The 2nd chorus as you call it has a key change. what you are referring to are the accidentals leading up to it. They did a great job, and I don't really like how you decide that you know what you are taking about. also, do you know what accellerando means? It's not something you can be...it is something that you do.
It's possible that you are playing a different arrangement. There are many for different levels. I am playing this in school as well, only difference is that it's the original (by Holst, arranged by Holst). It's very similar to this one. To those in the vid--well done!
It is more than likely a different arrangement, as the original has a need for a fairly uncommon orchestra, a symphony orchestra would need a rearrangement let alone a school band.
It's amazing what you find, abd James Curnow has done an arrangement as well. I played that in Catterick (a forlorn place in Yorkshire UK) in 1970! It was the Duthoit arrangement (out of print now).
This song is so...so...BIG and full. Awesome. I love it. I play 1st cello at my school and we are performing this at some comp next week! I can't wait!
I wish my band teacher would give my school's wind symphony hard music like this. We can handle it. He doesn't seem to realize that we can rise to the occasion; he just needs to raise the bar.
Yea gl459 and if you would have really known about music, you would know that he wrote the planets in 1917 and that lincolnshire posy was written in 1932. Learn something before you hate on it.
lol were playing this now, in my schools concert band (Senior Band) i play bass, we play it flawless and weve only been playing it for a couple of weeks, We just need harder peices -.-. anyways its still sick.
your middle school is playing lincolnshire posy? wow, i'm sure that no middle school is good enough to play that. The parts are so difficult to play well, rarely do even high school bands play it well.
mm now that you mention it, you're right :) my middle school wind ens is gonna play nitro this week <3. :0 omg this is colburn???? I might try out for teh orchestra XD;;;
gl459, you have the gawl to compare Granger to Holst. Two totally different composers, both respected in their own genre of music. But, seriously Gustav Holst "The Planets" is an all-time masterpiece! PERIOD.
Good brass!! Sometimes, the brass makes or breaks the piece, especially in a Wind Ensemble. Great work!
kewljunk82 3 years ago
i love this song we were going to do it in the M.A.M.S. concert next year this is my favorite song
daisydo95 3 years ago
Awesome piece. Play French Horn. Sounds much better with out the strings along with it.
DarkKnight6464 3 years ago
Yeah what he said!!!!!
DarkKnight6464 3 years ago
I want to correct what he said. He means that the piece sounds much better without the strings and that he plays the French Horn.
DarkKnight6464 3 years ago
I play trumpet in my band, we only play the friggin chorale
oxfordwang1 3 years ago 7
us too
pianoclarinet89 3 years ago
same here
godblesskentucky 3 years ago
slightly out of key in the 2nd chorus. tempo little accellerando in some places but overall a very good effort. keep up the good playing. love.
[shit i love this bit ^^]
ferrari2112 3 years ago
Are qualified to make that judgment about what is probably a professional or college band?
DarkKnight6464 3 years ago
The 2nd chorus as you call it has a key change. what you are referring to are the accidentals leading up to it. They did a great job, and I don't really like how you decide that you know what you are taking about. also, do you know what accellerando means? It's not something you can be...it is something that you do.
JoeAlMun 3 years ago
this is my skating solo music:)
HauntedHearts 4 years ago
But, I don't know why, this one sounds completely different from the one my school band plays. Wtf.
goodcharlottefann 4 years ago 3
It's possible that you are playing a different arrangement. There are many for different levels. I am playing this in school as well, only difference is that it's the original (by Holst, arranged by Holst). It's very similar to this one. To those in the vid--well done!
santefepony 3 years ago
It is more than likely a different arrangement, as the original has a need for a fairly uncommon orchestra, a symphony orchestra would need a rearrangement let alone a school band.
nerdcunt69 3 years ago
dude my shcool is playing it too it sounds nothing like this...
EmilyxthexWise 3 years ago
Is it that it sounds better, worse, or just all together different?
DarkKnight6464 3 years ago
I play tenor sax in my school's band.
We're learning this, and we have 27 people in our class.
I just LOVE IT. I almost tear up when I play it. No rly.
goodcharlottefann 4 years ago 2
they're good but the video and hence sound quality isn't thee-makes the band sound bad...
loho174 4 years ago
5 friends, and myself are playing this for an ec assignment in band this year. a tuba, melophone, baritone, Trumbone, and two trumpets
lnspttmn 4 years ago
playing on clarinet for this it so full bodied too
lshmel 4 years ago
im practicing a sax quartet arrangement for this, its really cool.
boringdude23 4 years ago
oh boy !
u have a sax quartet for this? i am so very interested! dyu have the references? thanx
jesuska 4 years ago
a sax quartet, huh? May you tell me where I can get this sax quartet? I would like to play it.
saxnumber1 3 years ago
There is a sax quartet at MCHS (Morgan County High School).
DarkKnight6464 3 years ago
there's a sax quartet on this, or am i being stupid?
bigw2012 3 years ago
It's amazing what you find, abd James Curnow has done an arrangement as well. I played that in Catterick (a forlorn place in Yorkshire UK) in 1970! It was the Duthoit arrangement (out of print now).
