Mariah Carey Vs. Celine, Christina, Beyonce and Others (Part 2)

[tertra114]

it's that TONE that sets her apart, her tone is so professional & high quality sounding

[iLLusion625]

you should make a Part 3..

[patipatou79]

Mariah Carey is the ultimate vocalist, no one can beat her on interpretations cause she got everything over her rivals : creativity,originality,talent,­her voice got Better tone,more flexibility,more agility,more feminity,more beauty and lot of power ! Mariah carey is the best !

[MsMc31]

yah becuase mimi is the best forever and ever

[zblamm2121]

Mariah is incredible. END OF. And I'm DYING for that next albulm...She is going to reign the summer season NO DOUBT

[pinkqintonsfier]

Of course the Vocal Trinity Rules.. Whitney, Celine and Course MARIAH CAREY!! :D

who says leona has the best head voice in the world..!!

[lovable902]

mariah carey all the way lol

[Ehadurkah]

is she and Bianca Ryan are in the Same Hall on Come all ye faithful?

[MCLAMB4LIFE1]

@Ehadurkah yes they are both were recorded at the national building museum for the Christmas in Washington special. but in different years of course.

[Ehadurkah]

OOh When Mariah Starts to Sing I cant Breath ayayay!!

[Ehadurkah]

Bravisima ay!! bravo, bravo, bravo!!!!! WE LOVE YOU MARIAH CAREY!!!

[chesleycareystar]

I LOVE CELINE AND MARIAH, AND WHITNEY.... :) THEY ARE AMAZING

[PaNdeM0niuM]

great video.

Mariah = Often imitated, NEVER duplicated.

[sakuraluver1000]

how come every video that people compare mariah to other artist that all her live performances are from the past. ( far in the past)

[TroyWannaBE101]

Someone needs to make a video of mariah singing live in 2012 and then compare it to other people singing live in 2012 then itll be fair ...

[TroyWannaBE101]

That open arms song that was sang by celine was done this year 2011, when was mariahs? ... How far back ... Lets get her to sing it as good as celine, "now" .. She couldnt ..

[Nofiih]

L.A. Reid worked with Mariah, so that prove nothing..

You can not say Mariah Carey is better because she sing Open Arms amazing. Celine version is made so he can sing it 4 years every day in Las Las Vegas.

Celine Dion sings the christmas songs O Holy Night and O Come All Ye Faithful (personaly I love Mariahs up tempo version) but vocally Celine is better in these songs .. I will say they both are amazing, Celine and Mariah.

The other artists are nothing, when we talks about Celine and Mariah!!!

[GhenMariahyonce1995]

Mariah is the Queen..:))

[IMMRKING123]

nvr mind at 58



[IMMRKING123]

what the song at 1:00

[zanoases]

mariah is best ever! celine sounds like a ameteur compared! for real!!!!

[ForeverComplaining]

I prefer Celine. :) but my favourite of them all is Whitney Houston.

[westlifemania1]

Mariah's the best. timbre of voice, versatility and highest note that can be reached. great!

[Bloapimp]

Yall saying Kelly Clarkson is on Mariah level u must be on dope or dog food

[Bloapimp]

Mariah killed em all

[goodchild181]

Mariah is more SUCCESFUL, voice is better, and has sold more records

[HannahLovecelinedion]

CELINE DION <3<3

[agators212]

but overall great video....it would be cool though if you did another video comparing mariah's covers to the original artist. i think that would be cool...haha...

imagine

diana and lional vs mc and luther

journey (steve perry) vs mc

foreigner (lou gramm i believe he was the lead singer at the time) vs mc

phil collins vs mc

hmm...is that all the covers she's recorded? thats all i can remember at the top of my head

[MCLAMB4LIFE1]

@agators212 YES!! i was definitely thinkning of doing a video like that. :)

[agators212]

@MCLAMB4LIFE1 that would be awesome and full of goodiness

[agators212]

what? celine sang open arms? lower key though.

