Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (215)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • love this version

  • Jlo "we almost sent her home yesterday"

    jlo and randy, in their heads "lets try and send her home every week during the competition by degrading every perfect performance of hers"

  • did anyone notice steven tyler's little song at 1:35 even he couldnt keep all his love for that incredible voice in!

  • this was the first time i saw haley, i don't rly watch hollywood week and auditions, and i fell in love with her :*)

  • She looks like Christina Aguilera!!

  • Haley Reinhart, this jazzy flower child, this little growler,,,

  • Wow. She ugly, but i do like her sexy shoes! =D

    She did do a nice job on the vocals...

    Jenny Lopez is soooooo freakin' HOT!

    Good Lord. ^o^

  • @NotTwoBrite how is she ugly exactly??????

  • @silentj152 Dear Mr. SilentJ,

    Well, overall she is cute enough, but she has a bit of a butterface....You know, everything is hot and cute but-her-face! =D

    Peace! ^o^

  • @NotTwoBrite the fuck you talkin about? she is really pretty!

  • @howcomeitisthisway24 Ok, Ok...... i take it back!

    i didn't watch this season, so i didn't get to enjoy her in all her hotness!

    i did just watch her Alicia Keys "Fallin" performance and did think she looked pretty nice in her sexy little dress! =D

    And i do love the sexy grrrowl in her voice; she is quite a talented singer!

    A thousand apologies, i beg! God Bless Haley Reinhart! :-)

    Peace! ^o^

  • she is no JACOB LUSK

  • people say she sucked? ugh! as i recall she got the most standing ovations by the judges in American idol history i believe :) shes AMAZING!! totally should have won!!

  • i miss haley. the whole of AI10 was about her.

  • when steve tyler starts chiming in, it reminds me of mumble in happy feet when he just like squawks LOL

    am i the only one that gets reminded by that?

  • How did she not win?

  • @SlothsAndBeyonce obviously because she sucked

  • even the backup singers are smiling haha

  • @lockedinsideurhsbox Check out the backup singers when Haley sings "Rolling in the Deep"! They are amazed by her vocals! :-)

  • Blew the competition out of the water right there!! Wow

  • @mumbalee that was until jacob sang his version

  • @mushoo4 LOL. You even compare Jacob to Haley on songs like this.. sure gospel he takes it..

  • @mushoo4 Okay I actually gave Jacobs version a try.. he over sang. He was trying way to hard and listening to it after this I don't like it. It seems like shes not even trying and singing great and he has to add all tons of shit to his.

  • @Gleek1able HAHAHA! not even trying? she had to try in order to even make it! you think you can just prance into american idol not try and expect to make it through? Dont get me wrong overall i like haley better. But for the performance of this song i would have to give it to jacob

  • @mushoo4 Not even trying means singing just comes natural to her. She hits the notes perfectly and she isn't gasping for breath. Not even trying doesn't mean she literally isn't it just means the notes come to her I feel like she never struggles when she sings live to hit notes. Give it to Jacob doesn't bother me none. He don't got a record deal Haley does. I guess our styles of the way we like songs sung is different.

  • @mushoo4 Also note even trying, she didn't have to add special effects and crap to get the judges to like her. Not counting her growl because that's natural. Natural as in she came to idol with it.

  • @Gleek1able When did he add special effects? it was nothing but him and his voice and his voice can do many things and THAT is natural. he isnt using auto tune or anything so i dont see what your getting at? If his voice can reach those high notes then he should use it anytime when he feels its necessary. Like haley used her growl in every performance she had. Did jacob over do it sometimes? yes he did but all im saying is that Jacob's version was better in my opinion.

