Ok sure I enjoy it, but I can admittedly see where Fantano is coming from, and like he said at the start of the review it was his OPINION, he didn't feed it to anyone as fact.
Also what will Planningtorock give you that The Knife wont give you but better?
I have never wrote anything controversial in any comment section, but today is the first time because I dont understand howcome there´s so many dislikes on this video. Not that it´s not allowed to give your own opinion but what is so wrong with this tune compared to others that is viewed on more commercialized channels? Not to attend to insult anybody! Just a question?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
seriously...no matter what any of you say...This is god awful...The vocals or whatever...I heard the review but i wait to hear for myself to make a decision and THIS IS TERRIBLE 80's synth garbage that is tooooooo uninspired to even make me want to consider thinking twice about hearing anything else they've written...come on people
The instrumentation are excellent. I absolutely dig the synthesizers and what I think are the strings. What I cannot stand is her VOICE. Her VOICE terrifies the crap out of me. If there is a karaoke version, I'll probably buy it.
...was intrigued after reading an interview...and the facial..influences of mathew barney..quite possible me thinks...musically...some laurie anderson in this track I also think...which is cool..as both artists got a lot to offer..one to watch? maybe.
I think this song is beautiful and quite touching not to mention a hit! This androgynous / queer sound and look I find extremely interesting. There are clear references but when done in this way I find it original. :)
You Fantano clones are TRIPPING. If this disturbs your sensibilities it is because you are mindless hipsters who cannot think for yourselves. To my ears and eyes, this is in fact sheer genius. It's provocative and highly intelligent -- unlike Fantano.
Rather hilarious how there's an influx of comments after being reviewed by needledrop/Pitchfork. They're both creating armies of kids who can't discover or enjoy music that hasn't been validated by someone else.
@MrLotteKestner Enjoy music that hasn't been validated by someone else? Are you kidding? Shit if it weren't for theneedledrop and various other music blogs I wouldn't know half the content existied. Do you honestly think someone else's "validation" forms an general opinion for the public? Fuck no it doesn't! Ant hated this album and gave it a 2. Yet, I'm really enjoying it and if it weren't for his "validation" and OPINION HOW THE FUCK WOULD THESE "KIDS DISCOVER IT"???? CHEW on that....
It's so hilarious I fell out of my chair laughing ... except not really. Everyone gets their music from somewhere and evidently these sites (which I don't personally use) are promoting good music ...
So why the fuck not use them? I doubt anyone who dislikes the music forces themselves to listen to it just because they heard it on either one ...
It's called leverage ... we're leveraging the internet to faster discover good obscure bands ... so why be a prick about it?
@MrLotteKestner Some ppl have busy lives mate and haven't got the time to find good music themselves that's why i use needle drop. what's so wrong with that and i make my own choice whether i like it or not, whats annoying is ppl like yourselves who think there so crash hot because they happen to have found a band/artist before it got a little popular. ALL HAIL MRLOTTEKESTNER FOR BEING SUCH A HIPSTER and probably unemployed
@MrLotteKestner I think you are wrong. I think its a brilliant thing that there are people like Fantano or Velocitiesinmusic that introduce the public to new stuff or music they would have not discovered before, rather than resorting to shitty electro pop/rap. I, for one, check out some of these bands and sometimes I will like the band regardless of the review or opposite way around. Its about discovering music, not making someone's opinion your own.
@MrLotteKestner I love PTR for a long time and I m very glad that her work is gaining appreciation she deserves. If you need to stay "alternative" and you don t like the fact of her being reviewed by media, go listen to Nickelback.
@MrLotteKestner Wouldn't those kids just be looking at the Monthly Picks at Pitchfork? Just seeing that it's on a website doesn't mean it's validated. That cyanide band is on websites. Is that validated?
@MrLotteKestner Or...there's a lot of music out there that would go unlistened to without places like needledrop/Pitchfork bringing them wider attention.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
The song is genuinely creepy and unsettling, but it sounds like something made in a half hour FL Studio session. In other words, it's shite. I haven't heard any other Planningtorock songs, any suggestions?
@LukeCowanMusic Well maybe it doesn't make sense to you. But it does for others. And her obviously. Lyrics don't have to be literal and in your face all the time. These are subtle lyrics that seem to come from her stream of consciousness.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@Yesiamblind To be honest, it annoys me when lyrics are in your face and literal. These lyrics truly just make absolutely no sense and if you'd like to explain to me what they mean, then I'd be happy to listen.
