@1mursyid1 no, not japanese, possibly russian/polish but those are complete guesses on my part so don't take my word for it, it's probably on the internet somewhere
FMA or FMAB if you're a fan and rated either of them really low, much less than it should (for example on imdb or Animenewsnetwork) because of the silly reason that one is better than the other. Then you are an idiot. Same goes for this song, and something like Happiness ~Requiem from The Blind Alchemist~ from FMAB.
For me personally I think that FMA is better than Brotherhood. The first 10 episodes for FMA were really emotional and had me hooked. FMA's story was more emotional while Brotherhood was more action or so it would seem (Roy vs Lust as opposed to Lust getting killed off my Wrath). I also did not like the ending of Brotherhood compared to FMA because I like the idea that our world and their world are two different entities (Alchemy does not work in our world) made the story so much more human. ♥
FMA has a simpler plot than Brotherhood. The brothers Ed and Al. Their love to each other.Their sin. Homunculus, a symbol of that. Confrontation with Mother, the root of everything (Sloth, Dante). "Where have we come from, and where will we go?"
And a lot of "brothers" appear in FMA. Russell brothers, Scar and his brother, Ishval kids... Like the echo of the Elrics. All the elements unite and form "the story of the brothers Ed and Al" . So it seems to me that this song fits to FMA perfectly.
@mirraco24 I'm sorry but Wrath is not horrid ok he cry a lot but he is not horrid by the way I love that song this is the must relaxing song of Fullmetal Alchemist
@blekmaster12 FMA original is much more creative, and has a lot of twists, but Brotherhood's story was absolutely incredible, since it was thought out before in the form of the manga.
@blekmaster12 I agree! At first, I preferred Brotherhood simply because I preferred the plot, but upon reflection, I find it incredibly hard to find which one is superior in my opinion. 2003 is more emotional, but Brotherhood has a better plot.
I'm actually thinking of making a video comparing the two and seeing which one is better. (Similar to Nostalgia Critic's "Old vs New" series.) Although, it'll be a while before that video can see the light of day.
@blekmaster12 Of course the first series is better!! Better OST, character development/story is outstanding, action/comedy is excellent, oh I could go on and on!!! FMA for life!! " To gain something, you must give up something with equal value" - Best quote ever.
@TheEyrton brotherhood follows the manga (original story) the other is (bar a few episodes) a separate story with a different antagonist and different plot in general
@blekmaster12 i know, they each have really good episodes. like FMA has mustangs dog speech, and FMAB dont. but FMAB is better cause its longer, and much more satisfying. i mean come on, i think we can all agree that ed getting stuck in london is the most random and terrible ending ever. am i right people?
@jennaleem you are all FUCKING MORONS the creator greatly aproved of the ending of the first fma and i very much support the ending as i think that the brothers should get close to reuniting and then be seperated as it leads to yet another problem for them to solve and then be reunited on the other side of the gate
@blekmaster12 I would choose Brotherhood, since it follows the plot of Manga more. Original FMA was great, true, but for me Brotherhood was, and still is, the true Fullmetal Alchemist.
@blekmaster12 "Full Metal Alchemist" is about the truth and it showed us all as fans we can't always have what we want, things don't always fall the way we want them hence that everyone wanted ed and al to return to each and live happy ending in the episodes but it didn't
"Full Metal Alchemist brotherhood" was about hard work paying off and them returning to their normal bodies and them having that happy ending. There both really great!!
@BRONXGIRL123456789 i know it showed more, i read the manga before it was made into a series and i watch the series and i am going to watch the new movie that just got released for it, brotherhood had other key points to it like the homunculus not all being evil and stuff and way other stuff. regardless you loved the show and i loved it also.
@blekmaster12 I say Brotherhood, because I just believed it to have better animation, better voice acting, it followed the story to the manga more accurately and it had a more satisfying ending. However, I still rate the first Fullmetal Alchemist series as my second favourite anime, with Brotherhood being at the top.
@blekmaster12 I watched the whole original series in 3 days and loved it! and then I went to brotherhood and they changed Alphonse and I just couldn't stand to watch it.
emo? When i say your stupid, you REALLY are stupid, you've never met me or talked to me before this arguement, you don't know what i am, you don't even know what music i like, until now you had NO IDEA that i have a list of 67 different bands i like, and "gym class heroes" "cataracts" and EMINEM, a FUCKING RAPPER, god... I can't stand idiots
@xXomgitslokiXxX I was calling you a emo for how you seem to be opposed with sad crap, just as i pointed out with quotes. It doesn't matter how many Bands/artists you like. The fact that you think it does is silly. EMINEM is a poor choice he has what 1 non-whining CD? Please learn to read and listen because like before you stated everything you like from FMA, almost every ounce of it is originally from the manga (brotherhood) aside form the mother being a homocili.
@xXomgitslokiXxX " "you call me stupid, well look at yourselfs!" All i need to quote is right here. If you plan on calling someone stupid, make sure to say yourselves right." I didn't call you anything... but now i am learn to read idiot. clearly you are stupid just as i knew you were when you were talking about how the 2003 anime is the original source. I don't need a "comeback" because you know nothing. BTW you don't need to quote band names smartguy. deeper idiot stupid deeper idiot stupid..
I think if Ed and Al were sisters, the entire series just wouldn't have been the same. A sisterhood and brotherhood are both beautiful, but they work in different ways, and I think in the story of FMA, anything other than a brotherhood (such as a sisterhood, parent-child bond, or even friendship) between Ed and Al wouldn't have given the same emotional impact...
@ImmaEminem wtf, im not even being rude. But are you for real. ive only watched the japanese version, but ive seen a few clips of the english version...seems so dead man.
and if you were even listening to what im saying, i said its because its deeper, i hate it when people do this, "you need a reason to back it up" no I don't! As long as i'm stating A reason it's good enough, I said the series is deeper, it's funnier, better acting, and shorter then the other one, I mean, a longer series can be good, but if it goes on and on it kindof ruins the whole fucking series, god, I hate people, you can't even argue good, you just state random reasons that aren't relevant
@xXomgitslokiXxX "you call me stupid, well look at yourselfs!" All i need to quote is right here. If you plan on calling someone stupid, make sure to say yourselves right. Also if you think you "explained the series" then why is everything you stated from episode 1-25, there is more episodes ya know. I brought up the emo thing because everything you said about the show was sad moments, seeing how you like them so much and like bands like 3 days grace... your an emo.
@DerpyFlerpy Again, pointing out things that aren't neccesary, yep, you are an idiot -__-'', what does three days grace even have to do with what i like and don't like? and really, correct me on one word? That's all you could come up with for a comeback, weak. Saying one word wrong doesn't make me an idiot. -_-' wow.
@xXomgitslokiXxX Deeper... I don't think you know what that means... Depth maybe? Lets see this :"Ed and Al fucking lost there mother!", "dad NEVER FUCKNG THERE FOR THEM THROUGH ANYTHING", "they lost everything!", " THEY LOST EVERYTHING! ", " oh, so happy, NOT! how dare you even say it's not the best!", "I hate people", WHAAAAA go cry emo kid and grow up so you can see more then 1 emotion. I tried my best to get a quote out of anything you said that wasn't whining or about sad crap. BOOOHOOO
do you even know what a troll is? A troll is someone who posts random comments where it isn't even neccesary, and harmlessly just annoys people, pfft.
