I don't think it's better than the original, but I'm sure that The Fratellis and the Withe Stripes, even if they're both broken, should have done a song together.
its not from the white stripes originally its a remake too jack heard this song and was stoked because only 2 people performing it and then he decided to form a 2-man band....check It might get loud I dont remember the bands name
@Grem91 yeah know I messed it up :D kinda mixed it up with another thing I guess, but didn't he write it early in his The Upholsteres time? or do I mess it up again :P
While I agree that the White Stripes version is better, you can't simply say all covers aren't as good: case in point, All Along the Watchtower's definitive version is Hendrix's, not Dylan's, and the same is true of Jeff Buckley's version of Cohen's Hallelujah.
oh yeh,you win that argument soooo conclusively...you fucking idiot. the fratellis do have a bass player,you are right.unfortunately he is in the worst fucking band around. clueless imagination free pub rock for people without taste. now go back to watching paint dry ,stamp collecting and listening to the dullest music ever made.
The last time I checked samey indie-pop really couldn't compete with the originality of the white stripes. The fratellis are good to listen to, the white stripes are good to experience. I'm happy to let you sit here and listen to them and have your own opinion.
Oh and by the way you obviously know very little about music so maybe next time you make a comment about anything about music (especially something as basic as tempo) you should check with someone who actually knows.
ok, im not trying to bag you out personally (or maybe i am, you decide) but heres the thing, if you just go through the comments to peoples videos putting people down for having an opinion, you're bound to get a few people wondering how you've had the time to become "quite the musician" when all you seem to do is sit on your ocmputer and have a go at people you don't know for having an opinion different to your own.
how about you grow some balls and come over here and argue with me.
haha probably because i didn't have to try at all, I just know what to do on guitar, bass drums, and anything with or having to do with strings. it just comes natural. Just like jon. PS i see that since you didn't mention it again that you realized how wrong your tempo argument is.
haha this is the internet dude, don't take it personal. now you really look retarded
haha wow did you consider that i didnt mention "how wrong" my argument is because it isnt wrong. there is a subtle difference in the tempo you fuckwit and thats what makes the fratellis version of this song sound rushed, or maybe its jjust that john has a fucked up strum pattern. For the record i play all those instruments too and it comes natural to me (im self taught)
like i say, i dont take it personally, i just find it funny that your entire life consists of you lookinf for people
haha oooOOooo I'm self taught too, in fact it took me only six months to get to the point where i could blow you out of the water.
and I don't take it personal, i find it funny that you say that I'm strangely spending a lot of time talking back and forth you when you are doing the same thing, I don't have a lot of free time, this video is on a playlist I made because its better that most songs out there. and they may be popular but that doesn't make them pop you'd know that if you were any good.
The White Stripes are far from garbage (you're forgetting who wrote Hotel Yorba in the first place) Jack White is an immense guitarist, and amazing songwriter.
Aw, that's not me - they are randoms!:P I made this video before I met them. If I had made it after I had met them, then they would have been a bunch of pics with me and them! ;)
Tough to get blown away that much by the cover of a song you consider to be originally perfect. Great great job the Fratellis, this is beautiful and refreshing.
This is really good. Especially as Jack White has such a difficult voice to try and cover. I like the way they manage to keep it the original and yet make it their own at the same time, but not copying the vocals exactly.
Yeah. Mon. Oh dear. I fear they've started a new trend amongst us Fratellis fans.
Oh My Gosh these are my two favourite bands :D I love this song so much
drtran227 2 months ago
@captnemo131 no discussion needed ..... this is a fact !!
Ticchick67 5 months ago
I don't think it's better than the original, but I'm sure that The Fratellis and the Withe Stripes, even if they're both broken, should have done a song together.
chokicou 5 months ago 2
i like the white stripes one more
TomAlexWhyte4SALE 5 months ago
1:27 amazing hair!!
