Added: 2 years ago
From: mjbeasty
Views: 1,383,970
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (2,405)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Ming mochdhsoghdokabjsix euros bfodneowjdiehduvddhudhid Chi bfich i u h g iihidndu hcid SDI d d xgrid u übrig b bicbdijc jjcfjcj igun fjcjj jvjrjcjfbjj Ichform unbeschreibliches Lied:D

  • <3

  • this song shows truly that your fighting for medals,love,scars.... and as they say best of all honour. but that's nothing after all the pain and mental distorted you put your give your self. to many people after the war committed suicide and left there family's and all because of are stupid government's!

  • better nerf irelia !

  • @TheWolskii and shen  he op after patch

  • @zotaaxHD Soldiers are stuid minded imho since they joined the army in the first place. That has nothing todo with bravery or patriotism. Thats doing a job which promotes war. Imagine if you nobody would join an army there would be no wars ever and we had this wonderful state named "peace". And using "moron" and "balls" in your argumentations clearly shows me how little you understand of what you are talking about and how narrow-minded your view of the topic complex is. Cheers

  • @myorigaccisbroken Actually ignorant child... if no one signed up they'd enable the draft then they'd send your pussy ass to the front lines against your will or sit your ass in prison....... lucky other men are willing to step up to keep you safe with your pillow at night. ungreatful fuck.. I don't agree with the war or any war really either but respect people are dying doing what they think is right.

  • @myorigaccisbroken Dude, if nobody joined the army they would set up a draft.... You are absolutely retarded. "Yea if nobody joined the armed forces there would be world peace YAY!!!" Well, I wish I was living in that world, but the real world would take your ass, hand you a gun, throw you in the desert, and force you to serve. Welcome to the real world kiddo.

  • @myorigaccisbroken So your calling both my brothers stupid you little shit? the jine to help protect us, and get your head you your ass, there will never be true peace. wanna know why? war is inevitable! just like death.....it will always be there.....no matter where you look.......everything is built on a pile of ashes, blood, shrapnel, and destruction.....that is war...the inevitable truth

  • @TheHUsoldier6 *they*join

  • @myorigaccisbroken Kid, You're fucking stupid, even My uniform could kick your ass.

  • @myorigaccisbroken Right

    an germen statment

    was ist grün und dämlich und sieht den bullen ähnlich

    die bundeswehr die bundeswehr

    wir scheissen auf das ganze heer

  • Comment removed

  • THIS is what I call sad...

    it's just a great song <3

  • That is the most beautiful song I've ever heard...

  • kony 2012

    

  • Comment removed

  • sorry aber jeder der dieses video disliked hat kein nivou.

    sorry but everyone who dislikes this video has no nivou

  • @UniteHunter96 das schreibt man niveau, aber ist ja egal ;P

  • @ContentFX ja habs auch bemerkt hab kein französisch in der schule :-)

  • Very Very Good !!!! :))

  • such a tunes

  • kacke

    

  • @Rumblebee97

    Nette Selbsteinschätzung.

  • Stop Joseph Kony!

  • This is a great song, but does it bother anyone else that he's making so much money criticizing something he really doesn't know about? He was never a soldier, as far as i can tell none of them have been. They really have no idea what they're singing about. it feels like he just read the cliffnotes of some news station reporting on Abu Ghraib and made a satire of his perception of what happened. it just feels so fake and forced.

  • @cyclopsman200 when i hear this song it don't feel forced and faked to me, it's more like there's somebody saying what war is all about. i never have been at war, too, but you can't blame us for, right? rise against is singing about the daily cruel soldiers have to suffer. that there is no place for heroic acts when you have to shoot people. they're telling that war isn't what most of the people think, that there is just cruel and suffer. good that they tell, cuz they are heard.

  • @Eick1995 that might hold a bit more sentiment if it was the 1920's, and everybody thought war was awesome and glorious. but after Vietnam i don't think anyone, anywhere feels that way. its just so stock and safe.and it doesn't sound to me like he's singing about the daily cruel soldiers have to suffer, he sounds like he's singing about how soldiers are daily cruel. Its just that every time i hear this song, it feel like he's one of those people that spat on Vietnam vets when they got home.

  • @cyclopsman200 have you seen the official video to this song?look at tape(dot)tv or google if you didn't.

    there you see, that it isn't mainly the cruel the soldiers causes but the cruel they suffer. Of cause soldiers are responsible for killed people,seperated families and demolished towns, but they also suffer theirselves from what they do, cause they are told to. they have no free will in war, it's the governments. and that's why i respect them and rise against does too. proud to be their fan!

