@zdpillow Actually, the etymology of the word "earth" shows that it was in use in the English language long before it was used to refer to our planet around 1400 A.D. Before that, it represented one of the fundamental elements - air, water, fire, and earth. The real question is how did these alternate native americans end up speaking English in the first place. It would have been mystery enough if they were found speaking Navahoe or Hopee.
It seems after their warp drive was fried, they could have called Starfleet to send out a repair ship or at least got a tow to a starbase. You would think Starfleet Command would have wondered what happened to them after two months.
beyond belief that they could mess up such a cool storyline so badly . . ..if they had bothered to get some real native americans it could have been great - that chief's daughter was on my last nerve from the get go and the medicine chief looked like a wise guy . . . they also wrote Shatner's role pitifully
to top it all, this season showed the approach of the cheesy seventies . Kirk's sideburns are atrocious and Scotty looks like he just came from the beauty parlor
@DEATHBYFLYINGCDS I pointed out to my daughter the token actual Native guy who only sat in the background in one scene while the white actors did all the work. Everything about this episode is so appallingly offensive all you can do is laugh hysterically. I love how they're made up of three tribes, none of which was represented. When we saw the longhouse with the tipis, we nearly fell out of our chairs laughing. Nothing says accuracy like the Lakotojibwaudenosaunee nation. ;)
@TorCoolGal "Mixture of Navajo, Mohican and Deleware", Spock said. I don't know how he could say that though because surely he knew, as I do, that those people were transplanted Generic-kee.
In this episode at 38:57 Spock and McCoy discuss The Preservers as an explanation of the proliferation of humanoid species throughout the galaxy, but on TNG they give an entirely different explanation about how a long dead race knew that they were doomed and seeded portions of the galaxy before their sun went nova.
Well...if Kerock was so smart, he'd just have the others go to the trees a few yards behind the obelisk where the wind isn't even blowing. Check it out around 37:55 and see how localized that mean old storm is. Y'gotta love those "special" FX!
Rock on Spock! You could be the lead vocalist of The Preservers. Kerock and his wife rocked til they dropped! Hey Spock, everyone must get stoned! ...with my mind on Miramanni & Miramanni on my mind! Oh man, I crack myself up!
I like the beginning "what are the odds a planet just like earth"? lol. That IS odd isn't it? And boy is it every lucky for production costs! Also, I find it intriguing how many alien civilizations speak English! I guess it IS the universal language!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i dislike spock because he treats humans like they are kindergarteners . and he acts like he knows everything and talks in stupid to humans because he thinks they dont understand "dis wok is owr planet, dis wok is de meteor"
27:00 - geesh Bones, don't be such a downer! At least Spock has the balls to keep trying! Besides he loves Kirk too much to just give up on him. He would NEVER do that!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Spock is such a Jackass to McCoy. That demonstration with the rocks was so unnecessary. "Here, puny brained man-child, let me used these pretty rocks to explain to you these basic principles."
Probably the best background music of any episode. Especially the final scene. The combination of the editing, insertion of the titles and the swelling of the music is a clinic on how all the elements combine to generate the desired emotional tone of the scene. My favorite scene of the entire series.
parallel earths, a.k.a.Hodgkin's Law of Parallel Planetary Development = using Paramount's stock sets and costumes to depict worlds. Hence so many planets with cowboys, indians, nazi's, gangsters, 20's garb, etc. Thats why the modern star treks tv shows had so many Holodeck episodes... especially voyager. Suddenly they are talking to Mark Twain or Galileo.. whatever they could dig up from the paramount stock wardrobe ...
poor spock. whenever he's forced into command, he can't do anything right in the eyes of mccoy. =( he tries his hardest, and bones just yells at him and makes him feel like crap.
...Since when can you do CPR without pinching the nose? Kirk pinches it like...once, then just holds the kids head. If you don't pinch the nose, the air just goes right out and never gets to the lungs. D:
@SkaarjSlayer Besides the fact that I'm an actor who knows CPR? Since it's a pretty common skill, someone could have at least given him a quick brush up. What he was doing was like shoddy resuscitative breathing...plus leg aerobicizing. :P
Miramani. My guess is when Kirk gave her the root he wasn't exacting going where no man had gone before. That broad looks like she's been around the block a few times.
