Nine Inch Nails Right Where It Belongs

[jaymesnin]

I like this version better then the one from the live dvd.. I do agree people that scream out are really stupid. I just like how the crowd was more into it at the end maybe.. That's how it was when he played at joe louis arena in detroit... the crowd was going crazy. Prolly because it had been so many years since he went on tour last. Which once again he's making us wait forever.. so I wouldn't be suprised on the next tour people scream like phsyco's on meth lol

[ScottBrown666]

y'all are so dum...

[CASEYMFCOPPOLA]

with_teeth is one of the best albums ever made.

totally in love with it. <3

[bragehhh]

If I was at that consert I would not have let those bitches scream if I stood at their sides. no fucking way

[archbob1]

If there is no vocal applause, it probably wasn't a very good show.

[misszzzjoe]

Ive seen them live on this tour ..Uber performance

[01jarf]

they needed to scream th feeling they had i guess..i think the clapin hands are more annoying

[inkiblinki]

aw...you angry little straight-edge mormons...

[mykylc]

another reason why alcohol should not be sold at shows...annoying. Lost me at 00:45 Pathetic people.

[thehockeypuck]

@mykylc umm it's a rock show...

[mykylc]

@thehockeypuck it is a rock show but the crowd needs to know when to listen. To scream is just to want to hear yourself. When you play loud..then get loud. When it comes to a quiet song...the best way to show respect to the artist is to listen. Loud people are annoying. Ask anyone in a movie theater...or the artist playing a small bar show. Drunk loud people are even more annoying.

[REALNassshole]

@mykylc me too man exactly 0:43

[Rykarduu]

i hope that bitch dies

[MrIndycysive]

That fucking girl who keeps yelling pisses me off. Someone should have punched her

[slayerfix]

nan mais sérieux... les gens dans le publique quoi... u_u

On vois un soldat exploser et ils poussent un cris de joie..

voila.. =/

[wellyjohn]

wicked at 2:08

[bererboy01]

Whats the video around 1:47 ??

[TheFairiesofGreen]

I wonder if anyone attending this concert actually understands this song.. or Trent for that matter jesus people are so thick.shut the fuck up and pay attention mates

[briantdt]

theres at least 1 idiot at every concert, seen an Aaron Lewis (staind's lead singer) acoustic show and this dumbass girl was laughing the whole time.

[lunalebelia]

It's disrepectful that you want to distinguish yourself amongst thousands by yelliing over an amazing song.....you're ruining it.. Also when one person yells it triggers yelling of other fans because people are a bunch social idiots.

[Khyrid]

On quiet songs you STFU.

[TheDannyr0ck]

awesome reznor is god :)

[2001ManicMonkeys]

Love NIN, but hate that idiot that keeps screaming out lol

[JimmyDiggs87]

i always feel like the crowd will throw the band off with their poor timed clapping.  it makes me nervous.

[deagla2]

Resist the NWO, grow a herb/vegetable garden

[JimmyDiggs87]

that video projection is trippping me out. trent knows secrets.

[beefybeebuzz]

screaming the shoot girl in front of messing up everything!!!!

[pistaltube]

Yes this was one of my favorite shows!! I saw them in 2006 I believe when they where on this tour (in Detroit) and it was amazing!!

[snowboarderforlyfe]

man that'd be so cool to see. I'm talking about the video on the thin? screen. That's awesome.

[peterkleinlich]

that girl really destroys the event... such a great song and she can't help herself ruining it :/

[ulurhu]

Who the hell gave that screaming girl a mic???

just joking:)

[Carlit0Tit0]

i wanna shoot just that one girl screaming, then she can really fucking screan god damnit STFU

[mrdeathamore]

amazing...

[carabacanaoff]

VIVA NIN!!

essa banda é muito foda!!!

[THeEraSerr]

With_Teeth is one of the most underrated albums of the decade imo

[mrdeathamore]

@THeEraSerr underrated? I don't think so. Fans of NIN knows that this is as GREAT as Nine Inch Nails every single album are, or do you care about what other people think?