"Emo/hipster bands? I never even mentioned emo or hipster at all! And how do I not have a clue what i'm saying? I just explained the whole series, you call me stupid, well look at yourselfs! Your saying things that don't make any sense, i didn't mention anything about music, and how i don't know what i'm talking about when i explained the series, and have watched it three times now, i don't understand, you both are fucking idiots
I have no problems with peoples opinion, but saying "This one is better IMO" and "This one is so much more emotional and the other one has a crappy story and characters" is completely different. Not having reasons why its "better" shows you clearly don't have a clue what your saying is better. I just wanted to know why it has better things, if you can't back anything up ( In a logical sense, Emotion = Hate,happy,sad,envy... not OMG THIS ONE IS SADDER !EMOTION!) then stick to just IMO its better.
Actually, Brotherhood isn't a "copy of the original". Brotherhood IS the original. Just like Hellsing and Hellsing: Ultimate. The first series is loosely based on the original story, while the latter is the true story. The original series is a separate anime than the actual FMA story, while Brotherhood is the full, real FMA story.
I love FMA too, but there's hardly any logic in your argument, and you're so hostile about it that it's hard to tell whether you're serious or trolling.
@xBradums The only thing xXomg... states that isn't from the manga (brotherhood) is that their mom is a homunculi. He clearly knows nothing about this. Probably only like it because its sad. looking at his comments I found : 1. Words - Mainstream and Label 2. bunch of the emo/hipster bands. He is clearly one or the other and around 13-16 years old. "Ed's hair is NOT that blonde" /wrist :P
Last one; Just a fucking copy of the ORIGINAL series, crappy voice acting, not even fucking funny moments! that isn't FMA, that's just a sad excuse for an anime, and Ed's hair is NOT that blonde, you fucking idiot! GO DIE OFF OF A FUCKING CLIFF!! your head is so thick you can't even see my poitn of view, your like a machine, fight fight fight, MORON
Continued; out tucker was using his family to transmute them into human speaking chemera's? oh, so happy, NOT! how dare you even say it's not the best! THAT series means everything to me! And what can the other series offer for me?
continued; al was being sucked into the gate, and there mom wasn't even human! they lost everything! Yet there here trying to get it all back, the rest of the series, there looking for the philosophers stone to GET there BODIES back, and ed feels bad for what happened to al, THEY LOST EVERYTHING! yet here they are trying to get it all back, and when they found
and how the fuck is it not deep!? Ed and Al fucking lost there mother! There dad was NEVER FUCKNG THERE FOR THEM THROUGH ANYTHING/! they loved her, so they tried to bring her back, al lost his body, and ed lost two limbs, it was a HORRIBLE experience from them, ed was bleeding and screaming in pain,
They are both made by the same production BONES. Bones created Fma 2003 nd fmabrotherhood, They were made to be diffrent for a reason. Hiroma Arakawa didnt like dark things, thts why she added a bit more humor in fma manga, Fma 2003 had humor too, but also had deep sessions. Lets put it this way, Both fma is an excellent story, animation is great, and has exspressive emotions,
OKAYY FOR EVERYONE WITH THIS FMAB VS FMA, first of all i would love to give all the credits to Hiroma Arakawa, the creator, Fullmetal alchemist has two diffrent personalities, and meanings, Full Metal alchemist 2003, shows relationship nd emotions between Ed And Al, and yes the story is deep,sad, and dark, FmaB is the same way, but it goes with relation between friends and trust, i say its action packed and also a story.
@DerpyFlerpy what the fuck does coldplay have to do with shit!? And how the fuck is my arguement invalid, I think brotherhood is a stupid fucking series that doesn't go deep at all, and it isn't the same, it makes ed and al seem fucking stupid and the funny scenes aren't as funny, the ORIGINAL series is much better, you are a fucking idiot
Well i guess its like this. If you like story and characters you'll prefer brotherhood. If you like Drama and sad emotional moments you'll prefer FMA. ( this is all on the 25+ episodes 1-25/1-10ish don't count as they are the basically the same thing) Reason i say sad is because that is the emotion FMA prays on the most from Wrath emo'in to the 2 bittersweet endings.
@DerpyFlerpy Simple for me: I couldn't engage with Brotherhood. It was forever missing something and the directing + script were just not up to the standard of 2003 for me. The characters were also ripped apart and rebuilt to be completely different, and that saddens me. Soundtrack wasn't great, and since I'm a high sucker for drama, the lack of emotion was staggering, for I saw 2003 the week before (only found out about FMA last year, OTL) so it was a let down so to speak. THIS IS MY OPINION :)
@BlackandWhiteDragons You should give FMA another watch or 2 and you will then notice the directing and scrip plot holes Brotherhood has little to none. The characters go through character development in brotherhood, were as in FMA they just either change after the 25 mark or don't follow simple things (exp. being envious is not being mad.). All other things you state show you seem to be part of the Reality TV/Twilight generation were drama/bad things mean a good show or book. I enjoyed FMA btw.
@DerpyFlerpy Look, I'm entitled to my own opinions, and just because I don't like Brotherhood doesn't mean I'm wrong, or you're wrong. It's a free world, I can choose what I like best and why I like it. I honestly tried to like Brotherhood when I first watched it and it didn't work for me. I tried to watch it with an open mind, it didn't work for me, and the Disney ending was just a way to make the fans happy, not to make it a powerful story. My thoughts on the subject, and I've watched it all.
@BlackandWhiteDragons When did i say you were wrong? Seeing how you think it's a Disney ending means you didn't understand the show. In brotherhood equivalent exchange is true so it's going to be a happy ending clearly. Just like FMA were it was not true so it came out a bittersweet ending. Thats quite simple to understand how did you miss that?
@DerpyFlerpy I think what @BlackandWhiteDragons is trying to say is that in her opinion; the storyline of Brotherhood was somewhat lacking. I am inclined to say that I agree. In the 2003 series; the plot goes through a series of interesting plot twists and changes; whereas in Brotherhood the plot stays the same throughout the series. An example of this would be Colonel Mustang's goals and interests: Brotherhood - Fuhrer. 2003 - Fuhrer, miniskirts, making fun of Ed, dogs... there is so much more.
@ScottieDoctor Miniskirts is a story line you. That's one thing i will say is wrong. Jumping the shark is not a plot twist either. Its easy to change something without explaining.
@DerpyFlerpy Ah; but I never said that his obsession with miniskirts was a storyline. I'm sorry if I confused you. My main point was that there was so much more depth in the 2003 series.
@ScottieDoctor "whereas in Brotherhood the plot stays the same throughout the series. An example of this would be Colonel Mustang's goals and interests: Brotherhood - Fuhrer. 2003 - Fuhrer, miniskirts, making fun of Ed, dogs... there is so much more." You did say that is a part of the plot. Two jokes and a dog are not depth. Try again.
Btw Brotherhood - fuhrer, real character development about huges, learning about his alchemy, more depth then a joke + dog.