Not that I am really complaining but I'm kinda mad he did have a wife and was going to have a child. It would just make Kirk more of a manwhore than normal...But I'm sad that she died trying to protect him from a stoning.
i love this episode... its sad... at end how his wife dies she was so pretty man and she like dies and stuff it just is :( 19:05 - 19:13 wat is that guitar rythem btw
lol! the part spock was explaining to mccoy about how the astriod will crash into the planet, with the rocks. i was expecting mccoy to say something like "i'm not a cave man spock!
From what I understand, violating the Prime Directive only constitutes interference with the natural progression of their culture, not saving their lives.
Is he gonna pump the kid's legs? I think he's gonna pump his legs! Come on, pump those legs! breathe... breathe... HE'S PUMPING THE LEGS!! YES! WEEEEE!!!
What's funny is in some episodes a starship is capable of destroying an entire planet effortlessly; but in this episode one asteroid is monumentally impossible to stop/alter course
What's more funny are the jackasses who get all technical/factual about this science fiction fantasy, and thus start to critique the Star Trek movie that came out this year, denoting "fictional facts". Fiction is fiction.
It's for fun, and what truth can be learned from it.
I just think it's funny that somehow its so surprising that a planet would evolve to have the same plants as earth, and yet it was perfectly acceptable that a planet's history could mirror earth (bread and circuses)... I love this show, but sometimes the consistency isn't fantastic...
There was an episode whre Kirk says "This planet is as close to paradise as any we've encountered," or something to the sort. I thought this was it, but apparently not.
I hate this episode just because of the fact that the writer would ASSUME that there is a duplicate culture the same as our native americain indians. BAD BAD BAD! Some episodes are good some are WAY BAD!
hey im just saying that with all his lovers out there in the universe Miramanee might not be the only one who was knocked up *cough David Marcus cough*
I watched star trek as a kid in the 60s and watching all the episodes again is a great treat. In this episode I noted that the primitive indians did develop elastic head bands - note when it is removed from the medicine man and placed on Kirk's head. It is one of the better episodes.
in the Khan movie Kirk fathered a kid, but it didn't seem he really loved that woman and bypassed marrying her. But when he met Reina the android, he fell hopelessly and recklessly in love. The only other time was here with Miramani. And this was the only time he actually married a woman. And even when he recovered his memory, he continued to love her and called her his wife. Also, Kirk could still see his friends Spock and Mcoy in his mind, even though he couldn't remember them.
Filming time is very expensive and they can't do retakes for minor things. It just made it more realistic. You would expect flies out in the wilderness.
Jeez. Speling on thi internit iz atroshus! People. Proper capitalization and punctuation are signs of higher intellect. Is it any wonder the aliens don't land on the White House lawn. Half of us can't even read let alone string a coherent, intelligent sentence together. Jeez!
@RandyWayneFricke or maybe higher intellect just realizes its a bunch of stupid rules that we don't need and are free to throw out . . . but if you'd prefer to grade everyone's papers, rather than just enjoy, we can send you to the principal's office
friggin 3 seasons...that's it. Sometimes that makes me so mad. This was such a cool show. Wished it could have gone on a bit longer like another 10-12 seasons :)
Bones gives it to Kirk now and then --- the most heated argument was on The Corbomite Maneuver over Kirk relieving the navigator
Most the time Bones messes with Spock regarding his feelings. The absolute worse example---I would call it blatant unprofessional conduct and Bones should have been charged was The Galileo Seven
The number of times they ALL have said and done things to each other they should be charged for is innumerable. That's the problem with being friends along with being crewmates.
On balance I prefer the episodes filmed outside, versus the inescapably murky interior sets (phony "outdoor" scenes with the styrofoam rocks, fake trees, arti. lighting, etc.) Clearly the location filming was centered in California -- same look as episodes of Bonanza, Little House on the Prarie, etc.
Ending of this eppy is especially sensitive and beautiful, bittersweet but not over the top. Lovely music, heartbreaking situation for Kirk. I found it quite upsetting when I was a wee lad.
Captain Kirk always gets the fines babes!
mrbrianmccarthy 1 year ago
When she puts her hand on her head, the only thing I could think was PEN-TA-TO-NIC SCALE!"
tiggersuitsme 1 year ago
This episode proves that Kirk really thinks himself a god.
