Nickelback ft. Evanescence -Amy Lee- _Broken ... NICKELBACK vs. SEETHER

[nyktiafajita]

Fail. Seether. And EVANESCENCE

[TheBobyMusic]

This isn't Nickleback

[Thecrow38]

Not Nickelback...It is still the same old seether

[reesesdemon]

they spelled evanescence wrong, that pissed me off >:(

[Spashleyy2010]

i think you'll find thats seether cockhead.

[Boxerbabe30]

NOT Chad Kroeger's voice haha

[09jarylene]

SEETHER -_____________________________­__-

[gshdrums]

Its not Nickelback at all.................

[barby256]

This song is of Seether and Evanescence -.- "

[Hardrockayelennon]

evanescenes???????????????????­????????

[Budini67]

Not Nickelback at all dude... Not even close, IMO....

[sheefaria1]

para o desinformado qe fez esse video, quem canta essa musica nao e o Nickelback é o Seether, e o nome da banda e Evanescence e nao evanescene, se fosse escrever do jeito qe se pronuncia seria Évanencess ;)

[StabbyJoe0]

I'm sorry i'm too busy laughing my arse off at the ignorance of it all.......where do i start......at the Nickelback tag on this ......yuss i think so.......

[HulioValdez]

yu ar awl dumas'es. Nicoalbeck suxs Sethear is bester.

[poethezeldaghost]

@HulioValdez Learn to spell!

[ErosaScuderia]

Learn humor.

[poethezeldaghost]

@ErosaScuderia Bad spelling doesn't equal good humor.

[ErosaScuderia]

The bad spelling IS the humor.

[poethezeldaghost]

@ErosaScuderia I do not find it funny. Spelling like you are in first grade doesn't make you funny. It makes you an idiot.

[ErosaScuderia]

Phuq it. Some of us find it funny; if you don't, that's fine.

[HulioValdez]

@ErosaScuderia

Lerne how too speel Fuk!

[ErosaScuderia]

Fuck. You happy?

[HulioValdez]

@ErosaScuderia

No. It is Fuk!

poethezeldaghost will insist that it has to be right. I don't want to disappoint him.

[ErosaScuderia]

-_-

[HulioValdez]

@poethezeldaghost

Pull that stick out of your ass, it is stabbing you in the place where your sense of humor used to be. It was hard work spelling that badly.

[mortuinonmordent]

Yeah...everyone on here is right. No offense to you, dude, but this isn't Nickelback. It's definitely Seether O_o

[SleepToDie]

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!

[Karchkhadze]

This isn't Nickelback

[samm2412]

this is Seether

[1988Geo1]

oh gawd....get ur fact right before posting....its Seether u fucking noob!!!

[Demonskin94]

It's seether -:( great song but give credit to the one who deserved it.

[dramagal7]

is seether not nickleback... there's a difference 

[clairexbear14]

its nickleback jezz

[wylde47]

I've seen nickelback 2 times,and seether once and this is definately not nickelback

[Copper389]

The first time i heard this i could have sworn it was Evanescence... and i was right 0_0

[ToxicPurpleCloud]

@Copper389 Hell you want, a pat on the back?

[ramdomgurl101]

It's Seether && Amy Lee! Not Nickelback && Evanescence.! 

[29movielover29]

Not to be offensive but ok this isn't Nickelback and I would know because I'm a very big Nickelback fan. It's difinitely not Chad Kroeger singing this.

[xVanityAttackx]

This is Seether, dumbass.

[stereotyped77]

it says on thiss page...

Artist: Seether

Buy: Buy "Broken" on: iTunes,

AmazonMP3

[101Magaly]

you spelled evanescence wrong...

[TheMortifer1]

Seether :P

[TheBloodyBlackJackal]

Seether's voice is more nasally then nickelbacks, this is definately seether... Anyways it wouldn't make sense for there to be a nickelback version as this is a seether song. If it were an Amy Lee song it would have said Evenescence featuring blah blah blah not the other way around adrdrr.

