I've been considering a higher end acoustic and I've been trying to decide between a Martin and a Gibson. I thought Martin was ahead, but this video has left me unsure!
@themaninme If its got an adjustable bridge the only cure is to have it replaced with a real bridge. It will no longer be original but the sound will amaze you. And try Elixer strings.
my two cents: if you're a singer and your voice is the lead instrument, get the j-45. if you're not a singer and the guitar is your lead instrument, get the martin
they are both the same thing. the modern classic is just the old stock they need to get rid of - thats why its cheaper. plus , the new standard comes with nickel grover tuners and silver Gibson Logo
What's the style are you playing at the beginning (finger picking)? I wish I could see it in slow motion. Is there any video or books available out there to learn it? Thanks for playing. It's really good!
@abolit I know it's a year late, but I thought I'd recommend searching for Justin Sandercoe Folk. He's done a lot of good lessons and his two folk picking videos will point you in the right direction.
well ive watched this and a few videos hundreds of times. so i went to nashville to find out on my own. the winner is the Gibson Southern Jumbo ( J45 with fancy neck). SJ and j45 same guitar. anyways the martin was cool but just didnt have the " backporch" sound of the Gibsons. but all sweet guitars
I have to modify my review. Today I played a HD28 and J45 side by side, and the HD28 was the nicest, most amazing sounding guitar I've ever played. My last comment was about the D18. The HD28 is a whole different animal. I still love the J45, but I have never played anything like that HD28. I now know my dream acoustic!
I played a J45 and a D18 side by side last week, and I can't deny the Martin's amazing sound. I would take the J45 for personal reasons, but sound-wise the Martin had the edge. Of course, this was two brand new guitars, and each one is unique, so who knows if you can really say one is absolutely BETTER as a rule. Both played like butter. The Martin sounded a little fuller and warmer. But the Gibson is just so beautiful, and not far off in sound.
Sounds great... love that Gibson sound. I actually prefer 13's on mine; with the shorter scale, they don't feel too heavy and they really thicken up the sound.
Sounds just like acoustic guitar should! I own a martin d 28 and a gibson j45 as much as i love the martin the gibson gets played more and holds my heart ..thanks for posting!
great playing man! The Gibson sounds good, but i still thing the Martin is stronger...especially on the bluegrass licks u did. both great guitars though
sounds good man
23mrcowboys 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i have a left handed j45 check us out me playing it live in a band .DARREN HARRIS BAND mary lou
1darrenknight 9 months ago
hello can you give me the chords of the second part too well! I have too have a J 45 thank you in advance happy birthday Year End
chris82710 1 year ago
great hands
awaliwu 1 year ago
Thanks a lot! It's not too late!!!
abolit 1 year ago
I've been considering a higher end acoustic and I've been trying to decide between a Martin and a Gibson. I thought Martin was ahead, but this video has left me unsure!
PowerThirteen 1 year ago
No problem of sticky neck with mine - great play
marcdjan 1 year ago
That chuggin's nice at the end.
headstock48 1 year ago
hello with strings are u using please?
ghaouat25 1 year ago
Have you ever found your guitar neck to be sticky? I've just bought a standar J-45, it sounds awesome but neck is sticky after playing for minutes.
Any advice? Thanks
tomfrustha 1 year ago
What are the names of every song?
Or where can I get a tab of these?
Thanks!
bruceknopfler 1 year ago
Absolutely love my J-45.
RussianBreadmaker 2 years ago
changing the pins do make a difference some guitars there is more difference than others but I have a J-45 and changed the pins and it did help
georyans 2 years ago
What will make the guitar ring better is to replace the plastic bridge pins with ebony
georyans 2 years ago 2
@georyans
did that years ago... and really its not making any difference
themaninme 2 years ago
@themaninme If its got an adjustable bridge the only cure is to have it replaced with a real bridge. It will no longer be original but the sound will amaze you. And try Elixer strings.
saullouis 2 years ago
Finally someone doing a good demo..
You're a good player.
ChanceCooper125 2 years ago
your great !
rokkaize 2 years ago
is this the guitar? it SOUNDS like it is!
