@mademan4life Shit, you responded to a comment from 2 years ago...and he made smash hit singles with D12 aswell as making his solo studio album and he was loved by all on the hip hop scene.
em is an awesome rapper because he white raps lol he doesnt have that black guy rapper voice hes got the white guy rapper voice its cooler imo and hes just plain good
'andipitesti' i wasnt there so how is your comment relevent you stupid retard go slit your wrist vertically in a dark room. whilst crying over your sad pathetic life you worthless piece of shit.
yes, you weren`t there. but when i go somewhere(for example at a concert) you are part of the crowd! so stop swearing the crowd bastard, use oyur little brain before saying smthing! moron head
LISTEN, i didnt read any of 'ur' comments, eminem is the GREATEST rapper eva, em is funny,real,honest, and the best EVER to put any ryme 2gether, slim is a explosion of lyrical genius, i met EM ...i won FANatic on mtv im english, em sed i was cool!,,,,, can you say that......................
tupac was over rated. the only reason he gets so much credit is because of his death. was the first death of a really famous rapper, next to eazy e. the world was shocked, and so he was remembered as legend. not saying he wasnt great, but just a little over hyped
Eminem is the best rapper ever thats my tought...I think 2pac is litlle overrated because his dead, I don"t say tupac is bad just he is behind shady!!!
I & everyvody!!!We respect R.I.P. Proof is motherfucker raper of Detroit he was motherfucker very great raper and i say if you know D12 Make´s motherfuckaa noice this!!!Proof Forever!!!
I do agree with some of you proof does ruin it cause it aint the orginal but he is there to get the crowed pumped and to let the lead rapper (eminem) take a breath with out missin a word
Hehe, u dont know who that is? It's proof, died some months ago. He was the best rapper in D12. But yeah, I think when he is/was on stage with eminem, he ruins the performance. It isn't the original rap, and it is annoying.
you are kidding right? WHO'S THE BLACK GUY?! it's Proof... Got killed in the fall of 2006. Got shot in the head, after he shot one in the head.. he was eminem's best friend.. they battled together in the "hip-hop shop" in detroit back in the day.. damn man.. hwo dosnt know Proof?
eminem is a jumped up little prick that can't rap too save his life. in my day he would be shot! cunt
MyJagdpanther 3 weeks ago
@MyJagdpanther ur a cunt, u lil dumb son of a bich, go fuck u momma
AnDyLoVeEm 2 weeks ago
proofs got a cool voice
abhouston1 1 month ago 2
eminem is shit hot (good for the yanks) but this if shit live
1985scotland 5 months ago
That black guy ruins it.
Grantofglyn 7 months ago
@Grantofglyn stfu u fucking retard! look what JTRD12SHADY said - that certainly applies to this case u fucking retarded fag...
i might be over reacting but jeez.... thats Proof - RIP - SO DO NOT DISRESPECT
mrdanish 6 months ago
@mrdanish I don't care, he does ruin it "RETARD". He's all in his face when Eminem is trying to rap, so please, fuck you.
Grantofglyn 6 months ago
Comment removed
Takashisensei1 7 months ago
this is from 01 or 2
Icelandicpride 8 months ago
this isnt from 2007. remember proof <3 rip. was killed in 2006, this says 2007, hows that?
pn1390 9 months ago
@pn1390 look at the dj,
its dj head its this from 01 0r 02
Icelandicpride 8 months ago
This was only a month and 4 days after he got arrested for holding a gun to John Guerra for kissing his ex Kim. He must have been on probation
SuperChamona 9 months ago
When rap was new to the main consumer market...I have so many memories of arguments about how he sucked compared to mainstream pop groups.
DresdenStarwing 10 months ago
I miss Proof so fucking bad.
pedrinfodin 1 year ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
@pedrinfodin No you don't, you only care about him because he's dead, you fucking hypocrite.
flyingpowerlogitech 7 months ago
justin bieber log in 4 times and thumbed down that
grzesi0pl 1 year ago
@grzesi0pl Actually, Justin Bieber it's an eminem fan, though, so that doesn't make any sense :)
Shady88Italy 1 year ago
i love eminem♥
sunny85905 1 year ago 2
i dun understand why that other man is there wit him in evry of his live performances....
rajatfanforever 1 year ago
@rajatfanforever because proof is em's hype man.
SLloydmusic1 1 year ago 2
@rajatfanforever Are you fucking serious?
pedrinfodin 1 year ago
A lyrical genious.
t5239857289578947594 1 year ago
i hate dis fuckin song i prefer kill u
nat12xx 1 year ago
..er yeah 'will the real Slim Shady please stand up!'....
