My condolences to you and your family. This video is a wonderful tribute to your grandfather. I have a relative who also served in the 3rd infantry as a Sargent. His company 75% kIA. My relative was wounded yet survived. He still gets emotional when he remembers the killing he had to do, and the deaths suffered on our side.
Chi mi na morbheanna, about going home to the Scottish Highlands, is a fitting song for the occasion. So many of our best and bravest soldiers were of Celtic descent.
The composer of Chi mi na Morbheanna was John Cameron (1822-1898). The song was written in Scottish and its title in English means I see the Great Bens. The view which inspired his song can be seen in Dunach1 on YouTube
.
John had disembarked from the Glasgow steamer and composed the song while walking towards his Highland home. All eight verses of his song can be seen under its Gaidhlig title in Wikipedia. He knew the young William Lawrie before he became the well-known bagpipe composer.
I am German so at first sorry for my English. My grandfather fought in the wehrmacht but not to fight for that crank thinking from Hitler ! He fought for his fatherland and his comraes . He doesnt support Hitler I am very proud of my grandfather and I will be very sad if he dies because i can so much learn from him. At all soldiers : rest in peace
@Shepp1rd Shepp, instead of fighting for his fatherland and his comrades, your grandfather should have fought against Hitler so that so many young Allied soldiers did not have to die.
@joelSanFrancisco tis was meant generally. soldiers fight for their home, their family, for their country not only because of the leader of their country. in this time people were faszinated of hitler. he gave them a feeling back that many people missed.
@Shepp1rd .. Shepp, I think we can both agree that WWII was an immense tragedy with great losses suffered by all sides. But we also must remember the lesson: citizens cannot give unquestioning support to dictators and evil leaders. We see right now in Egypt and Libya how citizens are standing up against tyrants.
@joelSanFrancisco yes thats right, but all i wanted to say is, that all soldiers deserve respect no matter from where they are. in the past now and in the future
This is a wonderful tribute my great great uncle was a salor in the proud brittish navy he served on the HMS Hood the navys flagship but was then attached to the HMS witshed which was attacked by the Luftwaffe and he was the only casualty that day , he was only 19. Able seaman Stanley nicol RIP 19 Years old from Arbroath , Scotland
Yes he did but he got deep pshycological scares. My grandfather fought in the djungels of burma as a british soldier of irish descent and became later a prisoner of war, he spent over a year in a japanese prison camp. He got tortured and lost alot of friends during that time. He became a changed man after the war, always very quiet. He died in the mid 80's.
VERY WELL done!! Thanks again and God Bless the LT and your family. The horrors he had to have endured. We're better for it, although.......well, we're just better because of that.
I don't understand the lyrics but, that doesn't matter. Lieutenant McGeorge would've been happy to know he had this. Probably wishes ALL those with him who didn't get it could've been afforded the same. Thanks for the upload. That is REAL nice. Thanks again.
Do I understand the words to Chi Mi Na Mór-Bheanna you mean? Actually yes, I do. I studied them (and Scottish Gaelic) so I could sing it at the funeral. I'll post a translation here for others in case they are curious.
I'm sorry about your grandfather! You must miss him! My Dad fought in the battle of anzio, Italy, WW2. He is 90 years old & in a home for veterans. I hope peace comes to us all soon & that wars will be no more. The Rankin Family song is beautiful. They come from the beautiful island of Cape Breton. One of the brothers, John Morris Rankin, has passed in a car accident a few years ago. Another song popular in the world, by the Rankins, is "Fare Thee Well Love". Take care.
I feel your grief,I sense your pride,I love your tribute to your grandfather.The music was beautiful. The Rankins are a class act.God Bless America !
Robescocia 1 week ago
im srry about u losing a family member i lost 2 grandpas who served for this country
snipermaster10001 5 months ago
My condolences to you and your family. This video is a wonderful tribute to your grandfather. I have a relative who also served in the 3rd infantry as a Sargent. His company 75% kIA. My relative was wounded yet survived. He still gets emotional when he remembers the killing he had to do, and the deaths suffered on our side.
JInks232 9 months ago
Thank your Grandfather for me he lived a good life and brought you life . I salute a Warrior and true soldier . Thanks Granps ! Hurrah ! AIRBORNE !
reddevilparatrooper 1 year ago
I love you Papa, and miss you. RIP, I need to go and visit Grinny soon and little cloud. Atleast now your with shadow. -Love Brittney McGeorge
brittneyy92 1 year ago
wonderful tribute.
rothaich5 1 year ago
Chi mi na morbheanna, about going home to the Scottish Highlands, is a fitting song for the occasion. So many of our best and bravest soldiers were of Celtic descent.
