Carter is surely one the best but not the best. Mj, Wilkins, Bryant, Ryder, Kemp and many more are as good as him. Plus the best dunker ever is not an NBA player: check Kadour Ziani and you'll see (and he's just 5"10)...
pshh dont even compare nate robinsons to this.... nate robinson used his back to get higher and it was a dunk contest not in game.... thers more pressure in game....
It's probably going to be a while before they get something like this on film again. Maybe in a playground or something though I doubt there are many 7'2" streetballers around. Simply amazing.
Not only is this guy 7'2"... He was picked number 15 in the FIRST round of the 1999 NBA Draft by the Knicks! ...No wonder he never actually played in the NBA though... To give you an idea of how good he really is, some of the players that were picked in the '99 Draft Class AFTER HIM include: Ron Artest (16th) James Posey (18th) Andrei Kirilenko (24th) Manu Ginobli (57th) Chris Andersen (Undrafted) Raja Bell (Undrafted) How many of them has VC jumped over? This. Was. Huge.
i dont get why people think lebron is. lebron has no style in his dunks all he does is jump really high and through it hard, tell me the truth have you ever seen lebron do a 360 dunk?????
VC has a top 10 360 dunks video
no question about it VC best dunker ever in the nba
@noblebeast5 which crazy ass compared lebron to VC?! man the ppl who say lebron is better than VC at dunking, they shall put their crack pipes away!! VC is the craziest motherfucker .. he has so many styles at dunkin .. i've never seen lebron doing a 360 or something crazy like vc did!! VC has way more style at dunking, he would beat MJ, Dr.J, Dominique Wilkins and and .. im sure about this!!! there are also ppl who say lebron is better than kobe .. loool quit smokin crack fellas ;)
Lebron's D I C K ? No James could not even do this dunk! To set the rcord straight Carter is for me the BEst Dunker in the History of the NBA He can do dunks thatnot even Jordan was able to do .
i question whether lebron couold do this at all. Firstly he jumps off one leg. Though he is IMMENSELY explosive off it, he would then have to part legs mid air to go over weis!!! His two leg jumps aren't as high!
That is the sickest play I've ever seen in basketball. If there wasn't a video, I wouldn't have believed it was possible. Vinsanity...must be the hair.
ohh yeah.. i was sitting on the baseline that day watching it with my boys in Sydney. It gave me the chills when I saw Vince in the air. I mean, to me he seemed like he wasn't gonna make the dunk, but when he smashed it through the hoop, my jaw dropped and we all stood silent with our hands on top of our heads, mouths wide open and eyes wide open confused as if to question if what we saw was real.
Pure classic, watched it live also and damn near pissed myself! And KG was an inch away from getting knocked out, LMAO! Just wish my Knicks didn't draft that worthless piece of shit! Could've had Artest or Ginobili among others...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
nice VC! sorry to say tho, in a 5th grade league game, i dunked over a 5'4 kid on our 7 foot basketball hoop. Everyone went wild! Especially as i hung from the rim waiting for help to get down!
hahaha i love the friggin title... french toast.. classic...
no matter how many times i watch this it'll never get old... i wish they could figure out how high he jumped when he did this... had to be around 46-48 inches...
yeah but the fact is that this dunked happened in an actual game. Not to mention in the olympics where millions of people watch around the world. this is by far the most memorable dunk in history not because the dunk itself was great but that it happened on the grandest stage of all
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Yes, i admit it was sick dunk onmyredeye. but he has only done that once. meaning there was some luck to it. There has been nba players that have jumped that height is what im saying. If you look carefully, weis was kind of ducking to get out of the way, but if he would have jumped up, it would not have happened. Remember the slam dunk in 01? I think his dunk was better. Still a good dunk, just not the most impressive of all time if you really evaluate the circumstances.
good dunk but the thing is if you watch carefully, he didn't exactly dunk over him. He sort of jumped on him and the guy ducked by about a foot. Just watch the vid and pretend weis isn't there. See? Jordan and webb's vertical still is more impressive. It's just that weis being there made it look better than it was. Good dunk though. But just cuz weis was in the way and ducked, doesn't mean it's the MOST impressive dunk ever. He wouldn't have dunked over weis, if weis stood tall.