WhenUgonnaGetAjob 1 year ago
eminem rules!!!!!!
kornvayne25 1 year ago
SLIM SHADY very nice.......respect from malaga spain distrit 29011
extraviao011 1 year ago
this one summer befor best Up in smoke tour :)
darkoaerodrom 1 year ago
He didn't even need studio equipment back then.
Ricearoni80 2 years ago 2
This did hit Number One did'nt it, why does it say 77 at the start - 77 what the fuck - no way !!!!!
Daylight2k9 2 years ago
proof eminems best frend died cos he shot sum 1 in the hed tht dikhed got what was coming
greekgooner9456789 2 years ago
stfu faggot
SteelieremiX 2 years ago
1:44 best part
wendz0r 2 years ago
if you go onto big proofs wikipedia then go to death it says 3 head 3 chest and he was at a pool game he shot someone and then his cousin shot him
jammyjammy1997 2 years ago
He got shot once in the head 2 times in the chest.
Konyak0 2 years ago
Wikipedia... wow - What a source, man!!
fjawnt1337 2 years ago
rip proof
didnt he get shot i the head
jammyjammy1997 2 years ago
no he got sho 3 time in the chest
53reichfan 2 years ago
without proof there wouldnt be eminem
so shut up and show some respect for proof
r.i.p proof we miss you
hybridbennoda 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wats the point of having that black guy in the orange up there??? he's pointless
mademan4life 2 years ago
STFU man that's Proof (R.I.P) Eminem best friend since high school, fuckin idiot.
JTRD12shady 2 years ago 25
@JTRD12shady so what! was he an established rapper?no? did he make any smash hits single? no,
mademan4life 6 months ago
@mademan4life Shit, you responded to a comment from 2 years ago...and he made smash hit singles with D12 aswell as making his solo studio album and he was loved by all on the hip hop scene.
JTRD12shady 6 months ago
RIP Big Proof !
MokerB 2 years ago 5
em is an awesome rapper because he white raps lol he doesnt have that black guy rapper voice hes got the white guy rapper voice its cooler imo and hes just plain good
Shalamalaman 2 years ago
I agree with AcousticTyGuy that dude is really annoying he's ruining for Em. Em is awesome but the other guy needs to shutup!
davieboy1970 2 years ago
thats proof
and he died
dennisrussian 2 years ago
Yea for realz, that was Eminem's best friend that got shot. He was the hype man. That's why he sounds loud.
Konyak0 2 years ago 3
Eminem is the king and godfather of rap,like it or not tupac fans
DeadRed94 2 years ago 3
Thats what you think
BigBossXJr 2 years ago
that other Random Rapper is Proof ... Eminems best friend who got shot dead. ....
BenRiley1234 2 years ago
Eminem is great in this, but the random other rapper is just annoying
AcousticTyGuy 2 years ago
Blimy im amazed they let him swear lol
Richy24Richy 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ø¤º°¨ ¸„ø¤º°¨°º¤ø„¸¨°º¤ø„
¨°º¤ø„ ¸Eminem The BEST¨°º¤ø„¸
¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º „¸¨°º¤ø„¸¸„ø¤º°°°°°PERU
SIEMPRE CON EMINEM
SNIFONE 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
☻/
/▌
/ \1. copy and paste
2. send this to 2 other videos.
3. hold your breath for 10 seconds
4. press refresh twice
3. LOOK AT YOUR BACKGROUND
kaylaiscool176 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
☻/
/▌
/ \1. copy and paste
2. send this to 2 other videos.
3. hold your breath for 10 seconds
4. press refresh twice
3. LOOK AT YOUR BACKGROUND
Thecjmaster 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
r.i.p proof
killaloc20006 2 years ago
awesome
vidsrighthere13 2 years ago 2
good song :))
placQwestcoast 2 years ago 4
the crowd look like twats :L
girdzy12345 3 years ago 2
this has nothing to do with anything but.
i realized eminem call pull of anything that he wears. hes the only person that could wear an american flag as a bandanna and not look like an idiot
eminem is fucking amazing
MarshallMathersxD 3 years ago 37
@MarshallMathersxD YOUR A FUCKING BITCH ANYONE WHO NAMES THE SELFS AFTER SOMEONE FAMOUS THEY DONT EVEN KNOW NEEDS A DOC TO CHECK THERE HEADS OUT
DAJAZDJ1 1 year ago
@MarshallMathersxD your a retard
youngenb123 1 year ago
crowd is gay as fuck
F4nb0ysDieYung 3 years ago
TOTP was the shit back then!!!