  • @cyclopsman200 One question: Why someone need to was a soldier to know what soldier go through?

    P.S.: Sorry for my bad english...

  • @DHLpenner2 I didn't mean to imply that you had to be a soldier to know what they go through. you can sympathize without having been there yourself. But when you want to actually criticize something or someone, you need to have a bit of knowledge about what your talking about. Like i said, its like those hippies that spat on Vietnam vets. They saw and heard about bad things without context and understanding, and grouped a minority in with a majority.

    Also, don't worry. Your English is fine.

  • @cyclopsman200 First of all thanks for the compliment. Know I know what you mean exactly. ;-)

    DHLpenner2

  • respect who gives his life for we.

  • The lyrics of this song are UNBEARABLE :O Soldiers shouldn't be adored. They should be pittied for being so stupid-minded as to work for such a stupid cause in such a stupid organisation. Make Tea not War!

  • @myorigaccisbroken Tell that to the politicans who start those stupid wars. But don;t you ever call a soldier stupid-minded atleast they have the balls to join the army and fight for the people who live their unlike you who is just commenting here about those soldiers. Many people lost their father,mother and kids in war don't you ever disrespect anyperson who has fought in war you MORON

  • @myorigaccisbroken

    and u think ud do a better job?

    these men and women fight to keep our countries safe from terrorists and u have the guts to say they are stupid minded?!?!?!

    if u wont stand behind our soldiers, please, feel free to stand in front of them.

  • @calumboiiiii Terrorists ? God, listen to yourself... This is just sad man, this is fucking sad.. You gouvernment took the oil and the money of the countries in the middle east and left them that way.

    Now you wonder why they're mad ? And of course, you don't stop, hell no you don't. Because rich people don't give a fuck about the people who have to suffer. I respect soldiers, because they have to stand that kind of shit Rise Against is singing about in this song..

    Peace man !

  • "War is not fun. Thank goodness there are soldiers. Thank you for serving."

    Think you didn't got the point right, did you?

  • and i love this song again and agian *-*

  • Love this song ♥

  • wtf?! DISLIKES?? :O

  • Dieses Lied hat vorgestern in Stuttgart gefehlt..

  • @TheGameYoker In Dortmund auch:/ aber den ihre Konzerte gehen sowas von ab:D:Dund swing life away ist auch ziemlich geil

  • Love my country, fear my government

  • Dieses Lied vermittelt die wichtigste Aussage auf der ganzen Welt hat, es sagt Krieg ist scheiße und er löscht Leben aus und veranlasst schon junge Menschen dazu schreckliche Dinge zu tun.Ich kenne keinen anderes Lied das diese Aussage mit solchen Gefühlen vermittelt ....

  • @Skyliner315 dann hör dir mal my life von jj an 

  • @Skyliner315 da haste recht gutes statement

  • Aber ein bisschen Krieg schadet der Menschheit auch nicht :D denk mal an die Überbevölkerung, die in den nächsten Jahrzehnten richtig zu spüren sein wird. Da wünschten Milliarden sie wären nicht geboren, aber die verhungern/verdursten dann elendig im Dreck.

  • @Nr1DanieL Jo super, durch Krieg lösen wir das Überbevölkerungsproblem, ist auch nicht dein ernstoder? Klar ist es traurig, dass viele Menschen aufgrund von Mangelernährung etc. sterben, doch das sollte doch nicht durch Krieg und Tod zu lösen sein? Das muss anders angegangen werden. Außerdem geht es in dem Lied auch gar nicht darum, sondern darum, was der Krieg alles zerstört und anrichtet. Und wir alle sollten mal darüber nachdenken glaube ich, wirklich vorstellen können wir uns das HIER nicht.

  • a song with message not as the other songs of our time ...

  • "Just carry this gun, You'll even get laid." Did anyone else hear that?

  • :D!

  • @FluXTurmoiL Agreed.

  • @BongaFish I remember when they played this song live, that ':D' was pretty much my face haha. They were pretty amazing.

  • This song reveals the true side of fighting and war. Despite good intentions, it changes a man for the worst. Support our troops, they need it.

  • Morgen in Stuttgart! Ich hoffe sie spielen das Lied!! ♥

  • @ringermane gruselig genau so ist es Youtube, Facebook und Rise Against <3 <3

  • @ringermane Wieso zum Teufel sollte man so etwas liken?!?!

  • @ringermane like wenn du denjenigen auslachst weil er im facebook ist. wir sind live dabei ( rock im park) kennsch :D?

  • @ringermane

    like das wenn du das mit den ohren hörst und atmest :)

  • @ringermane English motherfucker do you speak it?!

