Clearly, Yates did not read the books and had no idea what the story was about. The most important details will left out. His movies sucked! Bring back Chris Columbus and redo his abominations!
all of the fracking deleted scenes would have been fantastic in the movie! they need to include them in the DVDs and make a harry potter extended edition thing
they should of kept it in cause for people who never read the books wouldnt understand how dolohov and the other death eater found them in the coffee shop so easily
David Yates is a wonderful director. I've always loved the movies (except the 4th-phew!), but I didn't really start to enjoy them like I do before David Yates started directing. While I think he's a brilliant director, it's moments like this that make me 2nd guess my feelings. He does have a BIG tendency to leave out important scenes and make them deleted ones. Maybe he thinks they'd be bigger and more important alone. Still...
And without this scene, NONE of the movie-only audience members know why Harry, Ron and Hermione go around saying "You Know Who" instead of Voldemort. Without this scene, it looks like they have no reason to call Voldemort by any other name- they just start doing so for no reason. Think about it- in all the other movies, Harry (at least) has called him Voldemort. Why should he change that to "You Know Who"? This scene explains that, and without this scene, without the books, you'll never know.
The heck?! This is one of the most crucial parts. Without this scene, it's like somehow they automatically knew everything about the horcruxes, unless you fill in the holes with the books.
Seriously, This was a good scene for people who didn't read the books to know what was going on in the beginning of the movie with the death eaters and how they found The Golden Trio.
This is the scene. The key to understanding the whole movie. I have no idea why they cut this out. I watched the movie and was lost, but read the books and understood. My friends also said that if they hadn't read the books they wouldn't have understood the movie.
its funny that hermione says "its creepy. its like he's here with us" because then it cuts to harry and we all know now that he too was a horcrux. so really, voldemort has been with them the entire time. hermione and ron have been best friends with a bit of his soul since they were eleven....
Warum hat man die Szene rausgenommen. Es hat mich beim Schauen des Films schon geärgert, dass nicht klar wurde, warum Voldemords Leute die Drei plötzlich gefunden haben.
@LifeLiveLoveCheer I don't wanna sound like a big old nerd, but the book makes passing references about Hermione taking food from farms and supermarkets (and conspicuously leaving the money she would normally have used to pay for it) and also charming mushrooms and stuff to make them more edible.
Ron leaves because: The locket's effects on him, jealousy of Harry and Hermione, feeling hopeless about the Horcruxes, feeling left out, missed his family and feeling Comfortable and the good food and many other things.
Why the hell did that silly man, David Yates exclude that scene????? :( :(
For all the people who have only seen the movies, and have not read the books, I highly recomend you do cause you never know what good parts you might be mising out on.
@gullywog there is so much stuff about the horcruxes that i wish were in the movie. i feel that people who only watched the movies don't really know as much as they should about them
@gullywog at the same time i guess we gotta understand that these were only based off the books. writers had to shorten or summarize stuff to keep it within a reasonable amount of time for a movie.. it sucks though. the books are always better than the movie though :P
@gullywog Exactly!!! Or they should of made it into 3 movies!! I wouldnt mind if it was in 3 movies!! Atleast we will get to see the important stuff!!
@LifeLiveLoveCheer i wondered the exact same thing when i rewatched digimon, they are stuck on a digital island for months and they probably eat just a couple of times
@LifeLiveLoveCheer It says so in the book. They had a very hard time scavenging for food, and that was just one of the millions of little reasons that Ron left. They ate everything from random mushrooms to food swiped from muggle stores. Under the invisibilty cloak, of course, and obviously Hermionie gets all sqeamish and leaves some money before they leave.
As I say in all posts xD most of Rupert Grint's role in the movie is chipped off xD it is really a personal opinion.. but yeah lol I can't belive they missed this scene!
Watching the deleted scenes of this movie made me sooooooo mas because almost all of them really should have been in the movie! I mean I love love love the movie, but the deleted scenes were so good it would have made the movie better. They have a bunch of the stuff I came out of the theater saying should have been in the movie.
There was a taboo on saying voldemort, remember that's how they were found in the coffee shop? And they just said it again and nobody showed up. Lol movie messups.