i mean how are you qualified to evaluate the best dunk of all time. show respect. your god damn imagination can't even fathom something like this happening and he v.c. did it. for your next basketball evaluation, why don't you tell all of youtube what the best lay up of all time is
BUT but but but wouldn't you naturally duck if a guy's crotch is fyling into your face? Yes yes I would duck, either way it's either getting dunked on with or without swallowing a genital full of VC
Um why cant he do the same thing now?? Well being as Vince Carter is a human being um theres this thing called age and plus those jumps take its toll on the knees losing explosivness especially since hes been getting up like that since his high school days
Great dunk by Vince. But it is sad, that Vince will go down into NBA history as nothing more than a great dunker and scorer. He will also be remembered for being a arrogant ass (remember the Toronto episode) and screwing up the chances of the Nets to ever reach the Finals (or even playoffs) again. Hope they get rid of this spoilt kid and get Lebron into the Nets soon.
There was absolutely nothing racial about what I said. I am calling it like it is. He isnt white, or hispanic is he? He is black. and I was stating that Blacks are more athletic than most ppl merely by the way they are wired, there is a huge difference b/w being racial, and calling people what they are.
PEASE DONT READ THIS.You will get kissed on the nearest possible Friday by the love of your life.Tomorrow will be the best day of your life.However,if you don't post this comment to at least 3 videos,you will die within 2 days.Copy and paste this,to be saved
Carter is surely one the best but not the best. Mj, Wilkins, Bryant, Ryder, Kemp and many more are as good as him. Plus the best dunker ever is not an NBA player: check Kadour Ziani and you'll see (and he's just 5"10)...
insultmeplease 1 month ago
@insultmeplease Wasn't Spud Webb 5'^"? I'm sure he should be up there as well.
MrSav4life 1 week ago
vc is a great dunker and arguably the best open court dunker but i'd take jordan over vc when it comes to dunking in traffic/on people
ckakka2 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Love this video so much ! Don't you just miss the vintage VC days as well?
Come check out my channel with lots of dunk highlights dedicated to Vince Carter reenacted with 2K12 ! :)
NikeFaller 3 months ago
FRENCH HEAD
SKOPE915 6 months ago
best dunk contest dunker i'll take MJ over him in game though
redbull723 6 months ago
vince carter has dunked over the 18 people who dislike this video
jkap490 8 months ago
That dude got teabagged & posterized all on one play! haha....
888duane 8 months ago
Carters balls all over the 7 footers face. What a dunk
drivebyee 1 year ago
I make NBA Mixes with so much passion...but noone watches them. Could anyone here gimme a comment at least?
KingKoltAir 1 year ago
almost punched kevin in the face over the excitement.
incredible dunk though.
best dunker in the nba; HANDS DOWN.
SLiCKkNiCKk97 1 year ago
Vince Carter is a giant blubbering vagina
Richard Simmons could kick his bitch ass
Frankenpalin 1 year ago
@Frankenpalin Had too much dick lately?
Marakulous43 1 year ago
@Marakulous43 ask your Mom
Frankenpalin 1 year ago
pshh dont even compare nate robinsons to this.... nate robinson used his back to get higher and it was a dunk contest not in game.... thers more pressure in game....
zxzkilme3 1 year ago
Talk about not using your size...
CrazyWacky2 2 years ago
Didnt you see Nate dunk over Dwight LOL. thats epik!
Fatmouse25 2 years ago
vince carter + hair = massive dunk
lazyboii27 2 years ago
It's probably going to be a while before they get something like this on film again. Maybe in a playground or something though I doubt there are many 7'2" streetballers around. Simply amazing.
tysongeisler 2 years ago
i bet the guy is all like wtf where he go
Mrcabletwitch 2 years ago
Take da jersey off cuz jus disgraced VC number LMFAO
DeangeloThomas 2 years ago
I know there have been some great dunkers over the days....But VC is hands down the best one of all time. What he has done will never be touched.
CarmeloLeBronFan 2 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
have u seen dwayne wades dunk on varejao not too long ago? its amazing haha
206watt 2 years ago
WOW
rondocelticsfan9 2 years ago
shadster20 2 years ago 2
that was hot!!