  • @DHLpenner2 I really can't understand how someone can be that full of hate against somebody he doesnt even know.. Really, I'd love to know why..

    Isn't this song also about treading everyone equally ?

    He didn't do anything wrong, I suppose..

    Try to get away from that hate man, really, will make you hate yourself as well, eventually..

  • Heute in Dortmund :)

  • @Flowify94 ja und ich bin dabei! genial!

  • I used to identify with the character in this song, i wanted to be there, fighting and defending. now as i see the corruption and tragedy of our greed wars, i endeavor to create technology that will level the playing field for the rest of the world, just wait, give me time, I'll end this. soon resources will be irrelevant

  • but still a good song

  • @SuperNailimixam just not funny at all

  • Wtf warum redet ihr hier über den 2. Weltkrieg? Shut up and enjoy the music!

  • Krieg ist Scheiße.

    Es geht immernur um Geld und Religion (Wobei es da eigentlich auch nur um geld geht).

    Wenn einer der reichsten Menschen der Welt Angst um seine Extramillionen hat, fängt er an über Leichen zu gehen und eine ganze Armee von Menschen in ein fremdes, unschuldiges Land zu schicken, sie dann Amoklaufen sollen. Ich habe aus gutem Grund den Wehrdienst abgelehnt. You've got to die, got to die, got to die for your Government. You've got to die for your country, thats shit! -Anti Flag-

  • @SuperCybertiger Also ging es deiner Meinung nach im zweiten Weltkrieg nur um Religion und Geld,Ja?

    Wäre es dir etwa lieber gewesen wenn dieser Wahnsinnige nicht gestoppt worden wäre?

  • @Insertnamehere188 Wie kann man bitte so eine blöde Scheiße aus meinem Post raus interpretieren -.- Der Zweite Weltkrieg war ein Purer Amoklauf ohne wirklichen politischen Hintergrund

    Aber wo habe ich, dass je gutgehießen?

    Bevor so ein unqualifizierter Müll rauskommt von dir, solltest du erstmal überlegen was mein text zu bedeuten hat. Ich verachte Rassismus, Krieg, Mord, Faschismus und Mobbing zutiefst

  • @SuperCybertiger Ich wollte mich nur vergewissern das du nicht sagen kannst es ginge immer um Geld und Religion.Ich wollte damit nur klarstellen das der zweite Weltkrieg nötig war um einen Wahnsinnigen zu stoppen und ausserdem verachte ich genau wei du die letzter genannten Dinge.Lass mir doch meine Meinung,Danke.

  • @Insertnamehere188 Okay also nur ein missverständnis :) Adolf bekommt in der Hölle sowieso jeden tag eine annanas in den arsch gerammt :D

  • @Insertnamehere188 Was redest du denn für eine Scheiße? Kannst du nicht lesen?

  • @sneekofadown Hallo? Die Frage ist ob du nicht lesen kannst.Ich habe jegentlich klarstellen wollen das der Zweite Weltkrieg nötig war.

    Also ist die Frage:Was redest du fürn Scheiß? :b

  • @Insertnamehere188 Der zweite Weltkrieg war nötig?! Wer hat ihn den angefangen, du Vollidiot? Was hast du in Geschichte? Oder willst du mir im Ernst sagen, dass es nötig war, dass Hitler den Zweiten Weltkrieg begonnen hat?!

  • @sneekofadown Es war nötig Hitler im Zweiten Weltkrieg zu stoppen,les mein Kommentar richtig

    Gegenfrage:Was hast du in Deutsch bzw. Leseverstehen?

    Zu deiner Information ich habe eine 2 in Geschichte,Dummkopf.

  • @Insertnamehere188 In geschi hab ich ne 1 :DD deutsch 3 :/ :D ich weiß das du mich nid meintest aber das musste sein ;)

  • @YorckgoesChelsea ahja ^^

  • @Insertnamehere188 musste sein sry :DD

  • @Insertnamehere188 Du sagtest, der zweite Weltkrieg war nötig, um den Wahnsinnigen zu stoppen - das ist aber nicht richtig, denn der Krieg wurde von dem Wahnsinnigen begonnen. Er war also keine Reaktion auf Hitlers bescheuerte Scheiße, wie es in deinem Kommentar rüberkommt. Es war richtig und notwendig, Hitler zu stoppen - aber nicht, den zweiten Weltkrieg zu beginnen, denn das hat nun mal Hitler getan.

    Ach ja: Ich habe in Deutsch eine 1.

  • Random german people ftw.