[zxcvbnm5111]

people that scream out during performances piss me off...it almost seems like they don't respect the music enough to listen to it but to distort it cause they're trippin balls

[sifl007]

Dude, youre trippin balls. I scream at concerts A.) To rock out. and B.) To show the band how much i love them. How else could one be distinguished amongst a crowd of thousands?! Of course im sure youre gona tell us how thats disrespectful to the artist and although i could agree that for this particular song it might be but cmon in general its EXPECTED @ a rock concert.

[zxcvbnm5111]

Yeah its very disrespectful to the artists. I guess you were right that i would say that. ....dumb ass xD

[CreatureofMasquerade]

@zxcvbnm5111 it's amazing that trent went through with the song.. he usually HATES people who do that. a couple songs have been interrupted because of idiots like that.

[fitzyboy19792008]

@zxcvbnm5111 oh shut the fuck up u pompious ass...lighten up

[zxcvbnm5111]

@fitzyboy19792008 hmm i posted that...6 months ago...im pretty sure that ive been silent up until now :O

[thehockeypuck]

@zxcvbnm5111 don't respect? They are clearly having more fun than you. A rock concert is an experience not a time for you to sit down in your living room all alone. Maybe it is her fav song? You know you have been to a good show when it becomes intoxicating and you forget about everything but where you are right then and there. If you are distracted you are clearly not clicking with the band... Enjoy yourself, relax and have a blast

[steelundergrounder]

this makes me want to cry and give me shivers down my spine i love it this song gave me an amazing experience

[obbabob]

That girl screaming sends ME shivers down my spine. Sounds like she is being raped and stabbed.

[andnowyourott]

hahahahhahaha yeppers

[steelundergrounder]

this is great i love it so much.

[pacifist120]

This reminds me of when I saw Trent about a year ago on the "Lights in the Sky" tour. During his songs from the Ghosts album and songs like "the Greater Good" from Year Zero, people acted as if it was a fucking intermission. Could have been worse though. I met a guy who was at a NIN show, someone threw a plastic water bottle on stage, hit Trent and he walked the fuck off.

[CreatureofMasquerade]

bwahahah. people behaved here fortunately. "hurt" was sang all along by everyone there and it was powerful.

[bdonovan13]

haha was it in Grand Rapids? same thing happened there too. who the fuck throws shit at TRENT REZNOR? haha, fucking idiot. I'd be pissed too.

[Lemure333]

SHUT THE FUCK UP HECKLERS!!!! how fuckin important do you need to be? really ? If you need to be heard, go to therapy..... you ruined one of the most amazing live songs EVER!!! Drunk ass bitches

[Screamingdk]

Ya I second that shit,all you busters get the fuck out here!

[OMNOMMOUSE]

Ahahahah, so true.

[FefuFX]

1:45

[FefuFX]

I live in this illusion. I like.

[BigJRock1]

one of the better shows to see live, great job with the lights and the quality of the show was top notch. saw um @ UMASS a few years back now.

[skylandmountain]

They are screaming because that show is visually nuts (OK i only saw the dvd but what a show - also they are near enough the mic to be prominent - it would seem. But I would love to slap em in the mouth!

[skylandmountain]

But I agree with zombie ninja also - + the music would drown them out a lot more in the live situation. The video/video is also very emotional & really intensifies the song & puts it on a way higher plain...

[UnknownShadow718]

I swear, why are those bitches screaming? If you wanna hear yourself scream, go to your fucking room instead of a concert. Especially a concert of one of the best live bands EVER.

[ZombieNinjas666]

that was one of the smartest things I have read all day

[legof2]

I love how this is such a quiet song and everybody is screaming "WHOOOO!" as if it were really upbeat. I find it really funny.

[xSirMixAlot]

Have you ever been to a NIN show? :P

You should see Hurt live. People won't shut up during it.