I curious, but what is up with the second horn or bump on the bridge of her nose? I love this song and I have to ask. Is it makeup or was she born with it?
poem song. beautiful
sultanavasilisa 5 days ago
looks like the freak from "the hills have eyes" made a hit!
sequoiadendron5 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
just finished the BULLETT Magazine + Planningtorock interview it was great....if anyone is interested
Google: Planningtorock and BULLETT Media
xxx
LJpein 1 month ago
Rzadko powstaje coś tak idealnego.
4R2R 1 month ago
Heard the DJ playing this at Möbel Olfe last Thursday and we were like, what the fuck is this? I hope we get to see her perform soon.
joed66 1 month ago
They'll use words to kill us all.
halfzombiehalfrobot 1 month ago
I'm well over 50, and I like it. Its...different. I like it. Has an emotive quality. yeah I'm probably an aging hippy. Lol.
Kayenne54 1 month ago 5
Who knew the Kazon made hipster music?
gorzek 2 months ago
i love the tempo of this song
piatekmich 2 months ago 2
bela bela bela
vincenzoguasto1 2 months ago
Hipsters bitching about other hipsters...that's new.
blakbones18 2 months ago 6
@blakbones18 Everyone is a hipster these days, apparently.
terepotere 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm on fire!
erzerzer 2 months ago
Comment removed
baracik 3 months ago
Ok sure I enjoy it, but I can admittedly see where Fantano is coming from, and like he said at the start of the review it was his OPINION, he didn't feed it to anyone as fact.
Also what will Planningtorock give you that The Knife wont give you but better?
TimeForBold 3 months ago
beautiful... A lot of drama in it, and light at the same time...
Alfazemaemflor 3 months ago
Précieux
MickaelValli 3 months ago
Love it!
zehip3 4 months ago
This genious
TheAtreyustar 4 months ago
The rest of W is pretty bad, but this song is truly truly genius.
brokenshines 4 months ago
what a wank
kahnmoon 5 months ago
i looooooooove her new stuff!
TheKickasskatie 5 months ago in playlist More videos from JcFuentes85
qué belleza, no puedo dejar de escucharlo.! =D
Pzikodandy 5 months ago
The new revolution of music...LOVE!!
thejohnnygirl 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I am obsessed with this song! and love the video!
leelatik123 5 months ago
Comment removed
leelatik123 5 months ago
adoro
sarcibum 5 months ago
Minha paixão atual.
garotoinvisivel 5 months ago
fuck me in the ars!
ZliBokser 5 months ago in playlist Omiljene
this is bloody good
GriefTourist 6 months ago
her vocal effects are hidous and gut-wrenching, but it's still wonderful
TMSreptiles 6 months ago 2
i love that smile at 3:00
marsmitsu 6 months ago 4
planningtorock dzaan magaria
ika2 6 months ago
I already liked Planningtorock but this is just excellent.
Augustus7669 6 months ago
The Part from 2.24 is epic♥
Irietwins 7 months ago 2
@Irietwins I totally agree.. =0)
texicobitch74 6 months ago
Planningtorock is NOT a band, but the project of a single woman called Janine Rostron. She is my current musical hero.
carpefula 7 months ago 5
This is my no. 1 fav tune right now! Overplay!
tonyology2000 7 months ago
Found them on a video of a Photoshoot of Xavier Dolan on Vogue. :D
petit1406323 7 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
I have never wrote anything controversial in any comment section, but today is the first time because I dont understand howcome there´s so many dislikes on this video. Not that it´s not allowed to give your own opinion but what is so wrong with this tune compared to others that is viewed on more commercialized channels? Not to attend to insult anybody! Just a question?
krizpy187 7 months ago
Comment removed
krizpy187 7 months ago
Brilliant brilliant band,sound. Beautiful and haunting. Like Fever Ray but also unique in there own sense. Evolution in music.
MrRjmac 7 months ago
this isn't creepy at all. planningtorock is a very beautifully evolved project
vaskabocs 8 months ago 2
I like the psychedelic touch.. open space d.. :-)
Cosmalaya 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
seriously...no matter what any of you say...This is god awful...The vocals or whatever...I heard the review but i wait to hear for myself to make a decision and THIS IS TERRIBLE 80's synth garbage that is tooooooo uninspired to even make me want to consider thinking twice about hearing anything else they've written...come on people
SOLILOQUYMUSIC 8 months ago
Pozdrav za Elenuuuu ;) Fotkacu te, ne moras da spavas sa mnom....
