@tag180rotax well he must have lied because I saw NIN perform this live in 2008. I have the video to prove it on my channel. Cash died in 2003. I heard the same rumor tho, most rumors are bullshit.
Although I'm on Team Cash, I have a great deal of respect for Trent for writing this song. It's my absolute favourite song purely for the lyrics which I know are believed to be about drugs, addictions, battles etc which I don't have any experience with. However, I really relate to this song. So much. The line 'everyone I know goes away in the end' hits me everytime I hear it. Such a beautiful song, it doesn't matter what version you listen to. It's the lyrics that are beautiful.
It's hard to believe this is actually the original version... Johnny Cash really poured all his heart and soul - as well as anguish and regret - into his cover. (I'm one of those who heard the cover first) Nevertheless I praise Trent for the lyrical masterpiece that is Hurt.
At this point NIN's version and Johnny's version are two completely different songs to me, each with their own place in my heart. Neither is better than the other, they are both amazing, and by bickering over which is better, we are tarnishing both of them.
@JDetic *nods* He was. He went on record for saying, after hearing Cash's take on it, "I feel like I've lost an old girlfriend, because it's not my song anymore."
HEY!!! We can all stop bitching about who's is better (NIN or Cash) because Leona Lewis has now done a cover and it sounds like she's being raped with a machete.
@RufusLiekMudkip The Leona Lewis version is actually an amazing achievement, taking one of the most emotional songs of all time and making it totally bland, and emotionless. It sounds like she's never actually experienced anything at all that she can connect to the lyrics. At the same time, it's not actually 'bad', it doesn't ruin the song, or get it horribly wrong... it just makes it dull and unremarkable. Strangely, Kermit the Frog's version is way better that Leona's.
@TheRealAndyR Hm, never heard the Kermit version >.> but Gonzo's song in the original Muppet Movie kinda shows Henson understood more deeply than his otherwise happy happy joy joy show suggests.
"Hurt" is a song written by Trent Reznor, first released on Nine Inch Nails' 1994 album The Downward Spiral. In 2002, "Hurt" was covered by Johnny Cash to critical acclaim; it was one of Cash's final hit releases before his death.
@mitchwatts does it really matter i mean the song is bad ass and amazing in every way and both versions are awesome why can't people just listen to and enjoy it
@ddandevil67 Ummm no. Trent Reznor wrote it, Johnny Cash covered it in '02. The only thing i can REMOTELY agree with you about is that Johnny Cash did a better job. Even Trent Reznor said that...
@ddandevil67 no nin was the first! what the hell how could you get it so wrong! but cash version is great to but they are so different so they can´t be compared
Whoever calls NIN "emo" is completely retarded.They came out long before the term was even invented.Every time someone calls someone else emo,it's what I call a "mirror effect",where people are talking more about themselves than the person they seem to be talking to/about. I bet the kid who came up with the term and made it negative was most likely the one with more low self esteem than a fat kid in a bathing suit doing the shuffel truffel.
@sparrowstar1234 I hate it when people are stereotypical like that I mean I know people who do that and I don't think of them as 'emo' I think of them as people who are going through a hard time and need someone to talk to, need somewhere to get away from all the stress and people like that calling them 'emo' do not help them at all, it just emotionally scarrs them even more than they already were...
Trust me listen to their other stuff... They are FAR from emo! I recommend their song Head Like a Hole or The Hand That Feeds. But most people like them for their industrial sound, so don't judge based on one song...
@AllieSchmallie You need to do your research before you decide to make a fool of yourself. Google or Wiki Nine Inch Nails-Hurt. Check the dates. Does 2002 come before 1994?? NO. Now shut shut the fack up.
@CatUnderwater Um... via Wikipedia: " In 2002, 'Hurt was covered by Johnny Cash to critical acclaim; it was one of Cash's final hit releases before his death'
It's ok. It's not your fault that you have the IQ of mayonnaise.
@CatUnderwater Johnny Cash recorded this in 2002, NiN originally in 1994. I can't believe how stupid you've made youself look here. (Disclaimer: I love both versions)
@CatUnderwater Well if you read your own comments again, then you could very well see how easily they would be misinterpreted as saying Cash wrote this.