america the beautiful is mariah's song just like the national anthem is whitney's.

but somewhere over the rainbow, best patti perfromance was the one where she's wearing the red dress and half-fro.

i wish kelly sang a different mariah song though. theres a snippet of her singing vision of love during a radio interview. wish she sang that instead. still love you kelly

jonalyn, IMO the best singer the philippines has. love that A5 she hits

[sanato25]

Kelly screamin Gosh.>.>

[iiAmitx3]

"she simply has more talent than everyone else"

[fontenayperi]

i love Celine. but Mariah's open arms is way better! more creative.

[carshe209]

mariah!!! undisputed..

[jeremimi]

do u have that america the beautiful uploaded in that same quality. all the ones ive seen are terrible quality

[krazyshorty89]

I think the only one that is on Mariah's level vocally is Celine. Leona and Kelly? lol

[chesleycareystar]

she must do a Concert called 18 to perform her 18#1 songs

[vuongph]

This video is only for fanboys and fangirls. Is Mariah Carey the best female singer of all time? Absolutely not! But she is the biggest bitch in the music industry of all time.

[blinechagas1]

leona quase se caga tentando cantar a música da Mariah

muito engraçado, ficou horrivel....

[Snookiiiii]

This video just proves how amazing Kelly Clarkson is.

[BajcoTheSinger]

haha, why didn't you cpmpared leona lewis's over the rainbow with mariah...or whitout you...btw, kelly is as good as mariah...i'm realizing only now, what talent she's got...

[superx57]

@BajcoTheSinger Mariah and Leona's Over The Rainbow were sung in two very different ways. As for Without You, there are already a bunch of videos of Mariah slaying Leona in comparison with that song. I do agree that Kelly is amazing and doesn't get the credit she deserves.

[LILRuthlessplaya88]

@ablackguy1234567  lmao aretha a better singer then mariah? mariah's technique is far beyond arethas capabilities..remember lets not confuse loudness with greatness..mariah's technique and range is far more superior then arethas.. she just has soul. thats it.

[DanielAvilaAGT]

FAVED! :)

[foymanatee]

Ben oui, le doigt de Dieu l'a touchée.

[misterjerek]

of cos mariah is the best...but kelly clarkson singing love takes time was so amazing!

[Bernerker]

mariahs belts sound much more light and pleasant compared to the rest of the girls

so even if mariah doesnt have the highest belting range(which is still damn high), her quality makes up for it and more

you can hear this contrast especially in the bianca vs. mariah LOL and basically all of them

[LloydCafeCadena2]

Mariah Carey all the way..

[mariahphilmrazem]

all of the singers shown here are amazing as well in their own way but when compared the main difference I see is that the other singers seem to have to force their notes and Mariah's notes come out effortlessly. Except Patti Labelle. Patti is freaking awesome :)

[eonejc]

all i know all the song that mariah's sing is always end up with so much beautiful emotions...thats why i love mariah..love you forever...xxx

[MrJudube]

the most amazing mystery about Mariah is that she will not stop composing more and more dfficult songs and having stellar performances even when her voice is totally gone LOL

[TheWildstevo]

leona is rubbish at key shifting! an she does this weird yodelling thing which drives me mad! she needs to do us all a favour an swerve singing!

[Shazni1409]

She's just the best eva and no1 compares, and its amazing how she's probally had the most people trying to sing her songs coz their best just like her tht shows how other singers respect her and prove tht she is the best

[MrChachito90]

that charice WOUWOAAAAHH!!! 8:11

[kelvinpyaeko]

@MrChachito90 that's a scream! annoying

[MrChachito90]

@kelvinpyaeko OK that it's your opinion, LOL! not mine! :D

[LuGui76]

Mariah Carey tehs best forever!!