[legof2]

Actually, I only watched this because my teacher assigned these lyrics for a literary analysis paper.

[secretmethod70]

Cool teacher.

[eisenkreuzmusik]

Trent is my teacher

[Recovrd1]

Damn, I wish I had teachers like that when I was in school! These lyrics are so deep and meaningful. What an awesome assignment! How did u do on it?!

[ZombieNinjas666]

I know, and Trent fucking pours his heart and soul into that song, it really means something to him and these people fucking disrespect him like that wtf

[DarkBenjy]

Trent Renzor... if only he were a woman... or at least in my bed :P

kidding, but has a beautiful mind... beautiful music

[Atak0fth3Umpalumpas]

You kidding me? I'd totaly go gay for trent.

[1randomguy08]

suck a powerful song

[Oneiroi729]

Reminds me of a drug addict. Its like when he was younger he was warped as fuck due to drugs, and now that he's out of it its as if all of it was an illusion because the drugs themselves made him like that. It as if it didn't happen because the drugs forced a side of him that really never existed, and all the events that came to pass were due to drugs and alcohol. Whatever, this song is great. It'll suck when Trent dies. By the way wtf let the man sing.

[swyft187]

You got it soooo wrong.

[Oneiroi729]

really? oh well, fuck it.

[pitbulllover74]

You may have the meaning of the song wrong but you actually summed up the new Reznor and NIN more accurately than Ive seen anyone do in a long time.

[Oneiroi729]

Nice. What's the real meaning of the song?

[pitbulllover74]

Its about how life really is just an illusion and theres more behind reality than what we can 'see', almost a nihilistic theme. Listen to the lyrics with that in mind and youll actually see it this time.

[mfitzp]

Ah I missed my chance to see these live a few months back :( was planning on going with a OSR AIR flag, bad buzz... Screamers, kill yourselves

[ghostynoises]

Fucking beautiful, screw the screamers. I love the people who are honestly singing along. Reminds me that perhaps there are others out there that might get it, so to speak...

[mrhudds]

If one of those screamers was stood next to me, they would have had a knife deep into their throat very quickly.

[blablehde]

Beautiful song, but wtf with these dumb idiots ... "CLAP YOUR HANDS YEAAAAAAAAAH 8D" ... I could hit them.

[UniqueRedundancy]

I agree that it's very disrespectful to the artist and to the song to scream and shout and act foolish, at least during songs like this. Especially with NIN, which has plenty of songs that are pretty much MADE to scream and shout and act foolish too. "Burn", for example. But ESPECIALLY when it comes to songs like this one and "Hurt", seriously people, shut up and watch. Trent Reznor has more to say than your screams and hollers ever will.

[Meconstrue]

hey i really like all these remixs and nice videos to this song but I'm trying to find a copy of the original can somebody send me a link please?

[RockFanatic319]

Who are those bitches that are making my ears bleed? God, they need to shut the fuck up!

[jshanle]

was to begin with, let alone would connect it to the lyrics/music in the sone..

Does anyone know if he included this song in his Year Zero tour the following year?

[jshanle]

This is definitely my favorite nin song of all time.... I went to the show in Seattle for the 2005 With Teeth tour and was kind of shocked that this is one of the songs he choose to include.. I could not fucking believe it since it was kind of obscure and everything when he did use it.... Some people keep saying that the song is about solipism, which I must say made me look up the word and was very impressed that someone knew what it

[Ashramus]

agree, clap your hands but for the christ sake STFU.. let me hear it

[mindstormsabrewin]

That's one of the reasons I won't waste my time and money going to live shows. Too many drunken loudmouths whistling and screaming for no reason. They have no reverence for the music they claim to love. They are spoiled brats that have to get attention. They create nothing so the only way they can get noticed is to act out. You know.... the way a two-year old would.

[panopticon7]

nonsense. it's a group of like minded people sharing a moment. it's powerful stuff. i'm genuinely sad you can't feel that when you are among them. no kidding. i truly do wish you could connect like they do in this video. it's a special feeling.

