Brian May intended it to be a space cowboy epic tragic home-coming. He'd thought it would make a good single... but, no. Such are the hazards of being in a band. It did make it onto the album, & I am grateful for that.
To sacrifice your loved ones to travel to another star: That's terribly brave and terribly sad. This song always brings tears to my eyes. "Your mothers eyes, from your eyes, cry to me."
@Deuterium2H Brian May intended it to be a space cowboy epic tragic home-coming. He'd thought it would make a good single... but, no. Such are the hazards of being in a band. It did make it onto the album, & I am grateful for that. (I was watching the Biography Channel, that's what he had in mind.
@JoeJBuddha Believe that as you will. I see the speed of light as just another barrier that needs crossed. I see the speed of light as an imaginary wall one has only to push his hands through for it to come tumbling down. Feynman once said something along the lines of "Observing the universe is like watching two men play a game, moving pieces around the board. If we watch long enough, we may be able to pick up a few of the rules, but we won't be able to get all of them."
@MatthewHarper1121 Maybe so; I didn't say that we couldn't travel that fast some day. I just said that to date, nothing has been seen that does. The physics that makes the claim of light being the universal speed limit has so far held up; I could give you the small amount of the math I know if that'd help.
@JoeJBuddha Oh, that would be awesome! Naturally, I could look up these equations online, but there's no guarantee that those will be the correct equations. If you want to e-mail me those, I'd be willing to send you the link to what I have on the story so far.
@JoeJBuddha Didn't that neutrino break the speed of light? It was later confirmed by a second experiment. But if you could travel 99.995% the speed of light, this song could be correct.
@JoeJBuddha There where 2 experiments, both broke the speed of light. Yet because it is so unlikely, they try to find errors in the experiment. But it is confirmed for now.
@SebTownAlternative: Theoretically. However, I think that the physics are wrong. Remember when scientists thought the human body could not travel over 30 mph without disrupting the internal organs? Or when the Sound Barrier were an immovable object that would cause any aircraft to crash and burn? There are particles that travel faster than light, and there are partcles that travel back in time. Meaning both these things are possible without infinite energy.
Loved this song for years but hadn't given much thought to the odd twist in the lyrics. Thanks Mr. May for the buried treasure, and thanks to you guys for turning the light on for me.
Quoting TvTropes here -- "Seriously. Best song about theoretical Einsteinian space travel-induced time dilation masquerading as a sea shanty EVER." I agree, Dr. May is awesomeness personified.
Brian May is one of the most underappreciated musician/songwriters of his time. Well, byt the "media" anyway. We KNOW! And Astrophonix, my old man was an astrophysicist. Full Prof, and consultant to NASA, JPL, etc. Sadly he's 20 years passed away, but how I would love to share things like this with him.
For the longest time i had no idea what this song was about. It wasn't until I learned it was about space travel that I realized what a remarkably sad song it really is.
Great song, one of my favorites though under rated. Funny, I had never heard about the song's connection to space travel. I always thought it was a tribute to the English sailors going off th fight in World War II.
Great song, one of my favorites though under rated. Funny, I had never heard about the song's connection to space travel. I always thought it was a tribute to the English sailors going off th fight in World War II.
Some lines don't rhyme, like "For many lonely DAY sailed out across Milky SEAS", delete SEAS and add WAY, "Milky WAY" get it? Brilliant. They left in 1939 and came back in 2039 still a " '39" but a century later. Great tune.
Well I always thought it`s about space travelling. Because of the milky seas etc. And Dr. May is an astrophysican. and im believe had said so in some interviews. That it is of voluteers going to space. and when they came back. they havent aged, as the people they left behind. i dont know the name of this effect. i had known it, and i could explain it. argh... shitty brain.
@rockerlevel1 No, you're actually correct, that is exactly what the song is about. Brian May HIMSELF explained the meaning of the song. So you're correct.
"Creative, but it doesn't quite make sense. The "score brave souls inside" at the beginning of the song are clearly alive because they "ne'er looked back, never feared, never cried."