QMDExperiece 9 months ago
i dont like the voice in this cover.. but it's awsm the style..
tremeloblues 11 months ago
HOW DID HIS VOIC SOUND LIKE A HARMONICA!
a7x4ify 1 year ago
dead good cover- always thought he sounded like jack
wouldnt know the difference except for that top harmonica solo
brilliant
ramsay97 1 year ago
i always thought he sounded just like jack
top cover-wouldnt know the difference
ramsay97 1 year ago
I think this song really fits The Fratellis! Didn't expect that :p
AtomicVHPunk 1 year ago
a great band covering another great band got to love it
benharrison31 1 year ago
MON FRATELLIS from Germany ;D
hansmann87 1 year ago
Better than the original (the original is really good too though) :)!
Mon the Fratellis!!!
apskihtap748 1 year ago
Hotel Yorba Bob Dylan style! :)
helterskelter1980 1 year ago
its not from the white stripes originally its a remake too jack heard this song and was stoked because only 2 people performing it and then he decided to form a 2-man band....check It might get loud I dont remember the bands name
thinkbitchthink 1 year ago
@thinkbitchthink Nope, Hotel Yorba is written by Jack, It was a real hotel near to where he grew up.
Grem91 1 year ago
@Grem91 yeah know I messed it up :D kinda mixed it up with another thing I guess, but didn't he write it early in his The Upholsteres time? or do I mess it up again :P
thinkbitchthink 1 year ago
@thinkbitchthink he wrote it with two star tabernacle-theyre on youtube :D
ramsay97 1 year ago
*Jaw Drops*
goddamit Fratellis, you done it again
Puggwarrior 1 year ago
Actually it's originally by Two Star Tabernacle (Jack White's band before he started to play with Meg)
TheBlueMoth 2 years ago
The Fratellis have somehow found a way to make The White Stripes sound even whiter.
HalsRing 2 years ago
This is cool! The White Stripes is my Favorite band and Fratellis is a close second!!! 2 of my favorite in 1!
stupidtortle 2 years ago 2
veryy goooodddd. but i like the raw sound of the white stripes version. MON THE FRATELLIS
Crazyrockerfreak96 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
oh wow this guy isnt nearly as good as the white stripes
bloodrain744 2 years ago
Aha O__o
MarkusHomer 2 years ago
OH MY GOD.
My two favourite bands and one of my favourite songs have just been combined into one gigantic, masterful blob! =D
JONFRATELLIGASM
madmaddy94 2 years ago 33
What 2 songs? O__o
MarkusHomer 2 years ago
omg that was rlly funny haha u rock
Crazyrockerfreak96 2 years ago
Lol I just came here to post that, or something to that effect.
jcgamer107 1 year ago
the fratellis and white stripes are some of my fav bands ^-^
imafoolhahaha 2 years ago 22
I like this.
renotsecniv 2 years ago
beautiful guitar haha
i love the fratellis but u hav 2 admit, the white stripes version is better but so is all original versions 2 the remake
still, love the fratellis
fibbingcats 2 years ago
While I agree that the White Stripes version is better, you can't simply say all covers aren't as good: case in point, All Along the Watchtower's definitive version is Hendrix's, not Dylan's, and the same is true of Jeff Buckley's version of Cohen's Hallelujah.
goshou 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
wow..........terrible
ThatsRandomStudios 2 years ago
its not terrible because its different.
Overdose669 2 years ago
very good... i like this version :)...
matheusweigert 2 years ago
they did well-
but the white stripes will always be better
-always
funnystar44444 2 years ago
and also how exactly did he fuck up the strums?
reesealdrich 2 years ago
good but white stripes version is better.
smellslikerainbowsx3 2 years ago 2
i just thought id add the the fratellis are brit-pop.
nothing wrong with that.
benhaddad0 3 years ago
The Fratellis version is better than the White Stripes because they have a bass player. End of story. You can all go back to your lives now.
mayfair08 3 years ago
oh yeh,you win that argument soooo conclusively...you fucking idiot. the fratellis do have a bass player,you are right.unfortunately he is in the worst fucking band around. clueless imagination free pub rock for people without taste. now go back to watching paint dry ,stamp collecting and listening to the dullest music ever made.
kevsickboy 3 years ago
If you don't like the Fratellis, then why the hell are you listening to them?
mayfair08 3 years ago 2
i saw they had covered a decent musicians work and wondered how awful it would be.
kevsickboy 3 years ago
...and in the spirit of fairness i'll be honest and say its not that bad.better than i expected.
kevsickboy 3 years ago 3
well duh.
