Most beautiful song I heard in a long time! It's so full of joy and love and it feels like the ghosts of a long forgotten past have awoken once again. Thank you for sharing that experience through a wonderful playing and a lovely female voice!
I think the pronunciation of the Greek might be a bit wrong... but then I learnt Attic Greek so it might be a bit different. Really cool either way! :D
@armcelt nope again, you're wrong. G Mixolydian doesn't have c sharp, a note which is present in the song, it's the Phrygian scale of E, that scale has A as tenor, a note which is repeated a lot of times in the song, the second being E, which is also an important note in this particular mode, and has c and f sharp, both notes used at least once in the song.
@armcelt It seems i didn't express myself in the proper manner, what i meant was this piece of music its in the key of D, which has the two sharps i mentioned, but its in e because the the highest and lowest notes are an E, okay here's the part that i didn't explain, i was talking about the old tonos phrygian mode, which is the equivalent to the modern dorian mode. So in a nutshell what im trying to say is that the piece is in the key of D, and it was written in E dorian.
@mudkipero Yep, the notes with flats you've mentioned (like in Wikipedia article about Seikilos epitaph) which tonally resemles E Dorian are in A Mixolydian in truth )). This tune always comes in Mixolydian mode (modern). The only subject of change is its key ).
With all due respect to this beautiful song, I have to make this joke:
Even this is better than Bieber!
(P.S. Of course it is, this song is simple, yet beautiful... Who would'a knew that one creative person that, in memorial to a loved one, invented something that would one day change humanity.)
This is just beautiful. Sometimes I think...has music really progressed that much since this song? This song is simple yet very profound. A song does not have to be overly complicated in order to be a work of art.
@P2K725 Well, I suspect that spiritually the next incarnation in progress of soul toward enlightenment may be so-called backwards-in-time (eg from 2012 to birth in Rome 212 BCE). Skeptically who knows really. It stikes me looking at the Fayum Mummy Faces and other remnants of Antiquity that Matters of Self & Soul have ultimately little to do with Time! Thanks for the wonderful video! Oh, have you heard Ensemble De Organographia's reconstructions of Ancient Music? They are haunting! :-)
Ὅσον ζῇς, φαίνου/Hoson zês, phainou/Mientras vivas, brilla/While you live, shine//μηδὲν ὅλως σὺ λυποῦ/mêden holôs su lupou/Nada se haga tu sufrimiento/don't suffer anything // πρὸς ὀλίγον ἐστὶ τὸ ζῆν/pros oligon esti to zên/pues la vida existe solo un breve momento/life exists only a short while//τὸ τέλος ὁ xρόνος ἀπαιτεῖ/to telos ho chronos apaitei/y el tiempo pedirá su derecho/and time demands its toll.
it's really beautifu!!!soooo muchhhh beautiful!!!!!!and not only for it's music but for what it says,too!!το ειχαν πιασει το νοημα τηs ζωηs οι Ελληνεs απο τοτε λεμε!!!μπραβο για το post αυτο!!ευτυχωs που υπαρχουν και καποιοι που ανεβαζουν και κατι τηs προκοπηs εδω μεσα..κατι που πραγματικα να αξιζει!!ευγε!!!
"Little did he know, somewhere in the far, distant future, long after he had died and everything he had ever known had long ceased to exist, someone out there in the vast reaches of space and time, in a civilization that did not yet exist, heard his song and felt his pain."
I admired the synthesis but I distinguish the distinction of long and short voyels. It had ceased to be made at that time. The song is mistakenly executed.
That's right,my friend.Most linguists agree that in Hellenistic time the accent was almost identical with modern Greek,i.e. η was pronounced as ι instead of lomg ε,the diphthongs αι,ει and οι as ε,ι and ι respectivelly and the consonants β,γ,δ and θ were also pronounced like in modern Greek.
That's right,my friend.Most linguists agree that in Hellenistic time the accent was almost identical with modern Greek,i.e. η was pronounced as ι instead of lomg ε,the diphthongs αι,ει and οι as ε,ι and ι respectivelly and the consonants β,γ,δ and θ were also pronounced like in modern Greek.
@P2K725 well depends really, because many scholars believe, in particular an english one Robert Ellis who believes the Etruscans have their origins from Armenia.. i mean technically speaking the Armenian civilization does predate the Greek ( no hostilities what so ever mate just using historical facts ) i wouldn't be surprised if their was influence from both ends.. i tend not to look at mainstream history it is distorted and used to satisfy the needs of those nations exploiting it.