...because they're dead. The older world refers to the realization of futility and war, death and loss.
actually, I believe this tune was about the Abraham Lincoln Brigade returning with their dead from the Spanish Civil War and confronting the families of the "score brave souls inside".
Creative, but it doesn't quite make sense. The "score brave souls inside" at the beginning of the song are clearly alive because they "ne'er looked back, never feared, never cried." The volunteers also left and returned in '39, which doesn't fit the Abraham Lincoln Brigade.
Lines like "sailed across the milky seas", "the earth is old and gray", and "oh so many years have gone though I'm older but a year" are best explained by the song being about space travel and time dilation.
So Celtic!!! God bless!!!! Queen--Freddie i miss you!!! thanks for leaving the songs for us all to hear forevermore -the path of"Nevermore" Q2- is not your burdon, it is your light that brings us joy in all the recorded moments of you dudes ROCKIN!
Concerning the Bo Rhap picture, it's the same one from Queen II. They just reused it in the music video for Bo Rhap. Later, they did an updated picture where they posed again for their video One Vision.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I can't believe that no one here realized that its is about 1939, the call to go and fight in France against Nazism, and they went back in 1940 from Dunkaurque...Gosh, ignorance is so deep everywhere...
It's about a space exploration party going off into space and being away for, what was for them only one year, but on Earth many generations had passed, so they returned to a world where everyone they had known was long dead. Hence "you're many years away, though I'm older but a year"
The fact that they had only aged a year is down to Einstein's Special Relativity, whereupon the explorers are travelling at light speed, they age differently in relation to those on Earth.
In effect, time becomes zero at light speed in relation to the reference point of Earth. This is also called the Time Dilation Effect.
It's a beautiful song, one of their best and never fails to bring tears to my eyes.
@OffTheGrid Brian May, as well as being a fantastic guitarist, is an astrophysicist and would know relativitistic time dilation (my pet topic) very well. If the ship travelled at 99.995% light speed the time dilation factor is 100 to 1, so a century would pass on earth for their one year on the spacecraft. @ConenTyrson1 At 90% lightspeed the time dilation is 2.3 to 1, so time on the ship is a little more than twice as slow as earth time.
@OffTheGrid I'm writing a story based off this. My ship uses a Light Speed Barrier Rider type drive. (LSBR)
1: accelerates to light speed
2: shields trap a pocket of our space-time as the engines push her past light speed, the energy diffusion changing local space-time laws to create a shockwave that the ship rides
3: She's only cruising at about 5x light speed, but it feels like 500x due to the Einstein's Special Relativity laws
Of course, this takes an incredible amount of energy, but still.
@MatthewHarper1121 , It takes an infinite amount of energy to travel constantly at the speed of light. Theoretically you might be able to accelerate to 99.99999% the speed of light, but to reach 300,000 km/s, you would need an infinite amount of energy. And don't forget, the faster you go the more massive you become.
@mastersverk Ummmm, no. Brian May -- a highly respected astrophysicist, as well as one of the greatest rock guitarists ever -- himself was the one who explained what the song was about. There's video on YouTube of him explaining it. While Britain did declare war on Germany in 1939, the Battle OF Britain was from 10 July - 31 Oct 1940.
@AbsurdlySane you are exactly right, i heard brian may explain it too. i always loved the music and was confused by the words until the day he told the story.
@jjobie Robert Heinlein wrote a novel called Time for the Stars that dealt with characters traveling at close to the speed of light, and the ensuing time dilation. Being Heinlein, he might very well have been the first. But the Twin Paradox had been a well known topic in Physics for decades, and Brian May, who had dropped out of a doctoral program when Queen took off, would have known about it even in the unlikely event he had never read science fiction.
Who sing it? Freddy Mercury?