@khaodem no, the locket was from salazar slytherin. but it was supposedly created after voldemort killed a muggle tramp. I dunno if he "did" her or not though...
@InternetAholic It's Salazar Slytherin's locket. It belonged to Voldemort's family. His mother sold it for some gold not long before she gave birth to Voldemort then died. Voldemort in turn got it from an old woman who collected rare treasures. She had the locket and the cup. Voldemort killed her and framed her house elf and stole the locket and cup and turned them into horcrux's it's all in the 6th book.
@LifeLiveLoveCheer : At a point, they fish and Ron complains about Hermione having burnt the food or something like that. Otherwise, being british and as shown in this scene... Tea, I guess.
They should have kept that because you wouldn't guess that to say "Voldemort" the death eaters would be able to find you. It was a very critical part of the book that is how the death eaters found them at the lovegood's house
@LifeLiveLoveCheer in the book it said they struggled. hermione picked berries and mashrooms and made soups and they caught fish also but in the movie idk why they ddnt include that
@LifeLiveLoveCheer Hermione tries to find some mushrooms or something else and tries to make a meal out of it. But the problem is, that ron only likes the good food at hogwarts or from his mum and that another point why he runs away ;)
I think one time Harry tries to steal some food in a town, but there are too many dementores, that's why that did not work^^ :)
@LifeLiveLoveCheer did you read the book? Sometimes they had to starve, sometimes they got berries, sometimes they went found a farm or shop or something that eggs or bread or spaghetti
OMG why did they cut this? it explained about cutting you know who's name and why harry suddenly switched to you-know-who. i mean i read the book but that part REALLY ANNOYED ME!
@LifeLiveLoveCheer I remember when reading Deathly Hallows, Hermione said that one cannot must conjure up food unless it has already been prepared for them. I think they just took stuff from the places they went to with the invisibility cloak if I remember correctly.
@LifeLiveLoveCheer once Hermione sneaked into a Market under the invisibility cloak, but she left some money at the cash register, once they stole some eggs and bread from a farm but mostly it was herbs and mushrooms that they found and Hermione cooked
Hey, in this scene Harry says '' The ring that according to Dumbledore belongs to Tom's grandfather...'' but in fact in Harry Potter and The Half Blood Prince Dumbledore says it belongs to Tom's MOTHER!
@ylrmoo Maybe but Harry asked in the movie ''And the ring?'' and Dumbledore said ''It belonged to Tom's mother, hard to find even harder to... destroy.'' Oh well they must have made a mistake.
i hate 2 say this but ...i dnt like this scene ....cuz is like all this part is lost or out of cntext and if they show this scene we wouldn't love when ron and harry fight nd HARRY DANCE WITH HERMIONE!!!!!!!!! i love that part don't you???
Well...honestly, they took out alot of scenes. Just wait 'til the DVD's out.
The dancing scene was great, it was the perfect way to lighten up the athmosphere, since Part one was pretty depressing and there wasn't much action. So if it was either this or that, then I'd prefer the dancing.
Though, this is still a great scene, but I understand the choice of not using it if they had to cut something.
@LifeLiveLoveCheer in the books it says that hermione poorely tried to cook some mushrooms and stuff they found in the woods and when they came near a supermarket they would steal some food under their invisible cloak but hermione always left money there because she doesnt like to steal :)
Wow why would they take this out? I've read all the books and if you ask me this is kind of important. Not important as to you won't understand the movie, but it's still kind of necessary to put in the film. But also I like the dancing scene. It was very well made, and it showed the bond between the two characters. So don't bash that scene
Im glad they put the dancing scene in the movie its a great thing it shows how close friends they are :) it reminds me of my best friend toby and me exactley like that the dance scene always makes me smile and not use my brain but my heart :) -33333
@arsenalmn I do wish they'd kept details like this because they are important to the storyline. But even JK Rowling herself said that the dancing scene was a great idea
This is in the book, and is so great...these little small things that I loved in the book were taken out and instead swapped with "hollywood" dancing scenes of harry and hermione....
This is such an important scene! I have no clue why they took it out. When Xenophilius Lovegood says Voldemort's name and then the death eaters come to attack Harry Ron and Hermione, some people might have been completely confused as to why they came there and what made them come. True Harry Potter fans know, but those who settle for the movies are clueless.