@DerpyFlerpy The characters in 2003 are so much more vibrant it's not even funny. Brotherhood consisted of a bunch of facts that indicated a character. 2003 used facts but also added humour as well as light and dark moments for all the main characters. There were little mistakes and big mistakes that helped define the character. As xXomgitslokiXxX said; the original series was much better; and the depth of the story was a major component.
I'm not saying your wrong. I'm just saying I disagree.
@ScottieDoctor Funny how everyone saying FMA is better can never give a a real reason aside from this is better. Lets see a comparison. I wouldn't take the Emo/hipster kid on your side either.
@DerpyFlerpy Dude, this is getting really stupid. The whole point of this conversation has been to say 'IN MY OPINION 2003 is better'. By the way; I don't value people's opinions by their attitudes.
@ScottieDoctor My attitude is fine. I haven't said one bad thing. Unless facts are bad? The term "in my opinion" is usually used when someone has nothing to say to counter a discussion.
@DerpyFlerpy From experience 'In my opinion' is used to signify that you are not saying something is right or wrong; rather that it's what you prefer as an option, and I prefer 2003; because it appeals to me more as a viewer. And I quote 'I wouldn't take the emo/hipster kid on your side either'.
@ScottieDoctor You say it has more but can't give 1 reason why other then miniskirts, fighting with ed and a dog. Great job. "The characters in 2003 are so much more vibrant it's not even funny" yup..
@DerpyFlerpy I think Brotherhood COULD have been my preferred version if the directors and animating had allowed the voice actors to unleash their full potential.
@ScottieDoctor Watch berserk. Crappy voice acting. A lot more and properly emotional (not sad 90% of the time). So lets see voice acting, sad parts. Over story and characters.
@DerpyFlerpy Judging by the test that youtube just made me do to check I'm not trolling; this has been going on far too long, because you keep attacking and I keep backing myself up.
@ScottieDoctor This is a discussion it seems like I'm attacking because you have no valid points to use. If there was more "depth" or "vibrant characters" you could "attack" but they are empty words.
@DerpyFlerpy Just because I thought it was a Disney ending doesn't mean I didn't understand the show, I'm just saying what I thought of the ending, and I'm not the first one to say it, for me, the ending was to fulfil what the fans wanted, not to make it a good show. I'm entitled to my opinions (2003 is the one for me) whilst you in turn are entitled to yours (BH).
@DerpyFlerpy lol, I ran out of room XD But anyway....
Frankly, I'm quite sick of this conversation, and as I said in my original comment on this video, I can't really squash how much I love 2003 into 500 characters. I used to love Brotherhood, but then slowly, I changed my mind over the many months and strayed back towards 2003. "Brotherhood sucks" or "I hate Brotherhood" are too strong a words to use, but I don't like it is pretty much the bottom line.
Reading these comments. I don't think people understand the first 25 episodes were done as quick as possible in brotherhood so you wouldn't have to wait a week for something you have seen already. Oh and i would hardly say FMA is more emotional. The homunculi hardly stuck to their emotions were in brotherhood they stuck to their one emotion till the end. What was the point in naming them after the deadly sins then?
The original anime was far darker at parts. The ending was surprisingly coherent and one of the nest, showing that alchemy was created by the real world's misery.
Man kind can not gain anything without first giving something in return. To obtain, something of equal value must be lost. That is alchemy's first law of equivalent exchange... in those days, we really believed that to be the world's one, and only truth.
FMA is more emotionally driven, Brotherhood has a more full and complete lore and world. Both are excellent and I'd say getting rid of one or the other would be terrible. Both deserve appreciation.
i watched brotheer hood cuz i love happy endings but im think i should watch the original i dont want to be sad though im satisfied with the happy ending grrrr :(((
@sy9593 Brotherhood is the original, it is faithfully following the story of the manga. Because the first anime was it's own story that toke of in i different direction after acouple of episodes, an ended sad. Since they hadn't done it by the book, the original story, they made brotherhood, that is the true ending...
@khrocksforever Brotherhood isn't bad at all. Just the animation is different the story follows the original (Which I think is better) But some of the early scenes in the FMA are Much Much better. SPOILERS Pretty early spoilers but whatever, When Nina and Hughs die in the FMA is was so emotional, also the FMA animation is much more suited for a Story Driven Anime while FMA:B is more suited to a action/story anime. Both are amazing in the own way.
@khrocksforever I thinks it's better, they are both good but brotherhood follow the manga much better, Fma was a story of its own, brotherhood is the original story you could say, the real one. It makes more sense and has its emotional touches throughout the serie, you won't be disappointed
Well I am glad I am not only the one who missed this. I loved Brotherhood. I really did. But I don't understand why it had to artistically differ from the original. Why did the animation and music need to change? I can understand not all the voice actors could come back, and that's fine. But what was wrong with the animation and music? What really kills me is the beginning material they cut. Now a lot of new fans mock the original, and refuse to watch it. I was a gorgeous anime.
@TerraFaeOdosson I refuse to watch the original! its not because i watched the new one, but because i watched the old one... the new one is definitely better in my opinion, having seen both animes and having read the manga, i have to say i like the new one alot more.
@TheInuyashaAddict I knew someone was going to start a debate with me! In all plot line elements I agree. Brotherhood is better. If was the artistic things I missed. Music, animation changes, pacing. I also liked how the original anime had episodes based off the light novels in it. It made the world seem more real, there being other story lines going on. But I loved Fullmetal Alchemist in every form. I just wish they didn't rush the beginning. I read all of the manga as well.
@TerraFaeOdosson Though the manga is the only version that had everything, I really loved both animes in their own right. I just hate when people only watch Brotherhood. I feel like they missed so much. Either in the books, or the original series.
@TerraFaeOdosson I have to concur. Even though I didn't like the first anime for reasons, I felt that the emotions, atmosphere and choice of music was better and superior to Brotherhood's. Brotherhood was decent to watch, yes, but based on the lack of character's depth, scenes and detail that was supposed to be shown from the manga it seems like the staff was laid-back on making it. And that just leaves me very upset.
man.. Fullmetal Alchemist is over.. Beyblade is almost over... Naruto is nearing the end..i have no more animes to watch!!!!! i might resort to Pokemon.. but even that is nearing an end. (not One Piece, no taste there.)
@897theman oh man! come on! dont be hating on One Piece! At one point in time, when i was younger, i shunned One Piece for having a childish art style and i mean, come on, when you dont know what it is, it looks stupid! but then i read the manga and absolutely loved it, more than any manga i have read before. give it a shot man! (and i dont mean just read the first 5 chapters...)
@897theman you gotta be kidding me? One Piece is so good, give it a try that's what I did. Your missing out, yeah the drawing might seen childish but the story line is so good. Other good anime or manga is Sekirei, Elfen Lied, and GANTZ!!!!!
essa musica define minha mente confusa e paralela a este mundo ^_^ ontem fiz uma cosia que não fazia há tempos ^_~assisti full metal ^_^ saudade de quando eu era apenas um garoto inocente e totalmente feliz sem preocupação com o amanhã
Watched both series... IMO Brotherhood had greater depth due to character and plot development - as it followed the manga - whilst the original felt truncated and incomplete. Nevertheless there are elements of the original which can be appreciated e.g. the music tracks
I love Fullmetal Alchemist as much as you all do (I am assuming). I think however, that Brotherhood is by far better considering that it followed the anime much more... I am not sure what you are talking about when you say that the old series has more emotion in it? Brotherhood has by far more emotion and dramatic situations in it...
