Added: 4 years ago
From: themiserychick2000
Views: 105,647
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (652)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • um yuck?

  • yeah, this is defentily not the broadway cast 1 i seen 1,000,000 million times (jk), and they sort of suck

  • i love to watch other broadway casts (: its interesting to watch :D

  • Wtf? Why not sing Seasons of Love. Why not get a good cast? Why not get a REAL roger?

  • Im not one for ragging on RENT or people who arent the origional cast as Adam Kantor and Will Chase are my favorite Mark and Roger but this cast just fucking sucks. Especially this Collins. I mean, what the fuck!?

  • honestly, this was a bad performance, but i definitely see the potential, and i'm sure they did good in the actual performances. they are on BROADWAY so i think calling them horrible is a little bit exaggerated.

    although it is pretty hilarious when the roger forget his line at 3:00 and literally cant stop laughing...

  • I love the Joanne and Benny. In my opinion the others were just okay.

  • I love how Roger forgets his line at 3:00 and literally can't control his laughter afterwards... classic...

  • Guys calm your balls. On Broadway, the cast is constantly changing. This is a group who was on Broadway at one point...but there are a few OBC members left in that group. The poster of this video is right to call them the cast because they were.

  • Nothing compared to Anthony and Adam.

  • well, the roger was skiinier and the Mark had black hair.

  • My NIECE could do a better roger

  • this is not the broadway cast. i would know. i've seen it like 20 times.

  • @coookiesncream004 I assure you, this was the Broadway cast AT THE TIME. I would know, cuz it's my vid, I recorded it, and I have other clips of the cast of Rent from that episode of the Today show. It is NOT the OBC, it was the Broadway cast on October 2nd, 1999.

  • You people disgust me, productions get NEW CAST MEMBERS as they go on. It's not going to stay the movie cast for ever or the origonals. I hate when people compare proformances, just judge what you see, you don't need another proformance to back up your opinion.

  • Oh my freaking gosh, what the crap was that?

  • I just threw up a little in my mouth...

  • this cast fails....miserably

  • they are scaring me im gonna have nightmares DX

  • The movie cast will ALWAYS be the best.

  • again this was the broadway cast in october of 1999. Please stop comparing them to the original cast or the movie cast. You may not like them but the were the cast at the time

  • the last rent cast

  • oh my god manly pope is awful

  • HORRIBLE, who heck are these people, must have been an odd year

  • HORRIBLE...just saying

  • this is so gay. COME ON! GIVE US THE MOVIE CAST!

  • EW. THIS IS HORRIBLE. they all look like bored high school students, not broadway performers!

  • Everyone else is fine, if you werent used to the anthony rapp/idina menzel/adam pascal cast, theyd be good. Except Roger. He looked more like a jock than a struggling musician. AND HE MISSED HIS CUE. "Use your camera to spar" is gone!

  • Come on . . . My school did better than this

  • Ugh, that was painful. The guy they had for Roger was really awful. His voice wasn't bad, but his mannerisms are nothing like the character. The casting director should've thought that one through. Joanne's not so great either.

  • this sucks compared to the original...... wow...

  • this is a joke...

  • the random jumping in the beginning

    ...

    WOW, i just dont like mark and roger, the others r alright

  • i cant even watch this....this is horrible

  • Whaaat's up with that 0:31 ?? Dork?

  • I'm so annoyed with the "Gonna"!!! It's like Gernna!

  • Not liking this cast at all.

  • what is up with Joanne? and Mark? Collins? Roger? Benny?

    bad choice of cast dudes. always go for voice quality over the people looking like the originals.

  • i actually thought this cast was not terrible, there were some sound issues with the equiptment, but i didnt like the choice for Mark

  • As you guys should RENT is an extremely hard production to pull off, I'm sure they tried but no hard enough.

    I'm sure if they continue they will be better, I Hope so anyway. :/

    It never sounds right unless it's sung by Adam Pascal <3 and Anthony Rapp :) xxxxxxxxx

  • True true Adam&Anthony are awesomee <33

  • who ARE these people?!

  • This cast absolutely sucks!  It's definitely not Adam Pascal and Anthony Rapp...