Romancefantasy 1 year ago
That Indian chick is one fine mama. I didn't know they knew the art of an underwire bra.
LT1HILLINGHOE 1 year ago
"Pretend it's a seed!" Bugs Life
7:17
BunnyMasterMomiji 1 year ago
Miramanne states "I have a present for you, it may make you happy.." Kirk is like "Is it pink and warm with hair all over?"
RealityDefenseLeague 1 year ago
Comment removed
SethTurtle 1 year ago
Poor Scotty. It's like no one cares about the ship like he does.
Sandra0Argentium 1 year ago
I love Scotty at 24:36 - "My bear'ns, my poor bear'ns!" LOL
rvirzi 1 year ago
Am I the only one who notised the big mistake the girl maid at 36:24?
She said that the EARTH would start to shake!
That planit is not Earth.
zdpillow 1 year ago
@zdpillow Actually, the etymology of the word "earth" shows that it was in use in the English language long before it was used to refer to our planet around 1400 A.D. Before that, it represented one of the fundamental elements - air, water, fire, and earth. The real question is how did these alternate native americans end up speaking English in the first place. It would have been mystery enough if they were found speaking Navahoe or Hopee.
rvirzi 1 year ago
It seems after their warp drive was fried, they could have called Starfleet to send out a repair ship or at least got a tow to a starbase. You would think Starfleet Command would have wondered what happened to them after two months.
BigPoppaChump 1 year ago
best moment of the episode is spock's visual explanation of the asteroid's proximity to the planet. :D
tenshinokuragari 1 year ago 4
In real life McCoy would get punched in the face often.
He's lucky Spock never loses his cool.
charlesvan13 1 year ago 5
Road to El Dorado...the gods who bleed!
clpearson991 1 year ago 2
pitching a tent
Fritheby 1 year ago
34:24 my first impression was a giant sandal
Redchakra007 1 year ago 2
hahah 28:10 best part!!!!
andrewapplejacks 1 year ago 2
Instead of Kirk letting everyone thing he was a god, why couldn't he just teach everyone CPR? Selfish! lol.
BillMack27 1 year ago 6
kirk gets more pussy than most porn actors...
blimprue 1 year ago 5
beyond belief that they could mess up such a cool storyline so badly . . ..if they had bothered to get some real native americans it could have been great - that chief's daughter was on my last nerve from the get go and the medicine chief looked like a wise guy . . . they also wrote Shatner's role pitifully
to top it all, this season showed the approach of the cheesy seventies . Kirk's sideburns are atrocious and Scotty looks like he just came from the beauty parlor
controlledfolly11 1 year ago
Amazing, even these native american aliens are somehow caucasian.
DEATHBYFLYINGCDS 1 year ago
@DEATHBYFLYINGCDS I pointed out to my daughter the token actual Native guy who only sat in the background in one scene while the white actors did all the work. Everything about this episode is so appallingly offensive all you can do is laugh hysterically. I love how they're made up of three tribes, none of which was represented. When we saw the longhouse with the tipis, we nearly fell out of our chairs laughing. Nothing says accuracy like the Lakotojibwaudenosaunee nation. ;)
TorCoolGal 1 year ago
@TorCoolGal "Mixture of Navajo, Mohican and Deleware", Spock said. I don't know how he could say that though because surely he knew, as I do, that those people were transplanted Generic-kee.
Uyarasuk 1 year ago
@Uyarasuk All of whom had a great-great-grandmother who was a Generic-kee Princess. ;)
TorCoolGal 1 year ago
In this episode at 38:57 Spock and McCoy discuss The Preservers as an explanation of the proliferation of humanoid species throughout the galaxy, but on TNG they give an entirely different explanation about how a long dead race knew that they were doomed and seeded portions of the galaxy before their sun went nova.
MrRicardoSpears 1 year ago
These commercials can kiss my 'yaz!
moshfists 1 year ago
Well...if Kerock was so smart, he'd just have the others go to the trees a few yards behind the obelisk where the wind isn't even blowing. Check it out around 37:55 and see how localized that mean old storm is. Y'gotta love those "special" FX!
