超級星光大道 20100917 pt.15/20 陳珂冰-Killing me softly with his song

[GraceOh]

She reminds me absolutely of Isla Fisher

[guigui5201314]

i like陳珂冰^^

[fongbbb]

童話唱得很好,,,有feel有戲

但陳珂冰是全能型，中英文唱得都很好

童話的中文歌真的不行

[gaskay9265]

音有道但是能感觉到她很紧张

[RedCommander33]

童话唱得很平。。。。 不好听！

[2005tf]

童話是北京人吧, 說的英文有很重的鼻音, 跟美國南部的英文很相似, 唱得一氣呵成, 十分舒服。

冰冰唱的T0NE錯喇, Killing me softly, 一點也不soft, 像是唱歌劇, 冰冰本來的實力好過童話, 23分也不錯, 下次加油吧。

[ionglaichan]

我覺得聽起來 有種壓迫感 沒有能放鬆的心情 就是聽到有點辛苦

[Neins99]

@ionglaichan 

[jyosui]

那些說童話還是唱軍歌的各位~麻煩去聽聽原作，再聽聽童話唱的！­真是的，碰上個自信一點表現大方得體的女孩子就說人家高傲，唉，­現在的女孩子不容易啊~

[qszwax92]

很大馬人的國語喔　呵呵　＝）

[pk12102002]

這不是在用外表評分的好?



[jimigao]

作为大陆人 表示不能喜欢童话小姐

[tommarui]

陈珂冰，加油！加油！发挥出你的最大power,你一定行的！！ 

[umiseaz]

長的不錯。。。

我覺得她的妝化得有點濃 ～ 囧

[roy60906765]

看到童話唱到一半已經想關電腦,太造作啦.看得很不爽.

[Qing0414]

童話可以唱光良的"童話"

童話贏在他是新人所以評審覺得有新鮮感

冰冰是上屆的pk者,可能比較不新鮮了

[KUDODO2007]

我知道很多男觀眾都想意銀科兵 o_o

[a25479]

有前途~不錯唷!

[jer3899]

至少碼要同分 唉!  這些評審喔....

看到蠟筆小冰哭了....好心疼.....

[onimicha]

tong hua speak fluent english.. she's really good in english..

but still i think my bing bing should win this.. she perfect it.. lol

[TheDebbie99]

倆个都好听,同分！

[uunreal]

@dwsc1968 sorry, mind explaining what the 'backers' you mentioned mean? I don't remember it from earlier episodes.

[TheDragonor]

童話贏在最後一句挑逗了林志炫一下吧.

但是陳珂冰的力量沒有出來啊. 可惜. 加油!

有甜美的幼幼外表, 歌聲帶有強烈的穿透力.

一定成為新一代宅男女神.

童話......不知道自己有什麼問題是最大的問題.

當中央台新聞主播一定沒有問題!

[drunkvirus]

Pink Tan should have won!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[603patrick]

童小姐似乎比較沒辦法表現比較柔的部分.上次的中文歌是硬到不行­.這次英文歌有比較好一點.但還是感覺就是硬硬的.假如她唱歌都­是這樣.那比較需要一些情緒的歌應該是沒辦法表現到使聽眾投入.­頂多是適合一些需要大聲吶喊的歌而已.

[yyjw913]

兩個都不錯 但我覺得舞台上 童話比較有更多的自信和大將之風

[leoshanbob]

"Killing Me Softly with His Song" is a 1971 song composed by Charles Fox and Norman Gimbel. It was inspired by Lori Lieberman's response to having seen a performance by Don McLean.[1] It has been covered by numerous artists, most notably by Roberta Flack, whose version topped the U.S. pop singles charts, and won a Grammy Award. This song has more story telling then put your stupid records on. Just watch dpNdMIAnKko. What a perfect song for competition like this.

[sitsen417]

童話的咬字和英文的輕重音、氣音...聽起來怪怪的，不過他用身­體、臉部表情的表演把氣氛帶的不錯。陳珂冰唱的很好聽~但是後半­部唱的有點趕了。

但我覺得陳珂冰唱的比較好聽~

[a828136332000]

很多人對童話很有意見　刮別人鬍子　先看看自己　一味的批評並沒有什麼好處

我真不懂多給人一些鼓勵不是很好嗎？　我們應該相信老師的專業　不是意味的懷疑別人是不是有後台　從客觀的角度來看你的批評　只會讓感覺中立的人討厭pink而已

身為一個喜歡看星光的人我誠心的建議　ps陳坷冰　童話　加油加油!!

[dwsc1968]

@a828136332000 Is not most here wanna criticise her but the fact that her action is very unnatural and kind of fake. She will only be a one hit wonder. The fact that she has backers is a fact and has been mentioned during the selection.