The first thing I told my friends who didn't read the books after seeing the movie was about the taboo since all of a sudden they weren't saying Voldemort's name but in the cafe in part 1 they didn't say it either to get tracked. They should've made their minds up on that one.
GUYS VOTE FOR HARRY POTTER FOR THE TEEN CHOICE AWARDS! they NEED to win over twilight...i love both films but harry potter wins over twilight EASILY. i dunno, its just obvious! Common!! give thumbs up!!! :) so ppl can seee...plz vote :) they DESERVE to leave with awards! <3 i love harry potter :) and am voting NOW! :D
All HP fans plis vote in teen choice awards they really deserved to win plis plis vote this years they all need to win vote HP for everythig specially Emma Watson best Actress she´s really amazing you have until friday tell everyone and pass thumbs up if you want HP wins
they really should've kept this scene! i didn't read the books and i understood the horcruxes but this would've made it a bit easier to completely understand them at the time! also, "it's like he's here with us" lol foreshadowing FTW
@candidita203 Not really. I know people who watched the movies without reading the books and they understood the horcruxes just fine without this scene.
crikey that was powerful! The way that Ron and Hermione looked at Harry when they said it's like he's here with us and Harry replies in a way that shows he's absolutely determined to do whatever to end Voldemort
Clearly, Yates did not read the books and had no idea what the story was about. The most important details will left out. His movies sucked! Bring back Chris Columbus and redo his abominations!
jdhavo11 6 days ago
Argh
all of the fracking deleted scenes would have been fantastic in the movie! they need to include them in the DVDs and make a harry potter extended edition thing
ConfidencePants 4 weeks ago 7
@ConfidencePants I think exactly the same!
CropCircle1996 3 weeks ago
This should have been in the flipping movie... wow...
Otect 4 weeks ago
they should of kept it in cause for people who never read the books wouldnt understand how dolohov and the other death eater found them in the coffee shop so easily
truebloodfreak06 1 month ago
David Yates is a wonderful director. I've always loved the movies (except the 4th-phew!), but I didn't really start to enjoy them like I do before David Yates started directing. While I think he's a brilliant director, it's moments like this that make me 2nd guess my feelings. He does have a BIG tendency to leave out important scenes and make them deleted ones. Maybe he thinks they'd be bigger and more important alone. Still...
eyehatetwilight 1 month ago
And without this scene, NONE of the movie-only audience members know why Harry, Ron and Hermione go around saying "You Know Who" instead of Voldemort. Without this scene, it looks like they have no reason to call Voldemort by any other name- they just start doing so for no reason. Think about it- in all the other movies, Harry (at least) has called him Voldemort. Why should he change that to "You Know Who"? This scene explains that, and without this scene, without the books, you'll never know.
SorrowfulLesson 1 month ago 7
The heck?! This is one of the most crucial parts. Without this scene, it's like somehow they automatically knew everything about the horcruxes, unless you fill in the holes with the books.
Summerneechan 1 month ago 8
I feel like this was important..
KathrynLouise44 1 month ago
Seriously, This was a good scene for people who didn't read the books to know what was going on in the beginning of the movie with the death eaters and how they found The Golden Trio.
DawnIsBreakingThroug 2 months ago
the first think harry sais sounds like "dumbledore had a ferry" xD
Mauselmais 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
FOR HP FANS, PLEASE VOTE FOR POTTER ON MTV
FOR BEST MOVIE ENSEMBLE OF THE YEAR
PLEASE VOTE FOR HP!!!!!!!
stupid B Dawn movie has 1 or 2 pts. less which might increase
gullywog 2 months ago
It's a really important scene. By the way, I love how Hermione goes and sits on Ron's bed and their worried faces at 0:49
afreiresparragos 2 months ago
Thank God I read the books. This scene was well needed for those who didn't
MsKittyGoesMeow 2 months ago
This scene shouldn't have been deleted
TheLauraLongbottom 2 months ago
they def should have included that in the movie. would have helped the people who never read the books!
becca5star 3 months ago
This needed to be in the movie IMHO. It explains more about the horcruxes. oh well not for me to decide.
