Genesis - 18 - The Dividing Line (part 2) (Katowice, Poland 1998)

[SuperRedwing09]

They had alot of success evolving with different members thru the years,and I rather liked this version of Genesis.

[meurig100]

Nir plays the drums like Phil or tries it

[MattSpon]

It sucks they couldn't match the video with the actual sound.. the footage is 1/4 second ahead of the vid.

Awesome vid and recording though!

[renoo27]

Doesn't show enough tony!

[TheScyzorCK]

zajebisty kolo jest...! Pamiętam to jak dzis..!

[msnrc]

Drums solo kicks ass!

[Pinsel1960]

Schönes Lied , ein super geiler Schlagzeuger.

[ibrokeitdidnti]

@Pinsel1960 Ja, dieses Lied war ein wahres Juwel... es ist der beste Lied auf dem Album.

[ABittenfeld]

the drum solo sucks

[ibrokeitdidnti]

@ABittenfeld Yeah okay. Setting aside that you have no idea what you're talking about, post something you've done that's better. Actually post something you've done period.

[thesprinter1]

Not the better period but a very good song! Tony banks part= awesome!

[jamess909]

Its a super performance from Cristiano Ronaldo on drums, how can anyone say it isn't ? As I've said elsewhere, if this line-up had been given a chance instead of being bombed out after one album and tour, they could have become just as big as the previous line-ups. After all, if you do what you've always done, you'll get what you've always got !!!!

[HoosierRobert]

Great song and excellent vocals, but the drumming is as boring as dry toast. Nice techniques but no sense of dynamics or emotion. Would have loved to heard what either Phil or Chester might have done with this.

[Albertseye]

@HoosierRobert:

Nir Zidkyahu is drumming like a Two in One, because Phil needs always the support from Chester for that ;-)

[mulleops]

This album is highly underestimated. It derserved much better critic

[1squonk]

@mulleops

[RadiantSynergy]

Fantastic we love you!

[mikolasa]

These young men have talent. Too bad they did not get the shot they deserved.

[davep666]

"get the shot they deserved"??

Hello? This is Genesis u muppet, a band who have sold more than 159 million albums!

I think they have definatly "got the shot they deserved"

[BoBo0807]

I think he/she was referring to Ray, Nir and Anthony...and I agree, this was a great lineup. What a shame Mike and Tony weren't sufficiently moved by the artistic success they agreed CAS was to overlook the commercial disappointment.

[ibrokeitdidnti]

@BoBo0807 They wrote a majority of those songs before they worked with Ray and that shows a little. There are also some very strange fade-outs on the record which detract from it. I think a second record with Ray included in the writing would have been really good. That said, I don't enjoy Ray's renditions of earlier Genesis songs. I might have preferred if they changed the band name and only performed their own stuff.

[kamwrites]

@ibrokeitdidnti So...who do you suppose wrote the drum solo? Was that unused Collins material?

[floxanadu]

This is actually my "revenge" towards my beautiful daughter´s mum, wo mistreated her so badly and still do!!!!

Wanna stay on the right side of the law!!!!

DJ FLO

[dezigno]

Best song from the album "Calling all stations" and Ray Wilson's vocals are excellent!

[sinagarema]

Nir Zidkyahu and Tony Drennan did good jobs. Thanks for uploading!

[awesomedude1133]

Best song hands down from CAS. Whether people argue that this album was true Genesis or not this song had Genesis written all over it.

[renoo27]

What the hell is "true Genesis"? This is Genesis. Period.

[raidereddie]

@renoo27 I agree totally! To call it anything less is an insult to the very talented musicians in this band.

[SoloDrumMusic1969]

@renoo27 I totally agree with you...this IS Genesis, as well as 60's, 70's, 80's Genesis.

[Redrain87]

Mike and Tony....this is the soul of Genesis!!!!

[schockingschoko]

great gig!