Mrdonpeps 2 years ago
Vc is the best dunker alltime hands down
xxxkobsanity 2 years ago 32
...and legs up lol
washcloud 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I think Carter would be #2 all time. Dominique Wilkins would be #1.
agent7788 2 years ago
best dunker of all time in the nba ... VC
i dont get why people think lebron is. lebron has no style in his dunks all he does is jump really high and through it hard, tell me the truth have you ever seen lebron do a 360 dunk?????
VC has a top 10 360 dunks video
no question about it VC best dunker ever in the nba
noblebeast5 2 years ago 44
@noblebeast5
you could have just said "no question about it VC best dunker ever".
faythkx 1 year ago
@noblebeast5 which crazy ass compared lebron to VC?! man the ppl who say lebron is better than VC at dunking, they shall put their crack pipes away!! VC is the craziest motherfucker .. he has so many styles at dunkin .. i've never seen lebron doing a 360 or something crazy like vc did!! VC has way more style at dunking, he would beat MJ, Dr.J, Dominique Wilkins and and .. im sure about this!!! there are also ppl who say lebron is better than kobe .. loool quit smokin crack fellas ;)
SickVick7 1 year ago
@noblebeast5 who the fuck says that lebron is the best?
MrTiggy1998 10 months ago
@noblebeast5 lebron avoids the contact too
cacalac1 10 months ago
@noblebeast5 plus vince has a poster on pretty much every known defensive star
emericaclay1 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Dunks will only get you two points, and NO NBA championships!!!! Practice shooting, passing, teamwork, and the fundamentals first!!!!!!
privateclem 2 years ago
i bet yo white ass cant dunk... thats why you talkin shit.... ill dunk on yo ass and cash a three in yo face Bitch!!!!!
husalahhus07 2 years ago
nuts for supper my French friend.
rexman14 2 years ago 2
lol
MakeWay4TheBoss 2 years ago
●▬▬▬▬▬๑۩۩๑▬▬▬▬▬▬●
COPY AND PASTE
If you will be one of the people who is unsubscribing to fred on June the 1st.
●▬▬▬▬▬๑۩۩๑▬▬▬▬▬▬●
NBApro74 2 years ago
I.M.O.
THE BEST DUNK EVER
greenmatrix151023387 2 years ago 5
freaking amazing, btw was that kevin garnett nr 10?
RinorMaz 2 years ago
YES IT WAS
greenmatrix151023387 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
☻/
/▌
/ \
ReberBulut 2 years ago
that french dude had nuts on his face...hahaha
Beanertaco92 2 years ago 4
one of the most craziest ass dunks EVER!!!!!!
chaldofood36 2 years ago
dunk of the century
clazier 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
☻/
/▌
/ \
mofrechen 2 years ago
Carter is the all time best dunker
ramcess45 2 years ago 8
right over top of em!!!
KH1523 2 years ago
he flyed for a sec there
dontlikemb 2 years ago
wHATS UP WITH THESE young kinds on
Lebron's D I C K ? No James could not even do this dunk! To set the rcord straight Carter is for me the BEst Dunker in the History of the NBA He can do dunks thatnot even Jordan was able to do .
hitthemhard 2 years ago
damn right Vince Carter is the best dunker for me
Simongs 2 years ago 3
your an idiot.
He's good yes... but where is he? He isnt leading a team like Lebron is.
Is he a better dunker than Lebron? Maybe, there is valid evidence, but is he a better Basketball player than Lebron? No way.
And as for the best dunker in the history of the NBA? no... just no.....
jamycrothers 2 years ago
not better than lebron at the moment, but best dunker of all time, no doubts. team Flight Brothers can do crazy dunks, but not in an official game.
Baklkls13 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think lebron james is better he could easily do that dunk
boontron731 3 years ago
sorry but
lebron could never do this
B4balla 2 years ago 5
I don't think LeBron is better at dunking but he might be able to do this ...wait,,,"easily"?? I'm not so sure about that
SamdaWitness23 2 years ago
i question whether lebron couold do this at all. Firstly he jumps off one leg. Though he is IMMENSELY explosive off it, he would then have to part legs mid air to go over weis!!! His two leg jumps aren't as high!
