Tatu - All The Things She Said - Live Performance Festivalba

[SlavjanA]

wait a minute... this isn't live?!?! U LIE :P :D

[3cheers4Ger]

Oh, this is in Italy? Awesome! I've been taking Italian for 3 weeks now and I love it.

Grazi mille! Sorry, I don't know how to say "for posting this" yet lol.

[NihahCatz]

lip singing but they can definitely sing live

[OrangeCounty92]

@HahaItsAlice in america certain states are aloud gay marriage some are not...............

[Lolwutzers]

Although I enjoy these two's music, I can't help but notice the lack of stage presence ',:-/ of course, the kissing creates a pretty big reaction but damn girls, move around more! Get the audience involved! You two have amazing talent but you need to give the audience something to love other than sex appeal. Thumbs up from me all the same, however :3

[Latiao7]

TATU in my nation!! is fantastic!! I LOVE THEM!! Io amo le t.A.T.u. sono fantastiche!!!!!

[i8cheeseandbarfed]

R.I.P t.A.T.u.......*crys*!

[swabi2007]

cool!!!!!

[TheSweetmaribel]

obvio not live

[giuferfg]

When bunga bunga didn't existed yet, t.A.T.u. were bunga bunga already...

[a1n2i3s4a5]

this is amazing!

[xXSilverFireHawkXx]

wiki said they arent lesbians, but idk if i can trust that XDDD

[NoNameIsPutIn]

thats the realest love i've seen in a while.

[escgirlygirl]

they're not bad live,why do they lipsing so often?

[xXchelsearoxXx]

@escgirlygirl Because they're Russian and the accent might mess up the English lyrics, but I agree they're really good :)

[wolfiemoonOnROBLOX]

I wish I had straight hair so I could cut it short like that....

[tatubilan]

Lena 01:35  xDDD!"

[4everrainbowskittles]

WOW they kno ALOT of languages!!!!!!!!!! but besides that they are really awesome.....and i like to see different people once in awhile

[Alanaluna100]

I love T.A.T.U !!!!



[ni7770]

they r gr8!

[pwned596]

Lol when they kiss, you just hear the crowd go crazy xP

[enrikes100]

jijijijijijijiji

[MattiaHeaven]

I'm proud of them.

[neutronmayor]

this sucks

[8yuliavolk]

@neutronmayor why they lame no? if you don't like, don't try to find! Пойдите трахают себя!

[neutronmayor]

this sucks

[Tatuuuuuuuuuuuuu]

ahh bless them i love tatu so much they are the best band i have ever heard lol

[lucaai]

yes this is a playback....I remember so well this time in television....this was the first time that tatu appeared in TV..... they shocked italy, this kiss was so...unexpected!

[ljomar88]

playback

[etbt9]

live??? ... let me laugh

[belovedGhost777]

Hot

[AmourLyubov]

A lot of these performances from the earlier days have "backing vocal tracks" and the microphones aren't very loud, but it is not entirely playback.

[belovedGhost777]

@AmourLyubov not backing Vocal tracks they like to use Voice modulators. its sort of like guitar effects except its for the microphone. I have one myself and its awesome xD

[tokioteleiras]

is this playback?

[ExcellenceOfInnova]

@tokioteleiras Yes, but can listen a LOT of t.A.T.u, live... Search better.

[TheUnreaI]

every single tatu performance is lipsync :/

[Jsilvers10]

@TheUnreaI I sounded like it at first but this performance they didn't lipsynch

[ExcellenceOfInnova]

@TheUnreaI That's not true. Search better, there's an ENTIRE DVD, the truth live.

[MrProXiced]

Only lipsync.... sick

[marcelismooi]

i want to fuck julia volkova! =) Great video!!

[b0ng0b0ngi]

love dat girls

[Saramausi1996]

islam is the only true religion.

[Fryekid]

@Saramausi1996 Hardstyle is my true religion.

[AlbertWesker89]

@Saramausi1996 Techno/Trance & House are THE Religions!

[KiroRocks]

Man ist das geil, wie die sich küssen!^^

[antizicoh]

hu is the lesbian bothis so beutiful girls

[RuckalltheFules]

Are they at that big old thingy where they used to have gladiators. I'm not trying to be disrespectful but I dunno how to spell it. The colessium or whatever?

[SognatoreDiStelle]

@RuckalltheFules

it's an old Arena... it's called Arena di Verona, the city of Romeo & Juliet, in Italy.

And yes, it is very similar to the Colosseum even if the last one is huge compared to this one.

[Pollon138]

It's strange to see two girl kissing on italian tv! O.O

Trust me, I'm italian and here gay and lesbians are like lepers, you are safe only if others don't know who you really are T^T Kinda happy too see that somethimes things are different ^^ 5/5

[alessia01993]

yes unfortunately it's true =( i am italian too and i hate italy for this!!!!!

italian tv is very false........ and however a lot of people wanted to censure this scene =( it's very ashamed......

[XmusicXchikkX]

@Pollon138 The irony is that this is prolly the only, if not one of the only, recorded performances of this song on Youtube where they ACTUALLY kiss.

