Yea cuz they hyped the song up better, Amy just made the slow song....slower, I love her but this could have been better, She should have had Evanescence one it and then like rocked it out so it would be so much better.
That is just the most beautiful cover I've heard in awhile. I haven't listened to Evanescence for like a year but really, it's so smooth and so sad. It's just beautiful.
errm, maybe cus amy lee was like 11 when this film came out. Besides Sally isnt a singer, shes a character, and Catherine O hara portrayed the role perfectly, with all the nuance and imperfections of a lonely doll/girl thing with longing, heart and dreams. If amy COULD do that, then by all means she should apply for the next disney film.
the music is playing a i - III - iv progression and when it goes to iv the singer inflects the 3rd of the iv chord as major instead of minor thus briefly making the chord a IV instead of iv(minor) in its current key of d minor this would mean it's d minor chord, f major chord, then g minor chord(g-Bflat-d) but she first sings a B NATURAL in the g minor chord instead of Bflat so inflects it with a major intonation/appagiatura thus giving it that distinctive sound u hear at 2:14
omg all the other songs r like nothing compared to this!!! i love amy lee!! ussually the original is better but this song i soooo awesome!! but the original sally is better much respect there.
amy's version sounds 1,000,000x better then fiona's, no diss but her version was so ...blah... amy's is just way better.. nothing wins over the original sally though.. much respect!!
if you have the original soundtrack, it talks about the narrator visisting jack and it says that he saw 5 skeleton children. the title of it is "Closing"
da song not fan mAde tho alota good artists are doin this albumn nightmare revisted love M mansons and Korns
Maphirious 7 months ago
Amy Lee to play Sally and Warrel Dane to play Jack! would be so awesome! X)
mygoddessar 9 months ago
her voice is amazing, the 3 years of opera trainig really paid off for her.. my turn!!!! this is such a beautiful song and she made it even better
sanders9194 10 months ago 3
Wow... Just Wow.
Frozenkoldfury 10 months ago
It would be PERFECT if the movie really use this sound track :-O
carmentic 11 months ago 5
Epic
KitsuyaKiba 1 year ago
So haunting. Love it
LSysyn15 1 year ago 4
I have Three versions of this song!
London After Midnight
Amy Lee
And Fiona Apple
:)
Chrissiemusicdork 1 year ago
what a smashing video!! fantastic!!
egoadefonso 1 year ago
Okay i'll say most of the revisited songs are okay but this is amazing and actually gets the emotion the song was ment to portray.
Negima2006 1 year ago 2
i love this song!!!!
Underpressuregirl21 1 year ago
I personally prefer this version of the song and think that even though Evanescence didn't write/perform the song originally this is her best song.
Gruumsh4 1 year ago
God This woman has an amazing voice.. It gives me chills :)
JAGDandCA 1 year ago 2
I like this song!
beaglegirl101 1 year ago
She did a great job. She has a pretty dark/warm tone quality in songs like this even though she can't belt. Got to love her.
Euphorianna 1 year ago
i was excited to hear that Amy sang this song xD completely over joyed right now
BlairOWNs 1 year ago
Amy's Voice is So beautiful
Mikiv26 1 year ago
Oh Amy Lee, so wonderful, just so Sally!
elfen4 1 year ago
OMG...I love this. Amy is so amazing, and this is an amazing song. Her voice is so beautiful and haunting. <3
Listen2theMusic3 1 year ago
oh this song is beautiful :DD
TheDenmarkGirl1 1 year ago
Beautiful!!
robbiereindeerlover 1 year ago
this song gose with thw movie perfectly...i love it and amy lee's voice shes amazing
tiffanymichelle100 1 year ago 2
BRAVO!!!!!
xxgAggYchiZZyxx 1 year ago
This song is depressing, the EXACT reason I love it!!
McKennaLuvsBaha500 1 year ago
Omg. I love it. Cudos!!!
kut11223 2 years ago
this song is amazing...the piano is beautiful and the creshendo at 1:47 is out of this world!!!
mdollar1234 2 years ago 42
@mdollar1234it's actually called a glissando :)
Sk8erboi753 3 months ago
Wonderful.