Rock on Spock! You could be the lead vocalist of The Preservers. Kerock and his wife rocked til they dropped! Hey Spock, everyone must get stoned! ...with my mind on Miramanni & Miramanni on my mind! Oh man, I crack myself up!
moshfists 1 year ago
"Bones" can put Spock's brain back into his head two days after it was removed but he can't save a girl who got hit by a rock in the stomach?.
kristov29 1 year ago
I like the beginning "what are the odds a planet just like earth"? lol. That IS odd isn't it? And boy is it every lucky for production costs! Also, I find it intriguing how many alien civilizations speak English! I guess it IS the universal language!
PabloPena108 1 year ago 2
Crcry :( Kirk's baby died too :(
acescouter1992 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i dislike spock because he treats humans like they are kindergarteners . and he acts like he knows everything and talks in stupid to humans because he thinks they dont understand "dis wok is owr planet, dis wok is de meteor"
captainspock1000 1 year ago
@captainspock1000 you're forgetting one thing . . . humans do act like kindergartners - Spock has to work with what he's got
controlledfolly11 1 year ago
31:23 "My prescription is rest, do I have to call the security guards?"
*Spock raises his eyebrow and walks to his bed.*
*McCoy leaves*
*Spock gets up*
Really Bones, I can't believe you fell for that one.
LOL
otdtyh 1 year ago 5
everytime Spock is in command Dr Macoy always gives him a hard time. He is so annoying
emeraldz07 1 year ago
this one brought a tear to my eye :(
MTHDCS 1 year ago
27:00 - geesh Bones, don't be such a downer! At least Spock has the balls to keep trying! Besides he loves Kirk too much to just give up on him. He would NEVER do that!
Voileen 1 year ago
lol at 28:15
Sometimes you just need a hug. lol
niraha 1 year ago
@niraha LOL. And when no one is willing, hug yourself!
otdtyh 1 year ago
Are you kidding me right now?! What the hell kind of ending was that?!
Ugh. Poor Kirk :(
MiseryBusiness99 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Spock is such a Jackass to McCoy. That demonstration with the rocks was so unnecessary. "Here, puny brained man-child, let me used these pretty rocks to explain to you these basic principles."
serfky01 1 year ago
I'm sure it was written into the script to accommodate the puny brained viwers
avidmoviefan 1 year ago
I love Spock's lecture.
wattlemybird 1 year ago 11
Probably the best background music of any episode. Especially the final scene. The combination of the editing, insertion of the titles and the swelling of the music is a clinic on how all the elements combine to generate the desired emotional tone of the scene. My favorite scene of the entire series.
afamreport 2 years ago 6
"I bare your child"
We all knew Jim would hear that some day while his landing party was researching on a planet.
kikioshia 2 years ago 40
yeah, but the grin on his face is priceless :)
Zaz7y 1 year ago 7
to kikioshia:
Congrats - that is probably one of the funniest comments ever on this site
prreynolds 1 year ago
28:09 cracked my ass up!
Lamangelow 2 years ago 2
LOL @ 15:13. Nice badge Kirk.
EliteSonic 2 years ago
24:33
Poor Scotty! Spock is pushing his lovely lady too far!
TheSarahsaurusRex 2 years ago 7
That was the wierdest version of CPR I've ever seen, Kirk!
TheSarahsaurusRex 2 years ago 12
or you could deflect the asteroid first, and THEN investigate the planet...
nerad137 2 years ago 6
33:32 LOL bug lands on his face:)
TennyConductor 2 years ago 5
parallel earths, a.k.a.Hodgkin's Law of Parallel Planetary Development = using Paramount's stock sets and costumes to depict worlds. Hence so many planets with cowboys, indians, nazi's, gangsters, 20's garb, etc. Thats why the modern star treks tv shows had so many Holodeck episodes... especially voyager. Suddenly they are talking to Mark Twain or Galileo.. whatever they could dig up from the paramount stock wardrobe ...
wanageeska 2 years ago
@wanageeska
Nazis and gangsters were due to contaminationi
KarateKidX 1 year ago
poor spock. whenever he's forced into command, he can't do anything right in the eyes of mccoy. =( he tries his hardest, and bones just yells at him and makes him feel like crap.