@Argurotoxe Yet no one stops to ponder the mastery and powerful message behind songs like these. In ancient times there were hardly any distractions from nature and peace...but in our modern world it's impossible to get someone to sit and LISTEN. Except for the viewers of this video. =)
"Had Greek civilization never existed, we might fear God and deal justly with our neighbors, we might practice arts and even have learned how to devise fairly simple machines, but we would never have become fully conscious, which is to say we would never have become, for better or worse, fully human."
@DwaynHicks I wish that too. But if there was this wouldn't serve as intriguing. That little glimpse is enough to make it beautiful and mysterious, I think.
@P2K725 Enjoyed isn't a big enough word. My husband found this video and told me about it, and I spent a week learning to sing it, and we've come back again and again over the past month to listen to it. Thank you so much for posting it.
@designedsayer I searched and you have right to this! Also Η was double E, really (they wrote: ΠΕΡΙΚLΕS in Attic dialect)
Don't forget the Ω too, which was double O. In school they learned us the polytonic system with the small letters, but ancient Greeks used only capital letters and they don't use polytonic or monotonic system. Polytonic & small letters start from 9th century AC.
Nobody can possibly be acquainted with the sound of ancient Greek words to the extent of judging accents to be right or wrong, for the quite obvious fact that there are no vocal records (though it is generally agreed that it didn't sound like modern Greek). Besides, there always existed many accents along a wide country, as it presently happens. So don't be so foolish as to woory about it and try to enjoy before time claims its tribute!
It may not be possible to know for sure, but linguistic reconstruction can work backwards to a good approximation of the original sounds. With sufficient evidence, this works so well that linguists even have approximations for /most/ of the sounds in a few hundred words of Proto-Indo-European (the common ancestor of English, Greek , Persian, Russian, and Sanskrit some six thousand years ago).
But you're correct about many kinds of Greek existing at the same time.
@googlephi No linguistic reconstruction whatever can work so well as to reveal the nature of the accent of a few Greek words, not of the sound, but of the ACCENT, which is a quite different thing and was what some people were arguing about. I was only talking of our ignorance of the accents and the silliness of holding that the singer has a "foreign" accent. Your remarks, therefore, are not relevant to the question.
Although she is American, her pronuntiation of ancient Greek is perfect.
In the first century a.D., Greek was not pronounced like it is today; so, thanks to some philological theories and evidences, we can suppose that the way Italian scholars read Greek today is one of the most faithful ways we can read Greek in.
And, as a matter of fact, she pronounces Greek as Italians do today.
When French singers sing Bach or English ones Italian arias they are expected to lose their accent and sing in the accent of the original. So, I was just making a comment on the performance.
oso zis fenou (as long as you live, shine) miden olos si lipu (dont feel any sorrow) pros oligon esti to zin (cause life is sort) to telos o xronos apeti (time leads to our death, time demand the end)..
how nice!! very touching.. as a Greek i was deeply affected at the sight of this video ..but is this in greek?? i cant realise my ancient language..the accent of the singer doesnt sound like greek..love to all from Ελλάς..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This is ancient greek language. The new greek is a slavic-albanian-turkish-ancient greek language. This is why the musicity and majesty of this epic song sounds to you like no greek.
this girl is foreigner..thats way i cant understand the accent..our language is 4000 years old..same alphabet apart three letters..what albanian and turkish?..yes, we share some turkish words..so what?..we r neighbors and lived together for ages..
It is in Hellenistic Koine, something between Classical Attic Greek and Modern. However, the pronunciation is far from any really existing (or existed) Greek pronunciation...
sorry but ancient greek in not pronounced like this. and greeks DO understand ancient greek automatically! we get to know ancient greek from the age of 13 :) start listening to some 'daemonia nymphe' and not this crap!
sry, but I think that's not the point for you. I find it sad when I cannot enjoy a greek song like it should be. Imagine how great would it be if she also had the correct pronunciaton...tell u the truth I didn't realize she was singing in greek the first time..until I read the lyrics on the side :o
I know how the ancient greek dialect should be spoken or how the ancient greek should be sung. That's just a foreign accent singing greek with a foreign pronunciation thingie. Ancient greek dialect was a bit singie, but not that LIGHT...this is like english-butterflies singing. Dunno about italians tho...