  • @BecauseItsIronic Agree, I don't get it ..

  • Ich habe ein Plätzchen (sorry wanted to give the only german i knew a go)

  • @RAW450awesomeman

    hahahaha, laughkick! fucking important sentence in germany! :D

  • es war zwar nicht meine zeit, ich bin '95 geboren, aber wenn man sich mal den Deutschen Text durchliest.......

    Schönes, trauriges Lied

  • FUCK THE ARMY!

    Genialer Song!

  • For the dutch flag (h)

  • Bitte schaut euch dieses bewegende Video an : /watch?v=WhOIKZwsggk

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @motocrossneversdorf ich hoffe einfach mal das ist nur ein schlechter witz und du hast den ganzen text des songs verstanden. Ansonsten tust du mir echt leid.

  • @motocrossneversdorf Junge, wie alt bist du? 10? Sowas ist echt bitter...

  • @motocrossneversdorf Ich piss dir gleich in den Arsch und jetz halt deine Fresse und hör andere Musik, weil du hast es NICHT verdient solche Musik wie diese zu hören.

  • @motocrossneversdorf

    witzig nicht war? :DD

    NEIN -.-

    weißt du... ich wette dass das das einzige war was du im gesamten text übersetzen konntest... ein normaldenkender Mensch kann doch nicht so ignorant und nievaulos sein sich über sowas lustig zu machen oder bin ich da falsch informiert?

  • ich habe viel gesehen ich habe gesehen,wozu ein mensch fähig sein kann und dieses lied spiegelt all diese gefühle perfekt wieder

  • Ich finde es toll, hier englische und deutsche kommentare lesen zu können, OHNE dass die einen auf die andren losgehn... in anderen Kommentaren unter anderen liedern muss ich immer wieder lesen, dass leute von außerhalb uns als N*** beschimpfen, sobald sie deutsche Kommentare lesen... diese Tatsache, dass dies hier nicht der Fall ist, find ich toll :)

    And @mjbeasty : thanks for uploading ;)

  • HOW CAN U DISLIKE THIS SONG

  • I've hated every Rise Against song that I have heard on the radio but this one is amazing; I think that I am going to have to give this band a second chance.

  • @TheGeneralGandhi you better -.-

  • carrying a withe flag means, that you come in peace ...

    

  • @derMutterer ich glaub dass es in F dur is ;)

  • Can somebody explain verse 5+6 to me? Who is She?

  • @yxcvx I think it's a "civillian". just a Victim of the war and "the flag white as snow" is just the sign to give up. Just the white flag

  • @LightAndLiving Thanks

  • @yxcvx think it was a little girl

  • Comment removed

  • in welcher tonart ist das lied geschrieben ? schnelle antwort wäre schön ;)

  • I find it kind of sad, that many people don't get the meaning of this song.

  • @MuayThaiFighter4

    no im a boy :D

    but i love this song! it is so fantastic!

  • I hear this song 24 hours a day *-*

    I can't stop hearing this song! <3

    I LOVE IT! *_* <3

    Rise Against 4-ever!

  • @TheFo0l94 yeah im just curious...are u a girl...cuase thats something a girl would say

  • but what can you call a hero of war? someone that survives and comes back to his/her family? someone that kill a terrorist for the safety of many people? or the person who dies serving his/her country to make a free and peaceful place to live?

  • ähm...not thank godness there are soldiers...why are there fu*king soldiers??

    Why are they serving....and against what??

    Tell me!!?

  • @ModernSkyField They are fighting against the greed for Force!

    (sry, I dunno if "greed for Force" is right, because I'm not English)

  • @ModernSkyField My friend, freedom is not free. The army serve to preserve our freedom, and restore freedom throughout the world. They defend our rights, without them, we are vulnerable.

  • @ModernSkyField They defend your right of free spech for example, so you can be an asshole over the internet.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • chills.

  • Hammer Lied♥

    Auch noch 2012

    Und für immer :)

  • Comment removed

  • great song ...

    playing it with my band ;D

    

  • Comment removed

  • my best friend wants to be a hero of war when he gets out of highschool. hes like a brother me. i love him so much. id give my life for him if i had to. he has a girlfriend who hits him and screams at him for everything . hes always stressed because of her, i wish he would notice how much he means to me. it hurts so much to think of loosing him if he really does go into the army . but id even loose him. if it meant he was happy. thats all i want to see him be.