ToWhenTFor 2 years ago 27
This has been flagged as spam show
Speaking of crap.. GRUNT fart-plop... plop... GRUNT plop plop plop.. GRUNT plop FART plop....
AH!!!!
Hmm.. detecting gaseous anomaly.. and butt-eroids!
wanageeska 2 years ago
wtf?? okay then!! lol.
ToWhenTFor 2 years ago 2
@ToWhenTFor Yeah, McCoy is kindof a dick.
jimmyboo121 1 year ago
@ToWhenTFor That's because Bones is an old-fashioned racist bastard.
Novelboy2112 1 year ago
@ToWhenTFor but he doesn't feel
billyjoejimbob75 1 year ago
@ToWhenTFor Bones is rather ciritical of him.
paul7494 1 year ago
CPR isn't just blowing into the mouth. lol And what was he doing with his legs?
TearJerker2011 2 years ago
@TearJerker2011 seriously. He would've killed the boy had he done that CPR much longer. :)
valandilcamcacil 2 years ago 4
...Since when can you do CPR without pinching the nose? Kirk pinches it like...once, then just holds the kids head. If you don't pinch the nose, the air just goes right out and never gets to the lungs. D:
SinisterlySweet 2 years ago 4
Probably because he couldn't ACTUALLY give CPR since that kid's just an actor.
SkaarjSlayer 2 years ago 5
@SkaarjSlayer Besides the fact that I'm an actor who knows CPR? Since it's a pretty common skill, someone could have at least given him a quick brush up. What he was doing was like shoddy resuscitative breathing...plus leg aerobicizing. :P
SinisterlySweet 2 years ago
and this show is like from the late 60s and i dont think they had all the med. knolage and tec. we have to day
hairball3796 2 years ago 2
@hairball3796 Developed in 1960, went public in '62. It might have been 50 years ago, but it wasn't the stone age.
SinisterlySweet 2 years ago
or perhaps giving a breathing person CPR would be more than it's worth. No need to put the kid in pain for the sake of a scene.
arelimoon29 2 years ago
@hairball3796 even still, pumping the legs doesn't do anything lol
valandilcamcacil 2 years ago
@SkaarjSlayer or he didn't know how to give cpr the correct way :)
valandilcamcacil 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the fuck; I thought this was social analysis documentary.
but its star trek?
screw you youtube!
pillsburydoughboy47 2 years ago
Those Native Americans? Not really
Mizvictor07 2 years ago
Miramani. My guess is when Kirk gave her the root he wasn't exacting going where no man had gone before. That broad looks like she's been around the block a few times.
432F01 2 years ago
Not that I am really complaining but I'm kinda mad he did have a wife and was going to have a child. It would just make Kirk more of a manwhore than normal...But I'm sad that she died trying to protect him from a stoning.
arelimoon29 2 years ago 2
haha a fly landed on his head 33:34
gfyt 2 years ago 2
I wish the hell they would get some bigger relays, more dilithium crystals stronger shields and lasers, more powerful photon torpedoes.
It would help if McCoy would shut up.
breezebro 2 years ago 10
Why McCoy was funny but this isn't his kind of episode you can see he's not going to be funny.
Tehssnake01 2 years ago 3
Man, thats sad. Comon Bones, a meager stoning-related internal injuries? Dont be such a quack :)
polysmart 2 years ago 4
i love this episode... its sad... at end how his wife dies she was so pretty man and she like dies and stuff it just is :( 19:05 - 19:13 wat is that guitar rythem btw
il0veg0dbaby 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I am fuckin Kirok. Is this what happens when your fuckin face gets shocked? One of the most jacked up episodes I ever seen. I am Kirok ....Shit.
IANBOT2 2 years ago
7:50-7:55 XD
boxnerd 2 years ago
lol! the part spock was explaining to mccoy about how the astriod will crash into the planet, with the rocks. i was expecting mccoy to say something like "i'm not a cave man spock!
i understand you!"
McCoYiSaWsOmE101 2 years ago
Wouldn't saving a planet from utter anihilation be against the prime directive?
slayerowns666 2 years ago 2
From what I understand, violating the Prime Directive only constitutes interference with the natural progression of their culture, not saving their lives.