What a dark, powerful, and encompassing piece of music. Simply epic.
littleneddygoestowar 1 week ago
I think Johnny Cash did a much better job on this song...
starsnnightmares 1 week ago
JC's version is way better
Swimguitars 1 week ago
This is a cover to Johnny Cash And his version is the best
XXGauge31XX 2 weeks ago
@XXGauge31XX
-facepalm- You are stupid. This is not a cover.
RoboJoeDxm 1 week ago
A perfect song to exit the world..
TheRandomdarkchick 2 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
Trent wrote the original version, but when Cash died, he pledged to never perform it again, in honor of JC
tag180rotax 3 weeks ago
@tag180rotax well he must have lied because I saw NIN perform this live in 2008. I have the video to prove it on my channel. Cash died in 2003. I heard the same rumor tho, most rumors are bullshit.
jason1149719 3 weeks ago
@jason1149719 well whether he did or not people often go back on their word when integrity goes out of style.
KrimsonTwilight 2 weeks ago
Although I'm on Team Cash, I have a great deal of respect for Trent for writing this song. It's my absolute favourite song purely for the lyrics which I know are believed to be about drugs, addictions, battles etc which I don't have any experience with. However, I really relate to this song. So much. The line 'everyone I know goes away in the end' hits me everytime I hear it. Such a beautiful song, it doesn't matter what version you listen to. It's the lyrics that are beautiful.
indiemelon 3 weeks ago 2
It's hard to believe this is actually the original version... Johnny Cash really poured all his heart and soul - as well as anguish and regret - into his cover. (I'm one of those who heard the cover first) Nevertheless I praise Trent for the lyrical masterpiece that is Hurt.
PenaltyKillah 1 month ago in playlist Music in HQ!! (Audio only) 12
@PenaltyKillah johnny cash's voice and emotion is better suited for a song like this
stevenbaby78 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
At this point NIN's version and Johnny's version are two completely different songs to me, each with their own place in my heart. Neither is better than the other, they are both amazing, and by bickering over which is better, we are tarnishing both of them.
Samtastrophi 1 month ago
Comment removed
Samtastrophi 1 month ago
only 2 people got hurt
TyphoonHubert 1 month ago
@TyphoonHubert good one
Varder666 1 month ago
Johnny did it well. I bet Trent is extremely proud.
JDetic 2 months ago
@JDetic *nods* He was. He went on record for saying, after hearing Cash's take on it, "I feel like I've lost an old girlfriend, because it's not my song anymore."
You can't get more of a compliment then that. ^_^
Usagi1992 2 months ago
NIN originally did it, Cash covered it..both did a great job with the song, plain and simple.
cyrusstormcrow 2 months ago 3
@cyrusstormcrow Yeah!
Stop comparing people.Just enjoy the music.
psych0San 2 months ago
the way i feel
angelnoq 2 months ago
Comment removed
evilblondgoth 2 months ago
Trent Reznor (Nine Inch Nails) wrote and performed the original. It's an excellent song.
Johnny Cash later did a cover of it. It's also an excellent song.
Leona Lewis has now also done a cover of it. It's shit.
TheGloriousFail 2 months ago 3
HEY!!! We can all stop bitching about who's is better (NIN or Cash) because Leona Lewis has now done a cover and it sounds like she's being raped with a machete.
RufusLiekMudkip 2 months ago
@RufusLiekMudkip The Leona Lewis version is actually an amazing achievement, taking one of the most emotional songs of all time and making it totally bland, and emotionless. It sounds like she's never actually experienced anything at all that she can connect to the lyrics. At the same time, it's not actually 'bad', it doesn't ruin the song, or get it horribly wrong... it just makes it dull and unremarkable. Strangely, Kermit the Frog's version is way better that Leona's.
TheRealAndyR 2 months ago
@TheRealAndyR Hm, never heard the Kermit version >.> but Gonzo's song in the original Muppet Movie kinda shows Henson understood more deeply than his otherwise happy happy joy joy show suggests.