The music they played on there wasn't even pop lol!
=]
ILuvOmarionG 3 years ago
the crowd are so shit
sem3ability 3 years ago
when you go at a concert or in the club or in the disco YOu represent "the crowd" so fuck oyu dick head retard
AndiPitesti 3 years ago
'andipitesti' i wasnt there so how is your comment relevent you stupid retard go slit your wrist vertically in a dark room. whilst crying over your sad pathetic life you worthless piece of shit.
sem3ability 3 years ago
yes, you weren`t there. but when i go somewhere(for example at a concert) you are part of the crowd! so stop swearing the crowd bastard, use oyur little brain before saying smthing! moron head
AndiPitesti 3 years ago
R.I.P Big Proof
Skinhead313 3 years ago 3
didnt proof died in 2006
mluppen 3 years ago
big up em rip proof yo em get outya closet man and dominate the world again ...... HA HA
07853421024 3 years ago
I really don't listen rap, but I have to say this song is awesome :D
Modrogh 3 years ago
this is when TOTP was getting big...
NYSecond 3 years ago
R.I.P PROOF
i can rap al of dis
ToBzZy22 3 years ago 2
hahaha its funny the way Proof says hehe in 2:07-2:10
95RunDowN95 3 years ago
eminem is the only rapper or hell musician!! that can even sound better in a live performance!
RELAPSE!!
almost774 3 years ago 3
so true
humzahumzahumza 3 years ago
wooow eminem is great here.
this verse is better then the real version but the real one is also great
iamshadyfan 3 years ago
VERY GOOD
kayfd 3 years ago
BEST RAP SONG OF ALL TIME
rebl18 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
R.I.P Proof
andrewlee916 3 years ago 2
didn't proof get shot?
boogeyman1995 3 years ago
he did
andrewlee916 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
R.I.P Proof
boogeyman1995 3 years ago
rip proof
jackjohnson0 3 years ago
yea
andrewlee916 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
why is the black guy there????? is he a tag along that jus likes tryin to finish shadys sentences????? lol?
johnypink 3 years ago
it's proof he was his best friend and was in D12
SkyDayz 3 years ago
the 2nd best rapper in d12!!! and a really cool person
VenomouseViper 3 years ago 2
thats proof u fucking idiot
OCcrazy1 3 years ago
thats proof Dumbass
DawgVideos 3 years ago
WTF, he actually turned up for a live show
IxRoMpASToMpAxI360TV 3 years ago
f*ck everbody
Eminem is the best
mmilo14 3 years ago 2
yeahh eminem is FREAKIONG AMAZING
I love ya em. i wanna meet him :]]
shellshellgirl123 3 years ago 6
pff crazy performance...
Knotism666 3 years ago
Tupac made more money after his death rarther than before his death so who is better?
But
R.I.P anyways Tupac
saintjimmi192 3 years ago
he didnt make the money he was dead
nycmachinegun 3 years ago 2
eminem!!!!!!=]
shit crowd!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Xxnaynay15xX 3 years ago 5
hes just brill luv u eminem xxx
crazyandhazy 3 years ago
LISTEN, i didnt read any of 'ur' comments, eminem is the GREATEST rapper eva, em is funny,real,honest, and the best EVER to put any ryme 2gether, slim is a explosion of lyrical genius, i met EM ...i won FANatic on mtv im english, em sed i was cool!,,,,, can you say that......................
addwada 3 years ago
No doubt Eminem is a intelligent lyricist, but you cant compare him to Tupac. Tupac was the greatest in every way.
tsbomb 3 years ago
tupac was over rated. the only reason he gets so much credit is because of his death. was the first death of a really famous rapper, next to eazy e. the world was shocked, and so he was remembered as legend. not saying he wasnt great, but just a little over hyped
angrywombo 3 years ago 3
No lol, 2pac was killed before Em even got his record deal.
eminemfansite 3 years ago 3
mr drunk black guy can go away now
cunfuzzled44 3 years ago
cunfuzzled44 u can suck my mother fuckin dick
almost774 3 years ago
was tupac friends with eminem???
killer475 3 years ago
My birthday is on this day hehe.....
Eminem is the best rapper ever thats my tought...I think 2pac is litlle overrated because his dead, I don"t say tupac is bad just he is behind shady!!!
maksimir0 3 years ago 4
This iz a cool vid.
gutawafang 4 years ago 2
RIP Proof!