Ratatals2 2 weeks ago
@Ratatals2 Brian May sings, Freddie does back-up voices. According to wikipedia
WouterNed 2 weeks ago
this song brings to mind those dreary days when the Huns warred on the inoffensive Polacks. How I hated it!--W.H. Auden
BrokenneckYgor 1 month ago
Brian May intended it to be a space cowboy epic tragic home-coming. He'd thought it would make a good single... but, no. Such are the hazards of being in a band. It did make it onto the album, & I am grateful for that.
YesIknowitall 1 month ago
To sacrifice your loved ones to travel to another star: That's terribly brave and terribly sad. This song always brings tears to my eyes. "Your mothers eyes, from your eyes, cry to me."
JoeJBuddha 1 month ago
The style of the song is NOT "Country and Western". It is in the mode of a sea shanty mixed with a bit of skiffle.
Deuterium2H 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Deuterium2H Brian May intended it to be a space cowboy epic tragic home-coming. He'd thought it would make a good single... but, no. Such are the hazards of being in a band. It did make it onto the album, & I am grateful for that. (I was watching the Biography Channel, that's what he had in mind.
What JoeJBuddha said...
YesIknowitall 1 month ago
There are no particals known that travel faster than the speed of light. Period.
JoeJBuddha 1 month ago
@JoeJBuddha Believe that as you will. I see the speed of light as just another barrier that needs crossed. I see the speed of light as an imaginary wall one has only to push his hands through for it to come tumbling down. Feynman once said something along the lines of "Observing the universe is like watching two men play a game, moving pieces around the board. If we watch long enough, we may be able to pick up a few of the rules, but we won't be able to get all of them."
MatthewHarper1121 1 month ago
@MatthewHarper1121 Maybe so; I didn't say that we couldn't travel that fast some day. I just said that to date, nothing has been seen that does. The physics that makes the claim of light being the universal speed limit has so far held up; I could give you the small amount of the math I know if that'd help.
JoeJBuddha 1 month ago
@JoeJBuddha Oh, that would be awesome! Naturally, I could look up these equations online, but there's no guarantee that those will be the correct equations. If you want to e-mail me those, I'd be willing to send you the link to what I have on the story so far.
MatthewHarper1121 1 month ago
@JoeJBuddha Didn't that neutrino break the speed of light? It was later confirmed by a second experiment. But if you could travel 99.995% the speed of light, this song could be correct.
WouterNed 1 month ago
@WouterNed
They still haven't decided...
JoeJBuddha 1 month ago
@JoeJBuddha There where 2 experiments, both broke the speed of light. Yet because it is so unlikely, they try to find errors in the experiment. But it is confirmed for now.
WouterNed 4 weeks ago
@SebTownAlternative: Theoretically. However, I think that the physics are wrong. Remember when scientists thought the human body could not travel over 30 mph without disrupting the internal organs? Or when the Sound Barrier were an immovable object that would cause any aircraft to crash and burn? There are particles that travel faster than light, and there are partcles that travel back in time. Meaning both these things are possible without infinite energy.
MatthewHarper1121 1 month ago
fucking god, such a great band!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Marcooooooooooo11 1 month ago
Loved this song for years but hadn't given much thought to the odd twist in the lyrics. Thanks Mr. May for the buried treasure, and thanks to you guys for turning the light on for me.
crashlight1 2 months ago
amazing guitarist and Ph.D Astrophysicist (what i hope to get a Ph.D in) wow Brian May was amazing in so many ways
1KevinsFamousChili1 3 months ago 12
Einstein.
Sea Chanty.
Beautiful.
loZoneranger560 3 months ago
My favorite
justdadance 3 months ago
Quoting TvTropes here -- "Seriously. Best song about theoretical Einsteinian space travel-induced time dilation masquerading as a sea shanty EVER." I agree, Dr. May is awesomeness personified.
cypher515 3 months ago
the word is Brave..not Bave
ross2343 3 months ago
One of the best ballads they have ever made.
spokanetomcat1 4 months ago 2
That should have been "WE know". As in "we know this to be true". The way I posted it made it sound like blah blah blah. My error.
