@ninjalla How about a believable dynamic attack instead of a choreographed sequence of an uke waddling up in trigger position and freezing his attack in mid air while the tori makes five moves? This type of practice leads to poor technique and inflated instructor confidence beyond their actual ability to defend themselves in a real world dynamic attack. I wasted alot of time in a school with this problem. Train like you fight, fight like you train.
Well said, but I feel I should point out, that the uke dodged the kick by stepping back from it. I intend no disrespect here. I was merely pointing out, what may have a technical oversight. Overall, the video was quite informative. I have to ask something though. That last strike was a shuto, correct? I ask because it looks kind of strange and awkward. I would appreciate some feedback on this as I am also involved in the training of this warrior method of combat.
@owenspence The opponent moves his leg back as this is part of a Fudo ryu kata. That is his role.
The reason he moves his leg is to avoid the knee kick. With a slow opponent that means the kick will destroy the knee rendering the rest of the kata very very realistic.
Well said. The video was quite informative, when I watched it the second time around. I have to ask something though. That last strike was a shuto, correct? I ask because it looks kind of strange and awkward. I would appreciate some feedback on this as I am also involved in the training of this warrior method of combat.
I think we got our wires crossed, or rather I did. The shuto I refer to, is not actually in this video. I was actually referring to a different video and it seems I inadverently commneted on both videos, in the same reply.
@ninjalla Acting smug when you lack the ability understand a statement is your problem, not mine. Your desperate logic fallacy is a transparent device of you insecurity. Sorry your country sucks.
@ninjalla Acting smug when you lack the ability understand a statement is your problem, not mine. Your desperate logic fallacy is a transparent device of insecurity. Sorry your country sucks.
@unclesara With honor, my friend, I disagree with you. what seems like a dubious logic is actually the base rational in my school - war and martial arts are completely different creatures.
So, even though there are many realistic patterns in our syllabus, our current does not carry our craft toward war but toward art.
@ninjalla Your rational is built off of an out of context false syllogism. Retorting with magniloquent regurgitation of your school's mission statement does nothing to support the argument of training static vs. dynamic attacks and how that effects technique. Training unrealistically makes for a helpless artist.
@unclesara@owenspence The opponent moves his leg back as this is part of a Fudo ryu kata. That is his role.
The reason he moves his leg is to avoid the knee kick. With a slow opponent that means the kick will destroy the knee rendering the rest of the kata very very realistic.
@PierreCarette If you kick hard enough to make uke cooperative, then the rest of the technique is irrelevant, you could do anything at that point and there is little use in practicing the technique that requires uke to be cooperative. You can strike to disrupt uke's evil plans and insert your own, but cooperative? Who is afraid of a cooperative enemy?
:D
StrawberryPr0duction 11 months ago
Translated from japanese it means "Over cooperative uke syndrome".
unclesara 1 year ago 11
@unclesara, You are so right. Next time we do it realistically, like Uke's friends will try to shoot the tory or something.
ninjalla 1 year ago
@ninjalla How about a believable dynamic attack instead of a choreographed sequence of an uke waddling up in trigger position and freezing his attack in mid air while the tori makes five moves? This type of practice leads to poor technique and inflated instructor confidence beyond their actual ability to defend themselves in a real world dynamic attack. I wasted alot of time in a school with this problem. Train like you fight, fight like you train.
unclesara 1 year ago
@unclesara, I am a person who fought with real weapons for real. Your fight talk stemms from inexperience.
What a defender can do in a real fight depends on many variants. Enjoying Teki otoshi no kata is an important variant. Enjoy what you do, my friend.
In Akban we have a saying: If you prepare for everything you will be ready for nothing - so prepare for nothing"
Cheers!
ninjalla 1 year ago
Well said, but I feel I should point out, that the uke dodged the kick by stepping back from it. I intend no disrespect here. I was merely pointing out, what may have a technical oversight. Overall, the video was quite informative. I have to ask something though. That last strike was a shuto, correct? I ask because it looks kind of strange and awkward. I would appreciate some feedback on this as I am also involved in the training of this warrior method of combat.
owenspence 10 months ago
@owenspence The opponent moves his leg back as this is part of a Fudo ryu kata. That is his role.
The reason he moves his leg is to avoid the knee kick. With a slow opponent that means the kick will destroy the knee rendering the rest of the kata very very realistic.
ninjalla 10 months ago
Well said. The video was quite informative, when I watched it the second time around. I have to ask something though. That last strike was a shuto, correct? I ask because it looks kind of strange and awkward. I would appreciate some feedback on this as I am also involved in the training of this warrior method of combat.
owenspence 10 months ago
@owenspence this kata is gekan of fudo ryu.
what looks like a shuto is actually a hard grab of the trapesius muscle
ninjalla 10 months ago
I think we got our wires crossed, or rather I did. The shuto I refer to, is not actually in this video. I was actually referring to a different video and it seems I inadverently commneted on both videos, in the same reply.
owenspence 10 months ago
@unclesara What is believable? in my country people shoot each other or use bombs. Is that what you are hinting at?
Should my opponent bomb me dynamically?
ninjalla 10 months ago
@ninjalla Acting smug when you lack the ability understand a statement is your problem, not mine. Your desperate logic fallacy is a transparent device of you insecurity. Sorry your country sucks.
unclesara 10 months ago
@ninjalla Acting smug when you lack the ability understand a statement is your problem, not mine. Your desperate logic fallacy is a transparent device of insecurity. Sorry your country sucks.
unclesara 10 months ago
@unclesara With honor, my friend, I disagree with you. what seems like a dubious logic is actually the base rational in my school - war and martial arts are completely different creatures.
So, even though there are many realistic patterns in our syllabus, our current does not carry our craft toward war but toward art.
Sorry if I sounded smug. It's my perspective.
ninjalla 10 months ago
@ninjalla Your rational is built off of an out of context false syllogism. Retorting with magniloquent regurgitation of your school's mission statement does nothing to support the argument of training static vs. dynamic attacks and how that effects technique. Training unrealistically makes for a helpless artist.
unclesara 10 months ago
@unclesara, ok
ninjalla 10 months ago
@unclesara @owenspence The opponent moves his leg back as this is part of a Fudo ryu kata. That is his role.
The reason he moves his leg is to avoid the knee kick. With a slow opponent that means the kick will destroy the knee rendering the rest of the kata very very realistic.
ninjalla 10 months ago
@unclesara Depending how hard you kick Uke will be more or less cooperative...
PierreCarette 7 months ago
@PierreCarette :)
ninjalla 6 months ago
@PierreCarette If you kick hard enough to make uke cooperative, then the rest of the technique is irrelevant, you could do anything at that point and there is little use in practicing the technique that requires uke to be cooperative. You can strike to disrupt uke's evil plans and insert your own, but cooperative? Who is afraid of a cooperative enemy?
hkdharmon 3 months ago
That's a great technique. Time to subscribe :D
Shindai 4 years ago 3