FMA (not Brotherhood) clearly has superior music themes and sees things in a more mature way. Brotherhood was adapted literraly from the manga, which is clearly a shonen - a good one I'll give you that. FMA was inspired by the manga, and despite a few incoherences, grew up to be a mature piece of art.
@WolfGhost97 Indeed, the first FMA anime had much deeper drama and great tragedy throughout. It was by far the more 'real' of the two anime. It's one of the few times I've enjoyed an anime version more than the manga (FLCL, Evangelion, and Cowboy Beebop were the others).
The English version of this song is just so moving and touching,and when sung in Russian...damn..it's just so beautiful.No matter what language,I love this song!
I love both fma and fma brotherhood, they're both amazingly beautiful and awesome and the way they theorize about they're world of alchemy is both very well thought out, if I had to choose one over the other, I would say brotherhood, but only by 0.001 point better (their difference in awesomeness is smaller than a strand of hair)
You have a strong pair of legs. Use them.
digimaster107 2 hours ago
йоу, наш великий и могучий ^__^
я была молек в шоке, когда в аниме его услышала
Undina98 16 hours ago
is this japanese?
1mursyid1 18 hours ago
@1mursyid1 no russian.... i think
117starpower 5 hours ago
@1mursyid1 no, not japanese, possibly russian/polish but those are complete guesses on my part so don't take my word for it, it's probably on the internet somewhere
anonymous23904 5 hours ago
this must end!
KONY 2012: help please!
SuperGenericguy 1 day ago
What language are they singing in?
RatchetHeartsZ1 3 days ago
@RatchetHeartsZ1 Russian :)
Shana31100 3 days ago
@Shana31100 not Russian its Русский
nikolas20000 2 days ago
FMA or FMAB if you're a fan and rated either of them really low, much less than it should (for example on imdb or Animenewsnetwork) because of the silly reason that one is better than the other. Then you are an idiot. Same goes for this song, and something like Happiness ~Requiem from The Blind Alchemist~ from FMAB.
ShorelineDefense 3 days ago
what is this languange?
Razzilis 5 days ago
@Razzilis russian
thing2liv 5 days ago
This song is so nostalgic :'(, this remind me a lot of things...
For me FMAB is the best manga ! It should be more recompensed ^_^
HxLNe 5 days ago
For me personally I think that FMA is better than Brotherhood. The first 10 episodes for FMA were really emotional and had me hooked. FMA's story was more emotional while Brotherhood was more action or so it would seem (Roy vs Lust as opposed to Lust getting killed off my Wrath). I also did not like the ending of Brotherhood compared to FMA because I like the idea that our world and their world are two different entities (Alchemy does not work in our world) made the story so much more human. ♥
eYeDerezzed 5 days ago in playlist Music
@eYeDerezzed thanks for spoiling a bunch of Brotherhood for me there :D
DLOsniper 5 days ago
@eYeDerezzed i agree <3 x
LolzAngelxxxx 4 days ago
FMA has a simpler plot than Brotherhood. The brothers Ed and Al. Their love to each other.Their sin. Homunculus, a symbol of that. Confrontation with Mother, the root of everything (Sloth, Dante). "Where have we come from, and where will we go?"
And a lot of "brothers" appear in FMA. Russell brothers, Scar and his brother, Ishval kids... Like the echo of the Elrics. All the elements unite and form "the story of the brothers Ed and Al" . So it seems to me that this song fits to FMA perfectly.
eriya69on 6 days ago 22
What language is it in?
froggyribbit456456 1 week ago
@froggyribbit456456 Russian.
KyonGivesYouFacepalm 1 week ago
@KyonGivesYouFacepalm Yes! i knew it because i reconized the words but i want sure
froggyribbit456456 1 week ago
30 octover
Lawliet15zero 1 week ago
@mirraco24 I'm sorry but Wrath is not horrid ok he cry a lot but he is not horrid by the way I love that song this is the must relaxing song of Fullmetal Alchemist
killuanatsume 1 week ago
I dont want to butt in but pls stop the arguement
ShinichiUchiha18 1 week ago
Full Metal Alchemist original or Full Metal Alchemist brotherhood?
It is a hard choosing XD
blekmaster12 1 week ago 28
@blekmaster12 Both are awesome I can't pick between them :P
tiger2max 1 week ago in playlist Favorite videos
@blekmaster12 FMA original is much more creative, and has a lot of twists, but Brotherhood's story was absolutely incredible, since it was thought out before in the form of the manga.
DevilGuyUK 1 week ago
@blekmaster12 I agree! At first, I preferred Brotherhood simply because I preferred the plot, but upon reflection, I find it incredibly hard to find which one is superior in my opinion. 2003 is more emotional, but Brotherhood has a better plot.
I'm actually thinking of making a video comparing the two and seeing which one is better. (Similar to Nostalgia Critic's "Old vs New" series.) Although, it'll be a while before that video can see the light of day.
KyonGivesYouFacepalm 1 week ago
@KyonGivesYouFacepalm That's exactly what I think !
JC12712 1 week ago
@blekmaster12 I'd say brotherhood
yoyoloto 1 week ago
@blekmaster12 Both. Although Brotherhood is more true to the original manga.
AngelusExitium 1 week ago
@blekmaster12 Of course the first series is better!! Better OST, character development/story is outstanding, action/comedy is excellent, oh I could go on and on!!! FMA for life!! " To gain something, you must give up something with equal value" - Best quote ever.
kamuiyang 1 week ago
@blekmaster12 BROTHERHOOD ALL THE WAYYY :P
mariajohn28 1 week ago
@blekmaster12 ok,I may be noob,but,what is the difference?
TheEyrton 6 days ago
@TheEyrton They both have different story going...
blekmaster12 6 days ago
@TheEyrton brotherhood follows the manga (original story) the other is (bar a few episodes) a separate story with a different antagonist and different plot in general
sceeterp 5 days ago in playlist Favorite videos
@blekmaster12
Ones a Really Fucking goo fanfic
the other is a Really Good Recreation of the manga...
I choose both!
hankparish 6 days ago
@blekmaster12 i know, they each have really good episodes. like FMA has mustangs dog speech, and FMAB dont. but FMAB is better cause its longer, and much more satisfying. i mean come on, i think we can all agree that ed getting stuck in london is the most random and terrible ending ever. am i right people?
jennaleem 4 days ago
@jennaleem you are all FUCKING MORONS the creator greatly aproved of the ending of the first fma and i very much support the ending as i think that the brothers should get close to reuniting and then be seperated as it leads to yet another problem for them to solve and then be reunited on the other side of the gate
otakufan217 4 days ago
@blekmaster12 I would choose Brotherhood, since it follows the plot of Manga more. Original FMA was great, true, but for me Brotherhood was, and still is, the true Fullmetal Alchemist.