CantwrCymreig 1 year ago
The composer of Chi mi na Morbheanna was John Cameron (1822-1898). The song was written in Scottish and its title in English means I see the Great Bens. The view which inspired his song can be seen in Dunach1 on YouTube
.
John had disembarked from the Glasgow steamer and composed the song while walking towards his Highland home. All eight verses of his song can be seen under its Gaidhlig title in Wikipedia. He knew the young William Lawrie before he became the well-known bagpipe composer.
eoghanbeg 1 year ago
I am German so at first sorry for my English. My grandfather fought in the wehrmacht but not to fight for that crank thinking from Hitler ! He fought for his fatherland and his comraes . He doesnt support Hitler I am very proud of my grandfather and I will be very sad if he dies because i can so much learn from him. At all soldiers : rest in peace
Shepp1rd 1 year ago 6
@Shepp1rd fuck yeah.
thegranitebison 11 months ago
@Shepp1rd Shepp, instead of fighting for his fatherland and his comrades, your grandfather should have fought against Hitler so that so many young Allied soldiers did not have to die.
joelSanFrancisco 11 months ago
@joelSanFrancisco tis was meant generally. soldiers fight for their home, their family, for their country not only because of the leader of their country. in this time people were faszinated of hitler. he gave them a feeling back that many people missed.
Shepp1rd 11 months ago
@Shepp1rd Hitler gave the German people a feeling back ... it is unfortunate he can't give young Allied dead their lives back.
joelSanFrancisco 11 months ago
@joelSanFrancisco the allies cant give back young german lives!
Shepp1rd 11 months ago
@Shepp1rd .. Shepp, I think we can both agree that WWII was an immense tragedy with great losses suffered by all sides. But we also must remember the lesson: citizens cannot give unquestioning support to dictators and evil leaders. We see right now in Egypt and Libya how citizens are standing up against tyrants.
joelSanFrancisco 11 months ago
@joelSanFrancisco yes thats right, but all i wanted to say is, that all soldiers deserve respect no matter from where they are. in the past now and in the future
Shepp1rd 11 months ago
Nice video, I'd also been proud of such an honorable grandfather
h3ro1337 1 year ago
This is a wonderful tribute my great great uncle was a salor in the proud brittish navy he served on the HMS Hood the navys flagship but was then attached to the HMS witshed which was attacked by the Luftwaffe and he was the only casualty that day , he was only 19. Able seaman Stanley nicol RIP 19 Years old from Arbroath , Scotland
1690Shaun 1 year ago
Wonderful Gaelic song. May your grandfather forever rest in peace.
Sweden80Here 2 years ago
did your grandpa survive the war
stanislaw84 2 years ago
Yes he did but he got deep pshycological scares. My grandfather fought in the djungels of burma as a british soldier of irish descent and became later a prisoner of war, he spent over a year in a japanese prison camp. He got tortured and lost alot of friends during that time. He became a changed man after the war, always very quiet. He died in the mid 80's.
Sweden80Here 2 years ago
What a great song! My god..it's awesome.
VoDKaMarine 2 years ago
Rest in Peace Sir
Thank You
66cheesehead 2 years ago
VERY WELL done!! Thanks again and God Bless the LT and your family. The horrors he had to have endured. We're better for it, although.......well, we're just better because of that.
aviationwingnut 2 years ago
I don't understand the lyrics but, that doesn't matter. Lieutenant McGeorge would've been happy to know he had this. Probably wishes ALL those with him who didn't get it could've been afforded the same. Thanks for the upload. That is REAL nice. Thanks again.
aviationwingnut 2 years ago
Do you understand the words.. I hope you do
God4Dunoon 3 years ago
Do I understand the words to Chi Mi Na Mór-Bheanna you mean? Actually yes, I do. I studied them (and Scottish Gaelic) so I could sing it at the funeral. I'll post a translation here for others in case they are curious.
LiveDeepDoGood 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@LiveDeepDoGood If it was not for him none of us would be here.
spartin001full 10 months ago
God Bless
God4Dunoon 3 years ago
what was the opening music?
wehah73 3 years ago
It is from Medal of Honor: Frontline
LiveDeepDoGood 3 years ago
the used it in Allied Assault too
BUTLERSUPERFAN 2 years ago
I hope that your Grandfather has come home to Scotland to find his peace.
May his God love him.
Giesabrekk 3 years ago
I'm sorry about your grandfather! You must miss him! My Dad fought in the battle of anzio, Italy, WW2. He is 90 years old & in a home for veterans. I hope peace comes to us all soon & that wars will be no more. The Rankin Family song is beautiful. They come from the beautiful island of Cape Breton. One of the brothers, John Morris Rankin, has passed in a car accident a few years ago. Another song popular in the world, by the Rankins, is "Fare Thee Well Love". Take care.
earthenly 3 years ago