[TheBloodyBlackJackal]

Rofl this is still the seether version...

[SuperRavensoul]

this is so not chad if your true nickelback fans you would know this ass bandits

[anuk911]

It says under the Like bar

'Artist: Seether'

This is clearly not Chad Kroeger, it might be a different version, but I know his voice well enough to say it's not him.

[moetown75]

I like Chad, but Morgan is my preferance and this IS Seether. Also, once again, just my preferrance, the original version is better, minus Amy. Can't even explain why, Amy has an increadible voice. Just love the original "Seether Only" version.

[nickelbrigth87]

wtf?, y cuando canto chad aqui...

[jefflprater]

this is not nickelback

[lifsvrhrtbrkr]

@AshleighBeFree I wish people could be as sweet as you while pointing out other mistakes. :) I'm not being sarcastic or rude. I was looking for some new music for my writing playlist and came across this one. Your comment was at the top of the page. The world could your more of your kindness! :)

I'm in love with the music not the writer's or singers(well maybe the singers, a little :) If it sounds good and the lyrics hold a meaning, then it's worth while to listen to.

[sweetangiegirl1]

I'm not a huge fan of either, but I do like some songs of both. I downloaded this song from ITunes and it was Seether. I could be wrong, and it does sound like Chad, but i'm guessing it's seether.

[xxNickelbackRockz123]

How can anybody mistake Shaun Morgan's voice for Chad Kroeger's? Chad's voice is so distinct, and I'm sure Shaun's voice is as recognizable to a Seether fan.

[MC20119]

Wait... People actually think Chad did this? Hahahaha. I needed a good laugh. This is hysterical. This sounds just like Seether. Shaun may be doing shit with the new music, but this is when he was in his prime and any real fan of the genre (not one band or the other) could tell you that this is Shaun. Gawd.

[ixXxKIMAxXxi]

Alright, to all the 'ALLTIMENICKELBACK' fans, this isnt Chad. -.-

This is still Seether and to say Chad sounds a thing like this is a failure on your part. (Nickelback lover) Pull up the official video and listen to the two, exact same. On another note, if it was it would be listed under their 'joint' projects list, which it isn't. -.-

[inuyasha331]

It's Seether... even listening to the songs side by side, same thing.

[0223ize100]

this is definatley chad because he has a total different rasp to the high notes and a different accent than seether. i may not be a seether fan but im an absolute nickelback fan and this iss mine and my girls song and this is deffinatley chad.

[TheBadness98]

definatly seether

[AshleighBeFree]

This isn't nickleback darlin. Ihts seether, I'm inlove with seethers music and this is the original song. And nickelback and seether my sorta have the same writing styles, but the do NOT sound alike voice wise. Js

[justinbieberfan805]

when people do the reaction what? it is bad when they do that because AMY LEE IS AWSOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[DanielCesar1993]

So good ! More videos

[AverageTori]

bahaha i hate nickelback; mistaking seether for them is a disgrace.

[TheKentuckygirl21]

this is seether theres no way n hell this is chad sweetheart so next time get it rite thx ;p

[shorouq14]

this is really chad, u r the ones who need to clear their ears. and thanks a lot for the song

[Bigpimpmike786]

@mistersirmister idiot, it IS seether.. NOT chad.... -___- i just did a comparison with the regular broken song that i found in the side bar... its seether... not chad....

[MrCerberus000]

Not Nickelback... But the voice seems a lot(:

[thewolfdancers]

uhh i dont wanna sound like a stuck up know it all fan girl but ive been a huge fan of nickel back since i was like 8..so like 9 years now.. i know his voice in a half a second,....i also love seether but this my friend is seether.. >< and at 0:21 it proves very well its seether... i dont think anything could sound anything thing more like seether and not nickelback learn your damn bands

[TheRedrock17]

its seether not nickelback!!

