally like
"Broken, bruised, forgotten sore,
Too fucked up to care anymore,
Poisoned to my rotten core,
Too fucked up to care anymore"
Lyrically this has to be the best song ever for Trent (IMO the best NIN song ever...)
IanWebster81 3 years ago 7
it's definitely jamming as fuck
rexdch 3 years ago 3
SHIT!!!!
THE SONG SOUNDS BETTER LIVE
chivamex7 3 years ago
This is possibly my favourite NIN song
AlycenChesley 3 years ago 3
I think this is a lot of NIN fans' favorite song. It's the best song on their best album, so it's natural, I guess.
IanWebster81 3 years ago 2
i can agree with that
Staleyfan34 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wtf trent you ruined my favorite nin song
neonknights23 3 years ago
i was here, trent, i was right here.
molliesmania9 3 years ago
do they have the glass in front of them for the whole show?
officialryan1 3 years ago
God this song rocks 5 star opener for Halo 14
Salvador33HPR 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I have this DVD...which basically means I own all your sorry asses.
revolutionday1 3 years ago
except me. I have it too :]
mudvayne6101 3 years ago 8
so do i
blackcelebrationuk 3 years ago 5
and me dumbass!!!!
dundeevial 3 years ago 3
i have byit woodstock 94 and atchb live cd so i tripple own yous
michealpelletier2 3 years ago 3
kkkkkkkk
gpicinini 3 years ago
I have them and CLOSURE. Suck it.
hannibalsloat 3 years ago 6
the dvd is the shot trust me :) audio&video
shinjialpha 3 years ago
I don't think the guitars are coming through quite as much as planned, but still fucking awesome show
dimebag983 3 years ago
does anyone know where this show was filmed, because i believe the show was a the gorge in wa during sasquatch 08. That show was aweseome!!
klynch2006 3 years ago
*sasquatch 06 typeo
klynch2006 3 years ago
I remember hearing this song live in 06, ohhh man it was so intense, the whole crowd singing along
lingojac 3 years ago 2
awesome intro. watch him play somewhat damaged back in 2000 and it's hard to deny that this version blows it away
HellishHeaven 3 years ago
Wow. I'm so impressed. Trent sounds 4000 times better than on the CD.
<3
VanityInPerson 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Are you serious? All the feeling seems to be sapped out of it.
ProjectSikotik 3 years ago
what? i find all his live performances have much more emotion to them than the album versions
TheGimmers 3 years ago
Not since he got off the drugs, tbh. It did wonders for his music, even if it did fuck him up beyond belief.
Musicians should be prepared to sacrifice their well being for the greater good of the awesome sounds... Think The Fragile, his best album, released at his worst time...
ProjectSikotik 3 years ago
Ok, ProjectSikotik, you're basically saying that you'd rather have Trent Reznor die because of doing drugs to make more "emotional" music when he's much more happier off of the drugs making more positive music that is just as good of music compared to all of his other albums? Well, if that's so... then fuck you and go to hell.
backus007 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Just as good? Positive music? Either chop off your fingers or chop off your ears, because neither are serving you very well here.
ProjectSikotik 3 years ago
I think both are great, though they're somewhat different.
lingojac 3 years ago
i like the cd better, the echo live makes it really crap.
flyworld3 3 years ago
damn it just gets better every time
Fandanglius 3 years ago
I don't like the new intro, but it is nice they started playing it again.
hungryoprah05 3 years ago 3
the sound is so fucked up... it's probably because the original version is designed for a surround system ( DTS prob'ly ) and so it sounds bad after compressing to stereo ( what i mean is that there are almost no guitars, or they are wayyy to quiet )
panzerny 3 years ago 2
the dvd i have of beside you in time doesnt have this song. why?
SomeUsefulIdiot 3 years ago
pirate
this song is the first in the additional content...inside Summer Tour something like that xD
blindseba 3 years ago
cauze..this song is in the "suplemental con"
xD
mHz9911540 3 years ago
Uh.... What? This wasn't on my BYIT DVD. Is it hidden in the extra features or what?
mr5elfde5truct 4 years ago
It should be on the 'summer tour' option. Somewhere in extra content.
rmhanzel 4 years ago
Well I'll be damned..... Thanks a lot man.
mr5elfde5truct 4 years ago
I don't think this one is better
The all that could have been version contains sound effects, wich makes it more agressive.