Hint: don't try to defend sth u have no idea about.....imho
I have to say, SAVAE has incredibly beautiful intonation and tone, but their pronunciation of foreign languages is pretty unscholarly, mostly disappointing, and sometimes dreadful.
wow!! this song is amazing simple in its complexity!! I love it!! it is very soothing and somewhat loving.....I have heard this sond palyed live once and it was like listenign to raw beauty...anyway I love this song!!!!!
podarcis, do you see that epigraph in the video? That's the score of this ancient song. Musical notes are above the lyrics, but of course it's not same with the notation we've been using. I reccomend you to search this on internet. Regards.
I like the beginning. When it picks up speed, the thoughtfulness of the lyrics and melody don't match the tempo. This song is something special regardless.
in my humble opinion this will be like this for the englis speakers
Hoson dzes phai-nou,
Meden holo-os sy lypou-ou.
Pros oligon e-esti to dze-en, to telos ho hronos apaitei-ei.
but i dont know how dou you say the ou , the "t" must be no so much dental, just like spanish speakers
anyway , ist a wontherfull song !!! thank you very much
sorry for my english
yudego22 1 week ago
Love it !
pearlrose11 2 months ago
Beautiful, simply beautiful
Augalv 3 months ago
Comment removed
Augalv 3 months ago
Most beautiful song I heard in a long time! It's so full of joy and love and it feels like the ghosts of a long forgotten past have awoken once again. Thank you for sharing that experience through a wonderful playing and a lovely female voice!
Stratopeter87 4 months ago 9
@Stratopeter87 The pleasure is all mine, friend! I feel the same way.
P2K725 4 months ago
@Stratopeter87 I think you about summed it up for me too! Nice to see a like mind! ;-)
MushroomedAnymore 2 weeks ago
I HATE MY BASTARD FRIEND WHO SAY: WHAT THE HELL IS THAT VOICE... I said: SONG OF SEIKILOS, he Said: THATS WAS RLLY BAD
Mrpotsable 4 months ago
Im glad i found this. It made my day a little bit better :)
IsaacJustGotPwned 4 months ago
This song is really nice!
Fiskepudding127 4 months ago in playlist (mostly ancient) greek music
AHHH I WANT WHIS CD BUT I CANT FIND IT
nazarian3 5 months ago
@nazarian3 Not even on eBay??
P2K725 5 months ago
@P2K725 can't buy them on ebay because normally they don't arrive. I live to far away.
nazarian3 5 months ago
@nazarian3 Or Amazon. If not I can send you all the songs.
P2K725 5 months ago
@P2K725 I don't want to try, I would prefer the second choice hahaha :D, that would be nice :D.
nazarian3 5 months ago
that sweet voice
Mrpotsable 5 months ago
@Mrpotsable Rare.
P2K725 5 months ago
I think the pronunciation of the Greek might be a bit wrong... but then I learnt Attic Greek so it might be a bit different. Really cool either way! :D
domrivers 6 months ago
Beautiful melody in Mixolydian Mode)).
armcelt 6 months ago
@armcelt It's Phrygian, actually.
mudkipero 1 month ago
@mudkipero Nope. You're quite mistaken. It's G Mixolydian.
armcelt 1 month ago
@armcelt nope again, you're wrong. G Mixolydian doesn't have c sharp, a note which is present in the song, it's the Phrygian scale of E, that scale has A as tenor, a note which is repeated a lot of times in the song, the second being E, which is also an important note in this particular mode, and has c and f sharp, both notes used at least once in the song.
mudkipero 1 month ago
@mudkipero You've mixed up everything )))))).
First, neither G Mixolydian nor E Phrygian contain any sharp or flat.
Second, where did you find C sharp and F sharp here??? They're absolutely absent in this melody.
And then, try to play the tune on piano and you'll be able to manage it perfectly only on the white keys with G starting and finalising the tune )).
armcelt 1 month ago
@armcelt It seems i didn't express myself in the proper manner, what i meant was this piece of music its in the key of D, which has the two sharps i mentioned, but its in e because the the highest and lowest notes are an E, okay here's the part that i didn't explain, i was talking about the old tonos phrygian mode, which is the equivalent to the modern dorian mode. So in a nutshell what im trying to say is that the piece is in the key of D, and it was written in E dorian.
mudkipero 1 month ago
@mudkipero Yep, the notes with flats you've mentioned (like in Wikipedia article about Seikilos epitaph) which tonally resemles E Dorian are in A Mixolydian in truth )). This tune always comes in Mixolydian mode (modern). The only subject of change is its key ).
armcelt 1 month ago
Comment removed
mudkipero 1 month ago
With all due respect to this beautiful song, I have to make this joke:
Even this is better than Bieber!