[DJMusicMadness1]

also this was done around the time Amy Lee and the lead singer of Seether were dating.

[DJMusicMadness1]

@mistersirmister :/ I can tell you're a Nickelback fan, but this is Seether ft. Amy Lee of Evanescence. not Nickelback

[wjmcb]

@mistersirmister sorry man but this is seether.

[Music4ismylife]

its not chad's voice. I bet !!!

its seether.

[Colin2k41]

@mistersirmister i seen this perfromed Amy and seether live its Shaun not Chad

[ThePurpledove89]

although it sounds like chad, its actually seether just look it up, sorry. always did love this song though

[MrSudo97]

why there is no music video??? and when will bacom day when I can buy new album?

[AdjLee]

idiots think this is Chad fair play...

[nathanharper34]

some 1 needs a hearing aid

[EmCii14]

wouldn't it be awesome if seether and nickelback/chad kroger would do a duet?

[EmCii14]

where can i download this version?

[sandranickelback]

@EmCii14

Try at Dilandau. I've got mine there ;)

[XxOJBDjbLuverX]

I study everything Amy Lee.. And I listen to this song all the freaking time. There is to difference. It's the original, with Seether. Sooo yeah.

[xxNickelbackRockz123]

@mistersirmister Omg it is YOU that can't recognize Chad's voice. Even if I did not already know this song, I would know that this is NOT him singing, this IS the original.

[lilangus151]

I DID listen to this in comparison to the Suggested video....which is the real music video for this song. The actualy music video is a WAV file for the audio. This one you posted is prolly mp3 audio. Less quality! So, probably the reason for you losing your mind and thinking it's Chad Kroegar lol!

[lilangus151]

@mistersirmister You are definitely def!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!! There is NO difference between this and Seether! Know why? (1) Because it fucking IS NOT CHAD KROEGAR!!!!! LMAO....Shaun Morgan has a very distinctive voice! As does Chad! Not Chad! Wake up! Get off the drugs! This is Seether!

[darkhorse4eva]

trust me... I'm a die hard Nickelback fan... That's not Chad... I'd be able to pick his voice from Shaun Morgan's anyday when I'm asleep... I would know if that's Chad Kroeger... Take a listen to any and if possible every NB song, then listen to this... Shaun's singin' in this... Not Chad.

[xFallenAngeletteX]

and this isnt the ORIGINAL VERISON. THE REMADE THE SONG WITH AMYLEE ITS STILL SHAUN MORGAN SINGING IT DUMB FUCKS !

[xFallenAngeletteX]

this is SEETHER. no Nickelback. duh. dont you people no anything..? 

[melii0307]

Me encantaaaa!!! :D

[ughs2012]

there is no way this is chad kroeger i no his voice and this is not him omg damn for crying out loud how can u dis chad like that damn chad deserves better than that he is amazing lol so um yeah dont dis nickelback like that again thanks btw this is seether

[kiketeponeready]

excelent song!

[ESakowicz]

Sim, uma otima musica, eu sou fanatico pelo Nickelback, mas vamos fazer juz ao Seether, eles merecem o reconhecimento.

[harkasin]

@mistersirmister looks like u cant recognize Chad's voice

[sexysadie95]

This is seether you fucktard. 

[BARNIgum]

lolz

[1986jaibo]

this aint nickelback get your ears chacked.

[d1re5w]

@1986jaibo and while hes getting his ears checked learn how to spell checked?

[sandranickelback]

Come on, people ! This is Seether... And yes, this dude sounds like Chad, but you must hear the difference, especially if you're Nickelback fan :)

Now serious, I know Chad's voice, his style of singing, the way he pronounce words... Well, I listen to him 11 years... Love Nickelback <3

[EreminsMemory]

That's Seether... I swear, it's him. Just look for the video instead of standing there pretending it's Nickelback's singer !