  • The only diamond in the dirt is Wilson in the back (Angel)

  • I thought this was the today show crew until I found out they put this on broadway. I've seen schools do better than this

  • HELLA BAD!

  • because it doesnt. The only reason im watching it again is to show my friend how bad it is. And as far as manley, he's not even close to adam. Even i could do a better job than manley and i'm 19. Admit it dude, it's not good, and i don't think you would honestly pay money to see this cast.

  • you guys fucking suck.

    Manley was an awesome rodger

    you can't fucking expect every single cast to sound exactly the same.

    remember this is the same cast that had to put up with joey fatone.

    i know for a fact that these cast members understood the importance of this show and sung their asses off.

    so why don't you do yourselves a favor and take that huge stick out of your asses and try to understand that this rocks.

  • @ChrissyIsOhSoSpazy

    yes. i agree they TRIED. Im sure they did "sing their asses off" becasue no one would do theis baldly on purpose.

    they tried? yes. they suceeded? no. hell no.

  • your an idiot

  • yea no....

  • um *barfs*

  • wtf?

  • i thought this was a joke at first. not to be mean, bu the original cast was SOOO much better

  • they SUCKED!!!!!!! this cast was horrible.

  • Help. Me.

    This cast sucks!

  • ok, first 33 seconds of this clip and i already wanna kill this mark. he shows no emotion in his first few lines, and then before he says "Rent!" he looks constipated... worst acting, and the singing sux too

  • WHO THE FUCK ARE THESE PEOPLE? That's the worst roger ever!!

  • @mirraleighlv Yeah, Manley Pope was a whole lotta suck.

  • i hate this video. this cast is horrible, and most of the guys were trying to have deep voices, but it turned out really stupid sounding. this is an embarrassment to rent. :(

  • I'm only 44 seconds into this and I want to shoot this cast. They are horrible.

  • and by wayne i meant wayne brady:)

  • dude...what the hell happened...collins sounded like he was trying to be dracula, benny reminded me of a crappy clone of wayne, mark was just creepy, and roger sounded like that tone you make when you googoo talk a baby...that was pathetic im glad it cut off the song with a commercial cuz frankly...that was the best part:)

  • This isn't as bad as people might think. They are outside where it is noisy, and things like humidity and other weather conditions, noise pollution, and emissions contribute, either positively or negatively. The microphones are designed for talking and not singing, and the today show probably doesn't have Echo, Repeat, Delay, and Reverb on their mixing desk. So it isn't going to sound as good as they truly are in the appropriate environment and conditions.

  • lol Roger missed his line at 3:00. oops

  • my god there singing hurts my ears they are no way shape or form as good as the original cast of rent

  • part of the reason some of these actors may not sound the best is because they are outside and believe it or not it sounds different bc they aren't in a theatre that has great acoustics. also, some of these songs were written especially for Anthony Rapp's and Adam Pascal's voices. What You Own is one of them.

    i think this cast does a well enough job. not my favorite, but they aren't terrible. I wouldn't feel robbed of a great experience if they were the cast I saw.

    just my opinion

    <3

  • OG this is AWFUL, HORRIBLE and a totally INSULT !!!!!

  • I don't like the plaid pants that all the Rogers in the Broadway production. just to put that out. and Adam Pascal is better than the Roger here.

    They're not bad. but the original/movie cast are better. and yeah, almost all of the original cast was in the movie, except for Mimi and Joanne. (personally I liked the movie Mimi better)

  • Most of the movie cast is actually the original cast

  • So. Hey.

    All the people who are down on this cast?

    The movie cast was the movie cast. This is a whole different bag of chips, so ease up.

    I actually really like this Roger, partially because he looks just like I imagined Roger might (I heard the movie soundtrack before I saw the movie).

    Also, at least give the guy some credit for doing the role of Roger. It's a reeeeaaally hard role. Emotionally, definitely. But also physically. It does a number on your vocal chords. He has my respect.

  • omg the guy who plays colins is HORRIBLE

  • I love this song but ONLY when Adam and Anthony sing it...:(

  • i really dont like this cast, they're not as good. I loved the final Broadway cast, now that was a cast!

  • anyone who isnt adam pascal or anthony rapp sucks

  • The guy who plays roger sucks...adam pascal rules!!!