[BaByXgIrL]

OMG @ 9:50 That note!!! My jaw dropped when I heard this. Mariah sounds like a bird! Marvellous, she's indeed the BEST. I for one am Christina's fan yet I admit Mariah is in a league of her own. She's the best of the best. No one can get there. The others are great. Mariah is untouchable.<3

[DanScot19]

Leona Lewis now would absaloutley hold her own with Mariah, what was she like 15 in that video,, this video is actually just trying to make other singers look bad. !!!

[MCLAMB4LIFE1]

@DanScot19 no, this video is comparing singers singing the same songs, the reason some of these singers look bad is because Mariah is better, she sings every song better especially her songs.

[DanScot19]

@MCLAMB4LIFE1 Fair enough, I just think the whole comparing Mariah, Celine, Whintney Leona thingy is getting old n just generated alot of hate and bad feeling towards the artist . I respect your opinion

[belldandy113]

@MCLAMB4LIFE1 i agree:)shes the best:)

[TroyWannaBE101]

@MCLAMB4LIFE1 She isn't better no more haha ...

[kelvinpyaeko]

@DanScot19 there you are again. you whine me about how i feel the need to argue with you fans, lmfao. oh hypocrisy! are you irate that leona is not any better? #DEAL yeah, leona was 15 here. and so far, she hasn't even reached the feet of mariah in her prime

[DanScot19]

@kelvinpyaeko Oh and there you are again. Stop stalking me. Leona is THE BEST okay nothing u ever say is gonna change that so stop trying !!!

[kelvinpyaeko]

@DanScot19 LMFAO..stalking you? dude, i always came back to this video time after time. stop judging with your shallow brain. leona is the best? at what? clarify me, dude

[sfool]

@DanScot19 not everyones a hater. i like leona too but love mimi and she sounds better singing her own hit. i bet mimi cant do bleeding love justice like leona..we lambs dont like to hate for no reason. we only hate to retaliate and protect our queen

[RaceHobbs]

@DanScot19 ...Leona Lewis couldn't TOUCH Mariah Carey.....then or NOW!!!! Just sayin.....

[thecamil10]

@DanScot19: I dont agree with you.Just trying to show that Mariah Carey in her best it is really one of the best if not the best. Leona is younger, MC is twice her age.But just listen to the technique and you will see that Leona has a lot to learn with Mariah.

[KateConan]

OK, those who think (or pretend to think) Celine sang "Open Arms" better than Mariah are definitely dumb (or deaf). I'm Asian but I have to say that Jonalyn is just a copycat singer.

[Cbhan2108]

MARIAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[klitorisnababa]

WHAT IS THE NAME OF TV SHOW AT THE END?

[MCLAMB4LIFE1]

@klitorisnababa A&E Biography.

[esther1208]

I love the look Mariah has in her eyes during Butterfly :)

[JimmothyDean]

Mariah's voice conquers all. All the others are in her shadow.

[CelineDionVietSub]

Celine and Mariah <3

best voice. Ever

[stardusth2o]

Mariah destroys everyone here. LOL at Bianca Ryan smh... But O Come All YE Faithful and O Holy Night were lipped by Mariah. And Celine was in her 40's against a 20 something Mariah. But anyways a great and creative video! I love it! :D

[MCLAMB4LIFE1]

@stardusth2o O Holy Night was only partially lipped. thanks for watching :)

[MCLAMB4LIFE1]

@stardusth2o O Holy Night was only partially lipped. thanks for watching!! :)

[eFlyFowler]

@MCLAMB4LIFE1 And what makes you say that O Holy Night was partially lipped ?

[MCLAMB4LIFE1]

@eFlyFowler certain parts seemed lipped, but of course i could be wrong, thats just how it looked to me.

[KateConan]

@eFlyFowler @MCLAMB4LIFE1 And what makes you think that "O Holy Night" was partially (or entirely) lipped, @eFlyFowler ?

[tonyspizza1800]

The best voice. Ever.

