超級星光大道 第二季 10強 不插電指定賽 20071026 - 黃美珍 One of us

[a623712]

這是在美珍的所有的演唱裡我最愛的一個表演 太完美了! 那高音簡直是...我用言語形容不出來我有多享受聽她唱這首歌 聽幾遍都不膩 那爆發力是無人能敵的!

[FKlove29]

那嚜完美就差在分數沒滿了~

[MorningBunny12]

美珍的声音真的很适合唱这些英文歌，包括她也演唱过的Don't speak 还有every breath you take。 可是她的发音，太可惜了。不光是不标准的问题。会一直打断听者的­感觉啊....会让人觉得她咬字很蠢，却配上她整个酷酷的态度，­整个效果就很惨。个人意见。

[zwojek]

Ładna w chuj. Śpiewa też ładnie :) PROPSY!

[LowJumpinJeff]

Beautiful!

[madonnaprimrise]

感覺洪雪峰有唱得比較好吧

就這首歌

聲音比較沙!?

[yanly9623]

@madonnaprimrise 看完你的評論特地去聽了一遍

我覺得美珍的比較好..洪雪峰的比較平淡, 沒有爆點,

而且有一點唱錯了..

加上美珍是不插電的,本來就比較難唱

而且美珍的聲音非常的特別也非常吸引, 百聽不厭

如果就張宇老師的評論, 洪雪峰的我聽不出有太多的意思...

個人意見啦~ 看看就好~

[vagnerlubov]

Eu amo as chinesas, cantando uma canção maravilhosa como esta... eu me apaixono mais ainda. GOD IS GOOD!!!!!!

[egonzahailo]

morena gata  eu vou

[sinpk2]

traduscan lo que dice hablo del chino no del ingles...!!!

[sinpk2]

xD canta bien me gusta ella y su voz: porque no traducen lo que dice hablo del chino no del ingles !!!!!

[minthem1]

whahahahahahahah ok, ik kan echt geen woord verstaan x'd

[armourepisode]

美珍魂! 超愛她的嗓音

[sl414]

This is one of the best performances.

[shuttlecocksc]

美珍的聲音不插電聽起來特別有味道　表現得很棒！

[tanyapagsolingan]

i love ur version.,i always watch ur video and tRy to it so.,.ahha.,.thumbs up

[AI913]

哈哈好可愛啊美珍~~

[peterequation]

想笑又不敢笑 好可愛喔 哈哈! 最愛美珍

[magic250602]

第7名

在最後一場pk賽她狀況不好輸了

敗部復活沒有成功

我本來看好她能前三名的

[melo3897]

黃美珍最後第幾名??? 超喜歡她的

[welen2004]

應該25分滿分吧~ 都唱的這摸完美了 我光獨自一個人安靜聽了快 10次 找不到缺點~

[alaster493]

This voice was so special

[ycLucas]

天籁之音 ! ! !

[caca881caca881]

我覺得 我到了天堂了

我給予最高的肯定5分(滿分)

[nrfmjtvcxz50]

這嗓音真是太特別了

[amarhaciendoelamor]

She must be a good christian to pick this song for a competition. 美珍，加油！ 好好運用上帝給你的天份去做好音樂，唱好你的歌。

[puddingrbt]

不覺得咬字有問題,口音是一定有.

因為她唱之前特意學過英文,讓評審先入為主吧.

唱得很好,不需要有眼淚,已經比梁文音的流浪記更動人心.

[graylam]

轉音令我想起王菲

[canada999hk]

又關上帝什麼事，是她自己唱得好啊

[xiaozhu4ever]

what's your problem !! it's not their fault that they can't pronounce well since their first or second language isnt english !! she did her best !! i bet if you had to learn chinese, you won't be able to pronounce it etheir !!

[johboy2418]

If you don 't respect us, we WON 'T respect you either!!!

[johboy2418]

looks like you look down on taiwanese a lot ah...

[jaxng82]

f u

[TheMiraclePlay]

Dude she isn't chinese. She is taiwanese.

[cursednicorobin]

lol. you must be pro-taiwanese.

[TheMiraclePlay]

Not really, I just know who she is.

[0417305]

her voice make me calm...love her!