Justafan1107 3 months ago
hey doesn't this taboo thing come after ron comes back??
TheEamjay 3 months ago 4
@TheEamjay The books and movies don't need to be the same.
StartheSpark 3 months ago
They took this scene out because in the movie they weren't caught by saying the Name.
luf4rall 4 months ago in playlist More videos from RupertGrintTVChannel 2
Oh, so they did explain how the fuck they knew this shit. They just... didn't... put it in the movie! What... why... I have no words...
Joydawn 4 months ago
No. Way. They aren't at random?!?!?!
joyfulpoison257 4 months ago
i hope they release an uncut versio
tvaholic 4 months ago
LMAO love the replies to @LifeLiveLoveCheer
it's all
READ THE BOOK
hahahahaha XD
BeBeAyumiReturns 4 months ago
This is the scene. The key to understanding the whole movie. I have no idea why they cut this out. I watched the movie and was lost, but read the books and understood. My friends also said that if they hadn't read the books they wouldn't have understood the movie.
iiFallenWish 4 months ago 3
they totally should've kept this scene. it explains a lot
cornstar101 4 months ago 3
@LifeLiveLoveCheer wow, you've gotten a lot of replies! I bet you know more about how they ate now than most people lol :)
TheVildee 4 months ago
its funny that hermione says "its creepy. its like he's here with us" because then it cuts to harry and we all know now that he too was a horcrux. so really, voldemort has been with them the entire time. hermione and ron have been best friends with a bit of his soul since they were eleven....
happyhappydays122 5 months ago
...Why was this left out...
aishumaj1 5 months ago
Warum hat man die Szene rausgenommen. Es hat mich beim Schauen des Films schon geärgert, dass nicht klar wurde, warum Voldemords Leute die Drei plötzlich gefunden haben.
petzebaer 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer mushrooms, fish, sometimes they'd sneek into supermarkets under the cloak
227060 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer I don't wanna sound like a big old nerd, but the book makes passing references about Hermione taking food from farms and supermarkets (and conspicuously leaving the money she would normally have used to pay for it) and also charming mushrooms and stuff to make them more edible.
ganonisthebest 5 months ago
i agree this part explain everything...
23kendz 5 months ago
WHY WAS THIS DELETED!!!!
aliabooboo 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer read the book -.-
alee9955 5 months ago
ah tea how we British cope in dark times, that and tuting
timelordfromhell2 5 months ago
Ron leaves because: The locket's effects on him, jealousy of Harry and Hermione, feeling hopeless about the Horcruxes, feeling left out, missed his family and feeling Comfortable and the good food and many other things.
LetsStopThisSong 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer Well... have you read the books?
TheYou0Tuber 5 months ago 49
Why the hell did that silly man, David Yates exclude that scene????? :( :(
For all the people who have only seen the movies, and have not read the books, I highly recomend you do cause you never know what good parts you might be mising out on.
gullywog 5 months ago 151
@gullywog there is so much stuff about the horcruxes that i wish were in the movie. i feel that people who only watched the movies don't really know as much as they should about them
joyofpepsi 4 months ago 3
@joyofpepsi
You are right.
I was thinking the same thing to. :(
Well I hope many of the people who haven't read the books will see these deleted scenes so that they might have a better understanding.
Part 1 was good but still, many important parts were still missing
This is the reason why David Yates had pissed me off because too many good scenes like these were deleted
He is a good director but he made too many mistakes. I doubt he even took the time to even understand the book
gullywog 4 months ago
@gullywog at the same time i guess we gotta understand that these were only based off the books. writers had to shorten or summarize stuff to keep it within a reasonable amount of time for a movie.. it sucks though. the books are always better than the movie though :P
joyofpepsi 4 months ago
@gullywog very well said! THE SCENE SUM UP what HORCRUX really is about!
napholie14apple 3 months ago
@napholie14apple
Oh thanks.
That deleted scene with the trio talking about the horcrux was an important scene and it was quite good to.