MON THE FRATELLIS!
mayfair08 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
tho they still suck and always will.
kevsickboy 2 years ago
in your opinion. as long as you realize that. in the spirit of fairness right?
thefolgers 2 years ago 2
and don't get me wrong, i love the white stripes
(also who the fuck ever called the fratellis anything close to pop, you are retarded aren't you)
but there are a few reasons that they suck: Meg white
Jacks limited vocal range and imagination
They have done nothing but dive away from the music that me and everyone else love them.
did i mention that meg white sucks?
now the raconteurs
that was a good band
Jack should have stayed put.
and so should your little inexperienced fingers my son.
reesealdrich 3 years ago
ohmygosh that was AWESOME! and those are some really great pics! I heart the one with Jon wearing the glasses, heehee ^___^
mayfair08 3 years ago
personally i like the white stripes version bteter.
for the record im a fan of both artists.
i just think this version is too fast and too heavy.
benhaddad0 3 years ago
suck it its the same speed and Jon blows Jack out of the fuckin water 'mon the fratellis!
reesealdrich 3 years ago
I'm obviously talking to a connoisseur of music...
-rolls eyes-
ever heard of something called subtlety?
This lacks it, the white stripes version has it.
And I'm sorry but John does not blow Jack White out of the water.
benhaddad0 3 years ago
The last time I checked samey indie-pop really couldn't compete with the originality of the white stripes. The fratellis are good to listen to, the white stripes are good to experience. I'm happy to let you sit here and listen to them and have your own opinion.
Oh and by the way you obviously know very little about music so maybe next time you make a comment about anything about music (especially something as basic as tempo) you should check with someone who actually knows.
benhaddad0 3 years ago
uh yeah, I'm actually quite the musician. and its the exact same tempo
you sir, are a fool. Jon is simply rocking the shit with a guitar, something jack can only do with a foot petal.
reesealdrich 3 years ago
ok, im not trying to bag you out personally (or maybe i am, you decide) but heres the thing, if you just go through the comments to peoples videos putting people down for having an opinion, you're bound to get a few people wondering how you've had the time to become "quite the musician" when all you seem to do is sit on your ocmputer and have a go at people you don't know for having an opinion different to your own.
how about you grow some balls and come over here and argue with me.
benhaddad0 3 years ago
haha probably because i didn't have to try at all, I just know what to do on guitar, bass drums, and anything with or having to do with strings. it just comes natural. Just like jon. PS i see that since you didn't mention it again that you realized how wrong your tempo argument is.
haha this is the internet dude, don't take it personal. now you really look retarded
reesealdrich 3 years ago
haha wow did you consider that i didnt mention "how wrong" my argument is because it isnt wrong. there is a subtle difference in the tempo you fuckwit and thats what makes the fratellis version of this song sound rushed, or maybe its jjust that john has a fucked up strum pattern. For the record i play all those instruments too and it comes natural to me (im self taught)
like i say, i dont take it personally, i just find it funny that your entire life consists of you lookinf for people
benhaddad0 3 years ago
haha oooOOooo I'm self taught too, in fact it took me only six months to get to the point where i could blow you out of the water.
and I don't take it personal, i find it funny that you say that I'm strangely spending a lot of time talking back and forth you when you are doing the same thing, I don't have a lot of free time, this video is on a playlist I made because its better that most songs out there. and they may be popular but that doesn't make them pop you'd know that if you were any good.
reesealdrich 2 years ago
there is a big difference between subtlety and trying to sing out of your vocal range (jack white)
and Jon Fratelli made it sound like the country song it had the potential to be.
and yes he does
by far in voice and guitar my son.
reesealdrich 3 years ago
I adore the Fratellis, but nothing beats Jack White and his amazing original
ainsy17 3 years ago
MON THE FRATELLIS!
