@SpokenVerse Shelley frequently used eye rhymes which did not sound alike when pronounced, and reading mankind/wind/behind as an exact rhyme is forced, as it would be to read exact rhymes into there/ear in On Death, stone/frown in Ozymandias, or below/brow in To the Emperors of Russia and Austria Who Eyed the Battle of Austerlitz from the Heights whilst Buonaparte Was Active in the Thickest of the Fight.
"Normal pronunciation evolution made this word rhyme with kind and rind (Donne rhymes it with mind), but shifted to a short vowel, probably from influence of windy, where the short vowel is natural. A sad loss for poets, who now must rhyme it only with sinned and a handful of weak words. "...Etymology Dictionary
I always appreciate your work, but I think that you read this wonderful poem too much fast.
DimitrijFedorovic 2 months ago
Thank you sir !
nikolauzelac 1 year ago
Extremely well read. I had a professor who said this poem was very hard to read, as it almost had to become a wail. You wail well. :)
Thanks for helping these old poems to come alive.
sonofwalt 1 year ago
The pronounciation of "wind" is not correct,or better,is not correct for this poetry.
theusaisgay 1 year ago
It used to be pronounced to rhyme with "behind". The compromise is to pronouce it that way when it it has to rhyme. Do you understand?
SpokenVerse 1 year ago
@SpokenVerse
Yes,I do.
Thank you.
theusaisgay 1 year ago
@SpokenVerse yes you are right
nishanasujith 1 year ago
@SpokenVerse Shelley frequently used eye rhymes which did not sound alike when pronounced, and reading mankind/wind/behind as an exact rhyme is forced, as it would be to read exact rhymes into there/ear in On Death, stone/frown in Ozymandias, or below/brow in To the Emperors of Russia and Austria Who Eyed the Battle of Austerlitz from the Heights whilst Buonaparte Was Active in the Thickest of the Fight.
cengime 9 months ago
@cengime Blow, blow thou Winter Wind
Thou art not so unkind
As man's ingratitude.
"Normal pronunciation evolution made this word rhyme with kind and rind (Donne rhymes it with mind), but shifted to a short vowel, probably from influence of windy, where the short vowel is natural. A sad loss for poets, who now must rhyme it only with sinned and a handful of weak words. "...Etymology Dictionary
SpokenVerse 9 months ago
You have no idea how helpful your recitacions are!! I undersatnd the poems far better now!!
anaruxandra 2 years ago
Bravo Bravo!
s
savedbydeath 2 years ago
Marvelous, best interpretation I've hard yet. Thanks for posting.
kanij87 3 years ago