It's a pity Yates didn't add it :(
but oh well..
gullywog 3 months ago
@gullywog are you calling DAVID YATES SILLY??? you're crap you know
but you are right they shouldn't have taken it out of the book
rachmanninoffdrama 2 months ago
Comment removed
gullywog 2 months ago
Comment removed
gullywog 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@rachmanninoffdrama
Are you calling me crap?? I really don't care whether you like my opinion or not.
MAYBE I WAS WRONG FOR SAYING YATES IS SILLY.
I SHOULD HAVE SAID HIS DECISONS WERE SILLY INSTEAD OK,
BUT CALLING ME CRAP IS TOTALLY UNCALLED FOR!!!!!!!!! YOU DON'T KNOW ME SO SHUT UP!!!!!!
I WOULD SAY MORE THINGS BUT SOME THINGS ARE BETTER LEFT UNSAID. I PREFER NOT TO WRITE INSENSITIVE COMMENTS LIKE YOURS AGAIN
gullywog 2 months ago
@rachmanninoffdrama how that person crap?
okalani1992 2 months ago
@gullywog not sure it really was Yates call for being honest. More likely it's again one of Kloves awful decision. As usual.
RebelAdmiral 1 week ago
Comment removed
gullywog 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@RebelAdmiral It seems that you do have a point. I guess Kloves made MANY horrible choices : l
but as a director.... Yates could have made minor changes by adding these important scenes in the movie..
Then Again, maybe both to are to blame. Who knows?
gullywog 1 week ago
@gullywog Keep in mind that Yates did not know the story. He was creating sensationalism. He was not trying to tell the story!
jdhavo11 6 days ago
@gullywog Exactly!!! Or they should of made it into 3 movies!! I wouldnt mind if it was in 3 movies!! Atleast we will get to see the important stuff!!
Skid161 4 days ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer Read the book . . .
MrGegere 5 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
THEY LEFT IT OUT?!?!?!?! *RA...GE!!!*
genelin1995 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@LifeLiveLoveCheer They steal foods from Muggle towns by Summoning Charm. (Hermione always leave some cash behind because she is that honest.)
genelin1995 5 months ago
This scene is do important for the film! Ahh wish thy never cut it. And kept to the taboo of voldemorts name..
dela777222 5 months ago
that was kinda depressing
TheShanorton 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer read the book lol
spiritcrazy5000 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer well, in the book they eat mushrooms and fish... I think...
Silencemama 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer i wondered the exact same thing when i rewatched digimon, they are stuck on a digital island for months and they probably eat just a couple of times
Mohamed518 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer It says so in the book. They had a very hard time scavenging for food, and that was just one of the millions of little reasons that Ron left. They ate everything from random mushrooms to food swiped from muggle stores. Under the invisibilty cloak, of course, and obviously Hermionie gets all sqeamish and leaves some money before they leave.
MegaBookWormGirl 5 months ago
this scene wouldve made the movie ten times better! cant believe they took it out :(
lamb4n 5 months ago
This deleted scene is amazing, why they delleted??
NmetevesRuls 5 months ago
As I say in all posts xD most of Rupert Grint's role in the movie is chipped off xD it is really a personal opinion.. but yeah lol I can't belive they missed this scene!
ColonelMiiM 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer What i a always wonder is how people still havent read the damn book c'mon
1995chicken 5 months ago
In the beginning.... why exactly is that little window at the left supposed to be in here?? isn't their tent built in the forest? :D
urgentneedhelp 5 months ago
Watching the deleted scenes of this movie made me sooooooo mas because almost all of them really should have been in the movie! I mean I love love love the movie, but the deleted scenes were so good it would have made the movie better. They have a bunch of the stuff I came out of the theater saying should have been in the movie.
yougogirlphinney28 5 months ago
why did they deleted this!!! it was a very good escene!
loriblack23 5 months ago
There was a taboo on saying voldemort, remember that's how they were found in the coffee shop? And they just said it again and nobody showed up. Lol movie messups.
christinaamule 5 months ago
the ring didn't belong to voldemort's mother
ShockWave241 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer read the book, than you know what they eat :D in the book it's said that they fish and take food from farmers
sweetlittleshari 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer /watch?v=kDiMbJV23Y0&feature=related Bunnies? xD
Ifigenia98 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer its called read the books
angryauscritic 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer You'd know it if you read the book.