Evster2012 4 months ago
Brian May is one of the most underappreciated musician/songwriters of his time. Well, byt the "media" anyway. We KNOW! And Astrophonix, my old man was an astrophysicist. Full Prof, and consultant to NASA, JPL, etc. Sadly he's 20 years passed away, but how I would love to share things like this with him.
Evster2012 4 months ago
i wonder if someone would sound slow motion if they called me at 90% the speed of light...
ConenTyrson1 4 months ago
Roger Taylor.
spamhead2k 4 months ago
God, I love this tune. For as famous and as Queen is, they are so underrated. They were just so brilliant.
kgkidz4life 6 months ago
For the longest time i had no idea what this song was about. It wasn't until I learned it was about space travel that I realized what a remarkably sad song it really is.
Vook 6 months ago
agreed, a beautiful song no doubt about it.
TheZeqpelin 6 months ago
Brian May: Doctor of Astrophysics, London’s Imperial College 2007.
starbucksrogers 7 months ago 3
I just learned this on guitar. Words cannot describe how proud I feel
qwaz13 8 months ago 10
@qwaz13 Congrats with all my heart! I can't play any musical instrument, so I can only imagine, how it feels))))
HelenaVanCity 8 months ago
1 person is stupid!
148 are intelligent !
1996gonza 10 months ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Great song, one of my favorites though under rated. Funny, I had never heard about the song's connection to space travel. I always thought it was a tribute to the English sailors going off th fight in World War II.
MrChrisdube 10 months ago
Great song, one of my favorites though under rated. Funny, I had never heard about the song's connection to space travel. I always thought it was a tribute to the English sailors going off th fight in World War II.
MrChrisdube 10 months ago 3
The epitome of Queen tunes. Always one of my faves.
btrev60 11 months ago
It's such a pity Queen didn't made any more sci-fi songs, I mean they had some many fantasy songs...
IIIRodrigoVegaIII 11 months ago
GOD this is such a sad song. I love it.
Dancerpaw 1 year ago
Some lines don't rhyme, like "For many lonely DAY sailed out across Milky SEAS", delete SEAS and add WAY, "Milky WAY" get it? Brilliant. They left in 1939 and came back in 2039 still a " '39" but a century later. Great tune.
LAstump 1 year ago
@LAstump Or 2039 and 2139. Yeah, though, the averted rhyme gives it all away if you think about it.
cypher515 3 months ago
today's music is the product of assholes!!! anyone whom has the talent to produce good music, isn't jewish, good looking, or, not gay
arbuviknb 1 year ago
Fuck! I cant avoid singing this chorus everytime I hear it
Ardrion 1 year ago
Hands down, my most favorite Queen song.
U33C 1 year ago
Great song!!! brian has a really good voice...
Mirinat82 1 year ago
This was back in the day when bands were fucking bands!
Lewis1key 1 year ago 5
Amazing song!
leonardnyc12 1 year ago
This is the song that makes me prefer Brian May over Freddie Mercury.
Jabels24 1 year ago
Well I always thought it`s about space travelling. Because of the milky seas etc. And Dr. May is an astrophysican. and im believe had said so in some interviews. That it is of voluteers going to space. and when they came back. they havent aged, as the people they left behind. i dont know the name of this effect. i had known it, and i could explain it. argh... shitty brain.
rockerlevel1 1 year ago
@rockerlevel1 No, you're actually correct, that is exactly what the song is about. Brian May HIMSELF explained the meaning of the song. So you're correct.
jjobie 1 year ago
sure it does..
"Creative, but it doesn't quite make sense. The "score brave souls inside" at the beginning of the song are clearly alive because they "ne'er looked back, never feared, never cried."
...because they're dead. The older world refers to the realization of futility and war, death and loss.
thebrugster 1 year ago
@thebrugster That's an interesting take on it, and it would make for an interesting video :)
That said, Brian May did talk about the 'space travel' theme behind the song on a few occasions.
jjobie 1 year ago
actually, I believe this tune was about the Abraham Lincoln Brigade returning with their dead from the Spanish Civil War and confronting the families of the "score brave souls inside".
