Added: 5 years ago
From: ChakramXWP
Views: 37,534
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (77)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I've always thought Holly was by far the most talented actress on the show, then Shannen and Alyssa were both equally incredible... Rose never really did it for me though.

  • @ForLifetATu no soory!!!!! she means that she came across the original in 2011 :) i wigh though!!!!

  • i think alyssa and holly act like their characters but rose is very different from Paige.

  • I love Peige way more than Prue!

  • though most people dislike rose mcgowan...i love her.<3.

  • I'm so nostalgic! I totally missed Charmed as a teen, when it played on tv. I was in another dimension, even though my pagan friends were crazy about it! I discovered the series in 2011!!! Talk about late! Now I'm all into it... alone.

  • @0TheSeeker but Jennifer love Hewitt is too much like phoebe, girly. The show needed a quirky, different character to brighten the show up.

  • I think that Shannen was the best actress out of them all. They way she hit her lines was perfect. However, I do think Rose McGowan is a star. They are all gorgeous but Rose is exceptional. I thought Alyssa got more comfortable with her part as the show went on. She was a little awkward the first season. And she may have developed into the most versatile actress after charm. Holly seemed to be the rock of the show. She brought the normalcy the show needed.

  • @MrDoug41

    Though i got use to Rose , i think she was a miscast, i did not like her for this part .The part of Paige Mathews should have gone to Jennifer Love Hewitt instead.It would have been perfect.

  • I Miiss Prue

  • Personally. I liked the show better without Prue in it. it was always centered on her. Paige made is so much more fun. If they had kept Shannen in it, it probably would have been the same until the end. Rose changed the whole mood of the show.

    Hey, I love Shannen, but I love Rose more.

  • @Cutejess2407 ye but then it was all centered around phoebe

  • @CampRockfan40 Yeah I guess. But it also centered around Piper alot as well.

  • @Cutejess2407 yeah Charmed got like amillion times better when rose came... i mean shannens character had nothing going for her but arrognace, thats why the show was able to survive 5 seasons without her...imagine if holly or allyssa, left? now that wouldve been bad for the show.

  • I loved Shannon but I love Rose too she is awesome!!! She puts a different look onto the show!!! In a good way!!!

  • Ah, I love the character Paige and Rose was amazing .

    Although, I still love the original sisters together.

  • I love all of them !! <3 , aaron spelling and all the rest of the produsers did a really good job and holly , rose , alyssa and shannen are very very good actresses . <3 all of them . dorian gregory , julian mcmahon and brian krause are very hot and great actors too (L) :)

  • I think all the Charmed Ones are great in their own ways :) And I dont even wanna choose between the seasons with Shannen or the seasons with Rose because even though its not the same with Shannen it's still fantastic :) I love the show from the beginning till the end :)

  • Okay, guys, seriously. We don't know what really happened on the set of Charmed. So judging ANY of the actresses is quite unfair. Why is there all this bashing going around? We all love Charmed. Can't we leave it at that?

    If you have nothing nice to say, you really shouldn't say anythign at all.

  • Aw i don't think so. Rose McGowan was always my favorite, Alyssa, then Piper and with Prue bringing up the rear. I always thought she came off snooty in both real life and on Charmed, and though I'm not TV obsessor (I rarely watch) I have all the Charmed DVD's, I grew up on it. No one ever agrees, a lot of people are big Prue shippers, but I like Rose. She's very real and still has that sarcastic witty charisma Shannen did on the show, but less...idk, b*tchy.

  • @NevermoreXD27 I agree! her character did come off bitchy. That's why i liked Rose better because she made it so much more fun.

  • @madam Not to mention her even bigger feuds on 90210!

  • shannen was the best she was the lead charcter it said on the wikipedia i love shannen and alyssa the most but they fought alot and yes shannen could be mean sometimes but she is a very good actress

  • why are so many ppl commenting here like u noe the actors personally?:S I dnt get it...ppl are saying stuff like "shannen was a total bitch!" "shannen is SUCH a great person!!" "julian and alyssa wud make such a cute couple outside of the show." ....ppl shud realize that actors are NOT the roles they play...u may "know" the characters on the show well...but that doesn't mean you know what the actors who play them are like:)

  • @Kammar05025 Um the reason people say Shannen is this and that because Shannen had an fight with Alyssa and people arent acting as if they are like their characters on the show but because of the research to the reason why she left.

  • @Kammar05025 I agree! That bugs me so much too. No one here knows the actresses personally so no one should be judging or saying anything.

  • @Kammar05025 Couldnt agree with u more. The only thing that is sencible for us to judge, is their acting, not their love lives or their personalities off screen.

  • wow its like the same comment over and over again!

  • does anyone know any of their numbers? or anything like that?

  • and you know this because? were you there? no so shut the fook up Shannen is not a bitch she and Holly are still best friends and Holly would not be her friend if she was a bitch.

  • Christina Aguilera sucks...why don't you get a hearing aid and maybe a brain before you make lude and lascivious remarks.

  • *lewd

  • A Hearing aid? I watched the fucking show..

    I dont give a fuck if you talk shir about christina aguilera.. im a fan of hers but I dont know her personally so i dont give a fuck, be ahater idc. Its my opinion, Paige sucks.. Prue pwns.

  • Apparently your stupider than I initially perceived...Just because you watched the show doesn't mean you heard and or interpreted things correctly, and if anyone is a hater it would be you...you should consider opening your eyes and shutting your mouth, and adding words other than fuck to your vocabulary...and just because your a fan of Christina Aguilera doesn't mean she doesn't suck.