ScarlettRedTea 2 years ago
absolutley beautiful!!!! i love the Fiona Apple version better......but this is amazing
wallkrawlerx 2 years ago
i love amy lee's voice. good timing on the vid :3
w1ckedgame 2 years ago 4
I don't like Amy lee that much but this is beautiful
dementeddentist 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
bitch!!!!!!!!!!!!!
yzof2 2 years ago
@yzof2 yes, stating one's opinion means one is a bitch.. lol
dementeddentist 1 year ago
@yzof2 bitch really all you can come up with?
taylorcullen100 1 year ago
korn and marylin manson did a good job imo =)
manwithplan61 2 years ago 4
Yea cuz they hyped the song up better, Amy just made the slow song....slower, I love her but this could have been better, She should have had Evanescence one it and then like rocked it out so it would be so much better.
SailorSaturn91 2 years ago
I love this cover! Amy Lee was a brilliant choice!!! it's sadly sweet!
SCIfiNUT69 2 years ago 4
This the only real good cover other than possible manson and korn, those songs fit the original such as this
Chaos4knuckles 2 years ago 2
This version is truly amazing! I love it!
Alibobular 2 years ago 5
That is just the most beautiful cover I've heard in awhile. I haven't listened to Evanescence for like a year but really, it's so smooth and so sad. It's just beautiful.
RetroSimplicity 2 years ago 2
the song has a sad ending but you gave it a happy ending...hmm...i still like it! =D
turtlefanny 2 years ago
i cant believe i have only JUST heard this cover..... AMAZING
lonelysouloceansoul 2 years ago
In your opinion :) I loved all of the CD. Especially the Flyleaf cover.
Monkehpunk 2 years ago 2
Better than mine
IamThreedaysgrace20 2 years ago
luv this song
101st rating!
JnL471 2 years ago
I think this is a great cover, but in the movie it should be O´Hara singin.:D
ResponsLive 2 years ago
i love sally and mr jack!
rosenoir331 2 years ago
so beautiful.
lonleyhoboclown 2 years ago 2
...The best. Just the best.
orochimarui2 2 years ago 6
she has a voice of an angel
cbast2517 2 years ago 50
i think so too
lovebug980612 2 years ago
amy lee is the best!!!
DarckNightmares 2 years ago 3
Try this ^^ done years before AmyThing was around ^^
London After Midnight - Sally's Song
opalewiccan1990 2 years ago
hey... emmm... it's pretty good... but I really prefer Amy Lee's version...
Thank you SOOOOOO much though!!!!
Take care!!!
=)
DarckNightmares 2 years ago
wateva amy is the best at anything she tries to do!!
lovebug980612 2 years ago
oh yeah!!
lovebug980612 2 years ago
why didnt burton asked amy to do the voice of sally?
she could did a great work
rockerofrustrao 2 years ago 3
Because she didn't start her music career until 2 years after the movie came out,wish she was Sally though XD
karimaru 2 years ago 7
Why? Amy is a wonderful singer but she doesn't exactly fit the character of Sally.....
redrose588 2 years ago
I know she doesn't fit.
SomeRockerchick88 2 years ago
errm, maybe cus amy lee was like 11 when this film came out. Besides Sally isnt a singer, shes a character, and Catherine O hara portrayed the role perfectly, with all the nuance and imperfections of a lonely doll/girl thing with longing, heart and dreams. If amy COULD do that, then by all means she should apply for the next disney film.
gooched 2 years ago
the best version. I really love it! and the movie is awesome, of course.
clocloplus 2 years ago 4
Ah! Flyleaf and Amy Lee on the same album?! Sweetness!
hipnhappenin 2 years ago 3
agreed :)
boozkatiecakes 2 years ago
this is a really good video. I love the ending!and Amy Lee did an awesome job
iluvulquiorra 2 years ago
can anyone with a music theory background explain what happens at 2:14? I hear that kind of thing in lots of songs and its cool but what is it?
seudonak 2 years ago
the music is playing a i - III - iv progression and when it goes to iv the singer inflects the 3rd of the iv chord as major instead of minor thus briefly making the chord a IV instead of iv(minor) in its current key of d minor this would mean it's d minor chord, f major chord, then g minor chord(g-Bflat-d) but she first sings a B NATURAL in the g minor chord instead of Bflat so inflects it with a major intonation/appagiatura thus giving it that distinctive sound u hear at 2:14
requiemaeternam7 2 years ago
awesome! this helps a lot, thanks. that is exactly what I was looking for.
seudonak 2 years ago
This was way better than the original.
blackknight710 2 years ago
AWESOME MOVIE (but Amy Lee sings way better than the girl in the movie)
uglyduckbella 2 years ago
This is what Sally SHOULD have sounded like!