Vegabond13 2 months ago
reznor es genus....any real rocker knows reznor wrote this..... i knew this when i was like 10 years old when i first heard it
fuck cash, representing real music like nin and tool :D
gringoparadox 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fucking idiots johnny cash wrote this just google it jesus christ he wrote it in the 90s and NIN covered it
johnny cash version is clearly better they ruined it
ddandevil67 2 months ago
@ddandevil67 watch who your calling idiots you ass and get your facts straight Johnny cash covered this song beforte he died ; he did not write it
TiTaN4351 2 months ago
@TiTaN4351 YOU are an ass, idiot. YOU get ur fax straight
bee tee dubs i fuckd yo mums
ddandevil67 2 months ago
@ddandevil67 cash covered it in '02. nine inch nails recorded it in '94. so calm down.
teejay929 2 months ago
@ddandevil67 you might want to learn how to use google NIN released this on the album downward spiral C.1994, Cash covered it in 2002.
mitchwatts 2 months ago 64
@mitchwatts so u claim, citing google which is a SEARCH engine, not information database. so where did u actually get your bull shit claim?
ddandevil67 2 months ago
Hurt (Nine Inch Nails song)
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
"Hurt"
Single by Nine Inch Nails
from the album The Downward Spiral
"Hurt" is a song written by Trent Reznor, first released on Nine Inch Nails' 1994 album The Downward Spiral. In 2002, "Hurt" was covered by Johnny Cash to critical acclaim; it was one of Cash's final hit releases before his death.
Amyea1975 2 months ago
@mitchwatts haha, u tell him bro.
hateling666 1 month ago
@mitchwatts does it really matter i mean the song is bad ass and amazing in every way and both versions are awesome why can't people just listen to and enjoy it
ajgilmore1 3 weeks ago 2
@ddandevil67
Cash covered this song just prior to his death in 2002....This song was originally by Nine Inch Nails (and written by Trent himself)
Chasis1991 2 months ago
@Chasis1991 incorrect. if NIN did it, why do so many people say cash wrote it??
checkmate
ddandevil67 2 months ago
@ddandevil67 Obvious troll is obvious. Pretty successful too. Kinda sad that people are too dumb to notice you are just trollin them.
bbmisc420196 2 months ago
@bbmisc420196 lol ikr
ddandevil67 2 months ago
@ddandevil67
please tell me you're trolling! Get your facts straight next time you want to make a fool of yourself....
Chasis1991 2 months ago
@ddandevil67
please tell me you're trolling! Get your facts straight next time you want to make a fool of yourself....
Chasis1991 2 months ago
@ddandevil67
look up hurt on wikipedia and it will tell you all you need to know...
Chasis1991 2 months ago
@Chasis1991 wikipedia is unreliable. i could just go in and edit it myself
ddandevil67 2 months ago
@ddandevil67 Ummm no. Trent Reznor wrote it, Johnny Cash covered it in '02. The only thing i can REMOTELY agree with you about is that Johnny Cash did a better job. Even Trent Reznor said that...
Pleachymomma 2 months ago
@ddandevil67 you sir, made yourself look like a total fucking dumbass right now.. dont speak about shit you dont know nothing about
TheHavvoc123 2 months ago
@TheHavvoc123 double negatives make you look more stupid
ddandevil67 2 months ago
@ddandevil67 takes one to know one, OHSNAP
TheHavvoc123 2 months ago
@ddandevil67 duhhh
LIANNE530 2 months ago
@ddandevil67 lolsocks, johny cash DID NOT WRITE THIS... you might want to get yourself a ECDL so you know how to use a computer
neofuture 2 months ago
Comment removed
evilblondgoth 2 months ago
@ddandevil67 no nin was the first! what the hell how could you get it so wrong! but cash version is great to but they are so different so they can´t be compared
klamydialover 2 months ago
@ddandevil67 lol fucking tool!
CairnsyNUFC 2 months ago
@ddandevil67 <----Ladies and gentlemen, this man, is a fucking idiot.
Samtastrophi 1 month ago 4
@ddandevil67 What a fucking asshole you are...
Daniel121290 1 month ago
@ddandevil67 You Sir, are a fucking tool
tiggerNG6 1 month ago 2
@ddandevil67 lol gotta love morons like this
head0nfire 1 month ago
@ddandevil67 You sir, are an idiot.