[bluedragonblu]

@Pollon138 Really? Things are like that in Italy? :o I had no idea. i'm from Portugal and here the LGBT community is getting more and more accepted. Gay marriage is already approved :D I'm bisexual and I never had any problems here.

[3cheers4Ger]

@Pollon138 Kewl! I'm an American fan (for six years now), but I only understand the English cuz that's all I speak. I love hearing them n Russian, too. I'm taking my first year of Italian in high school, but my teacher never talks about same-sex couples...

[canine1993]

there both russain they cant sing well live in english they have to have the back music.... the dark haired one cant speak english at all tbh....

[RuckalltheFules]

@canine1993 They can sing very well in English thank you very much and the brunette (Yulia) can speak SOME English. They do playback for practically all of thier performances from 01 to 04. Why? I dunno but I don't care. If you go to a tATu concert (this is my opinion) you go to see them in the flesh not to just hear them sing.

[lucasdu54]

1:15 do u seriously believe its live?

[GDR1607]

They're singing above the music

[dichotomy89]

is it really live? i'm not sure about that. but if it is, then they can sing very good live

[blurtopia]

i have a feeling that by the time theyre gonna be back at the tatu project theyre gonna be at theyre 30s which i think might suck,

[voikvoiranxx]

is not live

[wesbrownyeah]

first REAL  live performance i found...

[wesbrownyeah]

ALMOST....

[nicesimonaf]

It's NOT

[natnunnfan]

@wesbrownyeah they have really good voices idk y they wudnt sing live

[wnmetal666]

@wesbrownyeah sounds EXACTLY like the mad tv performance

[Thecoolguy01]

they can't play an instrument...

[fruitcake12493]

Wtf are you talking about.

They play Piano. & I bet they are a hell of a lot better than you will ever be in your whole life.

[GenieBella]

Can't play an instrumental? lmao

Watch the Friend of Foe video. xD

[MsThiely]

I found very choreographed!

[gottaluvgreys]

tatu are not fully over...yes they are starting their solo projects however they are still going to be doing tatu stuff aswell when they can

tatu 4ever!!!

[xdeadinsidex2]

just cause there a lesbiand dosen't mean they dont sound good

[retarded01235]

yes lesbians this band rocks if les or not there just wowoowowoowoowowowoowow2owoowo­woow

[elliottdanielle]

good because if they were't that would be pretty gross

[tpcardoso]

this is lip-synch

[mimirusign]

Yes, most of their older shows were, since 1. Their English wasn't as good when they were younger. 2. There is so much editting on their voices they wouldn't sound anywhere near as good.

But Elena does sing for real from 2005 onward, while Yulia almost never has, specially after her surgery.

They broke up offically in March of 2009, Elena is moving to the U.S. for a solo-career and Yulia is going to work on being a mom.

Project t.A.T.u. is over. =(

[yunarikku2723]

no its not,they just released their new album Happy Smiles.They plan on releasing it in America probably next month then start touring and making more music videos.

[mimirusign]

Yes love, they have. :-/ Check their offical fan forum. They've dove their goodbye show, stated they have retired the t.A.T.u. project and all. Happy Smiles will still be released in English, but that has already been completed with everything they must do, the rest is all editting.

They will not be doing anymore tours according to Yulia and their old manager.

[elliottdanielle]

i love this song it sucks that the lez.

[dba82190]

there not, its a act

[blurtopia]

yes its was an act, but i heard that somewhere they did feel something for each other,

[duckey75]

i liked the part when they kissed

[syntheticwool]

who doesn't?

=)...too bad they zoom out a few secs later

[fabioedario]

i do not

[duckey75]

why the hell not!?

[FUCKAPOPE]

its a bit fucking obviouse tht hey are man fs u no seen all there vids on this man

[EvaShakii]

They are not!!! You stupid!!! It was just a part of marketing plan man!!! Their music is great and JULIA HAVE ALREADY TWO CHILDREN WITH TWO DIFFERENT MANS!!!!

[SweetAndSxcChik]

Just cause she has kids duznt mean they wernt 2getha, ever heard of being bisexual??

They were 2gether at the begining but there not no moor

[finalfantasyVII101]

sorry, but its true. i had trouble believing too. but you can look it up, Yulia got married to a man and they admitted they weren't really lesbians or bisexual

[chellybelly25]

it was an act put together by their original manager ivan._.

[Angelius]

they real lesbian guys!!!cant you see!!

[RioTSinger13]

no me and my best friend kiss eachother like that too :D.....nah just kidding lol yeah they really are Lesbians seriously right on the stage in front of millions of ppl COURSE THERE DYKE"S!!! did i help?

[Angelius]

hahahah!!yeahh!!!!!!!!!!!aweso­me i wish wanna do that of millions thousands of ppl!!xD ahahahha!!LOL!

[MikaMad14]

why does it matter anyway?

[Angelius]

idk..just for fun...

[tasa07]

lesbians are sexy man! so fuckin sexy i got masturbate thinking of these chicks fuckin....no lie.

