Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)
Link to this comment:
Share to:
Loading...
- Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
or sign in to load a different list.
Loading...Saving...
gówno ,gówno,beznadziejne wykonanie,smieć
hideharumijahir 11 months ago
Chopin is obviously not this man's métier.
Competent, but neither moving nor exciting.
The charm, atmosphere and character of a work comes more from phrasing, dynamic contrasts and a strong sense of overall structure than it does from "speed." In fact I'd like to hear a great deal less "speed" and a lot more thought, passion, imagination and attention to the poignant dissonances and mercurial harmonic changes that make each piece something special that stands apart from all the others.
Pischnaholic 2 years ago
@Pischnaholic - I agree, wholeheartedly - less speed, more thought to the next phrase with passion & intensity of highs & lows...the idea is take the listener somewhere, a place of serenity...not take them on a bullet train ride through Japan at rush hour.
It was neither exciting or moving; to play someone like Chopin, a romantic, THAT emotion, is crucial. I have seen the same thing by guitar players, trying to play this piece...stonefaced, no emotion; it doesn't work...& is not believeable. L.
Layna8 1 month ago in playlist Chopin op 10 no 3
E Major: The accompaniment in the outer sections is too loud. Second section is supposed to be faster! Bravura section pretty good! Needs still more sensitivity and tenderness, though some nice shaping and rubato. C Minor: needs more practice! Good top notes. Try to build climaxes more gradually. A titanic piece if done properly. Great work for an amateur!
soami2u 3 years ago
I don't like it....is really monotonous...more fast for me....
lucapianist91 3 years ago
Comment removed
Layna8 1 month ago
Comment removed
Layna8 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Layna8 - it's monotonous for 2 reasons -
no emotion
too fast
the worst thing you could do is speed up this romantic piece, meant to be played sensitively and emotionally...remember, the song is about a love lost, as far as I know...one, in hopes to recover...much thought, sadness, contemplation goes into such a piece...to speed it up, would be to desecrate it further.
L.
Layna8 1 month ago
The playing is monotonous and empty.
PianoRon 4 years ago
you too...
estomatologos 4 years ago
It's far from 'empty', there's lots of nice phrasing there and he does all the basic things of producing very good tone range. The outer sections lack the subtelty and beauty of phrasing of a true concert pianist, and the middle does drag you are correct there, although for a supposed 'amateur' he handles the 6ths pretty damn amazingly. The C minor is a bit messy, obviously a struggle for him, here his amateur status is revealed.
englishplayer40 3 years ago