Epicalchum 3 days ago
@blekmaster12 "Full Metal Alchemist" is about the truth and it showed us all as fans we can't always have what we want, things don't always fall the way we want them hence that everyone wanted ed and al to return to each and live happy ending in the episodes but it didn't
"Full Metal Alchemist brotherhood" was about hard work paying off and them returning to their normal bodies and them having that happy ending. There both really great!!
xx840 3 days ago 3
@xx840 fmaB had showed more than that hun
BRONXGIRL123456789 3 days ago
@BRONXGIRL123456789 i know it showed more, i read the manga before it was made into a series and i watch the series and i am going to watch the new movie that just got released for it, brotherhood had other key points to it like the homunculus not all being evil and stuff and way other stuff. regardless you loved the show and i loved it also.
xx840 3 days ago
@blekmaster12 I say Brotherhood, because I just believed it to have better animation, better voice acting, it followed the story to the manga more accurately and it had a more satisfying ending. However, I still rate the first Fullmetal Alchemist series as my second favourite anime, with Brotherhood being at the top.
RatchetHeartsZ1 3 days ago
@blekmaster12 I watched the whole original series in 3 days and loved it! and then I went to brotherhood and they changed Alphonse and I just couldn't stand to watch it.
MrJazzyGrant 23 hours ago
@MrJazzyGrant Well, did u know Alphonse from the orig fma, also starred in brotherhood? he was playing as young Hoeinheim.
BRONXGIRL123456789 22 hours ago
@MrJazzyGrant The Brotherhood is made from the manga dude XD
Brotherhood is original too....
blekmaster12 21 hours ago
@blekmaster12 Both!.
Lightingdragon777 10 hours ago
@blekmaster12 FMA Brotherhood is based off the manga. FMA was a spin-off from the Manga.
FullSwing9 53 minutes ago in playlist Favorite videos
Comment removed
jonfender123 1 week ago
emo? When i say your stupid, you REALLY are stupid, you've never met me or talked to me before this arguement, you don't know what i am, you don't even know what music i like, until now you had NO IDEA that i have a list of 67 different bands i like, and "gym class heroes" "cataracts" and EMINEM, a FUCKING RAPPER, god... I can't stand idiots
xXomgitslokiXxX 1 week ago
@xXomgitslokiXxX I was calling you a emo for how you seem to be opposed with sad crap, just as i pointed out with quotes. It doesn't matter how many Bands/artists you like. The fact that you think it does is silly. EMINEM is a poor choice he has what 1 non-whining CD? Please learn to read and listen because like before you stated everything you like from FMA, almost every ounce of it is originally from the manga (brotherhood) aside form the mother being a homocili.
DerpyFlerpy 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@xXomgitslokiXxX " "you call me stupid, well look at yourselfs!" All i need to quote is right here. If you plan on calling someone stupid, make sure to say yourselves right." I didn't call you anything... but now i am learn to read idiot. clearly you are stupid just as i knew you were when you were talking about how the 2003 anime is the original source. I don't need a "comeback" because you know nothing. BTW you don't need to quote band names smartguy. deeper idiot stupid deeper idiot stupid..
DerpyFlerpy 1 week ago
And, i said that for the rest of the series they spend on searching for the philosophers stone, and trying to kill the humonculi
xXomgitslokiXxX 1 week ago
The description reminded me this anime kicked ass
TheWolfBearer 1 week ago
i would love to play this with violin on a hot summer night by a camp fire <3
lightwing5000 1 week ago
One M 0:00 RE Time!
theworks98 1 week ago
Can someone please give me the link to download the third soundtrack?
ComaComaComatose 1 week ago
I think if Ed and Al were sisters, the entire series just wouldn't have been the same. A sisterhood and brotherhood are both beautiful, but they work in different ways, and I think in the story of FMA, anything other than a brotherhood (such as a sisterhood, parent-child bond, or even friendship) between Ed and Al wouldn't have given the same emotional impact...
claire1909 1 week ago
@claire1909 True that.
TheWolfBearer 1 week ago
Comment removed
MissJBond 1 week ago
You stop fighting here in front of such a beautiful song like this (T^T)
This song about brotherly love is used in FMA, and FMA is a masterpiece
That's all...
eriya69on 1 week ago
Can anyone tell me what episode did this song play in??
chemical2romance 1 week ago
FMA Brotherhood is the original! Even so i still say both are great!
Thaedlimar 1 week ago
One of the few animes that i prefer dubbed
ImmaEminem 1 week ago
@ImmaEminem wtf, im not even being rude. But are you for real. ive only watched the japanese version, but ive seen a few clips of the english version...seems so dead man.
UzumakiGaminG 1 week ago
@UzumakiGaminG Thats your opinion :D
ImmaEminem 1 week ago
and if you were even listening to what im saying, i said its because its deeper, i hate it when people do this, "you need a reason to back it up" no I don't! As long as i'm stating A reason it's good enough, I said the series is deeper, it's funnier, better acting, and shorter then the other one, I mean, a longer series can be good, but if it goes on and on it kindof ruins the whole fucking series, god, I hate people, you can't even argue good, you just state random reasons that aren't relevant
xXomgitslokiXxX 1 week ago
@xXomgitslokiXxX "you call me stupid, well look at yourselfs!" All i need to quote is right here. If you plan on calling someone stupid, make sure to say yourselves right. Also if you think you "explained the series" then why is everything you stated from episode 1-25, there is more episodes ya know. I brought up the emo thing because everything you said about the show was sad moments, seeing how you like them so much and like bands like 3 days grace... your an emo.
DerpyFlerpy 1 week ago
@DerpyFlerpy Again, pointing out things that aren't neccesary, yep, you are an idiot -__-'', what does three days grace even have to do with what i like and don't like? and really, correct me on one word? That's all you could come up with for a comeback, weak. Saying one word wrong doesn't make me an idiot. -_-' wow.
xXomgitslokiXxX 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@xXomgitslokiXxX Deeper... I don't think you know what that means... Depth maybe? Lets see this :"Ed and Al fucking lost there mother!", "dad NEVER FUCKNG THERE FOR THEM THROUGH ANYTHING", "they lost everything!", " THEY LOST EVERYTHING! ", " oh, so happy, NOT! how dare you even say it's not the best!", "I hate people", WHAAAAA go cry emo kid and grow up so you can see more then 1 emotion. I tried my best to get a quote out of anything you said that wasn't whining or about sad crap. BOOOHOOO
DerpyFlerpy 1 week ago
do you even know what a troll is? A troll is someone who posts random comments where it isn't even neccesary, and harmlessly just annoys people, pfft.
xXomgitslokiXxX 1 week ago
"Emo/hipster bands? I never even mentioned emo or hipster at all! And how do I not have a clue what i'm saying? I just explained the whole series, you call me stupid, well look at yourselfs! Your saying things that don't make any sense, i didn't mention anything about music, and how i don't know what i'm talking about when i explained the series, and have watched it three times now, i don't understand, you both are fucking idiots
xXomgitslokiXxX 1 week ago
Lmao weeaboo's...
Weeabo's?