[AiLD2]

your a sicko and need god in your life

[iHarajukuz]

they're not lesbians, their straight they only acted as lesbians for like money and fame

[slocombe29]

saying that, though, wheen they were teenagers, that was the feelings they had for eachother at that time: "overblown, but very real." Lena Katina, September 2008

[freakofskyline]

Sounds dubbed...I don't know if it is?

[ScarlettM457]

Yes, until they got rid of their first manager, tatu were forced to lipsynch by contract. As well as pretend that they're lesbians and dye their hair a certain color and act a certain way. They sing live now.

[Jessroxsoxx]

bu who freaky freaky who i luv that song OMG

[nedeska94]

tatu i love 4 everrr jajaja la amuu

ti amuu tatu jaja i loveee

[WinterEpiphany]

xDDDDD ''this is not enough'' why does Lena put that face if shes doing play back? xD

[WinterEpiphany]

what year is this from?

[ScarlettM457]

2003...I think.

[CRISTIAN12shark]

lena es la masa bonita

la amoo

[chioyankee]

adoro a yulia es ...tan hermosa...lena tambien es muy binita ..pero yulia tiene una cara de niña q cada vez q la veo siento q las amo a las dos...♥♥♥

[russiantoni]

ARRIBA TATU ABAJO PAULINA RUBIO

[tangodenoxiusrei]

DE UNAA!, la trola de paulina no se chapa a otra perra hermosa en el escenario, jaaaaaaa!

[orianaochoa]

ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh tatuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh TATUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU xD

[bmtimv]

awful sound quality

[dxwoman]

I Love T.A.T.U!!!!!!!!!Amazing Performance!!!!They"are the best of the world!!!!

[pablo221163]

wow !!!! i love t.a.t.u. they are the best....

[snoopdog41]

go tatu!

[WretchedLives]

Even if it was for publicity, I think their flirting on stage is cute ^^ They're beautiful with amazing voices :D

[romagnolo1989]

that was performed in Italy ... Tatu are the bests!

[untres5]

at 1:36 lena almost flew off the stage when they spinned in a circle

[djokenyon]

that's cause yulia let go of her hand

[Lenakatina21]

this is so cute, look how yulia plays with lenas locks while they're kissing - sweet ^__^

[acrosirisproductions]

i wonder if they're still together

[hamnoo]

They never were..it was just a publicity stunt. Doesn't matter, though, I love 'em anyway.

tATu still exists, though. They're releasing a new album! ;)

[freakofskyline]

omg theyve never been together..

theyre not even lesbians

duuh

[SweetAndSxcChik]

Some people say that in a documentary they sed they wer 2getha, but others say that in a documentary they wernt. im confused. i myself believe that they wer once 2getha cause i can see it in there eyes in the early videos and interveiws

[freakofskyline]

Lol..Theire not lesbians dude..Take a closer look at wiki :P

[SweetAndSxcChik]

wiki? im guessing your refering to wikapedia, and that is not a reliable sorse of information anyone can change it if you know how.

And i am a dudette. And i can read people through there eyes quite easily, I strongly believe they wer 2getha once, but there obv not now cuz Yulia has kids lol

[freakofskyline]

Wiki is wikipedia yes... I tought both of them had kids ? Cya dudette ^^,

[SweetAndSxcChik]

As far as i know only Yulia Has kids

[freakofskyline]

Oh.. :P

[dollfin000]

is this really live?

[taty4ever]

sorta. Their really singing. But a recording of the song is played over them.

[tori11193]

is it really live? dosnt sound like it

[monica1984JERSEY]

great song. yulia is so pretty......

[snoopdog41]

tatu is my fav band eva

[accounttemp]

They are lip syncing but, singing some parts. In some parts of their voice, they are echoed which is rare for live performances also,at 2:45 she sings and a fraction of a second later, the backup begins so, she has her voice twice

[wolfspike]

wow, they're actually not lipsynching

[FallingWithTheSun]

They're singing with the actual track behind them

[kornfreak2719]

not live

[inocenteyes4]

playback

[Bobbiehill31]

its live but the person who recorded this sucks at it

[Dragonza]

this was when they were younger so they actually did all their stuff live usually since yulia didnt have to save her voice like she does now

[Aerunfae]

Barely sounds live.....

[inolovesme]

So far this is the only live version of this song that sounds good.

[Jared5000]

great song!!

[ZytkaPants]

Tatu are not lesbians, yulia is actually bisexual in real life, and lena is probably a closet bisexual... i mean look at what their up to right now etc... what they say, do, feel for each other etc... come on its more than what youd do/say to a bestfriend/sister etc! plus lena is russian othrodox christian cause of her family etc so of course shes in denial when she says shes straight.. and the lesbian idea wasnt theirs, it was their sick peado ex manager at the time

[anitake14]

t.A.T.u.(L)(L)

you are my everything..!!!!(LLLL)(KKKK)

big hugs and kisses to russian lena And Julia

ya lyublyu tebya!!!

[LuckySkye1000]

dats true

[LuckySkye1000]

I'm nt against lesbians but if u kiss anotha woman just 4 publicity wel thats sick.

[TDementedAngel]

hey its not as bad as fake lesbians for porn movies

[dreamerbyheart]

are you sure?? I don't think so

[envey89]

so far this is the only one that ACTUALY sounds live