(P.S. Of course it is, this song is simple, yet beautiful... Who would'a knew that one creative person that, in memorial to a loved one, invented something that would one day change humanity.)
TheKevinDasilva 7 months ago 2
Funny how the first recorded song said everything there is to say.
kaimialana 7 months ago 16
@kaimialana Precisely. I love that about this song.
P2K725 7 months ago
This is just beautiful. Sometimes I think...has music really progressed that much since this song? This song is simple yet very profound. A song does not have to be overly complicated in order to be a work of art.
0ladystardust 9 months ago
That's strange to see how many people are living in the pass.
Thekateful7 10 months ago
@Thekateful7 In order to cherish where you're going you must acknowledge how and where it had begun. ^_^
P2K725 5 months ago 2
@P2K725 Well, I suspect that spiritually the next incarnation in progress of soul toward enlightenment may be so-called backwards-in-time (eg from 2012 to birth in Rome 212 BCE). Skeptically who knows really. It stikes me looking at the Fayum Mummy Faces and other remnants of Antiquity that Matters of Self & Soul have ultimately little to do with Time! Thanks for the wonderful video! Oh, have you heard Ensemble De Organographia's reconstructions of Ancient Music? They are haunting! :-)
MushroomedAnymore 2 weeks ago
@Thekateful7 I prefer to live in the underpass.
TheOmegaHG 3 months ago
Greetings from Georgia! nice
hacking38 11 months ago
Wow! This gives me flashbacks. I was an engineer on these sessions. :)
CyberianHusky74 11 months ago 7
@CyberianHusky74 REALLY? =DDD
P2K725 11 months ago
A more modern translation that follows the prosody of the original:
All through life -- Shine on!
Let nothing dampen your fire;
We have but a short while to live,
Until the end that time will desire.
odniwr 1 year ago 5
Comment removed
odniwr 1 year ago
Comment removed
odniwr 1 year ago
Ὅσον ζῇς, φαίνου/Hoson zês, phainou/Mientras vivas, brilla/While you live, shine//μηδὲν ὅλως σὺ λυποῦ/mêden holôs su lupou/Nada se haga tu sufrimiento/don't suffer anything // πρὸς ὀλίγον ἐστὶ τὸ ζῆν/pros oligon esti to zên/pues la vida existe solo un breve momento/life exists only a short while//τὸ τέλος ὁ xρόνος ἀπαιτεῖ/to telos ho chronos apaitei/y el tiempo pedirá su derecho/and time demands its toll.
SergioAlejandroLira 1 year ago 2
what is the name of the picture on 4:36?
xBoykex 1 year ago
it's really beautifu!!!soooo muchhhh beautiful!!!!!!and not only for it's music but for what it says,too!!το ειχαν πιασει το νοημα τηs ζωηs οι Ελληνεs απο τοτε λεμε!!!μπραβο για το post αυτο!!ευτυχωs που υπαρχουν και καποιοι που ανεβαζουν και κατι τηs προκοπηs εδω μεσα..κατι που πραγματικα να αξιζει!!ευγε!!!
mariax2010 1 year ago
@mariax2010 does she just repeat the lines or does she go on??
santero9999 1 year ago
@santero9999 you mean if there are other words after that?if i understood right,these words here:
Hoson zes phai-nou,
(As long as you live, shine!)
Meden holo-os sy lypou-ou.
(Let nothing grieve you beyond measure.)
Pros oligon e-esti to ze-en, to telos ho chronos apaitei-ei.
(For your life is short, and time will claim its tribute.)''
are the words of this song and she repeats these words Sant!
mariax2010 1 year ago
"Little did he know, somewhere in the far, distant future, long after he had died and everything he had ever known had long ceased to exist, someone out there in the vast reaches of space and time, in a civilization that did not yet exist, heard his song and felt his pain."
Xystus234 1 year ago 5
@Xystus234 I like this a lot. You think of that?
P2K725 1 year ago
I admired the synthesis but I distinguish the distinction of long and short voyels. It had ceased to be made at that time. The song is mistakenly executed.
eliopoulosgiannis 1 year ago
@eliopoulosgiannis Can't just enjoy the songgg? =(
P2K725 1 year ago
@P2K725 I enjoyed it and I loved what I heard!!
eliopoulosgiannis 1 year ago
@eliopoulosgiannis Yaaaay!