LeonUzuki 4 years ago 3
actully his name is eminem
feras1000 4 years ago
proofeminem i couldnt think them as seperate
heroboyx 4 years ago 4
r.i.p. big proof
mctrimz 4 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
proof reuined the song sorry but i think he did
lfctwentytwo 4 years ago
R.I.P. Big Proof
OnTop213 4 years ago 8
I & everyvody!!!We respect R.I.P. Proof is motherfucker raper of Detroit he was motherfucker very great raper and i say if you know D12 Make´s motherfuckaa noice this!!!Proof Forever!!!
DenihoSKS 4 years ago 5
his flow is sickk :O
thaninounette 4 years ago 2
1 of the best rappers
and the best live performer
OnTop213 4 years ago
you stupid fuck
show respect r.i.p. proof
Eminem has got his fame thanks
to proof most of it.
Proof and eminem is one
if you didnt now
and thats all of you fans
must now.
doxinjo 4 years ago
K-N-O-W
RIP Proof
I should have checked your solo shit earlier
SakurabaSan 4 years ago 2
somebody dying doesnt mean they cant be annoying in a video, and that everything they did was good haha
Death happens dude
jdk1238 4 years ago 5
I do agree with some of you proof does ruin it cause it aint the orginal but he is there to get the crowed pumped and to let the lead rapper (eminem) take a breath with out missin a word
ShadysBack123 4 years ago
if you dont know who proof is, then stop listen to Eminem. youre not a real fan! Proof died in 2006!!
impshit 4 years ago
the stupid orange guy thinks hes soo cool. not
mycommentisdownthere 4 years ago
hey thats proof show some respect
OCcrazy1 4 years ago 2
lol you suck mycommentisdownthere
Hebisasuke 4 years ago
proofs done alot of tings for eminem, but hasnt asked for credit for it, so people worldwide dont know about it. RIP
ryanfozzy2 4 years ago
The orange guy is totally ruining the whole performance.
jessicakeel 4 years ago
Hehe, u dont know who that is? It's proof, died some months ago. He was the best rapper in D12. But yeah, I think when he is/was on stage with eminem, he ruins the performance. It isn't the original rap, and it is annoying.
12WhiplasH123 4 years ago
please stund up
slimshadycar 4 years ago
Adarka1: It's called being a hype-man... Proof aka Derty actually raps really good.
FunKDoc831 4 years ago
Exactly. RIP Proof
SakurabaSan 4 years ago
da other guy cant sing
adarka1 4 years ago
best rapper of history
eminemthebest8 4 years ago
every one knows proof because of eminem he would be shit without him
jazza32 4 years ago
RIP
graceanna3 4 years ago
most of these comments r real sad :(
graceanna3 4 years ago
eminems a legend!! best rapper ever!
SexyKayleigh1989 4 years ago
yupp yupp~!!!!!!!!!!
rapandcomedy 4 years ago
amazing performance!! amazing man
asbo2006 4 years ago
r.i.p proof
Matscooling 4 years ago
proof was killed in 2006
stokesy111 4 years ago
the music vedio is much better then live
runenathan 4 years ago
yoooooooooooooo
seiles1 4 years ago
RIP Proof!
nutcover 4 years ago
The black guy's Proof. He was in D12 with Eminem and he was shot and killed in a club in Detroit back in I
think 2005. RIP Proof.
Bravesfan22 4 years ago
Dang! if that guy were in front of me, i wouldnt be standing up there dancing like all those ppl, hahaha XD
Naty736 4 years ago
whose the black guy?
alecjustin14 4 years ago
you are kidding right? WHO'S THE BLACK GUY?! it's Proof... Got killed in the fall of 2006. Got shot in the head, after he shot one in the head.. he was eminem's best friend.. they battled together in the "hip-hop shop" in detroit back in the day.. damn man.. hwo dosnt know Proof?
anyway... nice performance Marshall/Proof.
mrdanish 4 years ago
SO MANY FUCKING MEMORIES I MEAN I WAS IN THAT AUDIENCE man i loved this
lfc22 4 years ago
lol? you aren't serious, are you?
HydraulikXPRO 4 years ago
eminem is the legend
l6a1g8 4 years ago
eminem is fuckin' King!
jokerittaja 4 years ago
damn skippi
HJBlissett 4 years ago
very nice thx for this i had never seen it
davekief 4 years ago