At this point, I don't know what to believe about the Belski brothers. There is more proof of them helping than not helping(saving people), but who am I to say that there has been no massacure from their hands?
@uiopytrre There are 5 brothers, you are forgetting about Yehuda, he's my grandfather and he passed away before these interviews and defiance was made, thats why he and Asael aren't included in this stuff ... because they passed away before these were made
@magic081602 Azael after the war, kidnapped an elderly woman and stole her two hundred and fifty thousand U.S. dollars, which is why the media about him milczą.Bielscy not guerrillas but ordinary bandits.
@692ALBANNACH: I agree. The only country to make a film about the Gypsy experience in the Holocaust was Poland. I don't remember the name of the movie, but it was made in the 70's I think. And it didn't seem to be available outside of Poland.
Well that is a conjecture. Since we could never know this for a fact, we can at least base our premises on facts. The anti-defamation league, for example, fights for causes not only related to jews, such as the crisis in Darfur.
garyd857 Consider it an honour to serve Christ, and stand up for justice for any oppressed people... and remeber what the Lord says, 'Do not take revenge, my friends, but leave room for God's wrath, for it is written: "It is mine to avenge; I will repay," says the Lord.'
Ps, Jesus said no man can enter the kingdom of God unless he is born again. So your either Born again or not. Being Born again is not religious fanaticism its biblical.
I amsad to see that you are still carrying hate even after more than 60 years! I am candian and i feel hate but yu must learn from history and not act upon what heppened then. Please do not spread the hate as i cry reading after you. Grow from the hate and spead a new word.
FUCK the polish government for talking SHIT about these brave young men. Native Americans congrat them. the people of there lands get persercuted from all the forgieners. theses men are greatly appreciated for there tuffness u have shit to say come say it to me..PERIOD... ill show u the real way for sure.. if u hate ... hate me ,, im native with lots of magic WHUT??>>>
Bielskis aren't responsible for killing 128 people in Naliboki.
Bielskis aren't responsible for killing 50 people in Koniuchy.
Bielskis aren't responsible for running away and letting the Nazis kill Polish partisans. 500 of them died. It's a lie. They just decided to see what's on the other side of the river.
Bielskis didn't collaborate with the Soviets. They didn't. They made those weapons themselves.
Go read Peter Duffy's book. Are you upset that a few Jews defended themselves and fought back and survived the world. Do you think people that save other people are killers? Heh maybe the Red Cross starts wars so they can aid people?
Actually the Bielski Partisans and the Soviet Partisans were comrades. Tuvia spoke very highly of the Soviet commander Vasily Chernishev. The two killed 128 AK trash and however many pro-Nazis in Koniuchy. Soviet partisans often went to the Bielski camp for supplies and weapon repairs.
See Belarus accounts if you don't believe Jews- especially about SS Dirlewanger operation and its composition. Se also Belarus movie Come and See which is influenced neither by Hollywood nor Moscow.
Go see the movie "Defiance". It is great really. The men will want to be this brave and women will fall in love with all three brothers. 2 hours and 17 minutes of truth and excellence. Great flick!
"merciful god we have no more tears, we have run out of blood. we have paid for each of your commandments, we covered every stone and field with ashes....."
thank you for posting this very touching documentary!
wow... i think its bad that people only now are starting to recognize Tuvia and his brothers through the film Defiance. What a hero... he defines what a hero is, a real man a true leader and a legend. RIP Tuvia and Zus.
@InUrFce mate search it up on google or wiki
its surprisingly true
and theres no need for vulgarities
he didn't do anything wrong
Thisshitisfuckedup 1 year ago
Remember WHO KILLED WITH POLISH PEOPLE WITH NALIBOKI ??????
zaglebiak22 1 year ago
At this point, I don't know what to believe about the Belski brothers. There is more proof of them helping than not helping(saving people), but who am I to say that there has been no massacure from their hands?
SuperMollytheCat 1 year ago
@SuperMollytheCat if you're saying if the jews massucred no they didnt
Eshayzbra96 1 year ago
Tuvia Bielski =murder, raper& traitor.
"Defiance"=Jewish propaganda.
Bielski's bandit's never shooting to Germans.
domarat11111 1 year ago
@uiopytrre There are 5 brothers, you are forgetting about Yehuda, he's my grandfather and he passed away before these interviews and defiance was made, thats why he and Asael aren't included in this stuff ... because they passed away before these were made
magic081602 2 years ago
@magic081602 Azael after the war, kidnapped an elderly woman and stole her two hundred and fifty thousand U.S. dollars, which is why the media about him milczą.Bielscy not guerrillas but ordinary bandits.
domarat11111 1 year ago
When is someone going to make a movie about the gypsy experience during the same time,there must be lots of stories to tell also?