[joelh0627]

although that dude does sound a lot like nickleback

[roza3338]

 wanted you to know I love the way you laugh

I wanna hold you high and steal your pain away

I keep your photograph; I know it serves me well

I wanna hold you high and steal your pain

´Cause I´m broken when I´m lonesome

And I don´t feel right when you´re gone away i love it <3 this is soooo real :*

[webcrawler123451]

its sether not nickelback his voice isnt deep like chads srry

[HITTMAN123445]

that Seether not Nickelback right?

[drasle93]

@HITTMAN123445 its seether...

[HITTMAN123445]

@drasle93 i thout so

[17sk8rchick]

this and the "other" version sound exactly the same. dumbass

[MaicSkywalker]

Seether, not Nickelback. This voice isn't deep enought to be chad's voice. If you search on the web, there's no notice about a nb version of this song. Never published or listened on a live show. No way

[Rainbowsmurf666]

sorry dude but this is still seether no matter what you think dude and besides his voice isnt that deep ><

[Rainbowsmurf666]

sorry dude but this is still seether no matter what you think dude

[jezhai1]

What the F#CK are you stupid people on about,

SEETHER NOT F#CKING CRAP NICKLEBACK

[swordofsadness]

yes this is nick no way i miss his voice

[TheRavenHerst]

this is nickelback no mistake

[TheCroatianIdiot]

this is Nickelback!!

I listen to NB almost every day and this is Chad's voice! 0:21 !!!!

Nickelback rocks! :D

idiots -.-

[Shoaibiqbal7]

@TheCroatianIdiot

man seriously u need to get your ears checked.......................­and u say u listen to nickelback daily............it is seether.

[TheCroatianIdiot]

@Shoaibiqbal7 ok then think what you want to.. whatever i don't care -.-

[DJMusicMadness1]

@TheCroatianIdiot no it isn't. it is Shaun Morgan, like of Seether. which, uh, like this is Seether. -.- seriously listen real close. Chad and Shaun sound NOTHING alike

[nathandied88]

You're an idiot.



[NickelbackOwnz]

i'm addictid to this song in the "Seether Version" so trust me its not seether

i like both bands but to be honest.... but

Seether version is better

[bonduk13]

THIS SOUNDS TOO MUCH LIKE NICKELBACK AT TH BEGGINING BUT THEN NOTHING LIKE HIM. eITHER I REALLY LIKE THIS TRACK.

[deanna122895]

i come an listen to this song wen i have a break up it really helps me hahaha lolz

[deanna122895]

i love this song

[TheWolfniichan]

XDXDXD



[sweethazeleyesjp]

I thought it was nickelback when I first heard it.



[10thplanet45]

clown shoes.... its obviously not chad kroeger

[blitzace7]

Honestly people, who cares about the uploader's version of the twisted conspiracy to conceal the artist's name ? Maybe he did it to avoid copyright problems. Just listen to the track (if that's what you're here for) and shut up.

I'll follow my own words and cease to speak now.. =D

[AllAboutTheMusic45]

Not nickelback Seether.... 

[gwehabana]

wow proibs the dumbest guy ever. its no nickleback its a lead singer from a band called seether also known as Saron Gas

[Willian2727]

Que p**** é essa. Cade o Nickelback ?

"Vou ti contar em!"

[whallephy]

esse não é o nickelback, mas sim o Seether...

[Sabrineoliveirarec]

Amoo essa música minha inspiração! (♥)

[Jamaciana]

This is one of those Rare songs that , despite how many Times you've listened to it, it'll Never Get Old

[abdellagendy]

Nickelback ?-.-

[FerrariGood]

This is Seether and Amy Lee. Listen to other Seether songs, and you'll realise. Still a good song though =)

[ZDanielhimselfZ]

@dance77madness you fail

[Sarlota027]

super muzika....



[monkeygirl3101]

love this song

[Lokydock258]

Seether you hurpa derp

[flyaway623]

That's Seether or Nickelback????