ZliBokser 8 months ago
ovaj se jebao s jednorogom i dobio sina
ZliBokser 8 months ago
The instrumentation are excellent. I absolutely dig the synthesizers and what I think are the strings. What I cannot stand is her VOICE. Her VOICE terrifies the crap out of me. If there is a karaoke version, I'll probably buy it.
MuffinLandia 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Anyone else love that smile at 2:58?
zerospaceA4 8 months ago
Great atmosphere <3
XxAlexOnStereoxX 8 months ago
zola jesus meets q lazzarus
picchionero 8 months ago
@picchionero except PTR has been around much longer
hammeringz 8 months ago
49 leute ham ihr nosn brocha
HURENWEIGI 8 months ago
...was intrigued after reading an interview...and the facial..influences of mathew barney..quite possible me thinks...musically...some laurie anderson in this track I also think...which is cool..as both artists got a lot to offer..one to watch? maybe.
newlassie40 8 months ago
>I Love it ...i love it so much :I
Ausschwitzung 8 months ago
Where are all these retards coming from? In the comment sections, I mean.
AgalinSane 8 months ago
@AgalinSane theneedledrop
iwannabevictorio 8 months ago
BYE! I'm off to Fever Ray!
adsbegone 8 months ago
@adsbegone never come back
ika2 8 months ago
Janine, I'm addicted to you !! ♥
DakotaIcelandic 8 months ago 22
So awesome! I love it!
dreamspydr 8 months ago 22
LOL DONT BE SURPIRSIEDS I EM RPREISPING NOT Y I'S
MrVictiln 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this just sounds... cheap :/
TheOriginalZero1 8 months ago
I think this song is beautiful and quite touching not to mention a hit! This androgynous / queer sound and look I find extremely interesting. There are clear references but when done in this way I find it original. :)
michaelforrey1 8 months ago 13
You Fantano clones are TRIPPING. If this disturbs your sensibilities it is because you are mindless hipsters who cannot think for yourselves. To my ears and eyes, this is in fact sheer genius. It's provocative and highly intelligent -- unlike Fantano.
damondo88 8 months ago 38
Come on guys, it's not THAT bad.
Astraios91 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dear anyone who actually likes this garbage,
you are a hipster. or you are deaf.
thats all.
sockostealshearts 8 months ago
i like TND and this song. GET AT ME YALL LOL.
esmeronrpg2193 8 months ago 2
Rather hilarious how there's an influx of comments after being reviewed by needledrop/Pitchfork. They're both creating armies of kids who can't discover or enjoy music that hasn't been validated by someone else.
MrLotteKestner 8 months ago 85
@MrLotteKestner Enjoy music that hasn't been validated by someone else? Are you kidding? Shit if it weren't for theneedledrop and various other music blogs I wouldn't know half the content existied. Do you honestly think someone else's "validation" forms an general opinion for the public? Fuck no it doesn't! Ant hated this album and gave it a 2. Yet, I'm really enjoying it and if it weren't for his "validation" and OPINION HOW THE FUCK WOULD THESE "KIDS DISCOVER IT"???? CHEW on that....
mike22490 8 months ago 7
@mike22490 You seem... mad. Take a Xanax.
MrLotteKestner 8 months ago
@mike22490
excellent and fitting response.
zoticus1 8 months ago
@MrLotteKestner
Perhaps instead of expecting everyone to have hours to research good music and pissing on those that give light to some just enjoy!
Oh and I could care less what people think in reviews, that is what my ears are for.
But dont worry your SOO INDIE!
zoticus1 8 months ago
@MrLotteKestner dunno i just heard it on a bookshop and thought it was amazing, asked the guy for the name and now I'm here
dranicedream 8 months ago
@MrLotteKestner and how did you discover them??
yenbadcito 7 months ago
@MrLotteKestner
It's so hilarious I fell out of my chair laughing ... except not really. Everyone gets their music from somewhere and evidently these sites (which I don't personally use) are promoting good music ...
So why the fuck not use them? I doubt anyone who dislikes the music forces themselves to listen to it just because they heard it on either one ...
