This isn't pre-rotation...... pre-rotation is also known as a toe-axel..... and on edge jumps you are going to naturally have a little turn on the take off because they involve more torque! Thanks for the video :)
thanx for making this video!!!! Pre-rotation is NATURAL, and we're all humans!!!! And if anyone wants to keep calling these jumps "cheated", they better post a video of them doing a "real" triple salchow!!!!!!
No skater is perfect, because that does not exist. Yu Na skates as a princess and has good quality of movement, but Mao skating as a ballet dancer and also has better technique, makes more difficult jumps (triple axel) and best executed and has much better flexibility in placement and the spirals and The Billman.
@Emrak304 LOL! Really? Evgeni has since landed his 4-3-2 combination 26 times so far, he landed 4-3-3 combo 4 times, he landed cca 100 quad in competitions.
Pre rotation is not the problem here. The salchow does take off forward because you actually do a back 3 turn as you take off. A single is like a waltz jump and double like an axel. They just decided to give it a different name because it was a different take off.
There are those who make ugly videos on Yuna. It's terrible and shameless. But please do not automatically assume they are all made by the Japanese. The same is done for Mao as well, but I don't jump to conclusions that they're all Korean made. There are anti-Maoists and anti-Yunaists in both countries, and in other countries as well. The only thing I assume about people who make those videos, are that they're not figure skating fans. They've no admiration for the sport nor the skaters.
what's with the innocent korean fig-fan act? u'r the 1 goin around swearin at the japanese! u've been writin "fassaasgsgagas = ordinary japanese" "suck japs" "fucking ugly japs always lie" "go to hell fucking jap" all over the place & now u'r begging? did you think noone's gonna notice? if u want others to treat ur skaters right, stop ur dirty racist comments & accusing the japanese of bashing yuna. it could've been anyone frm any country. u'r only making things worse, u 4 letter word lover!
thank you 20arc and sirbaron. you will find people EVERYWHERE who say terrible things about others, it's not confined to ANY single area. these videos I'm making are not meant to be pro or anti any skater, they're just to show fans that the "prerotation" that many think is a horrible error in jump technique exists in all skaters and is just a natural part of the jump
Some korean yuna-fans can't understand this. So they say "yuna is perfect. other skaters are cheat jumpers because of 'pre-rotation'!!" They should study figure skating....:P
most jumps, salchows in particular and especially the doubles and triples, have pre rotation. contrary to popular belief, no jump takes off perfectly from backwards. my coach is actually telling me to hold on to the rotation after the three turn/mohawk a little longer because it will make the take off easier and the jump look cleaner and not so swingy. you just have to be careful with how much you prerotate because if you leave it too long, the jump will be downgraded
I didn't accuse the uploader of using photoshop. I'm criticizing this user who suggested she photoshoped Yuna's feet. That would be impossible. She would have to photoshop Yuna completely.
In order for you to make a fair comparison of skaters, you need to pick one competition and compare their jumps from that competition alone. Otherwise, you are simply cherry-picking jumps that suit you. I would suggest you choose the 2009 Worlds, as it's the most recent competition where most of the big-name skaters competed.
The problem with that is that not all of the skaters completed their jumps at 2009 Worlds. Yu-na popped her salchow and Mao didn't so a sal. I figured the best way to handle it would be to take jumps that were given positive GOE.
photoshopped? yuna's jumps doesnt even need to be photoshopped. and she's already unbeatable and untouchable. she cant photoshop yuna's feet because yuna's triple salchow is too perfect to even have to photoshop.
Yes, Yuna's salchow is textbook and beautiful. Textbook salchows take off forwards, off the toe, just like Mao, just like Joubert, just like Plushenko, just like Yuna, just like Joannie and just like every other skater.
I'm neither criticizing nor complimenting any skater, just showing their jumps, so please, spare me the drama.
Okay, so they're all facing forwards. Most US ladies flutz their lutzes. Just because they do it doesn't make it correct. There should not be 1/2 rotation on the ice before take-off. It should be 1/4 or less.
and then they're leaving the ice sideways in a trajectory TOTALLY opposite where they will be landing. How do they go from jumping in one direction to landing in the opposite? If a CCW skater took off on a 3sal at the 1/4 mark, they would be jumping completely OUTSIDE of the circle of the LBI edge.
1/4?! r u stupid? u kno nothing bout skating. u need to rotate 1/2 on the ice before jumping. if u rotate only 1/4 u'll end up jumping sideways and going off the hip or u'll just skid across the ice with no height and fall on the jump. i take sondra holmes and tammy gambill. i kno how to jump these salchow.
this is why USA sucks now. cause ppl like u dnt kno how to skate yet u think u know it.
I think brian and joannie are the best salchow jumpers
jakeymc3 2 months ago
Nice. Jouberts looked so easy that it looked like a double.
filipinoICEsk8ter 7 months ago
Comment removed
dorca000 10 months ago
This isn't pre-rotation...... pre-rotation is also known as a toe-axel..... and on edge jumps you are going to naturally have a little turn on the take off because they involve more torque! Thanks for the video :)
MrAmazingness1234567 11 months ago
Salchows are hard!!!!!