  • Okay, and obviously you're stupid, because "stupider", isn't even a word. Stop trying to be big shit on the net. Its my opinion on the show.. I liked the original charmed ones better, thats my opinion. Also I could give 2 shits whether or not you think Christina Aguilera sucks.. She has more celebrity status than this pale white ho.. so that says something.

  • I think stupider should be a word,and that's my opinion,your clearly a hypocrite for calling me"a big shit"for expressing my opinions,when you expect me to accept yours.Which is a lot stupider than using stupider as a word.Between Rose McGowan and ChristinaAguilera,I think it's pretty damn obvious that the one that dresses in slutty outfits that a hooker wouldn't even wear,and sings songs about being dirty,and is so undeniably nasty that Family Guy made fun of her would be the one to call a ho

  • Wait.. I think we're on the same side because we're defending Shannen.

  • I'm not even talking about Shannen in the comment you replied to, but for the record I have nothing against Shannen Doherty, and whatever happened between her and Alyssa Milano is their business...I just think it's ridiculous that so many people(including myself in some heated situations)insult either of the fantastic actresses purely based on what they think happened between the two, and whats even worse is when people like yourself drag Rose into it, when all she did was take an oppurtunity

  • Oh i totaly get it now your one of those people that act ghetto,and even if you do live in the getto you dont have to be so bitter i know people that live in a ghetto and they are not so mean.

  • I act ghetto? How the fuck do I act ghetto? Is your brain even connected, maybe you should see someone to get it up and running properly. Hater.

  • Hater that is soo ghetto

  • Yeah, I'm ghetto as hell.

    Gangster <3 With a name like Punkin? Please, you're one to talk.

  • then y did u say u dont act ghetto on here

  • Look, I'm not going to argue with you here, I'm not going to waste my time with you anymore, I have too much respect for the person who uploaded this video, than to tag it up like this. Have a nice day.

  • thank you, you have a nice day as well.

  • wow your an ignorant dumbass!

  • I'm an ignorant dumbass because I have my own opinion? I'm sorry I'm not exactly like you and that I have my own opinion and I speak my mind.

  • haha yeah you really need to find another excuse thats not going to work all through your life

  • thank god for your opinion otherwise i would still be the only one confronting c.a.08 and his/her "opinions"....

  • *Brad Kern is an executive producer as well...

  • Shannen could have also handled the controversy better...she stated that she wants to enjoy her working environment and not have to deal with "people who bitch about it",when it's a proven fact that she was the antagonist. In the interview above Alyssa handles the situation very well and stays focused on talking about her aspirations for the show, rather than dragging her feelings about Shannen into it...

  • Brad Kern (writer) even said that the cast was great except for the problems with Shannen ...Don't get me wrong I'm a fan of all the girls of Charmed, but besides having negative tension between Shannen and Alyssa, Shannen was also dating Julian McMahon during season three and probably wasn't too thrilled with the idea of her rival(if you could call her that)having intimate scenes with her boyfriend,or at least I wouldn't be happy about it, especially if the girl is as pretty as Alyssa Milano.

  • So,why didn't they continued the episode with Shax,with Paige?

  • Shannen wanted out and she even said that she did not have good attitude on set and didn't get along with Alyssa. Shannen has had history of causing problems on set. Although the first 3 seasons were good the show was better with Paige.

  • Shannen and Hally are the best Charmed Ones.And the person that call her a biatch is biatch yourself.Shannen is the best that this should had and she should'nt have left

  • Can I just say I dont hate her or anyone I just dont like her I find her very false and I dont think her acting is that amazing either. Shannen & Holly were the acting talent on Charmed Alyssa & Rose dont come close.

  • By the way "charmedreturnz" I have seen every role Alyssa and Rose have ever portrayed and they are both fantastic actresses...just because you don't like them in the show doesn't mean you can make ill informed accusations about actresses you clearly haven't seen much of...you took a very cheap shot, and as far as I'm concerned your opinion is beyond distraught, and therefor inadmissible.

  • i AGREE... Shannen Doherty was an incredible actress and so was Holly. Rose she doesn't even have facial expressions..and Alyssa..she was pretty good..but shannen did incredible things.

  • yes she does to u wach the show u idiot!

  • aa i did watch watch the show..and nothing you say, including your lame insults will change the fact that shannen doherty was the much stronger actress.

  • yeah i do agree i love shannon wwaaayyy more but rose is still good and it's not like it's her fault shannon left so quit bein a jerk!!

  • no, you're right it's not rose's fault that shannon left. But i guess I blame ber by default.

  • I love Alyssa!

    I think she and Julian make a good couple out of the programme!

    X

  • how can you hate alyssa???????

  • Alyssa Is The Besttt!! Part From Holly..Cant Believe You Hate Her!!!!

  • I like Alyssa..stop hatin lol

  • I seriously cant stand Alyssa Milano it should have been her who left not Shannen

  • i dont think the show would have done as well if Alyssa had left

  • Me too

  • hello shannen was the one who was the bitch through out the seasons. she slapped alyssa milano during rehearsal one time, and she was a pill to work with!! ask anyone. in every show she's been on she has been the most hated person on set!!!

  • Comment removed

  • cool ! thx

  • Great video...am a huge fan of Charmed..sad it's finished! Char

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more