GregoriusTheBrown 2 years ago
@slayerowns666 doesnt kirk almost always interfere anyway?
Yoshi741852 1 year ago
Is he gonna pump the kid's legs? I think he's gonna pump his legs! Come on, pump those legs! breathe... breathe... HE'S PUMPING THE LEGS!! YES! WEEEEE!!!
JacopoDiotallevi 2 years ago 6
What's funny is in some episodes a starship is capable of destroying an entire planet effortlessly; but in this episode one asteroid is monumentally impossible to stop/alter course
What's more funny are the jackasses who get all technical/factual about this science fiction fantasy, and thus start to critique the Star Trek movie that came out this year, denoting "fictional facts". Fiction is fiction.
It's for fun, and what truth can be learned from it.
Trying to do more with it is truly sick.
earp1673 2 years ago 5
its just a tv show,get over it like the rest below.
neilzep 2 years ago
how would there be a Soix teppee and a Iraqoise long ouse? Awnsers?
Totalwar476 2 years ago
its not earth. those arent Soix or Iraqoise
slayerowns666 2 years ago
I just think it's funny that somehow its so surprising that a planet would evolve to have the same plants as earth, and yet it was perfectly acceptable that a planet's history could mirror earth (bread and circuses)... I love this show, but sometimes the consistency isn't fantastic...
twhis 2 years ago
Why does everyone in the frickin' galaxy speak English?
b0nj0urm0nde 2 years ago 4
Because the show would be kind of lame if they couldn't communicate with anybody they met.
Ninquelote 2 years ago 7
why didnt they knock out the comet then go back to take a look?
ramenguy1 2 years ago
There was an episode whre Kirk says "This planet is as close to paradise as any we've encountered," or something to the sort. I thought this was it, but apparently not.
Anyone???
SothManigan 2 years ago
Shore Leave?
crazycoolone 2 years ago
Yeah, he says something pretty close, that's probably what I'm thinking of.
Thanks!
SothManigan 2 years ago
He also says something like that in "The Apple".
GregoriusTheBrown 2 years ago
I hate this episode just because of the fact that the writer would ASSUME that there is a duplicate culture the same as our native americain indians. BAD BAD BAD! Some episodes are good some are WAY BAD!
finnboy1967 2 years ago
well, this was just one of the many writers of the show. 3rd season also wasnt the best of seasons...
arelimoon29 2 years ago
You missed the part when it was explained that they were taken from Earth to preserve their race
logsliderrjh 2 years ago 7
NinjaPenguinRobot
I AGREE WITH WHAT YOU"RE SAYING BUT
IT WAS SAD TO SEE MIRAMANEE KILLED BY HER VERY TRIBE "STONED TO DEATH" !!
SHE WAS PREGNANT AND CARRYING CAPTAIN KIRK'S (KIROK'S) CHILD !!
IN THE EPISODE SHE WAS MARRIED TO
CAPTAIN KIRK (KIROK) !!
UNLIKE DR. CAROL MARCUS WHO WAS NEVER IN THE ORIGINAL SERIES AND
WAS NEVER MARRIED TO THE CAPTAIN !!
DAVID MARCUS WAS JUST A LOVE CHILD !!
MRJAVIER196619862009 2 years ago
@MRJAVIER196619862009 HARDLY WORTH YELLING ABOUT!!
controlledfolly11 1 year ago
I love how often Spock says the odds are against finding a planet parallel to earth... yet they are always coming across one that is!
xxbeautybabesxx 2 years ago 5
I think this episode was supposed to reconcile that inconsistency by the introduction of the "Preservers".
GregoriusTheBrown 2 years ago
AND I WILL LOVE YOU MIRAMANEE ALWAYS !!
MRJAVIER196619862009 2 years ago
NinjaPenguinRobot
IN THIS PARTICULAR EPISODE KIROK (KIRK)
WAS MARRIED TO MIRAMANEE !!
MRJAVIER196619862009 2 years ago
hey im just saying that with all his lovers out there in the universe Miramanee might not be the only one who was knocked up *cough David Marcus cough*
NinjaPenguinRobot 2 years ago
At 7:55... Spock keeps the "asteroid" moving towards the "planet" as McCoy considers. FRICKIN HILARIOUS!