Timoe2011 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer if you read the book, you would know :P
turtleturton 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer Read the book!
LydiaCooke97 5 months ago
they should of put tht in!!! again kicking out the inportant sences... honestly i was kinda lost in tht part of the movie... :/
XAndiAHx 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer It says in the book. they stole food, bought food, caught fish and gathered food, and starved a bit.
sheleftmalfoy 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer Lol. I'd wondered that, too.
BlackJadedHeart 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer omg when i saw your comment it was like you were in my mind!!!:P:P
RanDomME4u 5 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer read the books and you will have your answer
Snip3rfy 5 months ago
i forget where i heard it, but i've always thought the locket was from some muggle tramp that he 'did' if you understand my parseltongue....
khaodem 5 months ago
@khaodem no, the locket was from salazar slytherin. but it was supposedly created after voldemort killed a muggle tramp. I dunno if he "did" her or not though...
InternetAholic 5 months ago
@InternetAholic It's Salazar Slytherin's locket. It belonged to Voldemort's family. His mother sold it for some gold not long before she gave birth to Voldemort then died. Voldemort in turn got it from an old woman who collected rare treasures. She had the locket and the cup. Voldemort killed her and framed her house elf and stole the locket and cup and turned them into horcrux's it's all in the 6th book.
rbflowt2 5 months ago
Comment removed
kittyadell 5 months ago
u guys if u want detail info just read THE GODDAM BOOK!
reymuradaisuke 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer : At a point, they fish and Ron complains about Hermione having burnt the food or something like that. Otherwise, being british and as shown in this scene... Tea, I guess.
Aphrophro 6 months ago
They should have kept that because you wouldn't guess that to say "Voldemort" the death eaters would be able to find you. It was a very critical part of the book that is how the death eaters found them at the lovegood's house
Coffeebreakcam2 6 months ago 5
@LifeLiveLoveCheer I have always wondered how do they clean themselves?
heyitssophiema 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer MAGIC
Theriot6592 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer in the book it said they struggled. hermione picked berries and mashrooms and made soups and they caught fish also but in the movie idk why they ddnt include that
dracosBIGGESTfan 6 months ago 3
@LifeLiveLoveCheer it explains it in the books :)
anikila1 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer or did they poo or pee? i wondered the same thing.
lalanishie67 6 months ago
@lalanishie67 haha me too xD
14imke 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer Read the books - idiot.
Danalexist 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer Hermione tries to find some mushrooms or something else and tries to make a meal out of it. But the problem is, that ron only likes the good food at hogwarts or from his mum and that another point why he runs away ;)
I think one time Harry tries to steal some food in a town, but there are too many dementores, that's why that did not work^^ :)
MissNewBorn 6 months ago
Why deleting important scenes!!!!!!!!
fighterdoctor 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer Read the book! Everything´s there! :) They barely eat :(
oYoCkOo 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer Read the book.
uglyfudge 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer did you read the book? Sometimes they had to starve, sometimes they got berries, sometimes they went found a farm or shop or something that eggs or bread or spaghetti
MrOssumAnt 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer well im sure hermione packed enough food in her bag for a year XD
corinaluver 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer well, harry and ron DID hunt rabbits :D
meganinjapillow 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer they ate berries and mushrooms that were found in the forest :)
twilightthecullens 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer Hermoine bought food or if that ran out they could cook animails they find (poor animails)
Harratot33 6 months ago
They should've kept this bit in I think.
HydiestFaith 6 months ago 2
OMG why did they cut this? it explained about cutting you know who's name and why harry suddenly switched to you-know-who. i mean i read the book but that part REALLY ANNOYED ME!
megalodonkiss 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer I'm sure there was some god damn food in hermione's bag
bouchandre 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer I remember when reading Deathly Hallows, Hermione said that one cannot must conjure up food unless it has already been prepared for them. I think they just took stuff from the places they went to with the invisibility cloak if I remember correctly.
dumdeedum27 6 months ago
This explains so much!!!! Y cut it out?
meggyweasley728 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer once Hermione sneaked into a Market under the invisibility cloak, but she left some money at the cash register, once they stole some eggs and bread from a farm but mostly it was herbs and mushrooms that they found and Hermione cooked
sagitaripotter97 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer random herbs and mushrooms that they found and thought were safe to eat.
jelbertie 6 months ago
why leave this part out? WHY??