This one's just some upwarming, while hearing the older one, makes me go mad, just in the beginnnig of the concert
that's my opinion
cassiel2 4 years ago
You know, I read somewhere that there was a hidden part to that DVD, never found it though. Was this on that hidden part by any chance?
rmhanzel 4 years ago
IF you mean AATCHB there were quite a few hidden easter eggs. One was of Reptile live, another had Starfuckers with Marilyn Manson. After STarfuckers Mansons stays and NIN plays Beautiful People with Manson singing. Totally sick!!!
frank113 4 years ago
AWESOME
isaac8399 4 years ago
Even though Trent's screaming, was well...different lol. He still pulled it off to make the song intense as hell for the audience, imo.
...and yes the old one is better.
Kochson 4 years ago
yeah usually nin is better live but you couldn't hear alot of it that well.
0101110110001100 4 years ago 2
Trent won't play Sunspots because he is afraid it will strain his vocal chords ...
listen to how he screams in this lmao
dx313 4 years ago 2
old one is better
arfuswrinkledinks 4 years ago
this intro is terrible
arfuswrinkledinks 4 years ago 4
dumbass
FLOODTHEVOID 3 years ago
a nin fun say that manson never gonna be above nin, a manson fan say the opposite of this, I say that they are both great ,and there are things in both of them in which they are better than the other. (sorry for my poor english)
deadsyfun 4 years ago 5
Manson is never gonna be above NIN. He's no God, a god isn't created. Reznor created him.
Devilsblood 4 years ago
Everyone knows that he created Manson...
Can't we still enjoy Manson's old albums?
XxPsYcHo66xX 4 years ago
OLD albums. Maybe if he tried to sell his music instead of an image. That fool.
Huitzel 4 years ago
Very true, he practically admits it in his autobiography (which is a fairly entertaining read). Without Trent, Marilyn would never have gotten past Portrait. Trent wrote the notes to half the songs on AntiChrist, including his biggest hit, 'The Beautiful People.
rmhanzel 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
and without SP trent would not have existed.. and without throbbing gristle, or kraftwerk, etc etc etc you get it
spadesghost 4 years ago
I think every artist is inspired by another artist and needs the help of another artist.
Plus, I think Trent can handle his music by himself now. He's incredibly talented and has a basic idea about the music industry.
SmashItToPieces 4 years ago 8
oh undoubtably, maybe i meant without SP trent mightve been playing classical piano
and concertos or something else
spadesghost 4 years ago
Yeah...he would've. Down In It (inspired by Dig It) was his first song and it was what started his career. But then again, he listened to Kiss when he was young.
SmashItToPieces 4 years ago
didn't everyone? :)
i especially loved their monster movie
spadesghost 4 years ago
lol
SmashItToPieces 4 years ago
You seem to be forgetting that he was in the new wave band Option 30 before he started NIN ;)
kouler 4 years ago
Manson make good songs like [s]AINT and Coma mOBSCENE by himself, didn't he?
SmashItToPieces 4 years ago
Manson needs trent back.
unholydecay 4 years ago 3
Trent = awesome. he needs to do more songs with Manson, though. Those two were great. Though, Trent Reznor can make damn good songs himself.
SmashItToPieces 4 years ago
laughs so hard, if it wasnt for Rez there wouldnt be a Manson manson is just a rez wanna be that will never get there. Yep he does some decent stuff sure, but he isnt REZ
shae737 4 years ago
Seriously true. Mansons ONLY amazing work was with Reznor direction... The rest is just barely better then mainstream...
Seedr0 4 years ago
somewhat damaged, the perfect opening of a NIN-show! this is amazing..
andallthatcouldhave 4 years ago 3
What a band! I wish to god other bands would start making some decent music out there. gimme tool, nin, pantera, Fuck the rest
hannibalsloat 4 years ago 2
i believe this might have been recorded with the dvd set to "dolby surround" which is why the guitars as very quiet, they dont come out if you listen to it in stereo, and of course this video is either encoded in stereo or mono. if it were on "dolby stereo" at the time, then i think theyre a fair bit louder
theman362 4 years ago
...didn't quite, fell apart, WHERE THE FUCK WHERE YOU?
envirovore 4 years ago
at sasquatch 2006 at the Gorge in washington
FLOODTHEVOID 4 years ago
my god
rogersilva7 4 years ago
Seriously, I love the studio version but this sounds quite weak in comparison.
Sangdude 4 years ago
this isnt on the dvd is it??
AlexFruen 4 years ago
it is. it's in extras, in the summer 2006 preformances.
lely91 4 years ago
Fuckin' love that song to death! Shame most of the quality is taken away on this from the dvd!
Subliminallll 4 years ago
totally awsome
Collaborator 4 years ago