Spyre 2 years ago 4
I noticed that to. It was like he was daring McCoy to disagree.
GregoriusTheBrown 2 years ago
Bill Shatner dedication in great new bio (All About Jeffrey Hunter) at amazon!
Bestmanme08 2 years ago
This episode taught me something...
Somebody has got to take kirk to the Maury Povich show, just imagine how many space women need to give this guy a paternity test
NinjaPenguinRobot 2 years ago 7
It is unlikely that any group would live that close to the water due to adverse weather, flooding and insects.
andrewucc 2 years ago 2
If "Kirok" didn't have amnesia he'd remember he only falls for blondes....
there's extra tension between Spock & Bones whenever Kirk's not around
ThePiscean60 2 years ago 3
LOL
golden24680 2 years ago
kirks indian chick was SOOOOOO hot. what a babe....
ixfxi 2 years ago
@ixfxi I AGREE !!
MRJAVIER196619862009 1 year ago
BEHOLD A GOD WHO BLEEDS!
neneshubby 2 years ago
Ok, not a bad episode, but it was so so so so creepy when he revived the boy. I was a bit squicked. lol X]
HappyGirl01234567890 2 years ago 2
F*** the camercals
sjfriel 2 years ago 3
well it is far cheaper to watch 15 seconds of ads then pay for the actual eposides.
faeryfirefly 2 years ago
"I've always wondered why there were so many humanoids scattered through the galaxy."
Yeah, me too, Bones. It's called not enough funds from the network to procure proper prosthetics and make-up for your aliens. ^_^
HellsOnlyBelle 2 years ago 5
It's only offensive if you expect a late 60's TV show to have anything but a horrible representation of native people.
But hey, this *is* another planet!
hexalm 2 years ago 3
In what way is this a horrible representation of native americans?
StewieSwan 2 years ago
I watched star trek as a kid in the 60s and watching all the episodes again is a great treat. In this episode I noted that the primitive indians did develop elastic head bands - note when it is removed from the medicine man and placed on Kirk's head. It is one of the better episodes.
Thatpup16 2 years ago
love the guitar in this one! AWESOME!
knotbox 2 years ago 2
19:05 - 19:13 wat is that rythem i love it too
il0veg0dbaby 2 years ago
in the Khan movie Kirk fathered a kid, but it didn't seem he really loved that woman and bypassed marrying her. But when he met Reina the android, he fell hopelessly and recklessly in love. The only other time was here with Miramani. And this was the only time he actually married a woman. And even when he recovered his memory, he continued to love her and called her his wife. Also, Kirk could still see his friends Spock and Mcoy in his mind, even though he couldn't remember them.
eddtoro 2 years ago
I love this episode. Such a good story!
<3
Okamidachisan 2 years ago
too bad about the fly on kirk's face while they are getting all emotional. wonder if they did a few retakes to no avail?
seyretvision 2 years ago
Filming time is very expensive and they can't do retakes for minor things. It just made it more realistic. You would expect flies out in the wilderness.
magicianspirit 2 years ago
Jeez. Speling on thi internit iz atroshus! People. Proper capitalization and punctuation are signs of higher intellect. Is it any wonder the aliens don't land on the White House lawn. Half of us can't even read let alone string a coherent, intelligent sentence together. Jeez!
RandyWayneFricke 2 years ago 9
@RandyWayneFricke or maybe higher intellect just realizes its a bunch of stupid rules that we don't need and are free to throw out . . . but if you'd prefer to grade everyone's papers, rather than just enjoy, we can send you to the principal's office
controlledfolly11 1 year ago
Two episodes ago Bones reinstalled a friggin brain, now he can't fix some internal bleeding?
nondescript100 2 years ago 13
Hey, McCoy WAS under alien influence, if you recall.
Okamidachisan 2 years ago
I hate this episode... its sooo sad!!!!
CinciVulcan 2 years ago
friggin 3 seasons...that's it. Sometimes that makes me so mad. This was such a cool show. Wished it could have gone on a bit longer like another 10-12 seasons :)
shilack2 2 years ago 6
Yeah...
RJLupinRox 2 years ago
Well, had the show continued, the movies would have likely never been made. I, for one, think The Wrath of Kahn was worth the show's cancellation.
