When the Prophet finished reciting al- Fatiha, he would say amin loudly, prolonging his voice.[Bukhari in Juz al-Qira'ah & Abu Dawud with a sahih isnad]. He also used to order the congregation to say amin: "When the imam says,
"Not of those who receive (Your) anger, nor of those who go astray", then say amin" (Bukhari, Muslim, Nasa'i, & Darimi)
and even assuming that hadis is authentic (i'm skeptical of bukhari, because he lived hundreds of years after the prophet [saw]), that doesn't mean the prophet wanted everyone else to say "amen" loudly. there is a sunni mosque close to my house and everyone there says "amen" quietly after surah fatiah, in the same manner that they say the first ayah of surah fatiha quietly
Bukhari compiled already existing hadith that were there before him, he didn't invent any. And yes, there are some who interpret the hadith in another way, among them the Hanafis. However, those who say that the correct way is to say it out loud point to the example of people like Ibn az-Zubair about whom it is reported that he, together with those behind him, would say ameen and the mosque would ring with their voices.
All paises to ALLAH that i'am a muslim..o god guid us to the right path..ameen
NABILINC10 2 months ago
I'm not Muslim, but this is beautiful to see so many like-minded individuals gathered in the same place. A unification of faith. Beautiful.
kittycatcarley 1 year ago 2
@kittycatcarley did you think to be one of them?
come and stand between us and pray with us to the creator (god)
fahad1234554321 10 months ago
subahanlaa
rayhan67 2 years ago
wow so much Muslims :D i wanna visit mekka just to have the glory of praying in the same place as our Muhammed was born, peace be upon him
sexcn8v 2 years ago 9
esselamu alejkum
hamdibosni , ti sigurno znas , sta prija pocetnog tekbira govori
neka te allah nagradi i sve nas akobogda
esselamu alejkkum
bosanac0101 2 years ago
we alejkumu selam we rahmetullah
Govori dzematlijama da poravnaju saffove.
HamdiBosni 2 years ago
WOW! just wow
lolzza1234 3 years ago 3
impressive.
gopidravid 3 years ago
SUBHAN ALLAH
historyofislam 3 years ago 2
i am against saying "amen" after surah fatiha, because you are not supposed raise your voice above the imam's
lotfilms 3 years ago
When the Prophet finished reciting al- Fatiha, he would say amin loudly, prolonging his voice.[Bukhari in Juz al-Qira'ah & Abu Dawud with a sahih isnad]. He also used to order the congregation to say amin: "When the imam says,
"Not of those who receive (Your) anger, nor of those who go astray", then say amin" (Bukhari, Muslim, Nasa'i, & Darimi)
HamdiBosni 3 years ago
the prophet lead the prayer, so it's acceptable for him to say "amen" loudly (al hamdulilah lillahi rubanala meen is also acceptable)
lotfilms 3 years ago
and even assuming that hadis is authentic (i'm skeptical of bukhari, because he lived hundreds of years after the prophet [saw]), that doesn't mean the prophet wanted everyone else to say "amen" loudly. there is a sunni mosque close to my house and everyone there says "amen" quietly after surah fatiah, in the same manner that they say the first ayah of surah fatiha quietly
lotfilms 3 years ago
Bukhari compiled already existing hadith that were there before him, he didn't invent any. And yes, there are some who interpret the hadith in another way, among them the Hanafis. However, those who say that the correct way is to say it out loud point to the example of people like Ibn az-Zubair about whom it is reported that he, together with those behind him, would say ameen and the mosque would ring with their voices.
HamdiBosni 3 years ago
Ibn az-Zubair isn't the Prophet though.
lotfilms 3 years ago
No, but a principle in fiqh is that the practices of the Sahabais were, generally, based upon the practices of the Prophet.
HamdiBosni 3 years ago
ALHAMDULILLAH. ALLAHU AKBAR
abdulshaji1 3 years ago 2
Mashallah, I would not mind a little house next door to Makkah. No other place in the world can rival the tranquility and peace in this city.
vcreaux 3 years ago 4
lailaha ilalah....
hich101 4 years ago 2
Subhanal-lahi wa bihamdih!
baskerviliy 4 years ago 2
masha-Allah!
fist444 4 years ago 2