TheJojo2202 6 months ago
This is in the first movie... or at least something similar.
CreepinessFTW 6 months ago
They should of left this in. I know people who haven't read the books and had no idea what was going on.
westernpleasuresarah 6 months ago
Hey, in this scene Harry says '' The ring that according to Dumbledore belongs to Tom's grandfather...'' but in fact in Harry Potter and The Half Blood Prince Dumbledore says it belongs to Tom's MOTHER!
mermaidsh2o 6 months ago
@mermaidsh2o it belonged to his grandfather... then his uncle...
ylrmoo 6 months ago
@ylrmoo Maybe but Harry asked in the movie ''And the ring?'' and Dumbledore said ''It belonged to Tom's mother, hard to find even harder to... destroy.'' Oh well they must have made a mistake.
mermaidsh2o 6 months ago
why do they always leave out the important parts?
Blubs92 6 months ago
i hate 2 say this but ...i dnt like this scene ....cuz is like all this part is lost or out of cntext and if they show this scene we wouldn't love when ron and harry fight nd HARRY DANCE WITH HERMIONE!!!!!!!!! i love that part don't you???
MiruEmmaWatson 6 months ago
@MiruEmmaWatson ....no.
MrsBlack88 1 month ago
this would actually help people who haven't read the books...
emomazing 6 months ago 4
Well...honestly, they took out alot of scenes. Just wait 'til the DVD's out.
The dancing scene was great, it was the perfect way to lighten up the athmosphere, since Part one was pretty depressing and there wasn't much action. So if it was either this or that, then I'd prefer the dancing.
Though, this is still a great scene, but I understand the choice of not using it if they had to cut something.
xIceM 6 months ago 4
@LifeLiveLoveCheer in the books it says that hermione poorely tried to cook some mushrooms and stuff they found in the woods and when they came near a supermarket they would steal some food under their invisible cloak but hermione always left money there because she doesnt like to steal :)
Zuckerveilchen 6 months ago
Wow why would they take this out? I've read all the books and if you ask me this is kind of important. Not important as to you won't understand the movie, but it's still kind of necessary to put in the film. But also I like the dancing scene. It was very well made, and it showed the bond between the two characters. So don't bash that scene
TheDealer1228 6 months ago
Im glad they put the dancing scene in the movie its a great thing it shows how close friends they are :) it reminds me of my best friend toby and me exactley like that the dance scene always makes me smile and not use my brain but my heart :) -33333
RupertGrint1000 6 months ago
so they took this important part out and replaced it with REALLY awkward dancing?
Twejitoki 6 months ago
@ChrisKOkHP ugh I hated the stupid dance scenes and wher did she say this????
meowpower08 6 months ago
@arsenalmn I do wish they'd kept details like this because they are important to the storyline. But even JK Rowling herself said that the dancing scene was a great idea
ChrisKOkHP 6 months ago
This is in the book, and is so great...these little small things that I loved in the book were taken out and instead swapped with "hollywood" dancing scenes of harry and hermione....
arsenalmn 6 months ago
Why did they take this out? I mean, what would it matter if the film was an extra minute long?
MikeyMcN123 6 months ago
@LifeLiveLoveCheer Read the novel, you can find the answer. Those contents are too much for films.
frjty 6 months ago
@frjty it an't no novel its real bitch! jks =)
Benorahh 6 months ago
again, kicking out important scenes, they never showed the signs dumbledore showed them, and this scene was very very important
agominator 6 months ago 112
@agominator I agree with you about this.
BlackJadedHeart 5 months ago
@agominator VERY IMPORTANT!
imachamp182 5 months ago
Opps I meant the trace
tanimed 6 months ago
oh god this scene was fucking important!!! I always thought... oh god nobody mentions anything about the track and using the voldemort word
tanimed 6 months ago
This is such an important scene! I have no clue why they took it out. When Xenophilius Lovegood says Voldemort's name and then the death eaters come to attack Harry Ron and Hermione, some people might have been completely confused as to why they came there and what made them come. True Harry Potter fans know, but those who settle for the movies are clueless.
chinchillaqueen13 6 months ago
Why did they take this out! I've read the books multiple times, and I was mad they didn't explain the whole taboo thing. They should have kept it!