GregoriusTheBrown 2 years ago
two months? they couldnt find another star ship to go there in two months?
johnmonk66 2 years ago 3
The single saddest, most tragic ending of any show or movie ever made
nakedBison69 2 years ago 2
i know.. i got sad :(
il0veg0dbaby 2 years ago
Spock is the best in this episode!!
"Another calculated risk, doctor." HAHA you tell him Spock. Bones' got some nerve! Doesnt he know that Spock knows what he is doing????
ericsbuds 2 years ago 4
You leave my Bones alone! *cuddles him*
beautifulpassion 2 years ago 3
NO he is my Bones! *cuddles him more*
DarqRemake 2 years ago
MIIIIIINE! *snatches him back and squeezes*
beautifulpassion 2 years ago
noooo! give me my Bones! *snatches him from you and huggles him*
DarqRemake 2 years ago
We share teh McCoy? *puppydog eyes*
beautifulpassion 2 years ago
what does McCoy say? *listens to him* Okay deal ^-^
Rectroq 2 years ago
yayyyyy! ^_^
beautifulpassion 2 years ago
15:20 looks like John Lovitz....
CrashLanden 2 years ago
It bugs the heck out of me how the doctor always questions Spock's comands but never Kirks.
soz94 2 years ago 3
Bones gives it to Kirk now and then --- the most heated argument was on The Corbomite Maneuver over Kirk relieving the navigator
Most the time Bones messes with Spock regarding his feelings. The absolute worse example---I would call it blatant unprofessional conduct and Bones should have been charged was The Galileo Seven
prreynolds 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
The number of times they ALL have said and done things to each other they should be charged for is innumerable. That's the problem with being friends along with being crewmates.
beautifulpassion 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It's a 'mutual antagonism'. Also known as being 'frenenemies.' Spock does the same to McCoy.
beautifulpassion 2 years ago
you might be right!
ericsbuds 2 years ago
@beautifulpassion it happens when Kirk is in danger because they both love him and are afraid they are going to lose him
controlledfolly11 1 year ago
what is the episode with abe lincoln? please tell me by sending me a message please tell me
TheGreatPolkaWarrior 2 years ago
The Savage Curtain
ddenuci 2 years ago
The Savage Curtain
Season 3 Episode 22
71259mark 2 years ago
Kirk's sideburns make him look like elvis.
dude28901 2 years ago 5
Why couldn't they leave someone behind to search for Kirk even if they had to warp out of there?
SteveDurnin 2 years ago 8
Yeah...cause the red shirts are so devoted to Kirk that they'd willingly sign on for an open ended landing party. Right.
RodneyAHampton 2 years ago
Another beautiful actress Sabrina Scharf as Miramanee! Wow what a stricking woman!
And honestly I seem to remember many stunningly beautiful female actresses appearing in Star Trek during it's run!
RJupiter2 2 years ago
Geez, McCoy in the beginning freaks me out.
"Is that honeysuckle I smell?"
You're a doctor, not a botanist!
TurdFergeson5512 2 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
honeysuckle is a very unique and easily determined scent. Everyone has said something like this about a famaliar and unique scent. -_-
beautifulpassion 2 years ago
How dare you! honeysuckle DOES have a unique smell like beautifulpassion said.
DarqRemake 2 years ago
^_^ Thankies, Darq
beautifulpassion 2 years ago
Comment removed
TurdFergeson5512 2 years ago
but we all luv Bones!
TurdFergeson5512 2 years ago
On balance I prefer the episodes filmed outside, versus the inescapably murky interior sets (phony "outdoor" scenes with the styrofoam rocks, fake trees, arti. lighting, etc.) Clearly the location filming was centered in California -- same look as episodes of Bonanza, Little House on the Prarie, etc.
Ending of this eppy is especially sensitive and beautiful, bittersweet but not over the top. Lovely music, heartbreaking situation for Kirk. I found it quite upsetting when I was a wee lad.
sjplwc 2 years ago
haha i love how spock is moves the rock closer in the scenario as mccoy is thinking.
audreyisrad 2 years ago 6
"is moves the rock closer"??? where do you people get your sense of the english launguage?
lavaxtris1 2 years ago
That not how you do CPR...
loner1878 2 years ago 3