Av1on1cs 2 years ago
best dunker
quangthach89 3 years ago 4
greatest dunk in the history of basketball.... nuts on his head
akatillman32 3 years ago 4
if i was weis i would have announced my immediate retirement
fitzy11nb 3 years ago 4
lol he didnt retire but this guy was supposed to be one of the best in the nba but got to embarresed to declare for draft
ALBOMAFIA7 3 years ago
unreal, insane
acotytamwiesz 3 years ago
they said oh shit lol
lennox214 3 years ago
That is the sickest play I've ever seen in basketball. If there wasn't a video, I wouldn't have believed it was possible. Vinsanity...must be the hair.
gharlston11 3 years ago
ohh yeah.. i was sitting on the baseline that day watching it with my boys in Sydney. It gave me the chills when I saw Vince in the air. I mean, to me he seemed like he wasn't gonna make the dunk, but when he smashed it through the hoop, my jaw dropped and we all stood silent with our hands on top of our heads, mouths wide open and eyes wide open confused as if to question if what we saw was real.
jimsimsNnoodles 3 years ago 2
WHAT XD the guy he jumped must have been like.. WHAT THE FUCK, oh fuck this what is this the frekin matrix that is impossible. .. bnech time for me
MrsRandomMadeMeDoIt 3 years ago
Le plus grans dunk de tout les temps. Vince Carter est tout simplement incroyable
kimekarate 3 years ago
Freedom kiss my balls!
grinningchicken 3 years ago
I love how Garnett is waiting on the side for the hand off, or waiting to help then ends up watching Vince plaster this French Fag.
LSSRoshi 3 years ago
Pure classic, watched it live also and damn near pissed myself! And KG was an inch away from getting knocked out, LMAO! Just wish my Knicks didn't draft that worthless piece of shit! Could've had Artest or Ginobili among others...
HypeBigelow 3 years ago
man i remember watching this live, and it was amazing
volimcevape 3 years ago
i like how he almost sticks garnet in the face ha ha ha ha
Alberts713 3 years ago 5
poor guy gets Carter's crotch in his face
McTwiggy 3 years ago
Haha fucking French faggot!
JeffThunder 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Plzzz click into my channel and watch me and my daddy play some gr8 basketball ;)
BasketballShots 3 years ago
i like the lil leg kick :p
JeffThunder 3 years ago
Another French surrender.
hiflysi 3 years ago 5
There is no way the world will ever see a better dunk then this. This is the greatest of all time. Appreciate it for what it's worth.
spv2 3 years ago 5
Seriously HurleyIntI05 how can you diss a dunk like that? That is probably the greatest poster dunk the world will ever see.
taylormac88 3 years ago
wen was this?
sodapop10101 3 years ago
The 2000 summer olympics
mondopark 3 years ago
holy shit
sodapop10101 3 years ago
ddamn
TobiasxFunke 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
nice VC! sorry to say tho, in a 5th grade league game, i dunked over a 5'4 kid on our 7 foot basketball hoop. Everyone went wild! Especially as i hung from the rim waiting for help to get down!
HurleyIntl05 3 years ago
Cuz of this dunk, there is the shame on France :(
themvp76 3 years ago
if you think he was the first one to do it check:
"Shaq jumps over the defender's head and dunks"
daaaaaaaaaaaaaaaam
etherodromos 3 years ago
lol yeah i saw that he almost decked kg in the face.. and he tried to play it out..
would be funny if he did by mistake..
RatedRSteve 3 years ago
that guy must remember vince for sure.
harris1001 3 years ago
I CAN DO THAT
274766738 3 years ago
he almost punched KG in the face!!! lls
jamminjay301 3 years ago
i was just gonna type that until i saw ur comment. :D
reddfan022 3 years ago
wow thats so sick i wish i could do that
ttmoney94 3 years ago
the french always get owned lol
steve142 3 years ago
this is not an infamous dunk....maybe if your french..
cb4allstar2 3 years ago
yeah.
harris1001 3 years ago
thank you I hate when people use words they dont know the meaning of.
mikebibs2451 3 years ago
"My high school coach said 2 points is 2 points... My high school coach couldn't dunk"
-Vince Carter
BroGrizzle 3 years ago 10
haha nice!