P2K725 1 year ago
@P2K725 Can ou enjoy the food that was inadequately cooked?:)
Forcroi 1 year ago
@eliopoulosgiannis
That's right,my friend.Most linguists agree that in Hellenistic time the accent was almost identical with modern Greek,i.e. η was pronounced as ι instead of lomg ε,the diphthongs αι,ει and οι as ε,ι and ι respectivelly and the consonants β,γ,δ and θ were also pronounced like in modern Greek.
kostas68 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@eliopoulosgiannis
That's right,my friend.Most linguists agree that in Hellenistic time the accent was almost identical with modern Greek,i.e. η was pronounced as ι instead of lomg ε,the diphthongs αι,ει and οι as ε,ι and ι respectivelly and the consonants β,γ,δ and θ were also pronounced like in modern Greek.
kostas68 1 year ago
wow greek sounds soo similar to armenian
interesting
ZeeGooner 1 year ago
@ZeeGooner Well, at the time, did Hellenic culture not cross the Dardenelles into Turkey and beyond to modern-day Armenia? I could be wrong.
P2K725 1 year ago
@P2K725 well depends really, because many scholars believe, in particular an english one Robert Ellis who believes the Etruscans have their origins from Armenia.. i mean technically speaking the Armenian civilization does predate the Greek ( no hostilities what so ever mate just using historical facts ) i wouldn't be surprised if their was influence from both ends.. i tend not to look at mainstream history it is distorted and used to satisfy the needs of those nations exploiting it.
ZeeGooner 1 year ago 2
@P2K725
No, that's absolutely right
ZlorfikF17 10 months ago
@ZlorfikF17 =)
P2K725 10 months ago
@ZeeGooner They're both Indo-European languages.
jarblewarble 9 months ago
i can't even find the words to describe this gift
everyday when people wake up, they should think about this song
they knew it so many years ago, why does mankind dishonour this?
there are enormous amounts of animal kinds, but only one kind of beast
Argurotoxe 1 year ago 5
@Argurotoxe Yet no one stops to ponder the mastery and powerful message behind songs like these. In ancient times there were hardly any distractions from nature and peace...but in our modern world it's impossible to get someone to sit and LISTEN. Except for the viewers of this video. =)
P2K725 1 year ago 2
Best version by far
maire83 1 year ago
@maire83 Hehe, biased though I agree.
P2K725 1 year ago
love it...
scoupe1666 1 year ago
"Had Greek civilization never existed, we might fear God and deal justly with our neighbors, we might practice arts and even have learned how to devise fairly simple machines, but we would never have become fully conscious, which is to say we would never have become, for better or worse, fully human."
W.H. Auden
vanderbilt887 1 year ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
ı am live in seiklos quarter and city tralleis Aydın /Turkey
1969yaman 1 year ago
ı am live in seiklos quarter at tralleis Aydın /Turkey
1969yaman 1 year ago
@1969yaman NICE. And was this accurate, is it still standing?
P2K725 1 year ago
In proper Ancient Greek (i.e. polytonic) orthography it's:
Ὅσον ζῇς, φαίνου
Μηδὲν ὅλως σὺ λυποῦ
Πρὸς ὀλίγον ἐστὶ τὸ ζῆν
Τὸ τέλος ὁ χρόνος ἀπαιτεῖ.
Kwikspur 1 year ago
I putted off my dress and watched the sun goes down....thinking what we losed
Tauromenio 1 year ago 2
The words to this ancient song are inpiring:
While you live, shine
Don't suffer anything at all;
Life exists only a short while
And time demands its toll.
elementz1986 1 year ago 2
I find it breathtaking that the oldest piece kept in it's fullest is a song about celebrating life. :)
DukeLongfellow 1 year ago
This is really beautiful. I would love to acknowledge the ancient music of other countries. This should be a good start.
TheTimeTraveler100 1 year ago
@TheTimeTraveler100 Try South and Southeast Asia as well. Though Hellenic culture is a wonderful beginning.
P2K725 1 year ago
@DwaynHicks I wish that too. But if there was this wouldn't serve as intriguing. That little glimpse is enough to make it beautiful and mysterious, I think.
P2K725 1 year ago
Why is ancient Greek so different from modern Greek? thank you.
nicodagger 1 year ago
@nicodagger
Like periphyseos said, both pronunciation, accents, and dialects were all radically different.
P2K725 1 year ago
@nicodagger
The Greek we know today is the descendant of that form of speaking, not as pure, I suppose.
P2K725 1 year ago
La più antica canzone occidentale, di cui si conoscano testo e musica...dedicata da un marito greco alla giovane moglie defunta.