[mcdamian17]

LA Reid said it all

[benthehen07]

i hate dumb people if you study vocals you'll know how sloppy mariah crappy is

[MCLAMB4LIFE1]

@benthehen07 Jealous Much? oops! Voice experts, Classical Singers, & Music Critics all praise Mariahs Voice, Vocal Abilities and Technique such as a Baritone Malcolm Walker, Stephen Holden, Jon Pareles, Jeannette Lo Vetri, Montserrat Caballé. They describe her voice as pure,full, rounded,Warm, Bright,fast & controlled staccatos,glides effortlessly,Mastery of melismas&legato,Perfect timing,divine accuracy, subtle and refined phrasing, rhythmic melismas, effortless startlingly exact pitch.

[kelvinpyaeko]

@benthehen07 the only person i found dumb is, in fact, you! lmfao if mariah, one of the best singers, is crappy in your standard, then you would have been miles lower than 'crappiness' by your definition ohh

[JimmyJrock]

@benthehen07 Art thou angry? There's nothing sloppy about Mariah, the only issue is that she over-worked her voice & over-sang. Her techniques are highly praised. You may have her confused with Christina lol.

[benthehen07]

patti labelle is ten times the singer mariah is resonance range and tone .. she has it all even whitney out sang mariah on that duet

[undersc0re2]

i bliv mariah is the only underrated singer! i mean she deserves more than what shes getting now... other artists knows that..

[undersc0re2]

when the whistle part came, jonalyn didnt know what to do lol

[ivennein]

The others Singers Scream Mariah Sing With the heart and her soul and she don't care If she sing Good or not Because she really knows how to sing so She is The Queen of Music!!!

[ANDREOFNORTHDALLAS]

great..... love you Patti

[imafan123456]

Mariah in her prime was unstoppable!

[mcluver455]

I hate Regine Velazquez. Can she sing her OWN songs for once? And stop imitating Mariah for god sakes. She pisses me off. Stop trying to sing like Mariah. Damn! She tried to mimic Mariah high notes and all!

[CyprusHot]

@mcluver455 i know right? she shouts instead of sings

[kelvinpyaeko]

@mcluver455 forgive her, dear, after all, she is a karaoke singer lmfao

[mcluver455]

I love Mariah's Thy Lord at 6:47 to 6:52!

[underworld91200]

Mariah Carey is a Goddess and her music is a Religion!!!!

[CyprusHot]

Mariah has vocal control over her songs , shitina ruined that Xmas song , the Asian singers were off key and off note, celine didn't sing with emotion .... Mariah forever :)

[patrickmartin75]

She s just an inspiration to all ! GREAT and MAGIC Mariah

[CyprusHot]

Mariah wins effortlessly

[NiRie017]

So glad the song "Whenever you call" made me a mariah carey fan :))) haha :D mariah murders them all !!! :P 

[MimiDahhling30]

This was great! I can't believe i hadn't seen part 1 either haha :) love it lambie ♥

[MCLAMB4LIFE1]

@MimiDahhling30 Thank Ya Dahhling :)

[565guam]

POWERFUL.....!!!!!! MARIAH, A GODDESS IN HER OWN RITE...

[ThePianoguy89]

Mariah always slays!!

[DollPjTay]

IF Mariah could have sang the song in Patti's rendition THEN I would have been impressed. But she can't belt as high as Patti even on her off days. The break down of "you will find" and "can" are the hardest parts of Patti's rendition and I still haven't heard anything do it better than her. Nevertheless, I do love me some Mariah. Hehe

[lsaturn01]

I love Mariah to death and I think she is one of the greatest voice of all time but one of the greatest voices of all time not the best sorry.

[rayreyes2009]

Mariah made all the singers look bad. Haha I'm so glad I am her lamb. ;)

[KateConan]

Leona & Kelly did try their best but no high notes mean no good. Celine had no soul. Beyonce, Patti, Charice were good. Bianca was good at... SHOUTING, and who is this girl? She reminds me of the fat girl trying to sing I Will Always Love You. Christina was like "O Holy PITCH". Jennifer's "I'll Be There" makes me not to "be there" with her. Jonalyn (with those high notes) was like being f**ked. Regine wasn't "Butterfly", more like a caterpillar. Those are my ideas, no offences :)

[kelvinpyaeko]

@KateConan omg..you comment slays..last comment 'Regine wasn't butterfly, more like caterpillar' hahahahahaha

[FSSW21]

This was a really great video.