Y'all kids is fu-knuckled in the head skillets :V
subito113 1 week ago
I have no problems with peoples opinion, but saying "This one is better IMO" and "This one is so much more emotional and the other one has a crappy story and characters" is completely different. Not having reasons why its "better" shows you clearly don't have a clue what your saying is better. I just wanted to know why it has better things, if you can't back anything up ( In a logical sense, Emotion = Hate,happy,sad,envy... not OMG THIS ONE IS SADDER !EMOTION!) then stick to just IMO its better.
DerpyFlerpy 1 week ago
Actually, Brotherhood isn't a "copy of the original". Brotherhood IS the original. Just like Hellsing and Hellsing: Ultimate. The first series is loosely based on the original story, while the latter is the true story. The original series is a separate anime than the actual FMA story, while Brotherhood is the full, real FMA story.
I love FMA too, but there's hardly any logic in your argument, and you're so hostile about it that it's hard to tell whether you're serious or trolling.
xBradums 1 week ago
@xBradums The only thing xXomg... states that isn't from the manga (brotherhood) is that their mom is a homunculi. He clearly knows nothing about this. Probably only like it because its sad. looking at his comments I found : 1. Words - Mainstream and Label 2. bunch of the emo/hipster bands. He is clearly one or the other and around 13-16 years old. "Ed's hair is NOT that blonde" /wrist :P
DerpyFlerpy 1 week ago
Last one; Just a fucking copy of the ORIGINAL series, crappy voice acting, not even fucking funny moments! that isn't FMA, that's just a sad excuse for an anime, and Ed's hair is NOT that blonde, you fucking idiot! GO DIE OFF OF A FUCKING CLIFF!! your head is so thick you can't even see my poitn of view, your like a machine, fight fight fight, MORON
xXomgitslokiXxX 2 weeks ago
Continued; out tucker was using his family to transmute them into human speaking chemera's? oh, so happy, NOT! how dare you even say it's not the best! THAT series means everything to me! And what can the other series offer for me?
xXomgitslokiXxX 2 weeks ago
continued; al was being sucked into the gate, and there mom wasn't even human! they lost everything! Yet there here trying to get it all back, the rest of the series, there looking for the philosophers stone to GET there BODIES back, and ed feels bad for what happened to al, THEY LOST EVERYTHING! yet here they are trying to get it all back, and when they found
xXomgitslokiXxX 2 weeks ago
and how the fuck is it not deep!? Ed and Al fucking lost there mother! There dad was NEVER FUCKNG THERE FOR THEM THROUGH ANYTHING/! they loved her, so they tried to bring her back, al lost his body, and ed lost two limbs, it was a HORRIBLE experience from them, ed was bleeding and screaming in pain,
xXomgitslokiXxX 2 weeks ago
And dont forget..It was ment to be diffrent from each other, Bones did it on purpose, for hiroma arakawa
BRONXGIRL123456789 2 weeks ago
They are both made by the same production BONES. Bones created Fma 2003 nd fmabrotherhood, They were made to be diffrent for a reason. Hiroma Arakawa didnt like dark things, thts why she added a bit more humor in fma manga, Fma 2003 had humor too, but also had deep sessions. Lets put it this way, Both fma is an excellent story, animation is great, and has exspressive emotions,
BRONXGIRL123456789 2 weeks ago
OKAYY FOR EVERYONE WITH THIS FMAB VS FMA, first of all i would love to give all the credits to Hiroma Arakawa, the creator, Fullmetal alchemist has two diffrent personalities, and meanings, Full Metal alchemist 2003, shows relationship nd emotions between Ed And Al, and yes the story is deep,sad, and dark, FmaB is the same way, but it goes with relation between friends and trust, i say its action packed and also a story.
BRONXGIRL123456789 2 weeks ago
I hate it when the comments are spammed by two people arguing.
gzomyndzor 2 weeks ago 28
I don't care about the stupid manga series of this, or stupid brotherhood, the original series was MUCH better, they went much deeper
xXomgitslokiXxX 2 weeks ago
@xXomgitslokiXxX Coldplay. Your argument is invalid.
DerpyFlerpy 2 weeks ago
@DerpyFlerpy what the fuck does coldplay have to do with shit!? And how the fuck is my arguement invalid, I think brotherhood is a stupid fucking series that doesn't go deep at all, and it isn't the same, it makes ed and al seem fucking stupid and the funny scenes aren't as funny, the ORIGINAL series is much better, you are a fucking idiot
xXomgitslokiXxX 2 weeks ago
When I heared it I was like "Why this Japanese song sounds like Russian..?" until I figured out it was actually in russian lol...
XxDinorawrusxX 2 weeks ago
Well i guess its like this. If you like story and characters you'll prefer brotherhood. If you like Drama and sad emotional moments you'll prefer FMA. ( this is all on the 25+ episodes 1-25/1-10ish don't count as they are the basically the same thing) Reason i say sad is because that is the emotion FMA prays on the most from Wrath emo'in to the 2 bittersweet endings.
DerpyFlerpy 2 weeks ago
@DerpyFlerpy Simple for me: I couldn't engage with Brotherhood. It was forever missing something and the directing + script were just not up to the standard of 2003 for me. The characters were also ripped apart and rebuilt to be completely different, and that saddens me. Soundtrack wasn't great, and since I'm a high sucker for drama, the lack of emotion was staggering, for I saw 2003 the week before (only found out about FMA last year, OTL) so it was a let down so to speak. THIS IS MY OPINION :)
BlackandWhiteDragons 2 weeks ago
@BlackandWhiteDragons You should give FMA another watch or 2 and you will then notice the directing and scrip plot holes Brotherhood has little to none. The characters go through character development in brotherhood, were as in FMA they just either change after the 25 mark or don't follow simple things (exp. being envious is not being mad.). All other things you state show you seem to be part of the Reality TV/Twilight generation were drama/bad things mean a good show or book. I enjoyed FMA btw.
DerpyFlerpy 2 weeks ago
@DerpyFlerpy Look, I'm entitled to my own opinions, and just because I don't like Brotherhood doesn't mean I'm wrong, or you're wrong. It's a free world, I can choose what I like best and why I like it. I honestly tried to like Brotherhood when I first watched it and it didn't work for me. I tried to watch it with an open mind, it didn't work for me, and the Disney ending was just a way to make the fans happy, not to make it a powerful story. My thoughts on the subject, and I've watched it all.
BlackandWhiteDragons 2 weeks ago
@BlackandWhiteDragons When did i say you were wrong? Seeing how you think it's a Disney ending means you didn't understand the show. In brotherhood equivalent exchange is true so it's going to be a happy ending clearly. Just like FMA were it was not true so it came out a bittersweet ending. Thats quite simple to understand how did you miss that?
DerpyFlerpy 2 weeks ago
@DerpyFlerpy I think what @BlackandWhiteDragons is trying to say is that in her opinion; the storyline of Brotherhood was somewhat lacking. I am inclined to say that I agree. In the 2003 series; the plot goes through a series of interesting plot twists and changes; whereas in Brotherhood the plot stays the same throughout the series. An example of this would be Colonel Mustang's goals and interests: Brotherhood - Fuhrer. 2003 - Fuhrer, miniskirts, making fun of Ed, dogs... there is so much more.