Per il tempo che ti resta da vivere, splendi!
Non lasciarti affliggere oltre misura.
La vita è breve e il tempo reclama il proprio tributo.
giorgiodieffe 1 year ago
can anyone tell me where I can find sheet music for this song?
it sounds really nice
aardmaat 1 year ago
@aardmaat The melody is written out in the wikipedia article on Seikilos
KarenSDR 1 year ago
@KarenSDR Thank you for answering that question for him, KarenSDR. Hope you enjoyed!
P2K725 1 year ago
@P2K725 Enjoyed isn't a big enough word. My husband found this video and told me about it, and I spent a week learning to sing it, and we've come back again and again over the past month to listen to it. Thank you so much for posting it.
KarenSDR 1 year ago
i like it, althought i really dont think a woman sang this in the ancient greece.....
mauricioamf 1 year ago
haha, she didn't said "ἀπαιτει" (apeti) she said "ἀπαϊτέι" (apaitei). In Greek the ai is e and the ei is i
Tritalas 1 year ago
@Tritalas a is always a and is always i.
αι originally was pronounced as aï not ε like in modern Greek.
υμεις και ημεις sound exactly the same, how in the world am I suppose to tell if the speaker means you or we?
designedsayer 1 year ago
@designedsayer I didn't knew that!
OK. But when I learned Ancient Greek (Attic dialect & some Macedonian dialect) I did not learned that!
Maybe it's in some dialects.
Tritalas 1 year ago
@Tritalas Yeah η was probably a long e
and υ as a french u or i in later greek.
αμήν in Spanish is Amén, not Amín, from Latin amen, from Greek αμήν.
designedsayer 1 year ago
@Tritalas sorry α is always α and ι is always ι.
ε is always ε. so, ει was ¨εϊ και αι αϊ. υι possibly was vi or wi, not just ι as in modern Greek. οι=¨οϊ
designedsayer 1 year ago
@Tritalas They make a few mistakes here in the video like εί as εΪ instead of e-í ε-ί
designedsayer 1 year ago
@designedsayer I searched and you have right to this! Also Η was double E, really (they wrote: ΠΕΡΙΚLΕS in Attic dialect)
Don't forget the Ω too, which was double O. In school they learned us the polytonic system with the small letters, but ancient Greeks used only capital letters and they don't use polytonic or monotonic system. Polytonic & small letters start from 9th century AC.
Tritalas 1 year ago
Nobody can possibly be acquainted with the sound of ancient Greek words to the extent of judging accents to be right or wrong, for the quite obvious fact that there are no vocal records (though it is generally agreed that it didn't sound like modern Greek). Besides, there always existed many accents along a wide country, as it presently happens. So don't be so foolish as to woory about it and try to enjoy before time claims its tribute!
periphyseos 1 year ago 27
@periphyseos
It may not be possible to know for sure, but linguistic reconstruction can work backwards to a good approximation of the original sounds. With sufficient evidence, this works so well that linguists even have approximations for /most/ of the sounds in a few hundred words of Proto-Indo-European (the common ancestor of English, Greek , Persian, Russian, and Sanskrit some six thousand years ago).
But you're correct about many kinds of Greek existing at the same time.
googlephi 1 year ago 4
@googlephi No linguistic reconstruction whatever can work so well as to reveal the nature of the accent of a few Greek words, not of the sound, but of the ACCENT, which is a quite different thing and was what some people were arguing about. I was only talking of our ignorance of the accents and the silliness of holding that the singer has a "foreign" accent. Your remarks, therefore, are not relevant to the question.
periphyseos 1 year ago
@periphyseos however we can judge the melody by the instruments of the time.
VolkColopatrion 1 year ago
She sounds American, not Greek (either ancient or modern)
darthsyphus 1 year ago
She IS American.
P2K725 1 year ago
Although she is American, her pronuntiation of ancient Greek is perfect.
In the first century a.D., Greek was not pronounced like it is today; so, thanks to some philological theories and evidences, we can suppose that the way Italian scholars read Greek today is one of the most faithful ways we can read Greek in.
And, as a matter of fact, she pronounces Greek as Italians do today.