I find it funny how when Leona and Mariah sing the F5 part of ABMB Leona says "No no" and Mariah says "Yea" :-) LoL

Great vid!!!!!!!!!

[applmac2009]

Mariah Slayed Everyone Except Patti, Kelly and Jonalyn. Since Celine is a balladeer i thought she would have killed open arms, I was wrong. Christina's O'Holy Night is a disaster. And Mariah' OCAYF shows the difference between a pro and a amateur. Jonalyn was pretty good as was Kelly. And SOTR is Patti's signature song.

[kelvinpyaeko]

@applmac2009 joanlyn? are you serious? that girl is off pitch and her high note at FLB is sharp as knife

[applmac2009]

@kelvinpyaeko She did ok she was singing karaoke after all. and for karaoke it was ok.

[luisboricua9]

Haha they all suck besides MC just to show who really is #1!!!

[chrisak49]

That asian singer was awful (Fly like a bird and I want to know what love is) she was so off pitch all the time.

[chrisak49]

Mariah slayed Celine big time with Open Arms

[swacman04]

Mariah's belts never sounds like she SCREAMING...she always sounds like she singing! Thats one of the main differences between her and other singers.

[aquamarine11500]

now @MCLAMB4LIFE1 you know you wrong for that.Mariah slayed everyone else,but Over The Rainbow is Patti's song..lol

Then you picked a performance of older Patti where she doesn't peak at the at that sustained A5.

Im a MC fan,but No one can sing Over the Rainbow like her. Mariah's voice in that perf was moving,but she seemed hoarse and raspy,which added soul..still not quite like Patti nailed it.

[MCLAMB4LIFE1]

@aquamarine11500 Yes your right Patti's rendition is the definitive version, but Mariah's version is also Amazing!!! its all about taste.

[sentfromupabove]

LOL nice job enjoyed watching mc own everyone xD

[chewerboy]

I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOVE THIS YEAH I LOOOOOVE CELINE/CHRISTINA BUT MARIAH WIL ALWAAAAAAAAYS BE THE BEST SHIT IN THIS GAME!!! :D

now that aside, i looooooooooooooooove christina but 'o holy night' was a mess. i think jonalyn viray was pitchy. we know mariah is the best. but oh well, they still tried, gotta give credit. :I

[regadooooooooo]

bicth mariah playback

[aquamarine11500]

@regadooooooooo Get dat shyt outta here you hating ass bitch!!

by hoe,get da steppin!!

[pablosaimonunes]

I think Celine's, Beyoncé's and Bianca Ryan's version of those songs were better, but Mariah wins all the others. (Was" I wanna know that love is" performance live?)

[aquamarine11500]

@pablosaimonunes lol

Oh you.Yes it was live,you can hear the difference,and BTW When Beyonce gets an reaction like Mariah's performance of that song,then let me know.Celine doesn't have the soul Mariah has to make it better,Mariah's open arms version I S better..lol and Bianca???

WTF are you on!!!!