It's called leverage ... we're leveraging the internet to faster discover good obscure bands ... so why be a prick about it?
OutSourceRabbit 7 months ago 4
@MrLotteKestner I found Planningtorock on Last.fm. I heard of her about a year ago. I'm so hipster.
Vwoop 7 months ago 3
@MrLotteKestner Some ppl have busy lives mate and haven't got the time to find good music themselves that's why i use needle drop. what's so wrong with that and i make my own choice whether i like it or not, whats annoying is ppl like yourselves who think there so crash hot because they happen to have found a band/artist before it got a little popular. ALL HAIL MRLOTTEKESTNER FOR BEING SUCH A HIPSTER and probably unemployed
rubble1712 6 months ago 6
@MrLotteKestner I think you are wrong. I think its a brilliant thing that there are people like Fantano or Velocitiesinmusic that introduce the public to new stuff or music they would have not discovered before, rather than resorting to shitty electro pop/rap. I, for one, check out some of these bands and sometimes I will like the band regardless of the review or opposite way around. Its about discovering music, not making someone's opinion your own.
000theUnforgiven000 4 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
@MrLotteKestner I love PTR for a long time and I m very glad that her work is gaining appreciation she deserves. If you need to stay "alternative" and you don t like the fact of her being reviewed by media, go listen to Nickelback.
baracik 3 months ago
@MrLotteKestner Wouldn't those kids just be looking at the Monthly Picks at Pitchfork? Just seeing that it's on a website doesn't mean it's validated. That cyanide band is on websites. Is that validated?
DarkMessiBan 3 months ago
@MrLotteKestner needledrop, if anything, invalidates every fuckin tune he bibs on about.
theblahs 3 months ago
@MrLotteKestner Or...there's a lot of music out there that would go unlistened to without places like needledrop/Pitchfork bringing them wider attention.
MrRoute32 2 months ago
Comment removed
Modernscarsofficial 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Gotta agree with Fantano on this one. Her voice is awful.
dude11293 8 months ago
lol son, did he use fruity loops or sumtin?
eduardo13rocha 8 months ago
I Have little dark nice the Cure vibrations
wunderfull Komposition
Ausschwitzung 8 months ago
Rebecca Black. Take notes.
metalhasmyballs2 8 months ago
You people saying this sucks are f*cking weird, not her or her music.
joshuarotteveel 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is so fuckin bad that... its just kinda bad
codeofethics44e 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is so damn bad its just kinda bad
codeofethics44e 8 months ago
This makes complete sense to me. That can't be good.
deceptivepanther 8 months ago
really creepy...
dizzyisme 8 months ago
This song is horrible, but I still love it . Janine is wonderful.
SweetBananaa 8 months ago
Hmmm... not great but I'd prefer this over Justin Bieber.
BenjaminPaulWoodham 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol the saxophones sound so shitty
version191 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
THIS IS SOOOO BAD!
josheskimo 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is pretty vile music, my farts sound better.
lucpallot 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm sure the hipsters will love it.
communistromance 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Trying to be fever ray. Being a steaming pile of smeg.
metalmader 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Oh, to be a fly on the wall as this album was recorded... so I could land on her nose and take a dump.
Metalgazer 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yeah this is just unsettling and weird. I kinda like the melody at 1:08 but the vocals just makes it strange and uncomfortable.. damn this sucks
Deadmeatproductions 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The song is genuinely creepy and unsettling, but it sounds like something made in a half hour FL Studio session. In other words, it's shite. I haven't heard any other Planningtorock songs, any suggestions?
vanillabeanduck 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
like a pop song from the 90's this is just annoying and uncomfortable. lame.
JonPasqual 8 months ago
Fucking Fantano drones up in here. Listen to it before you comment you fucking idiots.
TheRealHimself 8 months ago 28
Not sure if like...
Metaalhoofdje123 8 months ago
I kinda like this song
xiempie 8 months ago
yves klein
ankh4ankh 8 months ago
LISTEN TO IT BEFORE YOU COMMENT YOU FUCKS>
mike22490 8 months ago 24
This comment has received too many negative votes show
At first this song sounded okay... but then she started to sing and it just went down hill from there.
nat4u235 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Wow, you're ripping out your eyes and you're on fire. I'm SO surprised! My suggestion would be "Stop, Drop, and Role."
