Big mistake, Herr Schumann. You should have put "Not too fast, BUT NOT TOO SLOW EITHER" at the top of the page. It would have avoided a lot of suffering later.
See countless other examples of Deadly Dead Slow Performances on Youtube.
Also, baritones who can't hit top A should stay away from this super piece. In my opinion .......
The young man does not understand what he sings about, but if he continues his studies a few years so it might be something. One should not publish the man might regret later! A good material, however.
The young man does not understand what he sings about, but if he continues his studies a few years so it might be something. One should not publish if one might regret it later! A good material, however.
Robert Schumann set the tempo at "Nicht so Schnell" on the manuscript. The accompanist is spot on. The Mr. Gubachev sings it well w/great feeling & emotion, but should have taken the climax up instead of harmozing down, it's a tough climb for a Baritone to be sure, but worth it. Overall excellent performance, w/great potential from this artist, I am particularly impressed by the Pianist, & her interpretation . 5***** to you. You are on your way to an excellent career - Keep up the good work!
omg, its soooooooooooooooooooo slow. It should be intense. The tempo should be a reflection of him want to scream, but not because he pities her. To go this slow is like giving up. No good, dont slide.
Terrible German pronunciation. For example, when you sing "nicht" you should be wetting the floor with your spit. Tempo gets to be OK, but starts way too slow.
Work on your German pronunciation. This performance is indeed much slower than usual, but that's the tempo the composer noted on the original sheet! Besides, it's a matter of taste.
I didn't particularly like the glissando, e.g in 0:33, but it's personal preference. Nice voice :)
Che voce!!! Me parece una voz de bajo-baritono poco común. Digamos en cuanto al timbre es una voz LÍRICA poco común. Digo no es engolada como las voces de ópera. Es interesante. Esto del youtube saca a relucir cada personaje. Muy bueno-
Nice tempo.
ajreid1 7 months ago
Sincere feelings of a very young lover. Beautiful voice, easy on the ear, good to listen to.
Mrpiazzetta 10 months ago
"Laube" means bower, "Laub", what you were singing, means leaves.
That's also why it is "Traume" not "Traum", the same word, but slightly more poetical.
SeltsamerAttraktor 1 year ago
Big mistake, Herr Schumann. You should have put "Not too fast, BUT NOT TOO SLOW EITHER" at the top of the page. It would have avoided a lot of suffering later.
See countless other examples of Deadly Dead Slow Performances on Youtube.
Also, baritones who can't hit top A should stay away from this super piece. In my opinion .......
Nice voice though, Fedor. Keep at it.
bobdoney1 1 year ago
Very good voice, but needs a shinning and high harmonics(sorry my english).
linow666 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The young man does not understand what he sings about, but if he continues his studies a few years so it might be something. One should not publish the man might regret later! A good material, however.
omboingr 1 year ago
The young man does not understand what he sings about, but if he continues his studies a few years so it might be something. One should not publish if one might regret it later! A good material, however.
omboingr 1 year ago
Was sind Sie?Ein Bass,ein Bariton,oder doch ein Tenor?
tenorbass100 2 years ago
@tenorbass100
ik denk een sopraan gehaktballe
KiNgOfKaRaBiNeR 1 year ago
totally no idea where hes singing about lol
KiNgOfKaRaBiNeR 2 years ago
Leaning flat most of the time. :(
renzy79 2 years ago
Robert Schumann set the tempo at "Nicht so Schnell" on the manuscript. The accompanist is spot on. The Mr. Gubachev sings it well w/great feeling & emotion, but should have taken the climax up instead of harmozing down, it's a tough climb for a Baritone to be sure, but worth it. Overall excellent performance, w/great potential from this artist, I am particularly impressed by the Pianist, & her interpretation . 5***** to you. You are on your way to an excellent career - Keep up the good work!
78timothy 2 years ago 2
Please keep up the fine work, you have a tremendous instrument.
youkali22 2 years ago
omg, its soooooooooooooooooooo slow. It should be intense. The tempo should be a reflection of him want to scream, but not because he pities her. To go this slow is like giving up. No good, dont slide.
vans1744 2 years ago
Terrible German pronunciation. For example, when you sing "nicht" you should be wetting the floor with your spit. Tempo gets to be OK, but starts way too slow.
markpianoman 2 years ago
Herz, not Kherz! it's German, not Russian!
Work on your German pronunciation. This performance is indeed much slower than usual, but that's the tempo the composer noted on the original sheet! Besides, it's a matter of taste.
I didn't particularly like the glissando, e.g in 0:33, but it's personal preference. Nice voice :)
noammor 3 years ago 3
00:28-00:33 is out of tune, and its far too slow.
sirinferno 3 years ago
Lets talk about what is positive. Voice incredibly warm, lot of potential. I predict that with a lot of technic, this voice is gonna be amazing
Frisou277 3 years ago
Che voce!!! Me parece una voz de bajo-baritono poco común. Digamos en cuanto al timbre es una voz LÍRICA poco común. Digo no es engolada como las voces de ópera. Es interesante. Esto del youtube saca a relucir cada personaje. Muy bueno-
Anibaal 3 years ago