RAFN90 3 years ago
nice vince carter in his prime
imdl31 3 years ago
yikes
gamehng007 3 years ago
hahaha i love the friggin title... french toast.. classic...
no matter how many times i watch this it'll never get old... i wish they could figure out how high he jumped when he did this... had to be around 46-48 inches...
basic2388 3 years ago
this guy like lifted off like he had rockets in his shoes, LEGEND
ctx60 3 years ago
i do that too
molins69 3 years ago
how can he do that
mj couldnt do that
or at least not as eassily as vince
gametheflame 3 years ago 5
OMG!!! lol. i hope that dude got benched then kicked off the team. and then kicked outta the country lol
Guunit 3 years ago
=/ I Think That Guy Got Posterized
marcaaron28 3 years ago
Vote vc for all star he wont let you down
osamaiam 3 years ago
i believe i can fly..
kier0018 3 years ago 4
lol vince teabagged that guy
outtriggers 3 years ago 4
omg!!!
tray91drummersop 3 years ago 3
i wonder what weiss does in his daily life.
N0KKAA 3 years ago 2
It's VINCEsanity!!! lmao
Scrap35218 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
wow! best free tips to improve your vertical on the net:
jumplikevince com
RedBullgakov 3 years ago
I would of just hit the showers if I was that guy!!1
sinniter 3 years ago 2
VC said: Taste my balls!
ZSOUPZ 3 years ago 5
So the Challenge is unbeaten; Who can dunk over someone in-game; Vince Carter over 7'2 Frenchman
Still Title Holder
TheUnspeakableTruth 3 years ago 4
THE GREATEST DUNK EVER. PERIOD
tenkre 3 years ago 10
fukin sic, garneet almost getting punched
ctx60 3 years ago 6
French Toast. hahahahah
bbllindrider 3 years ago
frederic weistman
salmaaO1x3 3 years ago
I love Vin Baker's reaction. He just walked away scared.
tealish 3 years ago 2
OMG WHY DOESNT IT WORK????????
tyjon2112 3 years ago
RIGHT OVER HIS FUCKN ASS!!! LOLOL
rdooze 3 years ago 2
lol even if weis ducked (barely) vc still jumped over his height of 6ft6, crazy!
aalrin 3 years ago
yeah but the fact is that this dunked happened in an actual game. Not to mention in the olympics where millions of people watch around the world. this is by far the most memorable dunk in history not because the dunk itself was great but that it happened on the grandest stage of all
jdiggy0424 3 years ago 4
the dunk I am talking about is in the 2001 slam dunk contest. Desmon Mason. I think his vertical was higher than vince.
JLeemich 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Yes, i admit it was sick dunk onmyredeye. but he has only done that once. meaning there was some luck to it. There has been nba players that have jumped that height is what im saying. If you look carefully, weis was kind of ducking to get out of the way, but if he would have jumped up, it would not have happened. Remember the slam dunk in 01? I think his dunk was better. Still a good dunk, just not the most impressive of all time if you really evaluate the circumstances.
JLeemich 3 years ago
n00b
hOOdilol 3 years ago 3
when the french was trying to think about jumping, carter already was in the air, noob.
ZiroGomez 3 years ago
good dunk but the thing is if you watch carefully, he didn't exactly dunk over him. He sort of jumped on him and the guy ducked by about a foot. Just watch the vid and pretend weis isn't there. See? Jordan and webb's vertical still is more impressive. It's just that weis being there made it look better than it was. Good dunk though. But just cuz weis was in the way and ducked, doesn't mean it's the MOST impressive dunk ever. He wouldn't have dunked over weis, if weis stood tall.
JLeemich 3 years ago
yes, he DID DUNK OVER him. wut u are trying to say is he didnt jump 7'2, which is really not the issue here, cuz he FUCKING DUNKED OVER A 7'2 CENTER.
OnmyRedEye 3 years ago
i mean how are you qualified to evaluate the best dunk of all time. show respect. your god damn imagination can't even fathom something like this happening and he v.c. did it. for your next basketball evaluation, why don't you tell all of youtube what the best lay up of all time is
SizzleMyBaconPlz 3 years ago
BUT but but but wouldn't you naturally duck if a guy's crotch is fyling into your face? Yes yes I would duck, either way it's either getting dunked on with or without swallowing a genital full of VC
spankyou 3 years ago
Vc is the best dunker ever..