UnsinkableJoe 1 year ago
thanx for making this video!!!! Pre-rotation is NATURAL, and we're all humans!!!! And if anyone wants to keep calling these jumps "cheated", they better post a video of them doing a "real" triple salchow!!!!!!
triciamatsuda 1 year ago
this video is truth.
Thanks for upraud!!
mikanvlovev25 1 year ago 2
I know Korean residents in Japan who are "self-styled Japanese" often say the lie concerning Yuna-Kim.
It is a too daily problem in Japan.
ikeshu2000 1 year ago 4
i love this video!
you are right!
kikirarasanrio2223 1 year ago 3
No skater is perfect, because that does not exist. Yu Na skates as a princess and has good quality of movement, but Mao skating as a ballet dancer and also has better technique, makes more difficult jumps (triple axel) and best executed and has much better flexibility in placement and the spirals and The Billman.
Of the men, the king of the jumps is Plushenko.
EricLensher 1 year ago 5
@EricLensher I'm not sure for men I think that Patrick Chan could also be close to that title
Emrak304 1 year ago
@Emrak304 LOL! Really? Evgeni has since landed his 4-3-2 combination 26 times so far, he landed 4-3-3 combo 4 times, he landed cca 100 quad in competitions.
dorca000 10 months ago
@Emrak304 The KING of the jumps is EVGENI PLUSHENKO!!!
dorca000 10 months ago
@dorca000 I cannot argue agaisnt such facts :P You are prehaps right but I still rather Patrick's Jumps to Plushenko's I think there more smooth.
xMRskatingx 10 months ago
@xMRskatingx Of couse, you can't argue. Chan's skating is smooth, but look at this:
the best 3A, what i have ever seen. He was 16.: /watch?v=bpLVaQGV2BI
quad combo, he was 15.: /watch?v=v6o9VR7S-P8
the first 4-3-2 combo in history: /watch?v=7aGZXEs4dIE&feature=related 17y.o
the first perfect 4-3-3 combo in history : /watch?v=DVplv_v4B4M 20 y.o I saw Chan in last WCH and Skate Canada, he had problem with the 3A
Do you understand why is Plushenko the king of jumps and king of ice?
dorca000 10 months ago 2
@dorca000 Yes I now agree with you
xMRskatingx 10 months ago
I love this video! You have helped a lot with my Salchow. I could never get of the ice. Pre-rotation is natural.
Spiralina15 2 years ago 2
Pre rotation is not the problem here. The salchow does take off forward because you actually do a back 3 turn as you take off. A single is like a waltz jump and double like an axel. They just decided to give it a different name because it was a different take off.
skatingcoach87 2 years ago
Pls make videos on 3A, too! plz!
seru98 2 years ago
I will. Busy with school right now, but I should get it done soon.
ibreakhearts66 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
and Japanese Please..
Don't swear at yuna in youtube
We korean really love yuna
yuna is reasonable World Champion
but some japanese again again upload
ugly video and negative campaign yuna
We korean really sad
Please stop negative campaign
Enjoy figure skating please
MsAtom2008 2 years ago
There are those who make ugly videos on Yuna. It's terrible and shameless. But please do not automatically assume they are all made by the Japanese. The same is done for Mao as well, but I don't jump to conclusions that they're all Korean made. There are anti-Maoists and anti-Yunaists in both countries, and in other countries as well. The only thing I assume about people who make those videos, are that they're not figure skating fans. They've no admiration for the sport nor the skaters.
sirbaronwest 2 years ago 5
what's with the innocent korean fig-fan act? u'r the 1 goin around swearin at the japanese! u've been writin "fassaasgsgagas = ordinary japanese" "suck japs" "fucking ugly japs always lie" "go to hell fucking jap" all over the place & now u'r begging? did you think noone's gonna notice? if u want others to treat ur skaters right, stop ur dirty racist comments & accusing the japanese of bashing yuna. it could've been anyone frm any country. u'r only making things worse, u 4 letter word lover!
shikakeya 2 years ago 9
you just have to ingore these stupid people. it's a sad thing, but such people exist.
and don't conclude these are only japenese. I've seen many koreans who are saying ugly things about mao. So, these poeple exist in any country.
As much as you (koreans) are really sad, they (japanese) are really sad.
Don't forget that!
yes, let's enjoy figure skating
20arc08 2 years ago
thank you 20arc and sirbaron. you will find people EVERYWHERE who say terrible things about others, it's not confined to ANY single area. these videos I'm making are not meant to be pro or anti any skater, they're just to show fans that the "prerotation" that many think is a horrible error in jump technique exists in all skaters and is just a natural part of the jump
ibreakhearts66 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
thanks ibreakhearts66!!
I totally agree with your opinion ( in salchow jump )
I think most skater pre-rotate in salchow jump .