YOURMUTHUH 3 weeks ago
@ddandevil67 Whats next? The Lead singer from Foo Fighters is trying too look like Nirvana's Drummer? lmao
HipnosisV1SvR 1 week ago
@ddandevil67 What kinda Google are you using? Gotta avoid it!
chrysrio 2 days ago
Whoever calls NIN "emo" is completely retarded.They came out long before the term was even invented.Every time someone calls someone else emo,it's what I call a "mirror effect",where people are talking more about themselves than the person they seem to be talking to/about. I bet the kid who came up with the term and made it negative was most likely the one with more low self esteem than a fat kid in a bathing suit doing the shuffel truffel.
Casshern1100 3 months ago
@sparrowstar1234 I hate it when people are stereotypical like that I mean I know people who do that and I don't think of them as 'emo' I think of them as people who are going through a hard time and need someone to talk to, need somewhere to get away from all the stress and people like that calling them 'emo' do not help them at all, it just emotionally scarrs them even more than they already were...
NaynayzAccount 4 months ago
I kind of like Breaking Benjamin's cover of this song.
Valnatix 8 months ago
@sparrowstar1234 Well said.. people should get their facts strait before commenting on videos
mitchwatts 8 months ago 23
This is really good, for a beginner.
xDarkfeather 9 months ago
love nine inch nails
musiclover420love 9 months ago
This is the first time I've listened to Nine Inch Nails. This is definitely some of the most emo music I have ever heard.
piemanbeatle 9 months ago
@piemanbeatle
Trust me listen to their other stuff... They are FAR from emo! I recommend their song Head Like a Hole or The Hand That Feeds. But most people like them for their industrial sound, so don't judge based on one song...
BRMETHHO04 9 months ago
@BRMETHHO04 They're the kings of emo. But okay.
piemanbeatle 9 months ago
@piemanbeatle dude your a retard if you think hes emo you know who originally wrote this johhny cash yeah prick look it up
BassplayerMurtha 9 months ago
@BassplayerMurtha They make it emo. And if you dont think this is emo, what is? They're even named after what they stab themselves with.
piemanbeatle 9 months ago
@piemanbeatle Someone is very confused.
AllieSchmallie 3 months ago
@AllieSchmallie You need to do your research before you decide to make a fool of yourself. Google or Wiki Nine Inch Nails-Hurt. Check the dates. Does 2002 come before 1994?? NO. Now shut shut the fack up.
CatUnderwater 3 months ago
@CatUnderwater Um... via Wikipedia: " In 2002, 'Hurt was covered by Johnny Cash to critical acclaim; it was one of Cash's final hit releases before his death'
It's ok. It's not your fault that you have the IQ of mayonnaise.
AllieSchmallie 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@AllieSchmallie NIN is the original you stupid fucking bitch!
CatUnderwater 3 months ago
@CatUnderwater Johnny Cash recorded this in 2002, NiN originally in 1994. I can't believe how stupid you've made youself look here. (Disclaimer: I love both versions)
Santana105 3 months ago
@Santana105 wtf are you talking about dude, ive have been saying NIN is the original, Dumbass!
CatUnderwater 3 months ago
@CatUnderwater Well if you read your own comments again, then you could very well see how easily they would be misinterpreted as saying Cash wrote this.
Santana105 3 months ago
@Santana105 Understood. Like I have been saying, NIN originally wrote this song, not Johnny Cash. End of story.
CatUnderwater 3 months ago
@BassplayerMurtha You don't actually think Johnny Cash wrote this do you?
ColonelPeppyCocker 9 months ago
@BassplayerMurtha Dude, Johnny Cash made a cover of this at the end of his life becuase it fit his life at the time.
brandonw2010mlg 5 months ago
@BassplayerMurtha you are officially disqualified from arguing. pfffftt originally johnny cash wrote this.. what a laugh!!! bahaha
CatUnderwater 3 months ago
@CatUnderwater You are a moron.
AllieSchmallie 3 months ago
@BassplayerMurtha actually Johnny Cash did the cover. NiN wrote and sung teh the song 1st darl.
Johnny Cash sung it as a cover not long before he passed. Both versions are just as haunting. but! each to thier own. :)
LittleMissCheekyBum 3 months ago 2
@BassplayerMurtha Wrong.
AllieSchmallie 3 months ago