[MrButler124]

Dang mariah kilt. Like forreal, the others sounded like crap compared to her. Tone, beltting, melisma, everything. Great video!! just proves she is a great legend!!:)

[kelvinpyaeko]

for i'll be there, no one (even those high and strong belters like j hud and charice) can top the quality of MC's F5s back in her prime. last but not least for those two karaoke flopping machines. well, honestly, no comment 10:40 eww i cringed! bitch needs to stop pushing her chords and yelping at the top. so sharp

[kelvinpyaeko]

your vids slayyyyy!!! LOL at leona TRYING (fluctuating pitches lol)..but well, she was so young, back then. celine's version is good, except kind of lifeless. beyonce and kelly are very good, indeed. but of course, as LTT is originally MC's song, and no one can sing MC songs better. Patti's song is of course and that last note mops the floor. MC did it justice, though! no competition for christmas songs, just MC. LOL at christina trying again (same with leona)

[daiell09]

Only Mariah can sing her songs best

[musicguy713]

Love it!! None of these woman can pull of mariahs songs like her. She is simply in another league. Patti my have done her original cover but mariah totally crafted and sang it with much more melisma than patti. Just shows the legacy mariah has left on all the singers today and to come :)

[jakey1126]

see even when other ppl cover a song, like when Jennifer sang I'll Be There, she sang Mariah's version of it <3

[witch26071]

Its funny how mariah always slays!

[Dam112]

Even on the songs that arent particularly hard to sing, she sounds much better than others singing the same song.. Kelly was good though & with Patti, it wasnt a quesiton of who was better but whos renditions you prefer, both vocally great. Celine on a song like Open Arms i thought would be just a great on those lower belts.. fell short of Mariahs belts

Bianca was really good, tad shouty

Holy Night.. oh dear Christina, and Mariahs is actually live on that part.

Ill be there... no comp lol

[MCLAMB4LIFE1]

@Dam112 lol i agree totally, thanks for watching!! :)

[Dam112]

@MCLAMB4LIFE1 great vid (no to check you Part4 Collab :P)

[Dam112]

now*

[RomuloVideos2]

She sounded better than every singer here. She have a gifted instrument indeed.

She's my favorite singer, and I disagree with the statement that she have the greatest voice of all time. And what about Whitney, Barbra, Ella, Sarah and others?

[MCLAMB4LIFE1]

@RomuloVideos2 Thats just an opinion, there is not just one greatest singer of all time, there are many, everyone has their favorite.. Thanks For Watching :)

[mcdamian17]

@RomuloVideos2 I don't know if she has the best voice of all time, but if not the best, the most skillful

[RomuloVideos2]

@mcdamian17 Do you heard all the singers around the world? And what about Aretha?

[KateConan]

@RomuloVideos2 The fact that whether Mariah is the greatest voice of all time is up to everyone. I say this: Mariah's voice is the most amazing and colorful voice ever. And I prefer her voice to the others'. Wherever you go on YouTube, you can always find a Lamb !!!

[im18dammit100]

2:20 obama <3 <3

[shacks29]

Mariah´s voice is touching from inside,thats why she outdoes all others in my opinion....!!!

The best example is "Open Arms".

Great Video!

[yuridiafan4]

I love all your videos :)

[MCLAMB4LIFE1]

@yuridiafan4 thank you so much!!! :D

[briobrandon911]

Mariah's songs are the hardest to cover, since you need that vocal agility, dynamics and the shifting of notes. Major props really to those who can cover her songs.

[Mcvideos92]

IMO Each singer is amazing in their own right but They cannot sing Mariah's song better than she can. Except for Patti who obviously Won , I mean no one does over the rainbow better than her.

[hatedbyniccaz]

Okay...you can not compare Patti and Mariah....no way or how.

[Jared95C]

Kelly clarksons was pretty good! Haha.

[170flyguy]

lol this vid just proves nobody can sing a song lik Mariah her voice is very unique

[VaunTV]

So, basically, Mariah has punched almost everyone out the game? LMAO.

[noctunalguy]

Mariah always be the best

09:39 screaming

09:51 yes, highest note

[marshavalentine]

ms is the way better of all

[turbomeanmachine]

OMG IM LOVING THIS... :D

[redred11212]

But in all in fairness to Regine she did sang it while being hanged... LMAO! She look more of a fairy than a butterfly...

[wezzzy]

wats the documentary u hav on mariah?

[MariahLambie92]

AMEN! Mimi is THE BEST! SONGBIRD Supreme!....