[mindstormsabrewin]

Connect? I played live a few times in my life and there is nothing more annoying than trying to concentrate on the music I have to play while people shriek and howl. It shows a tremendous lack of respect for the artist they paid money to hear. Imagine people doing that in a movie during scenes of dialog when everyone else is trying to understand what's happening on screen. Why not be quiet and experience what Reznor intended people to feel during that song? Freak out during the heavy songs!

[NoNameLeftToTake]

It's disrespectful. Those obnoxious screamers aren't trying to connect. They are trying to get noticed. They aren't feeling anything about the song, just being silly and corny, and it doesn't amuse when some people are at the show to listen and watch Trent perform. This happens during Hurt a lot too. And I'm sick of it. Mindstormabrewin is right. They have no reverence for the music they claim to love.

[MichaelDcodered94]

fuckin a

[rawrrcupcakeface]

Trent Reznor has said so himself that it ruined the songs live when people do shit like this. A few times he has actually walked off. Singing along, fine, clapping, whatever, but there is absolutely no reason to act like a child and shriek at the top of your lungs. Especially during a slower song like this. If it were another , faster. song, it wouldn't matter so much. It's very disrespectful to the artist and the song.

[Foxpoop]

Sounds like someone is getting murdered out there.

Ruined the moment.

[blaa94]

Shut the fuck up, goddamnit.

[LETITBEGINAGAIN]

The damn crowd just breaks the spell by screaming pointlessly, however if you had them all singing along, well, it could be great

[janzbukowa]

gOWONO Z eXO

[rtmueller85]

I love this song. Especially when I take adderall.

[a692poundgorilla]

I hope to go to the NIN concert coming to Albuquerque soon! As for the message being sent. It seems we all get the point. Now do something about it, rather than coming on youtube and arguing about it.

[DownwardSpirial]

This song is amazing

[seamirock]

all your opinions and theories are pointless enjoy the song. your words carry with them no intent or substanc.

[LakeBodom666Killer]

Life truly Is beautiful.But why do we deicide what speicies,nationality,religious beliefe,artistic values and lifeforms in general get to live or die.Not just Americans.The entire Human race has blood on there hands for one thing or another.Even me Im not excluded at all.We decide that pitbulls are illegal because they cause fewer deaths than humans do but yet they Rarly cause human death.We decide arabs die because they have oil and we are greedy .We kill Animals because were hungry.

[FearMyMind]

The crowd needs to learn to shut up.

[superlost90]

@FearMyMind umm, u need to learn to shut the fuck up. If you want to listen to your music interupted and in utter dispair put in your nin cd and start crying. Otherwise, relax and let these people enjoy the show bitch.

[FearMyMind]

@superlost90 I think it's just a matter of the mood of the songs, especially because NIN has such a wide range of them. If people AREN'T going nuts during March of the Pigs or Head Like A Hole, that's just heresy (no pun intended). But you have to admit there's a difference between Starfuckers and something like this or Hurt. You don't have to sit alone and cry, just...take a minute and appreciate the music. Just my thoughts, though a lot of other comments seem to express similar sentiments.

[GoLuckyOops]

The war is not in US interests and does not promote world stability and safety. Our meddling in international affairs gets us involved with feuds that have nothing to do with us. (do you honestly believe they attack us because we are prosperous and free?). We give weapons to one side, blow up the other, come back to the other side, and have our own weapons used against us. I'm all for a strong national defense but we cannot afford the ridiculous military presence we maintain around the world.

[GoLuckyOops]

you have to admit a balanced budget makes sense. Right now we pay more on interest (interest alone) for the national debt than we spend on the war. Most Republicans and Democrats make promises, always spend more for partisan interests, and put the US deeper in debt Why should our children pay our debts? What is wrong with a balanced budget? Why create money from thin air? Is the national deficit not deep enough?

[baverfjant]

Feels like you've watched Zeitgeist some times.......