Call me a historian, I guess..
thebrugster 1 year ago
Creative, but it doesn't quite make sense. The "score brave souls inside" at the beginning of the song are clearly alive because they "ne'er looked back, never feared, never cried." The volunteers also left and returned in '39, which doesn't fit the Abraham Lincoln Brigade.
Lines like "sailed across the milky seas", "the earth is old and gray", and "oh so many years have gone though I'm older but a year" are best explained by the song being about space travel and time dilation.
caljack09 1 year ago 2
Theatrical Rock & Folk
Keijz74 1 year ago
a country and western song about space travel? insane genius
cthulhlu 2 years ago 21
Not insane genius, CRAZY AWESOME!
Xanaboy13 1 year ago 5
@cthulhlu Folk, not country.
HeavyMetalSocialist 2 months ago 2
One of the many great songs from one of the greatest albums of all time.
animalhouse28146 2 years ago 3
So Celtic!!! God bless!!!! Queen--Freddie i miss you!!! thanks for leaving the songs for us all to hear forevermore -the path of"Nevermore" Q2- is not your burdon, it is your light that brings us joy in all the recorded moments of you dudes ROCKIN!
wacmac1 2 years ago
I cry when I listen to this... the lyrics are so meaningful 4 me.
I LOVE this song, thankyou Brian.
AIIeh 2 years ago 3
why?
Arsyautomo 2 years ago
Concerning the Bo Rhap picture, it's the same one from Queen II. They just reused it in the music video for Bo Rhap. Later, they did an updated picture where they posed again for their video One Vision.
youvebeenthunderstru 2 years ago
The greatest talents since the Beatles.
00watcher 2 years ago 19
@00watcher This song could have easily been written by Paul McCartney.
ladmex53 1 month ago
@ladmex53 No, only brian could come with something like this.
00watcher 1 month ago
@ladmex53 i don`t agree, paul and john lyrics are way more simple and than 95% of the queensongs/lyrics.
dianamartijn 1 month ago
Contry Rock
shaneinkster 2 years ago
the picture is the beginning of one vision
TheTriker1 2 years ago
This is a very peaceful song!
raykrislianggi 2 years ago
Why is there a picture from Bohemian rhapsody?
bmwc16880 2 years ago
cause its a cool picture
CoRNH0LI0 2 years ago 3
That's not the picture from Bohemian Rhapsody! They were taken in 1980's. Bohemian Rhapsody was in 1974.
raykrislianggi 2 years ago
ow i love this song
BRIAN MAYYYYY FOR EVERRRRR
elvis0258 2 years ago
AWESOME! Chills every time. . .
frigginurge 2 years ago
thoughs that have forgotten are destine to relive it.America is LOST
nunofubiz1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I can't believe that no one here realized that its is about 1939, the call to go and fight in France against Nazism, and they went back in 1940 from Dunkaurque...Gosh, ignorance is so deep everywhere...
fabzuc 2 years ago
Do your research, it's even Brian who tells about this song somewere on youtube; it's future story.
looi313 2 years ago
@fabzuc That's not what it's about. Brian May himself explained the space travel origins of the song on several occasions.
jjobie 1 year ago
@fabzuc easy boy, easy nyahahahhahahahahahahahhaha
alexandrefenix 6 months ago
in addition to absurdlysane, this song was based on a dream may had one night
snb1029 2 years ago
freddie mercury is and always will be the love of my life!!!
1946coolio 2 years ago
I still can't figure out what this song is about.
sfldd 2 years ago
It's about a space exploration party going off into space and being away for, what was for them only one year, but on Earth many generations had passed, so they returned to a world where everyone they had known was long dead. Hence "you're many years away, though I'm older but a year"
AbsurdlySane 2 years ago 53
Thank you
sfldd 2 years ago
The fact that they had only aged a year is down to Einstein's Special Relativity, whereupon the explorers are travelling at light speed, they age differently in relation to those on Earth.
