Mahler Symphony No.5 (piano solo version)

[2gercelticw]

/watch?v=oqIVL6Ch66E&feature=r­elated

[2gercelticw]

This interpretation has no soul

[larsgerret]

@Ben and Justice

Maybe you are right that John Bell Young´s version is the better one. I can´t check it.

Thanks for that advice.

[kakke0machan]

素晴らしいと思う。さりげないタッチですが、なかなかここまで弾­ける人はめったにいないと思います。

[chantalrao]

偉い！！

[fernandolimido89]

No tengo palabras para expresar mi amor por esta cancion. Very good!

[joanilo21]

¿¿¿De quién es el arreglo??? Me gustaria saberlo

[joanilo21]

¿¿¿¿Donde podré conseguir esa partitura????

[joanilo21]

muchas palmas!

[quinavivi]

私も10年前にこの曲が好きすぎてチャレンジしたことがあります­、あまりうまく弾けませんでしたが・・・楽譜も読めないのにすべ­てを指暗記してひきました・・・

もーできないだろなー

[septip123]

Brilliant!

[CrannyNoko]

これは非常にいいです

[larsgerret]

By the way, you could find this piano transcription by Otto Singer (Edition C. F. Peters, Leipzig in Germany, number 10264). As far as I know it is sold out at time, but you could find it in some music libraries.

[BENandJUSTICE]

@larsgerret Otto Singer's transcription is problematic, as he oversimplified the work's textures, making reductionism its sine qua non. He re-arranges voicing, too, so as to make things easier for amateur pianists. It's a superficial transcription that eviscerates the Adagietto of its complexity.John Bell Young's transcription, on the other hand, is a thousand times better; preserving the integrity of the original score, but it's far more challenging, expressive and difficult to play.

[larsgerret]

Good enough to get a first impression. It is hard to bring the right feeling or soul into this piece - that is only for professional pianists.

I could recommend this piano piece by Cyprien Katsaris (Label "Piano 21" from 2008 >>Piano rarities<< Vol. 1).

The best orchestra versions are for me by Bernstein and Karajan.

[tosi51]

ミスタッチも多くて残念なところもありますが、この曲に入れ込ん­でいる情熱の方が勝っているよい演奏だと思います。ついつい聞い­てしまいます。

[Lotarionesco]

hey, could you tell me please where can I find the score of this mahler...I will be very grateful

[spartacus71vC]

really good interpretation of mahler! i can imagine that it's quite difficult to play, because it is so slow.

to my ears you maybe play it sometimes a little bit "mechanic", but i think that's just a matter of time... :)

[1341hitoha]

夢見る様です。とても綺麗。

第５楽章も頑張っちゃってください。

１０年待ちますから♪