AenigmaVitae 1 year ago
This song was written in the first century AD, so under the rule of the Emperor Tiberius.
fellinian 1 year ago
When French singers sing Bach or English ones Italian arias they are expected to lose their accent and sing in the accent of the original. So, I was just making a comment on the performance.
darthsyphus 1 year ago
oso zis fenou (as long as you live, shine) miden olos si lipu (dont feel any sorrow) pros oligon esti to zin (cause life is sort) to telos o xronos apeti (time leads to our death, time demand the end)..
andromedahellinis 2 years ago
Οσον ζής φαίνου, Μηδέν όλως σύ λυπού
Προς ολίγον εστί το ζήν
Το τέλος ο χρόνος απαιτεί...
andromedahellinis 2 years ago 18
Comment removed
salaskie 2 years ago
Comment removed
andromedahellinis 2 years ago
Comment removed
salaskie 1 year ago
@andromedahellinis Thank you!
P2K725 1 year ago
how nice!! very touching.. as a Greek i was deeply affected at the sight of this video ..but is this in greek?? i cant realise my ancient language..the accent of the singer doesnt sound like greek..love to all from Ελλάς..
andromedahellinis 2 years ago 4
you just liked that archer's tits or that greek military Utilikilt after depending on what side your bread is buttered on.
doston1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is ancient greek language. The new greek is a slavic-albanian-turkish-ancient greek language. This is why the musicity and majesty of this epic song sounds to you like no greek.
grigorakis12 1 year ago
this girl is foreigner..thats way i cant understand the accent..our language is 4000 years old..same alphabet apart three letters..what albanian and turkish?..yes, we share some turkish words..so what?..we r neighbors and lived together for ages..
andromedahellinis 1 year ago
really amazing!
Lysandros 2 years ago 4
it should be sing by the men
DomiCro1 2 years ago 2
nice one
flyingtoothpaste 2 years ago 2
I liked it, but there are instruments which didnt exist in greece at that time, anyway i enjoyed it.
Mefistico 2 years ago
Yay!
P2K725 2 years ago
Sorry but I think thats wrong.... Which of the used instrumnets didn't exist??
Every instrument used in this song exits in ancient times too, for sure....
Neoptolomos 2 years ago 5
It is in Hellenistic Koine, something between Classical Attic Greek and Modern. However, the pronunciation is far from any really existing (or existed) Greek pronunciation...
stchat 2 years ago
Hellenistic? oh no! not seleucia!
dontbannme 2 years ago
It is Ancient Greek, Koine variant.
kerberosdelhades 2 years ago
Hehe.
P2K725 2 years ago
Great video thank-you.
Aegialeus 2 years ago
Thank YOUUU.
P2K725 2 years ago
modern
alexandrakarras 2 years ago
The language in which she sings, is it modern greek or ancient greek?
gold333 2 years ago
i think ancient ^^
PitaRnR 2 years ago
I'd like to know for sure whether it's modern, medieval, Koine classical or ancient Greek.
gold333 2 years ago
maybe Koine classical..
THERE'S SOMEONE THAT CAN TELL US WHICH TYPE OF GREEK IS THIS LYRIC??
PitaRnR 2 years ago
It is sung in an Erasmian pronunciation/phonetics which is not ancient Greek pronunciation/phonetics as is taught in many Western schools.
As for which Greek, could be Katharevousa also Koine, but not entirely Attic. Also hear and read Demotic modern Greek in it.
Aegialeus 2 years ago
Hoson zes phai-nou,
Meden holo-os sy lypou-ou.
Pros oligon e-esti to ze-en, to telos ho chronos apaitei-ei.
PoesSoul7 2 years ago
I LOVE this. Thank you so much, and posting the lyrics was just a wonderful asset!
Love to you <3
MidnaLover 2 years ago
wonderful interpretion, thank you!!!
digiric 2 years ago
No prob!
P2K725 2 years ago
LA ESTOY DANDO YO AHORA EN EL COLEGIO
DERUHQYYYYYTIUUUUUUU 2 years ago
Magyar fordítás:
Hungarian:
A napfény felvidít,
mikor az égre felragyog,
de sohase várd a holnapot,
mert titokban izen a zord halál.
A szépség boldogít,
amíg a réten száz virág,
de ha sose szívod illatát,
a sötétben izen a zord halál.
jamie1519 2 years ago 4
I love this arrangement! I'm in love with this song!
madderbass 2 years ago 4
Hehe. <3
P2K725 2 years ago
and that's because they don't get the pronunciation/accent thingie muehehehe
Aurense 2 years ago
it's not just the pronunciation, there are many spelling mistakes too
apa-iiii-teiiii
darkRoyalty 2 years ago
sorry but ancient greek in not pronounced like this. and greeks DO understand ancient greek automatically! we get to know ancient greek from the age of 13 :) start listening to some 'daemonia nymphe' and not this crap!
darkRoyalty 2 years ago
true!
and the "Corvus Corax - Seikilos" version is much closer to the ancient accent-pronunciation.
daemonia nymphae kickz ass!