THATHSBM 2 years ago
I've tryied with 10, 11, and 12 strings and my choice is the '11...
simonfowler81 2 years ago
my two cents: if you're a singer and your voice is the lead instrument, get the j-45. if you're not a singer and the guitar is your lead instrument, get the martin
MillStreamPictures 2 years ago
thanks
aeflint 2 years ago
is that the Modern Classic, or the standard. Musicians freind shows having both of them in stock. i didnt know that. whats the diff between the two?
AK47cowboy 2 years ago
they are both the same thing. the modern classic is just the old stock they need to get rid of - thats why its cheaper. plus , the new standard comes with nickel grover tuners and silver Gibson Logo
its 2008 model against 2009 - thats all
themaninme 2 years ago
i have that guitar sitting in my lap right now, it was my grandpas
treatb09 2 years ago 5
You give a great sound interpretation to this guitar, I have the same and is one of the best acustic around....no way....
simonfowler81 2 years ago
What's the style are you playing at the beginning (finger picking)? I wish I could see it in slow motion. Is there any video or books available out there to learn it? Thanks for playing. It's really good!
abolit 2 years ago
yes. its folk style fingerpicking.
there are countless videos here on youtube that can help you with it
themaninme 2 years ago
@abolit I know it's a year late, but I thought I'd recommend searching for Justin Sandercoe Folk. He's done a lot of good lessons and his two folk picking videos will point you in the right direction.
PowerThirteen 1 year ago
well ive watched this and a few videos hundreds of times. so i went to nashville to find out on my own. the winner is the Gibson Southern Jumbo ( J45 with fancy neck). SJ and j45 same guitar. anyways the martin was cool but just didnt have the " backporch" sound of the Gibsons. but all sweet guitars
AK47cowboy 2 years ago
I have to modify my review. Today I played a HD28 and J45 side by side, and the HD28 was the nicest, most amazing sounding guitar I've ever played. My last comment was about the D18. The HD28 is a whole different animal. I still love the J45, but I have never played anything like that HD28. I now know my dream acoustic!
khasperg 2 years ago
I played a J45 and a D18 side by side last week, and I can't deny the Martin's amazing sound. I would take the J45 for personal reasons, but sound-wise the Martin had the edge. Of course, this was two brand new guitars, and each one is unique, so who knows if you can really say one is absolutely BETTER as a rule. Both played like butter. The Martin sounded a little fuller and warmer. But the Gibson is just so beautiful, and not far off in sound.
khasperg 2 years ago
Sounds great... love that Gibson sound. I actually prefer 13's on mine; with the shorter scale, they don't feel too heavy and they really thicken up the sound.
smiaaron 3 years ago
Sounds sweet. Cant beat gibson acoustics. Martins are fine but they dont have the soul a Gibson puts out. Nice job.
hagtar12 3 years ago
To hagtar12.. I agree with you about Gibson guitars.If you get a chance though try out the Martin D-15 Mahagony it has a beautiful tone.
iamJROD 2 years ago
Sounds just like acoustic guitar should! I own a martin d 28 and a gibson j45 as much as i love the martin the gibson gets played more and holds my heart ..thanks for posting!
tigerfire44 3 years ago
do you hide your smokes in your knee?
hailtube 3 years ago
great playing man! The Gibson sounds good, but i still thing the Martin is stronger...especially on the bluegrass licks u did. both great guitars though
AK47cowboy 3 years ago
Magnifique ! =D
J'adore votre guitare & vous jouez très bien! bravo ! =D
---
Beautiful !
I love your guitar ;D
Sweet playing !
m0moz 3 years ago
What are you playing in the very beginning ?
bensander 3 years ago
Really the only solution is to have one of each.
jimmythefish 3 years ago 3
sweet guitar and sweet playin !!!
delpuckett 3 years ago 3
My head says Martin, but my heart cries J-45! That sound... makes you feel all loosey goosey inside - so expressive, so dynamic, so much soul.
nklebs 3 years ago
then go J45;)
wolfje91 3 years ago
i go both, actually...
nklebs 3 years ago 3
Sounds absolutely totally and completely glorious. I'd take the Gibson over the Martin any day.
gilliangirl1 3 years ago
Sounds wonderful. I love the J-45 sound for everything, and they are much cooler than Martins. You sound great.
steverok67 3 years ago