Dan1elJoyce 3 years ago
white stripes do it MUCH better
my opinion may be biased because i LOVE the stripes and HATE the frattellis tho.
rubyOXO 3 years ago
man do you really hate the fratellis?? whY?
they wouldnt hate you hahhaha
lonelyspanish18 3 years ago
How can you hate the fratellis? you must be a puff
reesealdrich 3 years ago 3
I love the fratellis,
I love the white stripes.
And they absolutely nailed it with this song! Spot on.
I honestly cant decide what i like better, the original or this one.
brianyi14 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
BOOOOOOOOOOOOOO leave it to the stripes. this is garbage.
Congamasternick 3 years ago
its not garbage! The white stripes-really garbage.....
AlyonaMatveeva 3 years ago
The White Stripes are far from garbage (you're forgetting who wrote Hotel Yorba in the first place) Jack White is an immense guitarist, and amazing songwriter.
skillageguy 3 years ago
I remember who wrote this song. And why you abused the Fratellis?
AlyonaMatveeva 3 years ago
When did I ever insult the Fratellis? I'm just saying that credit goes to Jack White for writing this.
skillageguy 3 years ago
Sorry, It was for Congamasternick.
AlyonaMatveeva 3 years ago
cool
ravenouspali 3 years ago
theres a bunch of pictures with u and the band
1313elijahj 3 years ago
Aw, that's not me - they are randoms!:P I made this video before I met them. If I had made it after I had met them, then they would have been a bunch of pics with me and them! ;)
MTF x
naomifratelli 3 years ago
how many times have you met them???????
im jealous
1313elijahj 3 years ago
the white stripes do it better :/
calmlittlehip 3 years ago 6
Possibly my favourite White Stripe on the White Blood Cells album. And for my favourite band to do a cover... A rather amazing cover too ;)
MTF xx
LuluFratelli 3 years ago
Haha, love the photo at 2:15!
srhbth 3 years ago
I see alot of Mr Jon Fratelli in there Naomi ;)
Mon the Fratellis.
Best cover in my opinion.
Jasmine
xx
teenagekicks444 3 years ago
loves this song!
adamparsonson123 3 years ago
Great cover
SamNUK 3 years ago
Tough to get blown away that much by the cover of a song you consider to be originally perfect. Great great job the Fratellis, this is beautiful and refreshing.
gouge97 3 years ago 3
fantastic cover of a fantastic song!!!
kaitie07 3 years ago
nae offence tae the guy, but that mince dude looks like a homeless junky! nice tune though
purdy1985 3 years ago
brilliant song.love both versions.did whitestripes cover it or write it tho??
dtrocks6 3 years ago
The White Stripes wrote the song, and the Fratellis covered it.
submison 3 years ago 2
Great song and cover! two great bands! Love the new album by fratellis!
mchl2slh 3 years ago 3
omg awesome cover!
samerika 3 years ago 2
This is really good. Especially as Jack White has such a difficult voice to try and cover. I like the way they manage to keep it the original and yet make it their own at the same time, but not copying the vocals exactly.
Yeah. Mon. Oh dear. I fear they've started a new trend amongst us Fratellis fans.
Nawanse 3 years ago 3
That was really actually really good :)
tommydomm 3 years ago
brilliant song.and the fratellis are unreal.nice upload
dtrocks6 3 years ago 2
nice. i like the way, they play white stripes
bauwong22 3 years ago 4
this song is beautiful!!
lostandthefratellis 3 years ago 3
Comment removed
thefratellisaregreat 3 years ago
amazin video naomi :)
the fratellis do a great cover of this song xx
xlisax2006x 3 years ago
Is it a fratellis song?
I haven't heard it before.
But it's good.
It must be good, because it is a Fratellis song.
Mon the Fratellis!!!
gyfanni91 3 years ago
No it's by the White Stripes really, but this is a cover by The Fratellis!:P
Mon xx
naomifratelli 3 years ago 3