But
I think delayed jump is more nice skill
and pre-rotation jump is bad skill
(especially flip and lutz )
sorry my eglish is very bad ㅠ
MsAtom2008 2 years ago
thanks ibreakhearts66!!
Some korean yuna-fans can't understand this. So they say "yuna is perfect. other skaters are cheat jumpers because of 'pre-rotation'!!" They should study figure skating....:P
Rachmaniyokonov 2 years ago 34
You totally should make videos for 3A and 3L as well. Keep up the good job, ibreakhearts66!
kei2012 2 years ago 17
i plan to!
ibreakhearts66 2 years ago
by the way, you shouldn't use SBS videos because they may delete it as soon as they find out FYI.
kei2012 2 years ago 6
thanks for the info. pardon my ignorance, but which of the videos clips I used are SBS?
ibreakhearts66 2 years ago
Sorry. I meant the other video clip you made for Toe Loop. The very first one is from SBS. Not always but sometimes they just do that.
kei2012 2 years ago
most jumps, salchows in particular and especially the doubles and triples, have pre rotation. contrary to popular belief, no jump takes off perfectly from backwards. my coach is actually telling me to hold on to the rotation after the three turn/mohawk a little longer because it will make the take off easier and the jump look cleaner and not so swingy. you just have to be careful with how much you prerotate because if you leave it too long, the jump will be downgraded
sammywright07 2 years ago 4
At this point I hope Yuna bombs at the olympics so all of her ubers heads explode.
eeyybob 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Photoshop in a video? O.o
kaoruzinha 2 years ago
I didn't accuse the uploader of using photoshop. I'm criticizing this user who suggested she photoshoped Yuna's feet. That would be impossible. She would have to photoshop Yuna completely.
kaoruzinha 2 years ago 4
I understood lol
ibreakhearts66 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
But Mao's prerotation is too bad. We can see hers without slow videos.
ddongsil 2 years ago
In order for you to make a fair comparison of skaters, you need to pick one competition and compare their jumps from that competition alone. Otherwise, you are simply cherry-picking jumps that suit you. I would suggest you choose the 2009 Worlds, as it's the most recent competition where most of the big-name skaters competed.
jayhl77 2 years ago 4
The problem with that is that not all of the skaters completed their jumps at 2009 Worlds. Yu-na popped her salchow and Mao didn't so a sal. I figured the best way to handle it would be to take jumps that were given positive GOE.
ibreakhearts66 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Please don't make forged vedios. You photoshopped Yuna's feet. Poor thing. Don't you know that this makes Yuna more unbeatable??
jeanie1021 2 years ago
I didn't photoshop anything (and it would have to be an entire body). This video isn't criticizing anyone.
And the only thing that makes Yuna unbeatable is her own skating, not some video I put up on youtube that says nothing bad about her.
ibreakhearts66 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@jeanie1021
photoshopped? yuna's jumps doesnt even need to be photoshopped. and she's already unbeatable and untouchable. she cant photoshop yuna's feet because yuna's triple salchow is too perfect to even have to photoshop.
phusk8r 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
stupid video. mao did prerotate so badly.
Yuna's salcow is textbook and beautiful.
pricekingfeed 2 years ago
Yes, Yuna's salchow is textbook and beautiful. Textbook salchows take off forwards, off the toe, just like Mao, just like Joubert, just like Plushenko, just like Yuna, just like Joannie and just like every other skater.
I'm neither criticizing nor complimenting any skater, just showing their jumps, so please, spare me the drama.
ibreakhearts66 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Okay, so they're all facing forwards. Most US ladies flutz their lutzes. Just because they do it doesn't make it correct. There should not be 1/2 rotation on the ice before take-off. It should be 1/4 or less.
courtneysk8s 2 years ago
find me a skater who leaves the ice for their 3sal facing backwards.
ibreakhearts66 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm not saying they have to be totally backward, but 1/2 rotation on the ice is too much. It should be more like 1/4.
courtneysk8s 2 years ago
and then they're leaving the ice sideways in a trajectory TOTALLY opposite where they will be landing. How do they go from jumping in one direction to landing in the opposite? If a CCW skater took off on a 3sal at the 1/4 mark, they would be jumping completely OUTSIDE of the circle of the LBI edge.
ibreakhearts66 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You don't even know what you're talking about. Seriously. Get over yourself.
courtneysk8s 2 years ago
i think that you know nothing about figure skating... its 1/2 rotation ...you need to do that in a salchow jump no choice :)
Koldej 2 years ago
@Koldej srry it was supposed to be in response to people saying a 1/4 or less :S
Koldej 2 years ago
@courtneysk8s
1/4?! r u stupid? u kno nothing bout skating. u need to rotate 1/2 on the ice before jumping. if u rotate only 1/4 u'll end up jumping sideways and going off the hip or u'll just skid across the ice with no height and fall on the jump. i take sondra holmes and tammy gambill. i kno how to jump these salchow.
this is why USA sucks now. cause ppl like u dnt kno how to skate yet u think u know it.
phusk8r 2 years ago
amen.
ibreakhearts66 2 years ago