Dorm2003 4 years ago
This song is so...so...BIG and full. Awesome. I love it. I play 1st cello at my school and we are performing this at some comp next week! I can't wait!
aew1324657 4 years ago
I wish my band teacher would give my school's wind symphony hard music like this. We can handle it. He doesn't seem to realize that we can rise to the occasion; he just needs to raise the bar.
FungusToes 4 years ago
Beautiful... I wish I'd been there to hear it live
prana85 4 years ago 3
Yea gl459 and if you would have really known about music, you would know that he wrote the planets in 1917 and that lincolnshire posy was written in 1932. Learn something before you hate on it.
mrbenjiii 4 years ago
I love playing jupiter. Also i love granada!! ta tetetetetetete ta ta
alisongal123 4 years ago
I got to play this song as well as Mars with my high school band. They're so much fun to play!
allyjackd 4 years ago
the planet stands out too much. anyway. i like this song.
dyloner 4 years ago
By Jove! I love the grand fullness and large swells, that represent the planet so well.
About 2:15 reminds me of the Great Red Spot and in contrast to its enormity, its tiny, tiny rings.
Anarchemitis 4 years ago
This, by far, is one of my favorite pieces...
paciv20 4 years ago
lol were playing this now, in my schools concert band (Senior Band) i play bass, we play it flawless and weve only been playing it for a couple of weeks, We just need harder peices -.-. anyways its still sick.
hardfiction89 4 years ago
im plaeing at about a few month later as a gurl of bass clarinet player haha
noendingpain 4 years ago
my middle school just played this last week at their spring concert.
derekdahmen14 4 years ago
lucky!! our junior band could only play the other easier one -.-
-flute player
TwinkleLemonGirl 4 years ago
I wish our band would play something that hard. It's so stupid! I love this song, but our band can't handle it. Eghad.
cryingsoumi 4 years ago
your middle school is playing lincolnshire posy? wow, i'm sure that no middle school is good enough to play that. The parts are so difficult to play well, rarely do even high school bands play it well.
Chynk4Life 4 years ago
we played this is 7th grade. Awesome!
kari05 4 years ago
nice except for the begining
then again, that part is hell to play
dinhd101 4 years ago
omg very good job with that. i love he song. you had a few issues but i mean it was outstanding!!!!
darkmagicboi 4 years ago
i never noticed but the beginning of Jupiter and Nitro by Ticheli sound very alike
amartinez1337 4 years ago
mm now that you mention it, you're right :) my middle school wind ens is gonna play nitro this week <3. :0 omg this is colburn???? I might try out for teh orchestra XD;;;
MiyokoxClarinetti 4 years ago
we've only played from about 4:00 - 5:00, didn't know it was longer. i love that sound, though
lana303 4 years ago
Yeah. In middle school I played the middle section, which is beautiful in itself, but not quite up with the entire thing.
colossus999 4 years ago
Junior high band, and were playing it. <3 Trombones
pfff.. WHO NEEDS strings
Azerothian 4 years ago
Our middle school band is playing Lincolnshire Posy!! Trombone also.
tromboneteen13 4 years ago
thats what you call watered down lincolnshire posy
gl459 4 years ago
gl459, you have the gawl to compare Granger to Holst. Two totally different composers, both respected in their own genre of music. But, seriously Gustav Holst "The Planets" is an all-time masterpiece! PERIOD.
seecritagent 4 years ago
I think he was responding to another person's comment on Lincolnshire Posy. I don't think he saw any comparison between the pieces.
colossus999 4 years ago
lol. i really like this song. my middle school played it for festival a couple months ago.
jayat27 4 years ago
i love the planets. my school band is gonna play it in like 26 days. YAY!!!!
jayat27 4 years ago
the whole thing? damn that will be one amazing concert if your good
eastbayray1969 4 years ago
My Senior Concert Band is playing this!
Uggghh. the clarinet part is really boring to play. :(
This one it really long. Ours is like five minutes.
merrylegz92 5 years ago
what arrangement of the piece are you playing? The clarinets take on the Violin part from the Orchestral composition, which is not boring at all.
JoeAlMun 3 years ago
omg i love the planets its one of my favorite pieces
MtnManTromboner 5 years ago
love this tune
jaykay72001 5 years ago
Sounds better in full symphony, and live of course. still, a great arrangment
bonviea 5 years ago
very well arranged without strings...sounds very good
dibeas 5 years ago
six minutes in, the high woodwinds sound incredible!! Congrats on a great gig.!
leadtrumpetgirl 5 years ago
I just played this yesterday!
AznHylite 5 years ago
My band has just started on this song (Junior High) and we've only learned the music approximately between 4:00 and 5:00.
^_^ Awesome job, I love it.
elfroxx 5 years ago
u must be playing chorale from jupiter....the most beautiful part of the song
dibeas 5 years ago
lol same here too learn the same i play the flute!
totallyjoey 4 years ago