[indigo6309]

War IS ugly. People die. The only way to stop it is for everyone to refuse to partake in it. As long as there are politicians to feed us fear of going with-out oil or food or what-ever, it will never stop.

Love this vid, love NIN...

[halo3master14]

this is a remake of the video

[halo3master14]

ummm yea NIN/ trent are very anti war i have seen them like 2 times they have to be one of my favorite bands and this is a great song and oyu will never see the real video unless you go to one of there concerts i have seen it at one and thats the only plac you will see it trust me its not allowed to be shown on tv because it really shows you what goes on in the war THE TRUTH actual footage of what happens over there. its a great vid though

[pvtBRLUSMC0311]

FUCK NIN, after I learned they were anti-govt and anti-military This music started to sound like shit buzzing in my ear. I wont listen to music that scorns what I do for my country every day. I hope the members of this group gets nine inch nails slammed into their wrists and burn to a crisp with flame throwers.

[sasessiontc03]

Are you serious? Trent Reznor is not anti-government nor anti-military. You obviously are not understanding his ideas correctly. Do more research. He just didn't believe the direction of the Bush Administration and who we are, the human race, in general. We are a sad race and can only hope we make smarter decisions for the future.

[TuMira85]

A sad race compared to what?

[Avalaros]

Compared to an ideal that seems so desirable, but so impossible to realize when looking at... well what, the world itself?

The most intelligent living being on our planet still hasn't managed to get over it's egocentrism. Isn't that interesting?

What always amazes me is the small amount of people even THINKING about those things. Might be worthless anyway ;)

[TuMira85]

So you're saying you haven't managed to get over your egocentrism? Please, speak for yourself.

Everyone thinks about these things, are you kidding me? Existentialism, Purpose, what do you think those are? You seem like you get off on thinking you have some great knowledge everyone else doesen't. Truth is, everyone deals with life in different ways. You ain't special.

[666Hellsing]

Fuck you, you stupid faggot. Go and slam your cock into your fellow army lads arseholes. Waste of space. Military is for fuck ups and failures, especially if you BELIEVE what you are fighting for. Cunt.

[SirPurpalHaze]

Hey guess what.....Fuck the government

[gmodesike]

anarchist

[SirPurpalHaze]

and this is suppose to effect me how?

[gmodesike]

by you replying to the comment... you have been affected more than i would have expected. i expected no reply.

[SirPurpalHaze]

i reply to just about anything. I love good dialog

[amarinosson]

To me it seems like a part of the video is about how USA abuses the worlds resources to keep up the biggest consumer style society in the world. Also how the non whites get the worst end of the bargain. Otherwise I love this song, best song of "With Teeth" cd.

[FlyingBurritoMan]

No, you would just like that to be what he thinks.

[Leetfx]

solipsism > your interpretation, sorry. lol

[THEOMGProduction]

"Also how the non whites get the worst end of the bargain."

try being white and find a scholarship for college. you'll be lucky to find one.

try being mexican and find a scholarship for college. you'll find tons of them.

same for being black, you'll find scholarships.

so how do "non whites" get the worst end?

[THEOMGProduction]

my last comment was a reply to "amarinosson" btw. :S

[magicmagicnosegoblin]

Eveyone should just fall to their knees in silence.

I forgive them for screaming though, you'd be taken in by the moment as well. It's different when you're sittting in your room with scratching your bollocks on your own in silence.

[flyworld3]

I don't understand the cheer, it was in the single as well. The piano was the best parts. All those who are cheering? Newfags.

[nflpanthersrock]

those people need to sthu.

[BettietheRipper]

when they played this song at the bowl in hollywood, 05, the entire place fell silent. we knew how to show respect to such a song.

[peetree696]

i personally believe Trent made a dick out of those people cheering, i see it as the crowd cheering for death and conformity while he sings to them, to try and open their minds.

i might be totally wrong but im sticking with what i think.