Aurense 2 years ago
Alrighty then.
P2K725 2 years ago
thx for letting ppl know about this song tho :)
Aurense 2 years ago 2
You're welcome, friend. =]
P2K725 2 years ago
sry, but I think that's not the point for you. I find it sad when I cannot enjoy a greek song like it should be. Imagine how great would it be if she also had the correct pronunciaton...tell u the truth I didn't realize she was singing in greek the first time..until I read the lyrics on the side :o
that imho...
Aurense 2 years ago
She's supposed to sing ANCIENT greek, which is very different to modern greek.
Pronuncation of any language changes over the centuries.
Italians don't undertsand Latin automatically either.
DarthJesco 2 years ago
...lemme assure u thats not ANCIENT greek!
I know how the ancient greek dialect should be spoken or how the ancient greek should be sung. That's just a foreign accent singing greek with a foreign pronunciation thingie. Ancient greek dialect was a bit singie, but not that LIGHT...this is like english-butterflies singing. Dunno about italians tho...
Hint: don't try to defend sth u have no idea about.....imho
Aurense 2 years ago
Well, the slightly agressive style in which you wrote and the remark that you are fluent let me assume you were refering to modern greek. ;)
DarthJesco 2 years ago
dude! I speak greek fluently and I thought she speaks some LotR shit!
Let a greek sing this!
Aurense 2 years ago
sorry, not proper accent but proper pronounciation
velerephon 2 years ago
Yah.
P2K725 2 years ago
Really beautifull!!!thanks also listen to the version of Corvus Corax The Seikilos from the album of the same name...thanks for uploading this
smirnov21ruso 2 years ago
=).
P2K725 2 years ago
thanks corvus corax has the proper accent but this version is easier on my ears.
its a pitty they destroy the greek language with that cacophonic erasmian dialect
velerephon 2 years ago 3
great effort!great upload. the problem is that she sings greek with a foreigner accent and i dont understand a thing.
velerephon 2 years ago
I thought there might be somewhat of an issue in SAVAE's rendition of this.
P2K725 2 years ago
HERMOSO, BRILLA EN TU VIDA!
guillerminavera 2 years ago
BRILLIANT! =D
I'm a history buff, and it excited me when I found this. Thank you for uploading!!!
EATxBANANASx95x 2 years ago 2
'Very welcome.
P2K725 2 years ago
awesome!
What a marvellous song!
When I listen to it I wish to go back in time for 3000 years
PersephoneInvicta 2 years ago 2
Me too. =D
P2K725 2 years ago
I have to say, SAVAE has incredibly beautiful intonation and tone, but their pronunciation of foreign languages is pretty unscholarly, mostly disappointing, and sometimes dreadful.
StevenShields29 2 years ago
Soooo how do we know the timing?
YearoftheKlown 2 years ago
This song makes me feel truely alive!
JimEyeDen 2 years ago
I love this song!
jeabo0adhd 2 years ago
As do I, friend.
P2K725 2 years ago
PERFECT!!!!
i will try to download it
slatsTHOMAS 2 years ago
You may try, but the album is a rarity in and of itself.
P2K725 2 years ago
wow!! this song is amazing simple in its complexity!! I love it!! it is very soothing and somewhat loving.....I have heard this sond palyed live once and it was like listenign to raw beauty...anyway I love this song!!!!!
wackylammo 2 years ago
its so pretty and soothing
Woeism3 2 years ago 2
i can play it with my recorder flute... :)
podarcis1987248 2 years ago 2
Aww!
P2K725 2 years ago
podarcis, do you see that epigraph in the video? That's the score of this ancient song. Musical notes are above the lyrics, but of course it's not same with the notation we've been using. I reccomend you to search this on internet. Regards.
ctimur 2 years ago
How you understood what the notes were? it was a music scroll too?
podarcis1987248 2 years ago
It was inscribed with the writing on the pillar.
P2K725 2 years ago
amazing....
AkiraVC 2 years ago 3
the simplicity is shocking,but very effective.i like it.
KiingNiikos 2 years ago 2
Very beautiful !
atlanteen 2 years ago 2
I like the beginning. When it picks up speed, the thoughtfulness of the lyrics and melody don't match the tempo. This song is something special regardless.
5RetardedSquirrels 2 years ago