Telebee319 6 months ago
I can't understand this it's coming out in a different language..but it doesn't matter cause this scene is in the movie.
funlexa1234 6 months ago
He leaves because he put on that necklace!!The necklace causes people to go mad and say things they dont mean!
KateandVanessa12 6 months ago
Erm, this scene is actually in Part 1, what's everyone talking about!?
royamurs 6 months ago
@royamurs Nope its not
MattC1195 6 months ago
@MattC1195 really!? in the dvd i watched it was, :O
royamurs 6 months ago
why did they take this out?
it's kinda really important...
thegingerbreadgirl16 7 months ago
The first thing I told my friends who didn't read the books after seeing the movie was about the taboo since all of a sudden they weren't saying Voldemort's name but in the cafe in part 1 they didn't say it either to get tracked. They should've made their minds up on that one.
niyoels 7 months ago
Ummm why on earth did they take this out? This was really important.
Shadoessa 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
GUYS VOTE FOR HARRY POTTER FOR THE TEEN CHOICE AWARDS! they NEED to win over twilight...i love both films but harry potter wins over twilight EASILY. i dunno, its just obvious! Common!! give thumbs up!!! :) so ppl can seee...plz vote :) they DESERVE to leave with awards! <3 i love harry potter :) and am voting NOW! :D
4everChrisiecream 7 months ago
Ahhh! They should've left this in! This answered like three questions of mine which NEEDED answering. -.- Glad I found this.
annachristinesims 7 months ago
@annachristinesims you should read the books!! :) they are amazing.
themagicbegins 7 months ago
This scene is so important! The taboo on the name!!
hannabelletrackstar 7 months ago 5
All HP fans plis vote in teen choice awards they really deserved to win plis plis vote this years they all need to win vote HP for everythig specially Emma Watson best Actress she´s really amazing you have until friday tell everyone and pass thumbs up if you want HP wins
5m3add 7 months ago 5
Where did you find this scene?
amberkphilpott 7 months ago
I really hope this scene is on the DVD release....it's all necessary exposition!
SilaVendethiel 7 months ago
This isn't even a long scene ! It would make the movie a one minute longer so why cut it off ?
TheLittleDomino 7 months ago
they really should've kept this scene! i didn't read the books and i understood the horcruxes but this would've made it a bit easier to completely understand them at the time! also, "it's like he's here with us" lol foreshadowing FTW
natlovesjb143 7 months ago 3
david yates is a looser.. this is a very important scene
candidita203 7 months ago
@candidita203 Not really. I know people who watched the movies without reading the books and they understood the horcruxes just fine without this scene.
LilaBear 7 months ago
cool, bayrische bierbänke in harry potter ^^
schneggilein89 7 months ago
I cannot figure out any single logical reason to remove this scene from the final product. Not a one.
LadyNellethiel 7 months ago
DUDE!!!! Why did they cut this out! This was very important! It teaches us about the horcruxes!
JuicyJuice1116 7 months ago
i dont understand..why did they took this? its not that im retarded its cuz i didnt watch deathly hallows part 1 so can anyone explain to me?
ahrims221 7 months ago
does this tent actually have a toilet? or a shower?
VampireDiariesxGer 7 months ago
I felt a bit of a rebel for referring to him as Voldemort then! And not as "you know who"
hhalez 7 months ago
crikey that was powerful! The way that Ron and Hermione looked at Harry when they said it's like he's here with us and Harry replies in a way that shows he's absolutely determined to do whatever to end Voldemort
hhalez 7 months ago
i feel like that scene was mega important.. WTF ...
brookeluvsu212 7 months ago
I don't understand why this was deleted
tiamat1990 7 months ago 6
They take out most of the scene where hermione shows feeling for ron or when ron shows feeling for hermione :(
HeiMyong 7 months ago 7
emma watson kinda grew out of her character. she doesnt look like a hermione anymore, she looks all grown up
<