[ajoe999]

好喜歡美珍,嗓音真獨特 華語歌壇少見的聲音

[bleahxblah]

she's a really good singer! ah! i love her!

[augthenoob]

she cantonese i think

[thegiant1]

Taiwanese and part of some aborignal tribe

[siupingbabii]

你不知道喔?選手可以把歌曲改的.

她喜歡唱那段就那段.

很多選手都把歌曲副歌唱2次當最後1段的.

[Servancerse]

嗯~可能在台灣這樣比較無所謂

不過也是學到了一個英文歌的流段唱法

謝謝你給的一個新資訊囉

給你加分

[Lamerstu]

Her english voice is so sexy!

[cn02271981]

mei zhen jia you!

[qqw12012]

may jane is the best ! ! !

[cutieferfer]

she sings very wonderful!

[ameliamah]

蛮特别.

[catrina0727]

she is awesome!!love her much much..

[kobekentus]

her english is okay for a taiwanese..and also sings well

[897570]

when she speaks english...she's gt a unique voice

[sistars]

i LOVE her!!!

[isitasibar]

what a great voice!

[meoow92]

amazing o.o

[hidex1213]

VERY GOOD!!!

i usually like guys singing better (not being sexist), but she's really good

i really like her

[sleepyhealer]

she has a good voice

[Annie1314168]

its okay but she learns english like a lil kid.

[cssmylove]

stranger picth跑了

[cssmylove]

stranger picth跑了

[sseexxyygguurrll]

lol i really love her she is just too pretty

[christychui55]

anyways good enough

[AttackOFTHEPIE]

She reminds me of Lacey Mosley from Flyleaf.

[lindocmj]

全世界不管華語 英語 西班牙語...地域不同 都有不同腔調

只要不差太多還是ok的....

值得一提的是 美珍的嗓音 可以在這首歌裡 如魔術般的切換出那麼多不同音質 而且還那麼流暢 "珍"是不簡單.....

[maninweb]

我一聽就覺得有23分以上

果然23分

靠

[jimmy1118]

you're hilarious

[beisian]

每次都被這首歌深深感動,我想發音固然重要但那是基於要讓聽者聽­到所要表達的,如果太細究根本太無謂

更何況不是英文native理所當然會身受第一母語影響

為什麼要很標準呢?這是發音語言學開宗明義,如果抑制挑踢

發音更甚至是一些末端情緒性的英文字母我想是因為沒什麼可挑踢之­處而本末倒置了

[ilovejiro]

i like her hair

[morrisgordon]

the judges gave 美珍's one of us the same mark (23) as 文音's song because they're all so white-washed in terms of the music they've been listening to since they were young. most of the classic rock music originated from the non-asians and 美珍 is into rock so obviously all her taste in songs are the same as the judges. yes of course 美珍 did excellent on this song, but there is not enough emotions there as compared to 文音

[mi036]

still perfer leung wen yin ..too bad she's been pk off..damn.i thought she would be at least in the last three..man what a waste of a talented singer..

[rentluv]

wow this one gimme the goosebumps. awesome. liking it.

[Fr023n]

anyone got convert this to mp3 ver?

[mezzopiano1017]

coolllll

[yayableu]

her english is good. and her voice has this rock husky feel to it. really good! thanks.

[slps8610]

I like

[genecatcher]

Her best performance by far :)

[lurdespancadas]

teste

[gdlin222]

she is from Taiwan, but she is actually an aboriginal.

[meimei419]

i love this song after she sings it! Amazing performance!

[numbers00]

is this Chinese??

[jen150025]

Taiwanese :)

[Fr023n]

yeah, the guitar playing is nice

[abqnisk]

nice guitar playing.

[scujean2]

like the way she sing this song

[sillyasiantrixr4kidz]

amazing, I never liked this song until now

[aNXie1y]

well done girl

[holybliss]

Nice job meizhen keep up the good work

[verycoldice2]

a slob like us!!

[sincai0344]

thanks for sharing

[cylmcp2007]

her pronunciations did help her...at least I dun have to look at the subtitles all the time to understand what she is singing

[gossiplover]

the english lessons really helped her. thanks for uploading!

[clairelulee]

It says "ROCK"

[arevl]

Eh, what does her necklace say?!