  • ughhh she is so beautifulllllll inside and out

  • i love the way steven randomly sings to their songs (:

  • God Bless Haley!!! :-)

  • sound so ugly fucking ugly too

  • @TheAllahonegod Shut the fuck up dirty islamist piece of shit

  • @TheAllahonegod She looked bad in this performance but she is far from ugly.. lol

  • This girl has bigger ***** than `King Kong` her ass is on the line, its NOW!!!! there`s No tomorrow for her, and she comes on stage, with a song that was big in `1941` and makes this song, Her`s comes out, and just BLOWS!!! the song out, you can see the so called judges, were taken back, Steven the ONLY one, who knows what real talent is, WHO has seen thousands of girls, was completely in Haley`s spell, This girl, is the most talented Idol ever

  • who sings this song ..?

  • @ceirawalsh That would be *Billie Holiday* and the song is `God bless the child` Haley change the the song, completely 2 her style, check Mrs, Holiday`s video, 2 see how much!!!

  • she should've won

  • At 1:02 after Haley's growl JLo is like: UGH! That growl! Oh wait Randy likes it so I do too!

  • Skip to the awesome 0:50 you're welcome

  • That Growl! where does that live in a person's body? please do tell :) lol

  • she literally gave me the chills

  • she is the sexy sexy thing

  • the fact that steven said "you made my day thank you" says it all

  • steven's face says it all

  • Haley put Steven Tyler in a trance! :-)

  • that growl=Awsomness:)

    

  • screaming in tune

  • J-Los face says it all...JEALOUSY. 1:02 if you cant tell.

  • I've never heard such a growl in the 10 seasons of AI - or by any other singer that I've ever heard.

    GROWL NUMBER ONE ! Only Sexy Haley can do it -and sing amazingly!

  • Jacob Lusk

  • if they would have "sent her home yesterday" I would still be thinking American idol is crap, generic and not my taste at all. But since there was such an unbelievably talented girl that shook up the competition, I still have some faith for AI on finding very raw and unique talent, with the IT factor. Being able to get together all those runs, and growls making a superb performance. Yes, Haley Reinhart at least she is making a difference for someone. And I'm sure I'm not the only one, at all.

  • thats 'sposed to be 'PierceAbrams' New Orleans jazz Club

  • i love how steven sings with her lol

  • No your all wrong - and the best version is NOT THIS ONE Either ...Is one performed by Haley in New Orleans - and posted (3days ago) by Casey Abrams (PiercedAbrams)

    - This is a Jazz Club owned by Irvin Mayfield - think they'd know music and she brought the house down

    - the last 3 minutes where Mayfieild on trumpet - is answered by Haley vocally IS NOT TO BE MISSED!

  • 0:55

  • @gleek1able no really jacob done it with more passion and hers sounded ugh

  • @blancoscupcake hers was way better than jacobs....by 100000000000000000000x better

  • Lakisha Jones did the best version of this song! Very few can sing as well as Lakisha. Haley isn't in her league by along shot!

  • i hate when jlo says "you made it by the skin of your teeth". it makes me really upset for some reason. probably because i love haley so much.

  • Jacob Lusk done it better

  • @blancoscupcake who? exactly. lol

  • she should release that song!!! her version is just amazing !!

  • She made my day too!

  • This is waay after the fact, but ..... most of the American Idol contestants are bunting or hitting grounders between short & second, lots of small victories, and little danger of falling....Haley keeps swinging for the fences, and quite often connects.....a few strikeouts is a small price to pay for such performances.

  • Awesome performance by Haley. And the rest is history. Haley is going on to greatness.

  • Awesome performance by Haley. And the rest is history. Haley is on her way to greatness.

  • LOL at the end everyone looks like: "we have to compete with that?"

  • @darthGavin just......no

  • I keep going back and forth watching Haley and Jacobs performance of "God Bless the Child" cause they both did a great job!

  • sexy, sultry, growler, luved it

  • The girl has IT!! "It" is going to take her far! I would love to hear her sing the whole song. She is so sexy but can freaking SING!

  • I must say that i really prefer Jacob Lusk's Version of this Song

  • Jacob Lusk murders this any day :)

  • If you look you will see all those musicians wided eyed! I bet they were thinking, "WOW!"