TritoneMcgee 8 months ago
Chuchesta
peachkey 8 months ago 8
I actually quite enjoyed it alone on a saturday night.
chiken420 8 months ago
this wouldn't be bad if it were satire
Hamandchees3 8 months ago
Fantano
RockerDuk 8 months ago 80
Trying WAY too hard.
Or
Not trying at all.
Bulldog22031 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol this is so bad
soranaru 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This song is garbage, along with the album
timbalin45 8 months ago
@timbalin45 daw, did you get that from the needledrop who got that from pitchfork?
alucardisdumb 8 months ago
@alucardisdumb "Who got that from Pitchfork"? They gave it a way more positive review than he did.
dannyspiterijr 8 months ago
LOVE the lyrics, so heartfelt.
Yesiamblind 8 months ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@Yesiamblind Got to assume you're joking there. "Don't be surprised if I'm ripping out my eyes. I'm on fire." What? That doesn't even make sense.
LukeCowanMusic 8 months ago
@LukeCowanMusic Of course he is kidding
nge1301 8 months ago
@LukeCowanMusic Well maybe it doesn't make sense to you. But it does for others. And her obviously. Lyrics don't have to be literal and in your face all the time. These are subtle lyrics that seem to come from her stream of consciousness.
Yesiamblind 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@Yesiamblind To be honest, it annoys me when lyrics are in your face and literal. These lyrics truly just make absolutely no sense and if you'd like to explain to me what they mean, then I'd be happy to listen.
LukeCowanMusic 8 months ago
really awesome video
LkAuYrNtE 8 months ago 19
I wish music like this was more popular in north america. all they listen to over there is plastic, stale shit. This is real music!
tickertape82 9 months ago 5
I curious, but what is up with the second horn or bump on the bridge of her nose? I love this song and I have to ask. Is it makeup or was she born with it?
Carnacki23 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow this is bad
trufiend138 9 months ago
This reminds me of the "Lost Boys" for some reason.
badboyrhythmdub 9 months ago
BE MINE JANINE
reegstasaurus 9 months ago
This is AMAZING. Omg I can not WAIT for this to drop! first a new iamamiwhoami track revival, then I discover this. sooooo awesome <3
TheWorldsLimits 9 months ago
simply beautiful.
lorenzoschiavo 9 months ago 18
Planningtorock - I am your man ( from the album "W" coming in may 2011)
youtube.com/watch?v=HEVUExhiz2U
Handlungsbedarf 9 months ago
My friend booked her for a festival this summer and we got invited to her gig @ Electrowerkz Islington, London - SO GOOD.
samanthastretch 9 months ago
chilling. haunting. beautiful. review at poemculture(dot)blogspot
NicholausBonfire 9 months ago
I saw her last night in London. What a fantastic gig. She is amazing.
Riskiamo 9 months ago
sehr geil....freu mich sehr auf das album !
Handlungsbedarf 9 months ago in playlist music 21
i found of this for Fever Ray
ApplesiPhone4 9 months ago
like my best surreal dreams in tangible form. too good
Yngelel 9 months ago
i´m freaking out with everything about Planningtorock. sounds kind a atemporal stuff.
manumazzaro 9 months ago
Cant' wait for this album!
iAmElectroPopTart 9 months ago
Absolutely a genius¡¡¡ She is a great musician¡¡¡ This song is too deep¡¡ WE BREAK TO EASILY ¡¡¡ Thanks Janine¡¡¡
yonderyef 9 months ago 21
totally addicted!!!!!!!! LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE IT.
androplasm 9 months ago 19
I am really interested about her outlook. Is it her real face or just make-up?
graveboy1 9 months ago 2
@graveboy1 Her outlook! But still great!!!
JcFuentes85 9 months ago 5
@JcFuentes85
Sorry, my English is not so good :D What I ment is her natural appearance
graveboy1 9 months ago
@graveboy1 no it's not... it's make-up.
theblahs 9 months ago
@JcFuentes85 "outlook" is quite correct german english u know hehe
sassmani 8 months ago
@graveboy1
make up :)
CrackWhoreModels 9 months ago
@graveboy1 It's make up. That's why the little kid has the same look. She likes masks.
TheMedusaSlayer 9 months ago
@graveboy1 Its makeup. She's a complete performance artist.
cedqwig 9 months ago
@graveboy1 It's her real face.
PorroFirst 8 months ago