DoomedMello 2 years ago 3
omg totally! WAY better than Fiona Apple!!!
livelaughlove094 2 years ago 5
totally ;)
MinamimotosGirl 2 years ago
amy lees is way better, i think sally has a bad voice. but this movie is still the (((BEST!!!!!!!!!!!)))
jokervalencia 2 years ago
all i can say is
wow
xBlaCkxrOsEx6 2 years ago
i simply LOVE DIS SONG.....ITS AMAZINGG...!!!!!!!!!!!! DA LYRICS R SOOO HEART-TOUCHING...TRUELYY ENCHANTINGG..!!
vampire707stacey 2 years ago
Oh my god!
Just plain amazing!
Amy.....you are a god!
VenusEnvy2 3 years ago
loooooove Amy Lee
MarcosMora 3 years ago
omg all the other songs r like nothing compared to this!!! i love amy lee!! ussually the original is better but this song i soooo awesome!! but the original sally is better much respect there.
softballstardoh 3 years ago
i love how she sings it!
fghjghf 3 years ago
great idea, ur awesome i love it
amy's version sounds 1,000,000x better then fiona's, no diss but her version was so ...blah... amy's is just way better.. nothing wins over the original sally though.. much respect!!
LatinaLiiindaz 3 years ago 2
it`s so great... i love it....
I ust sing this song every night for my doughter... and she is 3 ... ^^
Amy is the best 4 me
Darkvamp87 3 years ago
She is amazing!!!:)
Vampirexinxthexally 3 years ago
i love this song!!!!!♥♥♥♥♥♥
maryducks 3 years ago
nice, very nice video! congratulations!
fufycasu 3 years ago
i'm in love.
missmurder99 3 years ago 3
beautiful! far better than the original. I wish amy lee had played sally in the movie :)
Kapilia 3 years ago
lol yeah i love this version is better =]
BloodyValentineAudre 3 years ago
They both sound great in my opinion.
CrimsonNineTail 3 years ago 2
hmmm. I think i like Sallys version better. But Amy lee still rocks!!!
emily11055 3 years ago
i find it kind of funny that jack and sally have five skeleton children
jinjantreprid 3 years ago
When does that happen?
BarkGrrArggWoof 3 years ago
if you have the original soundtrack, it talks about the narrator visisting jack and it says that he saw 5 skeleton children. the title of it is "Closing"
jinjantreprid 3 years ago
i never liked Sally's voice in the movie,,
so glad Amy did this =]
shelleybelly93 3 years ago
this is great
FueledByAlex 3 years ago 2
this version made my cry a lil bit.
roweboat2 3 years ago 2
i know, that was just beautiful
untitled25chick 3 years ago
and will we evr end up together... I lovethat so much!
evanescenceroxxox 3 years ago
i can't remeber is NBC or The Black Cauldron was the first movie i ever saw
(and of course the first animated one)
AMY ROCKS!
nobody will do a better version of sally's song
!
NEVER!!!!!!!!!!
facu2929 3 years ago 2
im not dissin on N.B.C
cuz i freakin love it soo much
but man
amy lee is like my favorite chic
and she just made that 10x better!!!!!
i love jack and sally!!!!
tipsyguttsy 3 years ago 2
i remember when i watch
the movie in the last
x-mas, my mom say's sally's ugly XD
but, she's my favorite character from
disney, after jack sparrow XD
but, i love this version
of the sally's song,
it's so sad
vijinxed 3 years ago
me encantaaa esta cancion!!! =P
XxcOlorsSxX 3 years ago 3
exactly what i was looking for! thanxs(:
violetheaven77 3 years ago 2
Very very good. =)
SasheeML 3 years ago 2
that was a very good song and i like how yoy put the video together
redfield737 3 years ago 2
this is my fave version of this song. she sings it beautifully
RyaNataki 3 years ago
Fucking Awsome!
Realllllly Amazing!
:D
kaichiii 3 years ago
WOW!!!! I love Nightmare! Thanks for making this.
Starfire917 3 years ago 6
You are welcome glad you like it :]
VampyyriBathory 3 years ago 3