ScottieDoctor 2 weeks ago
@ScottieDoctor Miniskirts is a story line you. That's one thing i will say is wrong. Jumping the shark is not a plot twist either. Its easy to change something without explaining.
DerpyFlerpy 2 weeks ago
@DerpyFlerpy Ah; but I never said that his obsession with miniskirts was a storyline. I'm sorry if I confused you. My main point was that there was so much more depth in the 2003 series.
ScottieDoctor 2 weeks ago
@ScottieDoctor "whereas in Brotherhood the plot stays the same throughout the series. An example of this would be Colonel Mustang's goals and interests: Brotherhood - Fuhrer. 2003 - Fuhrer, miniskirts, making fun of Ed, dogs... there is so much more." You did say that is a part of the plot. Two jokes and a dog are not depth. Try again.
Btw Brotherhood - fuhrer, real character development about huges, learning about his alchemy, more depth then a joke + dog.
DerpyFlerpy 2 weeks ago
@DerpyFlerpy The characters in 2003 are so much more vibrant it's not even funny. Brotherhood consisted of a bunch of facts that indicated a character. 2003 used facts but also added humour as well as light and dark moments for all the main characters. There were little mistakes and big mistakes that helped define the character. As xXomgitslokiXxX said; the original series was much better; and the depth of the story was a major component.
I'm not saying your wrong. I'm just saying I disagree.
ScottieDoctor 2 weeks ago
@ScottieDoctor Funny how everyone saying FMA is better can never give a a real reason aside from this is better. Lets see a comparison. I wouldn't take the Emo/hipster kid on your side either.
DerpyFlerpy 2 weeks ago
@DerpyFlerpy Dude, this is getting really stupid. The whole point of this conversation has been to say 'IN MY OPINION 2003 is better'. By the way; I don't value people's opinions by their attitudes.
ScottieDoctor 2 weeks ago
@ScottieDoctor My attitude is fine. I haven't said one bad thing. Unless facts are bad? The term "in my opinion" is usually used when someone has nothing to say to counter a discussion.
DerpyFlerpy 2 weeks ago
@DerpyFlerpy From experience 'In my opinion' is used to signify that you are not saying something is right or wrong; rather that it's what you prefer as an option, and I prefer 2003; because it appeals to me more as a viewer. And I quote 'I wouldn't take the emo/hipster kid on your side either'.
ScottieDoctor 2 weeks ago
@ScottieDoctor You say it has more but can't give 1 reason why other then miniskirts, fighting with ed and a dog. Great job. "The characters in 2003 are so much more vibrant it's not even funny" yup..
DerpyFlerpy 2 weeks ago
@DerpyFlerpy I think Brotherhood COULD have been my preferred version if the directors and animating had allowed the voice actors to unleash their full potential.
ScottieDoctor 2 weeks ago
@ScottieDoctor Watch berserk. Crappy voice acting. A lot more and properly emotional (not sad 90% of the time). So lets see voice acting, sad parts. Over story and characters.
DerpyFlerpy 2 weeks ago
@DerpyFlerpy Judging by the test that youtube just made me do to check I'm not trolling; this has been going on far too long, because you keep attacking and I keep backing myself up.
ScottieDoctor 2 weeks ago
@ScottieDoctor This is a discussion it seems like I'm attacking because you have no valid points to use. If there was more "depth" or "vibrant characters" you could "attack" but they are empty words.
DerpyFlerpy 2 weeks ago
@DerpyFlerpy Just because I thought it was a Disney ending doesn't mean I didn't understand the show, I'm just saying what I thought of the ending, and I'm not the first one to say it, for me, the ending was to fulfil what the fans wanted, not to make it a good show. I'm entitled to my opinions (2003 is the one for me) whilst you in turn are entitled to yours (BH).
BlackandWhiteDragons 2 weeks ago
@DerpyFlerpy lol, I ran out of room XD But anyway....
Frankly, I'm quite sick of this conversation, and as I said in my original comment on this video, I can't really squash how much I love 2003 into 500 characters. I used to love Brotherhood, but then slowly, I changed my mind over the many months and strayed back towards 2003. "Brotherhood sucks" or "I hate Brotherhood" are too strong a words to use, but I don't like it is pretty much the bottom line.
BlackandWhiteDragons 2 weeks ago
When I listen to this I like to pretend I'm Russian
PokeMasterKelly 2 weeks ago 4
wouahhhhh !!!! it's beatifull metal
mihwakdu006 2 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
Say, what language is this song in?
NeoSaturos123 2 weeks ago
@NeoSaturos123 it's in Russian
shinycelebi225 2 weeks ago
Reading these comments. I don't think people understand the first 25 episodes were done as quick as possible in brotherhood so you wouldn't have to wait a week for something you have seen already. Oh and i would hardly say FMA is more emotional. The homunculi hardly stuck to their emotions were in brotherhood they stuck to their one emotion till the end. What was the point in naming them after the deadly sins then?
DerpyFlerpy 2 weeks ago 3
The original anime was far darker at parts. The ending was surprisingly coherent and one of the nest, showing that alchemy was created by the real world's misery.
killerbumble 2 weeks ago 3
Man kind can not gain anything without first giving something in return. To obtain, something of equal value must be lost. That is alchemy's first law of equivalent exchange... in those days, we really believed that to be the world's one, and only truth.
guncannon109 3 weeks ago
I only like Brotherhood for that Shang Wang guy or what ever hsi name is, that uses a Scimitar, he is cool.
897theman 3 weeks ago
FMA is more emotionally driven, Brotherhood has a more full and complete lore and world. Both are excellent and I'd say getting rid of one or the other would be terrible. Both deserve appreciation.
Kerrathlol 3 weeks ago 41
i watched brotheer hood cuz i love happy endings but im think i should watch the original i dont want to be sad though im satisfied with the happy ending grrrr :(((
sy9593 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@sy9593 Brotherhood is the original, it is faithfully following the story of the manga. Because the first anime was it's own story that toke of in i different direction after acouple of episodes, an ended sad. Since they hadn't done it by the book, the original story, they made brotherhood, that is the true ending...
SilverFang4Life 3 weeks ago
I just started watching FMA because my friend recommended it and I love it geez Im sure brotherhood cant be all that bad...
khrocksforever 3 weeks ago
@khrocksforever Brotherhood isn't bad at all. Just the animation is different the story follows the original (Which I think is better) But some of the early scenes in the FMA are Much Much better. SPOILERS Pretty early spoilers but whatever, When Nina and Hughs die in the FMA is was so emotional, also the FMA animation is much more suited for a Story Driven Anime while FMA:B is more suited to a action/story anime. Both are amazing in the own way.
walkernintendofan 3 weeks ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
@khrocksforever I thinks it's better, they are both good but brotherhood follow the manga much better, Fma was a story of its own, brotherhood is the original story you could say, the real one. It makes more sense and has its emotional touches throughout the serie, you won't be disappointed
SilverFang4Life 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
Casdaine 3 weeks ago in playlist Liked videos
Comment removed
Casdaine 3 weeks ago in playlist Liked videos
I hear rain in background, is this heaven?