692ALBANNACH 2 years ago 10
@692ALBANNACH
there is one i couldnt tell you what its called but we watched it in history once.
guitardude05 1 year ago
@692ALBANNACH: I agree. The only country to make a film about the Gypsy experience in the Holocaust was Poland. I don't remember the name of the movie, but it was made in the 70's I think. And it didn't seem to be available outside of Poland.
hectorbolshevik 11 months ago
If the nazis chose another group to go for the the majority of the Jews would of sat back and done nothing like most of the others. Thats the truth.
lynus111 2 years ago
Well that is a conjecture. Since we could never know this for a fact, we can at least base our premises on facts. The anti-defamation league, for example, fights for causes not only related to jews, such as the crisis in Darfur.
pinnecco 1 year ago
3 Bielski Bandits
arwena55 2 years ago
they saved some Jews, but how many Poles and Belarusianss they killed?
xTrudnyDzieciakx 2 years ago
what language was the lady in the beggining speaking??
dwsmith1972 2 years ago
Hebrew. With very strong accent :)
psymouss 2 years ago
Hebrew. With strong accent :)
psymouss 2 years ago
in hebrew
yacov72 2 years ago
dwsmith1972
It is hebrew
SiggyStern 2 years ago
garyd857 Consider it an honour to serve Christ, and stand up for justice for any oppressed people... and remeber what the Lord says, 'Do not take revenge, my friends, but leave room for God's wrath, for it is written: "It is mine to avenge; I will repay," says the Lord.'
Ps, Jesus said no man can enter the kingdom of God unless he is born again. So your either Born again or not. Being Born again is not religious fanaticism its biblical.
LaMOi1 2 years ago
A Nazi should NEVER receive any mercy!
Demjanjuk should be at least thrown into a cell full of hungry rats.
Great movie, even greater story it is based on.
nowUhave 2 years ago
I amsad to see that you are still carrying hate even after more than 60 years! I am candian and i feel hate but yu must learn from history and not act upon what heppened then. Please do not spread the hate as i cry reading after you. Grow from the hate and spead a new word.
JohnnyCoolMusic 2 years ago
To become what it is you despise is a tragedy of the worst kind.
quanyin23 2 years ago
Don't hate the nazi soldiers, they were following orders, hate the officers and higher ranked people.
Mailboxbillthefirst 2 years ago
ok... if you were ordered to put a gun to the back of someone's neck, while they lay naked, face down on the ground and told to fire, would you?
JSOTF 2 years ago
FUCK the polish government for talking SHIT about these brave young men. Native Americans congrat them. the people of there lands get persercuted from all the forgieners. theses men are greatly appreciated for there tuffness u have shit to say come say it to me..PERIOD... ill show u the real way for sure.. if u hate ... hate me ,, im native with lots of magic WHUT??>>>
phall17 2 years ago
Don't listen to those liars.
Bielskis aren't responsible for killing 128 people in Naliboki.
Bielskis aren't responsible for killing 50 people in Koniuchy.
Bielskis aren't responsible for running away and letting the Nazis kill Polish partisans. 500 of them died. It's a lie. They just decided to see what's on the other side of the river.
Bielskis didn't collaborate with the Soviets. They didn't. They made those weapons themselves.
Everyone says those lies is an anti-Zionist!
TheZIDF 3 years ago
ZIDF,
Go read Peter Duffy's book. Are you upset that a few Jews defended themselves and fought back and survived the world. Do you think people that save other people are killers? Heh maybe the Red Cross starts wars so they can aid people?
Hubert7777 3 years ago
Actually the Bielski Partisans and the Soviet Partisans were comrades. Tuvia spoke very highly of the Soviet commander Vasily Chernishev. The two killed 128 AK trash and however many pro-Nazis in Koniuchy. Soviet partisans often went to the Bielski camp for supplies and weapon repairs.
hectorbolshevik 2 years ago
Oh my God, another one trying to falsify history.
The only trash was the Red Horde, that wasn't welcome in Poland. The other trash was Nazis.
Pro-Nazis in Koniuchy... What a laugh. Could you prove they were pro-Nazis?
WielkiZielonyMelon 2 years ago
See Belarus accounts if you don't believe Jews- especially about SS Dirlewanger operation and its composition. Se also Belarus movie Come and See which is influenced neither by Hollywood nor Moscow.
IanHunedoara8 1 year ago
@TheZIDF
There is plenty of documentation and testimony to the contrary, Where is your evidence?
NortonAV2010 1 year ago
Go see the movie "Defiance". It is great really. The men will want to be this brave and women will fall in love with all three brothers. 2 hours and 17 minutes of truth and excellence. Great flick!
reginaDexant 3 years ago
it had always been hard being jewish everyone i know is christian
newcomster 3 years ago
"merciful god we have no more tears, we have run out of blood. we have paid for each of your commandments, we covered every stone and field with ashes....."
thank you for posting this very touching documentary!
peace to israel.
Weariout 3 years ago
wow... i think its bad that people only now are starting to recognize Tuvia and his brothers through the film Defiance. What a hero... he defines what a hero is, a real man a true leader and a legend. RIP Tuvia and Zus.
Brady2k10 3 years ago
Amen to that. I just saw Defiance today. One of the most powerful films I've seen all year. Have you seen it?
sedwards27 3 years ago