Pink is more natural and will progress thru to the final. Most here has good impression as she was a PK contestant in season 6 and has done well.

[MICHAEL2010SIEW]

Roger is point. he must lean more English.

[yukiboy90]

Pink delivered the song lovely. Support you always!

[RataFucker]

do not like either contestant. they seem like the type who feel they are clearly better than everyone else.

[yc188]

陳珂冰唱得好很多 怎麼會這樣  評審是怎麼評的 真的看無

[MyXianxian]

She has a great confidence ,and she gives me a charming feeling. But,actually I like 童話more than坷冰.

[TheNoobhoho]

为什么roger 会给少一分呢???...

至少都应该同分啊...

[yayaadel]

@TheNoobhoho roger给的分数是-----外形

[arielichin]

童話的咬字其實根本就沒有道地的腔調啊? 為什麼大家都說她英文講的很好呢? 就是很流利而已啊，只不過是中國人的捲舌英加英文，聽起來似乎有­特別的腔調而已...

[arielichin]

童話的咬字其實根本就沒有道地的腔調啊? 為什麼大家都說她英文講的很好呢? 就是很流利而已啊，只不過是中國人的捲舌英加英文，聽起來似乎有­特別的腔調而已...

[yvonneshelove]

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!啊!!!差一分!!

[springgod1121]

看完這特地去找童話影片~聽不到30秒就關掉了~

這樣居然會輸~ 真扯~

[chan95822]

其實我認為童話和珂冰不相伯仲吧 但是童話的絕招才和珂冰不相伯仲的話 佢應該20強止步喇

[pc750619]

兩個都很能唱，不要看畫面的話...其實童話唱的也不差...，­但陳珂冰她整體的感覺就是比較有觀眾緣、明星樣吧，有時候在會唱­的人，沒有觀眾緣、機會也是沒用的‧‧，畢竟星光只是一個暫時的­小舞台，輸贏是在外面，但童話也是有很大的進步空間和淺力。

[yayaadel]

@pc750619 观众缘？可是Roger不那么认为哦。。仔细看看童话的脸，看她­眼睛，看她下巴，真的很像一个人-----Roger。所以那么­有Roger缘

[go371211]

特色很明顯

珂冰加油!!~

[shiang730422]

感覺童話很刻意有人推??該不會是某高層而之類的吧~哈哈哈!!

感覺很沒感覺...聽不完就切了!

我也覺得珂冰唱的好聽多了!!

[taka777chu]

我喜歡珂冰 討厭童話

[chermiiin2803]

dont know y...hate hate hate tong hua

[Dollbabyzz]

omg... if say smilin tong hua win...

but for english i think chen liao ping better thn tong hua...

taiwan english really got prob..

[hungrikanjors]

陳珂冰 … she's obviously so much better !!

i will support her to the fullest

[huntergonfreecss]

陳珂冰唱得很好阿!!

不要失望拉!!

真不知道為什麼評審會這樣評...

[mustup2002]

比童話好多了

[hildahuang]

大爱~~

[dannypanchiao]

陳珂冰唱得比童話讚!!!~加油~

[zone0614]

愛死陳珂冰．．！！！你唱歌感覺實在太自然喇．．！！

努力．．．支持你

[Rocklobsterport]

陳珂冰 星光六不就唱了好一陣子嗎?? 加油 這次唱久一點啦

[boys8120]

童話唱歌抄死板 而且好做作 一直裝可愛超噁

[yayaadel]

only 1 flaw---"with" ---wit . roger 搞的鬼

[yayaadel]

only 1 flaw---"with" ---wit

[saddam250]

童話不要裝可愛啦 不適合你

[cherrypinable]

看好陳珂冰.应该是前三名.

[linn1085]

不明白童话为什么分那么高〉。。 

[http1303cc]

童話唱的... 沒聽完就切掉了

陳科冰詮釋的好多了

給分整個怪

[shuipingwaitao]

伟忠帮本来要捧陈珂冰的，结果这届选手一个比一个厉害，囧了

[uunreal]

I actually like the feeling of the second girl's singing better. More layers and emotions. Would be perfect if she pronounced the 'with' better.. But that's not really the point...don't cry :)

[tamaggie0609]

童話明明就很軍歌....居然贏了

[0988yzk]

@tamaggie0609

贊成，陳珂冰唱得好多了，唉！有點不公平！

本人不看好童話的實力能進十強！

[kenhorng0709]

@tamaggie0609 赞同你说的话！感觉她很骄傲~

[dwsc1968]

I just dun understand the Lin guy, felt Pink sang better. just completely dun like the other girl's, (Story) singing. Kind of fake.

[leoshanbob]

WOW another MAlaysian contestant, carrie underwood alike KL-Malaysia support u