[skaryclowner]

@flyaway623 seether :) The Punisher OST

[DebbieRockAngel]

@flyaway623 It's Seether feat.Amy Lee

[flyaway623]

That's Seether or Nickelback????

[Guitarplayer1469]

your fucking retarded. talking about this is nickleback! bitch clearly this is seether. dumbass

[nintendex07]

Even though this isn't Nickelback, it's still a good song. Seether, Nickelback and Evanescence ROCK!

[lilangus151]

@nintendex07 It's Shaun Morgan dude! THAT is NOT Chad Kroegar!

[ammarfarisnoori]

seether not nickelback

[MrEsahc22]

seether ??? lol

[kuchki1]

Thats Seether not nickeback

[chamaqta]

so swett!!! i love this song!!!:))

[chamaqta]

so swett!!! i love this song!!!:))

[maungisk8rz]

fuck! how many people hav 2 say that its NOT nickelback!!

[AsaandYusuke]

Seether.

But awesome too =D

[majejka]

i love this song <3

[VampRose88]

its seether NOT nickelback dude

[TheSess911]

what the hell??

know your songs!!

[TheSess911]

what the hell??

know your songs!!

[sminter91]

It isn´t Nickelback, is seether

[rooruchi]

its definitely seether not nickelback

[joey878082]

your a tone deaf idiot if u think this is nickelback how dare you even compare chad to shaun, shaun wins everytime nickelback just got lucky nd got really big but in reality they suck ass..lol seether is better

[TheSess911]

HAHA agreed!

[skintoaster]

@joey878082 well you got one part right, how dare he compare those two, but uhhh, theres a reason nickelback is bigger than seether ever will be....maybe cause they can make it through a concert without having to be rushed to the hospital for smoking ten pounds of crack right before they go on stage....seether is a buncha fuckin burnouts much like their career

[joey878082]

@skintoaster um no u fucktard ther just underrated Nickelback is overrated they suck ass and fuck u and really u gona reply to a comment made along time ago? u have no life so fuck off

[leroywannabejenkins]

bahah this vid is one huge troll haha, but srsly LOL @ this dude

[DaveOfTheDead94]

If you aren't a troll, im gonna drink bottles of bleach untill i fucking burn from the inside out.

[Pythosinhell]

Aparently you don't know what Chad Kroeger sounds like this is not nickelback. The guy doesn't even sound like Chad kroeger

[TheCamaZotz]

i love this song

its so......im must cry.....

i love evanescenes ♥

[theyolanman]

it sounds a bit like nickelback but its seether

[Musicalgrl1016]

dude Amy Lee and Sean Moran dated, it is PROVED that it's Seether. It's RELEASED as Seether. Just because you think their voices are similar doesn't mean it's some big conspiracy and it's someone else singing. Retard.

[FallenAngel58525]

@Musicalgrl1016 They did more than just date. They were engaged for a while too.

[DaveOfTheDead94]

@Musicalgrl1016

Nah man, its on Seethers album to trick the masses. Lies and scandals.

[HelloXrancidkitteh]

this is seether and amy lee. -.- and you spelled Evanescence wrong..

[Pedrolucas39]

quando nego é burro não tem jeito ne --'

[mystic17pengy]

Everyone that has said this song is by Seether featuring Amy Lee is correct. I don't know what world you're in to think it's Nickleback, but you need to come back to earth. Also, you need to go back to school, cause you can't spell worth shit. I feel bad for you. This must be embarrassing. Don't post any videos if you don't have your facts right about it.

[Wolfe5005]

Wow guys..I think Sean Morgan died a little..poor guy..and Chad, if this is you, drop the coke bro, you sound like you're dying lmao

PS- Seether ft. Amy Lee

[BSbrockers1]

Seether Has The  Same voice Of Nickelback in This Song he- such as

[canikostar99]

its a cool song