In effect, time becomes zero at light speed in relation to the reference point of Earth. This is also called the Time Dilation Effect.
It's a beautiful song, one of their best and never fails to bring tears to my eyes.
OffTheGrid 2 years ago 41
Thank you for explaining the science - my Physics 101 was a long time ago!
AbsurdlySane 2 years ago 2
Thanks for sharing! Initially, I thought it's about the discovery and colonizing of North America.
I guess this is what is great about this song, that it is about exploring the new, and one can relate it to many scenarios. It inspires imagination.
victoriadoneva 2 years ago
I tough it was about WWII....once i dicovered the truth this become my favourite song!XD
TheMoltyPethon 2 years ago
@OffTheGrid Brian May, as well as being a fantastic guitarist, is an astrophysicist and would know relativitistic time dilation (my pet topic) very well. If the ship travelled at 99.995% light speed the time dilation factor is 100 to 1, so a century would pass on earth for their one year on the spacecraft. @ConenTyrson1 At 90% lightspeed the time dilation is 2.3 to 1, so time on the ship is a little more than twice as slow as earth time.
astrophonix 4 months ago
@OffTheGrid I agree. Hadn´t heard it before but one of the best Queen-songs indeed.
PeterRoeder31 4 months ago
@OffTheGrid I agree. Hadn´t heard it before but one of the best Queen-songs indeed.
PeterRoeder31 4 months ago
@OffTheGrid I'm writing a story based off this. My ship uses a Light Speed Barrier Rider type drive. (LSBR)
1: accelerates to light speed
2: shields trap a pocket of our space-time as the engines push her past light speed, the energy diffusion changing local space-time laws to create a shockwave that the ship rides
3: She's only cruising at about 5x light speed, but it feels like 500x due to the Einstein's Special Relativity laws
Of course, this takes an incredible amount of energy, but still.
MatthewHarper1121 2 months ago
@MatthewHarper1121 , It takes an infinite amount of energy to travel constantly at the speed of light. Theoretically you might be able to accelerate to 99.99999% the speed of light, but to reach 300,000 km/s, you would need an infinite amount of energy. And don't forget, the faster you go the more massive you become.
SebTownAlternative 1 month ago
ummmmm, no, dont you remember what happened in 1939? thats when the battle for Britain began
mastersverk 1 year ago
@mastersverk Ummmm, no. Brian May -- a highly respected astrophysicist, as well as one of the greatest rock guitarists ever -- himself was the one who explained what the song was about. There's video on YouTube of him explaining it. While Britain did declare war on Germany in 1939, the Battle OF Britain was from 10 July - 31 Oct 1940.
AbsurdlySane 1 year ago
@AbsurdlySane What was the name of the video? I would be greatly interested in watching it.
wassup131994 1 year ago
@wassup131994 The video can be found on the channel of YouTube user mobile4357. It's called Queen: A Night at the Opera - '39.
AbsurdlySane 1 year ago
@AbsurdlySane you are exactly right, i heard brian may explain it too. i always loved the music and was confused by the words until the day he told the story.
rkeime1 1 year ago
@AbsurdlySane Wasn't this partiallly inspired by a Robert E. Heinlein short story? Or am I confused.
jjobie 1 year ago
@jjobie Robert Heinlein wrote a novel called Time for the Stars that dealt with characters traveling at close to the speed of light, and the ensuing time dilation. Being Heinlein, he might very well have been the first. But the Twin Paradox had been a well known topic in Physics for decades, and Brian May, who had dropped out of a doctoral program when Queen took off, would have known about it even in the unlikely event he had never read science fiction.
streamingmadly 1 year ago
@AbsurdlySane
Well and obviously the amount of years past on earth was 100, hence also, they also came back in the year of '39 (only in the next century)
jella11 3 months ago
AMAZING!
excellent job on this
LifeSuxsThenUDie 3 years ago 4
GOOD VIDEOO!!^^
I LOVE QUEEN :)
merygore666 3 years ago 3