DjFrewd 3 weeks ago
Well I am glad I am not only the one who missed this. I loved Brotherhood. I really did. But I don't understand why it had to artistically differ from the original. Why did the animation and music need to change? I can understand not all the voice actors could come back, and that's fine. But what was wrong with the animation and music? What really kills me is the beginning material they cut. Now a lot of new fans mock the original, and refuse to watch it. I was a gorgeous anime.
TerraFaeOdosson 3 weeks ago
@TerraFaeOdosson I refuse to watch the original! its not because i watched the new one, but because i watched the old one... the new one is definitely better in my opinion, having seen both animes and having read the manga, i have to say i like the new one alot more.
TheInuyashaAddict 3 weeks ago
@TheInuyashaAddict I knew someone was going to start a debate with me! In all plot line elements I agree. Brotherhood is better. If was the artistic things I missed. Music, animation changes, pacing. I also liked how the original anime had episodes based off the light novels in it. It made the world seem more real, there being other story lines going on. But I loved Fullmetal Alchemist in every form. I just wish they didn't rush the beginning. I read all of the manga as well.
TerraFaeOdosson 3 weeks ago
@TerraFaeOdosson Though the manga is the only version that had everything, I really loved both animes in their own right. I just hate when people only watch Brotherhood. I feel like they missed so much. Either in the books, or the original series.
TerraFaeOdosson 3 weeks ago
@TerraFaeOdosson I have to concur. Even though I didn't like the first anime for reasons, I felt that the emotions, atmosphere and choice of music was better and superior to Brotherhood's. Brotherhood was decent to watch, yes, but based on the lack of character's depth, scenes and detail that was supposed to be shown from the manga it seems like the staff was laid-back on making it. And that just leaves me very upset.
Casdaine 3 weeks ago
I cried at the FMA ending...ALOT!
LolzAngelxxxx 3 weeks ago
Why the fuck does this show have to end
mohammedsamaduddin 3 weeks ago 3
man.. Fullmetal Alchemist is over.. Beyblade is almost over... Naruto is nearing the end..i have no more animes to watch!!!!! i might resort to Pokemon.. but even that is nearing an end. (not One Piece, no taste there.)
897theman 3 weeks ago
@897theman oh man! come on! dont be hating on One Piece! At one point in time, when i was younger, i shunned One Piece for having a childish art style and i mean, come on, when you dont know what it is, it looks stupid! but then i read the manga and absolutely loved it, more than any manga i have read before. give it a shot man! (and i dont mean just read the first 5 chapters...)
TheInuyashaAddict 3 weeks ago
@897theman you gotta be kidding me? One Piece is so good, give it a try that's what I did. Your missing out, yeah the drawing might seen childish but the story line is so good. Other good anime or manga is Sekirei, Elfen Lied, and GANTZ!!!!!
SunnyNShine02 3 weeks ago
@SunnyNShine02 i've tried to get into it, tons of people have tried with me, i'm just not a fan =/.
897theman 3 weeks ago
essa musica define minha mente confusa e paralela a este mundo ^_^ ontem fiz uma cosia que não fazia há tempos ^_~assisti full metal ^_^ saudade de quando eu era apenas um garoto inocente e totalmente feliz sem preocupação com o amanhã
anderuto1 3 weeks ago
Watched both series... IMO Brotherhood had greater depth due to character and plot development - as it followed the manga - whilst the original felt truncated and incomplete. Nevertheless there are elements of the original which can be appreciated e.g. the music tracks
jellybelly596 3 weeks ago 3
I love Fullmetal Alchemist as much as you all do (I am assuming). I think however, that Brotherhood is by far better considering that it followed the anime much more... I am not sure what you are talking about when you say that the old series has more emotion in it? Brotherhood has by far more emotion and dramatic situations in it...
AnubisToke 3 weeks ago 2
FMA (not Brotherhood) clearly has superior music themes and sees things in a more mature way. Brotherhood was adapted literraly from the manga, which is clearly a shonen - a good one I'll give you that. FMA was inspired by the manga, and despite a few incoherences, grew up to be a mature piece of art.
WolfGhost97 3 weeks ago
@WolfGhost97 Indeed, the first FMA anime had much deeper drama and great tragedy throughout. It was by far the more 'real' of the two anime. It's one of the few times I've enjoyed an anime version more than the manga (FLCL, Evangelion, and Cowboy Beebop were the others).
Alondro77 3 weeks ago in playlist Favorite Songs
@897theman yes! i´m of your opinion :)
one in the west one in the east. it must go one :)
1 more season
IR0XX0R 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
IR0XX0R 3 weeks ago
FMA makes to glad to have a brother.
guncannon109 3 weeks ago 14
mine33222, this song was made special for FMA..
Kaijinamer 3 weeks ago
@Kaijinamer Thank you so much! I've always wonder why I couldn't find it...;(
Now I got a truth
mine33222 3 weeks ago
It's rare to hear my native language in Anime. Good song. Yeah, very good.
Kaijinamer 3 weeks ago
somebody please tell me what's the original song of this?...or is it original?
I heard that this song was changed from Russian folk song.
If I'm saying wrong, I apologize about that.
mine33222 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
LolzAngelxxxx 3 weeks ago
Makes me really teary :')so emotional xxx
LolzAngelxxxx 4 weeks ago 4
Brotherhood has the storyline, FMA has the soundtracks.
SuperMoine777 4 weeks ago
best music EVERRRRR
nowzadick 4 weeks ago
emotional theme
ROADTO1950ELO 4 weeks ago
thumbs if you have seen all the ep. of fma more than 3 times
zmanx2111 4 weeks ago
@897theman 1 more season of FMA (FullMetal Alchemist) that is.
897theman 4 weeks ago
Hermosa canción :DD
panxaita123 1 month ago in playlist Liked videos
The English version of this song is just so moving and touching,and when sung in Russian...damn..it's just so beautiful.No matter what language,I love this song!
RedaFox1 1 month ago
I love both fma and fma brotherhood, they're both amazingly beautiful and awesome and the way they theorize about they're world of alchemy is both very well thought out, if I had to choose one over the other, I would say brotherhood, but only by 0.001 point better (their difference in awesomeness is smaller than a strand of hair)
cheenadengin 1 month ago 4
I went to a part of Flagstaff, Arizona last year while it was snowing, played this song and it was magical!! =D
pnar13 1 month ago
I don't know why, but every time I listen to this song, I'm reminded of snow.
balltongue666 1 month ago
I am very sorry for their mother, that death is bad medicine there. =(
MultiHoCoK 1 month ago
I'm russian. At first, then i heard this song in the series, i thought that our fandubbers tried to joke, and inserted this.
AstreinW 1 month ago
Was this really in Russian in FMA? Weird that i didn`t recognize it, kinda seems obvious now :S
TheOwlslayer 1 month ago
@TheOwlslayer It was.
GLaDOS567 1 month ago
FMA was a very good anime, but the ending wasn't the best in my opinion.
xEL3C 1 month ago
I think Fullmetal Alchemist ( NOT Brotherhood ) has a way more emotional story
mirraco24 1 month ago 82