  • The great irony is, he mocks those that give him the rights to be a complete uneducated moron. I'm glad they defend his rights but Rise Against lost a fan with this garbage. It was fun while it lasted guys

  • @TheDczarnecki Shut up idiot

  • @TheDczarnecki yup becase Iraq had either terrorists or WMDs oh and btw even if Iraq did have WMDs the no fly zone set up by the U.N. would have knoked any attempts to use them out of the sky

  • @TheDczarnecki are you fucking retarded. In this song he is not mocking the soldiers he is talking about how many innocent people die. In the middle east where wars are happening the civillians dont understand english so when they are told to stop they walk forward, of course soldiers are forced to shoot. Also many soldiers get carried away and lose their sense of humanity thus causing them to do horrible things. He is in no way mocking soldiers so get some common sense before you speak.

  • @TheDczarnecki you are a fucking idiot. im gald you arent a fan because you didnt understand the meaning.

  • how is the struming in hero of war ? ??????

  • This song is saying everyone who goes to war is not exactly a hero, And then ones that really are hero's face tough challenges .

  • It is an unfortunate fact that we can secure peace only by preparing for war... *JFK*

  • I may not agree with the lyrics of this song... but I will defend to the death their right to sing it.

  • Es gibt viele menschen die einfach liken und nicht wissen um was es in diesem lied geht und es ist schrecklich um was es in diesem lied geht weil es die wahrheit vom krieg zeigt und des ist echt traurig das es den menschen so kaputt macht das es ihm egal ist wie der andere darunter leidet und ich hoffe das es bald vorbei ist mit den kriegen weil DIESES lied hat mich dazu gebracht das ich krieg hasse und ich bin froh dieses lied gehört zu haben weil einen traurig macht wenn er weiß um was es geht

  • @6000Creeper ich war selber im Krieg, zwar nicht an der front, sonst könnte ich das jetzt nicht schreiben, aber selbst dann ist es hart. krieg macht ein kaputt, ich bin sanitäter. und ich wache jetzt, 2 jahre nach dem ich dort war, nachts immernoch total verschwitzt und von albträumen gequält auf... dieses lied war sozusagen unsere hymne

  • @framesOfMindFan also weißt du wie schlimm es ist und ich finde des lied sagt alles

  • @framesOfMindFan Danke!

  • @6000Creeper besser kann mans nicht zusammenfassen. ich werd jedesmal sentimental wenn ich diesen song höre. Krieg ist grausam und im Endeffekt immer sinnlos.

  • @6000Creeper ja ich hasse ebenfalls krieg und dazu hat nicht nur dieses lied beigetragen ! aber das der krieg bald vorbei ist ? wie stellst du dir das vor? menschen bekriegen sich leider nun schon seit ewigkeiten und im moment ist der weltfrieden wohl noch ein wunschtrum so leid es mir auch tut das zu sagen )=

  • @6000Creeper Ich stimme mal zu, blinde likes sind sch**ße. Ich hab den Song allerdings geliket, weil ich den Inhalt verstehe und es gut finde, dass die Band ein solches Thema behandelt.

  • I think that the meaning of this song is that Heroes Of War just don't exist, beacause there's nothing heroic in the violences and cruelties that soldiers have to do when at war...

    war is just the top of mankind's cowardice...

  • @druunniiajer putting their lives on the line every day isn't heroic? please explain lol... i mean sure torturing soldiers isn't heroic but most don't have the balls to do what soldiers have too every day at war...

  • @mrsmileycorps I'm sorry, I have to disagree...There's nothing heroic in dying for the economical interests of few people. Soldiers are seen by their commandants just like pawn in a checkerboard and I think this means only to make a regress and an offence to their being human... maybe the good thing in soldiers is their belief in brotherhood and friendship, 'cause in this condition you give and recive strenght, by men you live side by side...

  • @druunniiajer Agreed

  • "We all became friends"? Not just friends, brothers, but even that can not come close to the bond formed between soldiers. Thank god they volunteer for such jobs. (I was planning on serving as have my father, grand fathers and great grandfathers until I developed a condition that stops me from serving)

  • I'm Lovin it :*

    

  • Greetz from Germany !! We love Rise Against <33

  • @ProfPHiLeX Greetz was fürne grütze schreib wenigstens deutsch wende sowas schreibst und nich mit östereicher Dialek ;)

  • My best friend went into basic training and he told me to listen to this song and if he ever got into war think of that. .-. i cried for two days.

  • @MiddyDeme You do realise if you're taking in the intended meaning of this song that it would probably just make you feel worse if he went to war?

  • "War is not fun. Thank goodness there are soldiers. Thank you for serving."

    You completely misunderstood this song.

  • German Bundeswehr 4 ever but DAMN I love this song

  • this song is just amazing...

  • :,( <3 I love this song!