The point is not if she is a mezzo or not... I think she knows better than everyone here what she is, please. But the real point is music. Is it music? Yes, beautiful music... So, we can start discussing the quality of the voices rather than vocal range.
I don't understand people who think if a mezzo does a soprano role/aria decently we should at least give her credit for trying... I mean singing is singing... if u want to sing something, make sure you will do so superbly, like what celicia does here.... This is one of my fav recordings... Incredible... Only second to barbara schlick...
Lo siento mucho pero la interpretación de Inger Dam-Jensen es muchísimo mejor, de lejos, mucho más bella que la de Cecilia, cuya voz en este caso parece muy baja y casi inaudible.
@Samarachelle I've heard several sopranos sing it in this key. And I also know she's a mezzo. I guess I need to pull up an original score to see what key its in. Even the opera Norma is performed in a lower key from the original intended, even at the Met. I've heard Bartoli in soprano roles, and she's great doing both, so I'm sure a whole or half step higher would not break her. :-)
unica cantante barocca nel vero senso del termine: capace cioè di suscitare meraviglia, stupore e commozione quando l'ascolti! la sua voce è strumentale, elettrizzante nelle agilità, la musicista è impeccabile, ma al tempo stesso l'interprete è partecipe e comunicativa.... grande bartoli....
The point is not if she is a mezzo or not... I think she knows better than everyone here what she is, please. But the real point is music. Is it music? Yes, beautiful music... So, we can start discussing the quality of the voices rather than vocal range.
mariliamesmo 4 months ago 3
I don't understand people who think if a mezzo does a soprano role/aria decently we should at least give her credit for trying... I mean singing is singing... if u want to sing something, make sure you will do so superbly, like what celicia does here.... This is one of my fav recordings... Incredible... Only second to barbara schlick...
CallasAfrica 5 months ago
Who on earth cares about labels like mezzo or soprano when someone sings like this? If I were Caesar, I would leave the world for Cecilia Bartoli.
panajody 7 months ago 2
è abbassata di mezzotono!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Dish951 1 year ago
I love this. Maybe better than some sopranos have done it. Great job Cecilia!
musikenergy 1 year ago
So so super beautiful :)
SawyersSexy 1 year ago
Lo siento mucho pero la interpretación de Inger Dam-Jensen es muchísimo mejor, de lejos, mucho más bella que la de Cecilia, cuya voz en este caso parece muy baja y casi inaudible.
nancyfi 1 year ago
divina mon amour.
andmat5 1 year ago
agreed Motetftw! its a shae she didnt embellish the second part! it would have made it more interesting but overall wow! i love her voice
eebaism 2 years ago
Who's that yuts that gave Bartoli less than 5*?
whoever you are, you've got issues.
Cecilia does an exquisite and smooth job. There should be an extra sixth star for that.
On top of that, she's really a mezzo, and she tackles that soprano part like a GOOD soprano.
So, there.
compeld2sing 2 years ago 2
@compeld2sing and on top of all this she is a gorgeous lady!
oliviasmulyan 4 months ago 2
Cecilia does so many superb jobs on soprano aria's that I start doubting if she even is a mezzo.
ciguenitacanta 2 years ago 8
@ciguenitacanta This version is in a lower key.
Samarachelle 1 year ago
@Samarachelle No its not. She's singing it in the original key.
musikenergy 1 year ago
@musikenergy No. Look up any other version. Cecilia Bartoli is a mezzo, and as a soprano I sing this in F major (original key).
Samarachelle 1 year ago
@Samarachelle I've heard several sopranos sing it in this key. And I also know she's a mezzo. I guess I need to pull up an original score to see what key its in. Even the opera Norma is performed in a lower key from the original intended, even at the Met. I've heard Bartoli in soprano roles, and she's great doing both, so I'm sure a whole or half step higher would not break her. :-)
musikenergy 1 year ago
@musikenergy It wouldn't, I've heard her do Queen of the Night. Was just saying this is a lowered version. :)
Samarachelle 1 year ago
She is breathtaking ...
I almost can't believe how beautiful is this !
This is the best aria I've ever heard and that I'll probably never hear again in my life.
musiccoloratura 2 years ago 2
Cecilia Bartoli is an amazing singer, but I am disappointed that she did so few embellishments in the D.C. :(
Motetftw 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
unica cantante barocca nel vero senso del termine: capace cioè di suscitare meraviglia, stupore e commozione quando l'ascolti! la sua voce è strumentale, elettrizzante nelle agilità, la musicista è impeccabile, ma al tempo stesso l'interprete è partecipe e comunicativa.... grande bartoli....
vincik80 3 years ago 3
Quite special!
Cecilia is actually a mezzo, yet she's
doing a super job on a soprano aria.
hereismy2cents 3 years ago 4