  • Comment removed

  • that was truly bad......

  • i don't like this guy who plays roger. Adam pascal was the best and all the cast of the movie all rocked

  • UGH my absolute fave is the OBC no one can top them (coming in second on my list would definitely be the 2008 cast)

  • hahah wow roger messed up, they really sucked the OBC is the best

  • at 3:05 Roger sounds and looks like he's gonna laugh

  • tht would b cuz he forgot to sing his line =p honestly otherwise these guys wernt all tht bad youtube ppl r wayy too critical

  • Comment removed

  • I thought they had the same cast for the whole broadway show for 10 years

  • dude...

    i dont really like this cast singing it...

    and yea them looking

    straight into the camera

    made it disturbing

  • That was Horrid.

  • they didn't have to look at the camera... it gets really... akward.

  • Not at all the best, at all.

  • I believe that Roger is Manly Pope. he was the first Roger I saw back in '98. I remember liking him. This cast I believe wasn't as strong as some, although I am saying this after seeing Anthony and Adam four days ago!

  • Yea they over acted to the camera....and i dont' think it should say THE cast of Rent in the description unless its the actual original cast

  • i can write THE CAST because it was the broadway cast at the time ......and for everyone else they were still selling out at the nederlander with this cast so they coundn't have sucked too badly

  • that was one of the WORST i've ever heard. who the hell casted these people?

  • wow. they SUCKED.

  • They suck compared to ANTHONY RAPP and ADAM PASCAL.

    The dude who was collins sucked too.

  • haha they missed a line at about 3:00min in

  • haha yeah it was "use ur camera to spar!"

  • so, it happends

  • i'm not a fan of the roger here lol

  • why are you guys all bashing this cast?!?! they are pretty good and stop comparing them to the original cast because its just annoying...they give there own personallity to their charecter and stop saying they suck because you know that they are better then you would be doing this so give them a break!

  • not a big fan of the way they do this......

  • OVERACTORS! this is the reason why people think musicals are a joke

  • I hate this version! They suck! They can't top the original cast. xP

  • Hmm. 'Collins' sort of creeped me out. =/

    I liked the 'Joanne' though.

    The 'Mark' was okay as well. (:

  • who the fuck are these people?!?! D= i get the at the time thing but....

    ACK!

    though i loved joanne

  • this is nothing compared to the original -.,- ADAM PASCAL IS THE ONLY ONE ROGER, Anthony rapp the only one Mark, and the other members too, 'cuz they give the songs, and characters an unique voice, a believable personality, -.,- i love the original cast

  • original cast is so much better than this

  • Can you do any better?

    I don't think you should complain if they're most likely more talented than you.

  • hate this cast.

    Hate it.

    The Joanne was pretty okay, and so was the Mark.

    ....The Benny well...er...GORGEOUSNESS. x]

  • Can you do any better?

    I don't think you should complain if they're most likely more talented than you.

  • This was REALLY bad

  • EW!!!!!!!!!

  • I may get chewed out for this, but I don't think that this cast was /too/ horrible. I liked the Joanne, and the Mark was okay.. But yeah. The Roger was pretty horrible. The actor tried to make him far more rough and bad ass then Roger was. Overall, not my favorite, but it wasn't the worst I've seen.

    OBC = Best <3

  • wow....either this cast was having an off day or they are always bad. damn...

  • I HATE THIS CAST!!

  • This wasn't good. To get the full effect of their awesomeness, watch the movie and do nothing else. Don't get your questions answered. Don't look up spoofs, parodies, or even clips. You completely forget about how wonderful the movie is.

  • or, even better the ORIGINAL broadway one.

  • Yeah, the broadway show is much better than the movie.

  • I don't like watching movies of musicals

    However, there is a filmed version of the last broadway cast, which is probably one of if not my favorite RENT casts, and it is DEFINITELY worth watching.

  • W-W-W-What happened to Adam? Man, this cast was not really good.

  • Don't take this the wrong way, but these people need to make the parts their own. They're trying to portray the original characters, and they need to stop singing through their noses.

    Joanne was the only good one.

  • Their too happy and they sound all Nasally. ICK!