  • I could listen to it on & on!!

  • she sucks *shrugz*.. but she's super sexy

  • this was the song that made me loveee herrrr!!!

  • What song did the sing for the group number that she messed up on? I can't place it even though it sounds so familiar

  • @andrewbeirl According to Wikipedia, it was Carry On Wayward Son by Kansas.

  • @IdolGlotze yup, that's it. Thank you!

  • This was the moment....that I fell in love with Haley! <3

  • @0:02, i would be soo nervous to walk out!

  • and jacob lusk who killed it!!!

  • had no idea it was possible to get goosebumps on my face but that growl just gave them to me..

  • One of her best performances. Also it is the first time Haley ever growled. What an amazing talent!

  • i think she make steven cry a lil bit

  • see the guy giving her a standing ovation at 1:58 ? that guy should be me

  • i feel like as soon as she belted her first line... everyone else was just like "oh fuck..."

  • @bms71488 Yeah and can't you imagine what the next performer was thinking. "Crap!, I have to follow that! " LOL

  • has she been signed to any label yet?

  • @NadiaLFCullen yup! Interscope records same with Lady Gaga and other big artists!

    !

  • @AeolusX100 cool, thanks :-)

  • SHE SOOO PRETTTYYYYYYYYYYYYY

  • When jennifer said " we almost sent her home yesterday" i was thinking yeah, dummy!

  • when she did that growl my throat started to hurt lol

  • Don't you know the person up next was thinking "Damm, I got to follow that!" And the rest were thinking, "Damm, I'm glad I don't have to follow that!". SEXY is an understatement!

  • This is when I fell in love.

  • What a voice!!!

  • Was Steven crying? Anyways, 1:51 was exactly like my reaction to this performance.

  • Steven "You made my day. Thank you."  Ditto! A little piece of Haley every day.

  • 7 people don't understand pure talent

  • haley - the sexy superstar. I have a nickname for her: Haley Magnetic

  • love the growl its so sexy

  • So didn't realise that Haley and Jacob both sang the same song. Imo Jacobs was better by far. Haleys better than Jacob overall, but this version was just.. Yeah. Too much growling and riffs, not that i don't love it when she does that, but yeah. Eh

  • damn haha when they did the flashback to group round, i was like ohhh so THATS when jlo started being a bitch to her..... got it :)

  • @Tulsasparty575 yeah. I already saw it. There was just a mistake about her age.

  • Haley Reinhart - Perfection Incarnate

  • jlo the jerk she's great even when she fucks up

  • Wow, I didn't realize she and Jacob both sang this song in Round 3 until now....in my opinion, Haley's was much better although Jacob's is highly remembered - it could be just because I didn't like Jacob and LOVED Haley.

  • does anyone know the song

    0:27 - 0:35

    thanks!

  • @iStyleNetwork god bless the child , its covered by many people . but look up the billie holiday version , its beautiful<3

  • @laiseylabell i was actually talking about the song that she messed up the words to from 0:27 - 0:35 but thanks anyway, i will look up the billy holiday verson of god bless the child though!! :)

  • @iStyleNetwork Sounds like Carry on my Wayword Son

  • she makes me laugh i cant stop listening to this :)

  • I see Casey at 2:01? <3 lol. But ah always gives me chillls.

  • I love this performance so much. This is the performance that made me become a Haley fan in the first place. It made me realize, she is a great singer, better than the rest, and can win. Unfortunately people are deaf. But seriously the sad thing is she can sing country better than Scotty and Lauren and it isn't her main genre.

  • I love this version and the one by Jacob Lusk. Casey did a great interpretation of Georgia on My Mind. True artists can really interpret jazz...Haley is so good at jazz.

  • I hate that people don't know Billie Holiday.

  • Did someone just say who's the song by....its from the legendary Billie Holiday..you crazy! Lol :)

  • i hate jennifer lopez seriously.