[v0mer]

totaly agree with you. imo they lost the messege of the song while they were bissy cheering like fools...."see the animal in its cage"..

[nflpanthersrock]

um yeah because he totally controls there cheering? dumb ass

[peetree696]

way to miss a point. derrrp.

[nflpanthersrock]

im missing the point? would you like to explain how? like i said he can't control there cheering, he acted like it's trent's fault.

[zombiieboy]

NIN RULZ !!!!!

[Adenoseine]

fuck sakes , people in the crowd who are screaming during such a beautiful song need a kick in the skull.

[twanbakker]

ow man that looks awesome!

[musicluver266]

i went to a concert once, and there was a guy 3 or 4 rows down from me, and he wouldnt sit down! at all! to make it worse he would be dancing throughout the entire concert, even if it was a slow song he would be dancing like a derranged fool. tragic, really. But the concert was amazing, too bad I couldnt go see these these guys live, i think i'd about die if i had the chance!

[Salvador33HPR]

I don't recall Trent saying "Hey everybody, scream at the top of your lungs to drown out the song, especially at the slow songs".

[endemoniada1334]

what a douche bag,shut the fuck up

[956GDUBZ]

this would be fuckin perfect if that asshole screaming would just stf

[chaszmyr]

I went to a NIN concert in Columbus Ohio back in '00. There was a girl screaming just exactly like that for the entirety of the concert, she was about five rows down from me.

[chavez9422]

There was a bitch like that at my concert...I hoped she would just stfu, but she actually had a seizure. They had to light up our whole section for the meds to come in..But the show continued

[XaraWhite]

this is simply brilliant...

[empty216]

Whoever it is screaming, I hope you die a painful death.

[XaraWhite]

if it's not having a heart attack, she has no excuse :))

[k2ller2abc]

sounds like rape or murder to me

[rangadanga1]

that bitch should kill herself

[Schmok66]

That is very rude,what they do on the pictures and how they scream.That scream is tasteless and brutal silly.but the song is uplifting.

[BeatleSoph]

I *hate* people who scream like that during intense songs

[NecrosisOfLight]

I know! That fucker ate the mood so he could get his 5 seconds of fame.

[nin514]

I agree. I'll never know why people go to live shows just to scream over the performance.  STFU! Almost as bad as a Tori Amos show.

[JLeaf311]

This song makes me cry every time... I wish they would've had a little respect and shut their huge yaps.

[trush129000]

omg are they killing a whore in that concert !!!! SHUT THE FUCK UP BITCH youre ruining a great song

[pandazenian]

too funnie. killing a whore.

[M4rcom44]

shut the fuck up

[ragnaccio71]

la mia canzone preferita. Lenta al punto giusto e molto molto malinconica. Grandissimi. Per me i migliori.

[billysandals]

that chick man, somebody shut her up! go see madonna you stupid piece of shit!

[roxylifexoxo]

hey!!! shut the fuck up!!!

you're killing a great moment!!

[accountname098]

lolol WTF "WHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH!!!!".......­shut the FUCK up!

[Verasoul]

Those Attention whore Bitches just killed the gravity of this performance. You're supposed to sing along with a deep, slow song like that... not SCREAM like a Fuckin' Rooster!!!

[TaraKaylor]

Trent is fucking brilliant live, I was front row when I saw him and it blew my mind, I couldn't breathe!

This is a great song!

[sasessiontc03]

Such a beautiful song...

[rockonecrack]

wow

[commy9191]

fucking fatass bitch screaming the whole time

[buze]

best lyrics i've heard ever

[reed359]

TheStig000 said it right

[TheStig000]

Would be a lot better without all the stupid bitches screaming.

[gilcost]

LOL

[hlbq]

i totally agree with you

[boli198]

...

My favorite NIN's song

...

[orion588581]

ac333334 you are deserving I am sorry if any christian made you feel like you are not because you are deserving all of you are.I am sorry if any catholic made you feel that way too.Believe in yourselves