Flamiano20 3 years ago 2
a world history
llsoundwavell 3 years ago
Lol it wud be funny if he accidently punched Garnett
babyyao11 3 years ago 4
Um why cant he do the same thing now?? Well being as Vince Carter is a human being um theres this thing called age and plus those jumps take its toll on the knees losing explosivness especially since hes been getting up like that since his high school days
nbprince3 3 years ago
Great dunk by Vince. But it is sad, that Vince will go down into NBA history as nothing more than a great dunker and scorer. He will also be remembered for being a arrogant ass (remember the Toronto episode) and screwing up the chances of the Nets to ever reach the Finals (or even playoffs) again. Hope they get rid of this spoilt kid and get Lebron into the Nets soon.
freemsia 3 years ago
crazy vc mix this other guy made
/watch?v=k05eNigRVI8&fmt=18
yomama123abc 3 years ago
LMAO on 0:25 the guy on the left walked away like he's scared. omg
muffinscousin 3 years ago 2
lol i noticed that too
ItalianDunker12 3 years ago
french toast hahahahahahahahaha
and they got beat in swimming, hahahahahahaha
LVL95ForumTroll 3 years ago
Weis should ahve stuck his hands up and then fell when Vince hit him. Could of picked up the charge easy.
upinflamezzz 3 years ago
no, he stepped in towards carter when vince jumped. Sorry but not gonna happen.
muffinscousin 3 years ago
they dont give u a charge for having your hands up.
tywonellington 3 years ago
IS THIS POSSIBLE? he just jumped ovr a 7"2 guy? he gets so much frekin air... y cant he do the same now?
NJNets4ever 3 years ago
Age and conditions just have to be perfect. Adrenaline took over there.
dbadmus 3 years ago
BOO-YAH!!
MegaSpiderMan 3 years ago
Our stupid Knicks could've got Artest, Posey, AK 47, but what a great selection Weis turned out to be
ironmikegtyson 3 years ago 3
HUMILIATION!!!
Andy123180 3 years ago
thats why he didnt play in the nba
tbone072892 3 years ago
lol
JW2K3 3 years ago
was this the 2000 olympics?
mz768 3 years ago
dont get into arguments.dont say bad comments.its the best dunk ever.period.
eluspjewgold1299 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
can you read this? go to my person--al page to see me n-a-k-e-d (meetyourfling) c o m
17624
bayard
blogdacidade 3 years ago
the best dunk ever the best the best give that 100
NoypiFighters 3 years ago
french toast. ahah i like i like
ccchrv 3 years ago 2
see what happens when you play against black people
walls777 3 years ago 2
I don't like ur racial comment but ironically the name weis means "white" in German..( this french guy is from a former german town of france...)
Kdoris 3 years ago
umm I think your rather ignorant to be honest.
There was absolutely nothing racial about what I said. I am calling it like it is. He isnt white, or hispanic is he? He is black. and I was stating that Blacks are more athletic than most ppl merely by the way they are wired, there is a huge difference b/w being racial, and calling people what they are.
walls777 3 years ago
Vince like, "eat my shorts, weis."
jchristianw 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
PEASE DONT READ THIS.You will get kissed on the nearest possible Friday by the love of your life.Tomorrow will be the best day of your life.However,if you don't post this comment to at least 3 videos,you will die within 2 days.Copy and paste this,to be saved
gameking605 3 years ago
yeah, he has some nice steals and blocks in mixes with the nets
encore707 3 years ago
I'm looking for videos of Carter playing defense-- has anyone seen any?
veranka3 3 years ago 2
lol
josephohsnap 3 years ago
hahaha that made me laugh
JmanM 3 years ago
lol that's cold man haha
Skyhighblu 3 years ago
are you kidding me? lmao....
ccchrv 3 years ago
in this video carter does the perfect defense in the beggining: Steal
ZiroGomez 3 years ago
And this is the guy the Knicks drafted over Artest.
Mike28326 3 years ago
haha seriously. he got wat he deserved for being a bs pick for us.
TeeneNY 3 years ago