  • omg that was terrible lol

    you're deaf if you think 0:54 to 1:12 was at all good. it was horrible!

  • @ArcticSnoww perhaps not my favorite song by her but there isn't a person alive who can sing like she did 1:14 to 1:28

    oh and BY the way Laurens version of blue was rushed and the yodeling was outright aweful

  • @renduke

    I didn't comment on Lauren. xD

    Not even a fan of her, really.

    I dunno I just don't think in this song it was particularly shining on her part, but that's just me.

  • I'm going to be honest. I thought she over did it, vocally. But then in a recent interview she did, she said this is the point where she learnt for the first time she can growl. It makes sense now. It's like a superhero discovering a new power. She didn't fully used it gracefully here, but overtime she learned how to fully control it. She should have won the season. America got it wrong, IMO. 

  • that is awesome

    i want fool version of this performance in studio version

  • God bless Haley!

  • Mama may have.....PAPAAAAA MAY HAAAVE.

  • i love her and the song who is it by?

  • @Brookeypoo5 I think the original version is by Billie Holiday. But there are many artists who covered this song.

  • @IdolGlotze like jacob lusk who KILLED it!!!

  • @Brookeypoo5 billie holiday

  • amazing chick

  • thank you judges for letting haley through to the next round. we would've lost such an amazing talent otherwise!

  • I've surfed and listened to the different renditions of this song from Billie Holiday to Aretha Franklin to Liza Minelli to Eva Cassidy to Alicia Keys, and I have to say that this is uniquely Haley's version and it sounded like the best one for me. Talk about making this song her own! I hope she gets to release this song because it's really great.

  • she makes me cry

  • Strong voice. I love it :D

  • yupp just here for my daily fix of Diva Reinhart!

  • I don't think J.Lo liked "The Growl" :)). Look at her face, she's shaking her head and when Randy starts aplauding Haleys growl she switches and smiles.

    How can anyone not like that growl? It sent chills through my entire body. Awesome.

  • she's a goddess! no question...

  • having my Daily Dose of Haley.

  • This is amazing but Its not as electrifying as Jacob Lusks performance.. What do you guys think?

  • NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • Lol... she definitely is not Chinese. What is she?

  • Vote for HALEY!! Get her into the finals!!

  • This is why Haley is the best, her voice is never boring, she needs to belt it out like this from now on to win Idol.

  • @xx1x231x actually she has been belting out like this, :D, her voice is just something that we thought extincted a long time ago

  • look at the audience who are also contestants.. haley made this far. also james at the audience.

  • HALEY =

    Hot

    Amazing

    Lovely

    Electrifying

    Youthful

    Haley is so UNIQUE and cutting edge, I totally get her as do most of you - someday the rest of America will wake up!  She is just amazing! :-)

  • Why would Chinese belief matter? Is she Chinese?

  • @GDave92 no. I think she is half german. because its from her family name. "rein". Reinhart. my 2nd name is also has the rein prefix. Reiner.

  • I can't wait to buy her album!

  • @AntMan1980 hell yea

  • VOTE FOR HALEY TONIGHT! no more bottom 3 for all this talent :)

  • this girl is unreal. she has such beautiful range. she can growl, whistle like Mariah carey, and has a bit of a yodelly sound sometimes. she and casey are my faves.

  • OMG if JLo told me like she told Haley I would've sung my butt off like there was no tomorrow too

  • She MUST record this!

  • if she sings like this every time she gets on the stage, she will take the whole damn thing, but she needs to sing with the raw emotion of redeaming yourself after a shitty performance

  • she sang this in december 2009: youtube.com/watch?v=jlchHJ0JpX­­g much more low key but gorgeous nonetheless.

  • When i seen this, i was SOLD. Haley rocks my socks

  • This is unbelievably good and I love watching Paul's arm gestures in the background of the group part :)

  • She is the best singer there...stevens likes her haha

  • Pause at 1:10 ... Steven has a crush on her lol :)