  • wow, this cast all sucks!

  • yea!!

  • Really.

  • they sound like teenagers....  not that good

  • .. wuts up with the girl in the begging?

  • wow.

    fail.

  • What the fuck. At the end, the roger forgot his line and then he just started laughing. There supposed to angry in this song, not smiling and laughing.

  • is that rodney hicks?

  • Where is Adam?? I'm sad now.

  • Despite what people are saying, they're *not* bad. There's probably a bias toward the original cast or whatever, but these guys are being recorded live. It's always going to sound weird. They don't have the acoustics of a stage, and maybe someone wasn't feeling their best--it happens. o_o; Don't go calling them crap for that. How many of *you guys* are up there performing live on television, anyway?

  • Who is the Maureen

  • idina menzel

  • excuse me, this is absolutely terrible. my ears are bleeding. mm, anthony and adam cannot be beat. they are god.

  • I agree!!! This is despicable.

  • Good Lord, you're right... this is embarassing. The guy who plays Roger looks like a pompus kid who is trying to act cool... jeez.

  • YES!!!

    no contest at all!

  • This is so flat and overall, just absolutely TERRIBLE!

  • oh gosh...i mean no harm, but Anthony and Adam cannot be outdone, lol. This Mark and Roger...and Collins for that matter cannot TOUCH the originals...

  • oh my I cant believe the today show had them on! this is sad

  • is this the broadway cast?

  • He's no Rapp. Great though

  • my bad

    no need to snap

    and even if they arent the origional

    doesnt mean ther're not any good

  • this cast sucks

  • this ISNT the original cast,

    the original cast is MUCH better,

    and none of these people are in the movie.

  • yea, this isn't the original cast from the broadway version

  • I'm not a fan of Joanne..at all...and Adam is one of the very few Rogers that do incredibly well. This one- not so much.

  • This cast, especially Mark and Roger, are really under par compared to both the original cast and the closing cast seen on the "Filmed Live On Broadway" DVD. Also, the staging is really poor. I know that for real shows they would obviously have the same staging as the originals but whoever did the staging for the Today Show special left a lot to be desired. :-(

  • im going to see rent on tour but i wouldnt be if adam and anthony werent doing the show. THIS NEW CAST STINKS

  • i miss my Adam

  • The singing is good... but the visuals.

    what makes anthony rapp and pascal an amazing combination is rapp has this really amiable geeeky look, and pascal is really good looking. this cast here is the exact opposite, rapps role looks like hes too good looking to be playing that geeky role, and pascals role is to this guy who looks like he should be playing football, not singing.

  • I agree....and their voices sound so weird...i just saw them life, with Pascal and Rapp...they were awesome...

  • I went last night in Dallas. Anthony and Adam were AMAZING.

  • Omg! I know right?! I went on thursday, and they came out afterwards and I touched anthony and adams hand...sighs....anthony... :D

  • exactly!!! thank you!

    Although I disagree about the vocals... I think they're not so good. Adam and Anthony are the only ones for me!

  • Sounds like they really aren't grasping anything that they are saying or the power behind the words. I agree! This cast reaks!

  • this cast sucks

  • but the Benny's really HOTT. =D

  • D=

    Why this Roger?

    The Mark and Joanne are pretty good though

  • the benny is actually good.

  • ........rent? this is rent? this is not rent!!

  • NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • is this a joke?? really? this is horrible.

  • i like the movie cast better. I just like the chemistry and the way they acted it out..

  • AhhhHhhH--this is...Ahhhhh!

    i prefer the OBC--i prefer the movie cast (almost the same thing...) i prefer the final cast

    hell, i prefer anything but this!!!

  • i cringe every time they say gonna

    horrible vowels... this is broadway?

  • They kind of sound like an epic fail boyband....hey wasn't 1999 when sexy Wilson (OBC <3) returned for a little while to play Angel because they couldn't find anyone? =0 But yah, these guys sound bad. The best so far Ive heard to take Anthony's place still yet is Adam Kantor. The guy playing Roger here is trying way too hard, he fails bigtime. RENT casts need to be able to sing, guys...who did this casting? *smacks forehead* Joanne is epic FAIL too WOAH. *is scared of this collins* O___O